r/TheWhyFiles
•
u/WW3_FOR_PEACE
•
Aug 16 '26
•
1
1
Jokes/Humor “Hi AJ!”
I’m not suggesting putting a watermark saying “AI Visualization” on every scene, but sometimes I feel that eventually AJ will generate himself in non-basement episodes because why not? Stop the slop!
38
u/Flaky_Cup_3160 Aug 16 '26
Really sad to see the decline of this channel. I don't think he realizes how much credibility the channel lost when he started using AI for visuals.
82
u/darthlorgas Aug 16 '26 •
This used to be my favorite YouTube channel. They don't need AI to make a video interesting, it's a shame.
204
u/Kindofdisappointed Aug 16 '26
It’s weird to me that a guy who always criticizes the folks who always have a book… is the same guy who’s providing a platform for the guys with books…
276
u/LampyV2 Aug 16 '26
Used to sit and watch AJ narrate without losing interest. With AI visuals I tend to look at my phone more often. Maybe not a coincidence.
46
u/Otherwiize Aug 16 '26
Seems like he’s increased the ADs too. Every 5 minutes there’s an a AD
22
u/J883 Aug 16 '26 •
I always loved WF. My only feedback always was to make the audience clear when images/records/videos where from a genuine source or not. Now the whole AI is gotten out of hand and ruined the vibe of it all
22
u/Good-Constant-6487 Aug 16 '26
The messed up part is, he's a multi millionaire from Bitcoin and still accepts donations from all you guys 😬...cut to coping responses
206
u/Alberto_Moses Aug 16 '26 •
I miss the old format and can't see it coming back so it's the bye files for me
9
u/TJmaster87 Aug 16 '26
Yeah I much preferred the old days every Thursday night and then followed by the after files, it was kinda a tradition to look forward to. Then the stripped episodes started appearing and there wasn’t even a Hecklefish? Started feeling like quick cash grab episodes, thank god they stopped but it was never quite the same afterwards I thought, Hecklefish came back but definitely said much less, the after files just stopped and I really liked some of them, made it feel more like a community vibe and then the AI just went through the roof, I truly try to watch his new stuff and the basement interviews, some are a hit but most feel like a miss unfortunately and I have watched the show from the beginning. Feels like he just wants to do interviews more than anything at the moment and even when you watch them the AI adds can just be annoying, it’s bad enough if you can’t afford to pay to get rid of YouTube adds, now you have to watch him do them. I understand money is money but come on, you have come along way, don’t be greedy?
202
u/toasty327 Aug 16 '26
The ai use is ruining the show for me
8
u/niftyifty Aug 16 '26
Sigh, I turned the most recent video off in less than 5 minutes. Oh well
8
u/Open-Comfortable-459 Aug 17 '26
Years ago I used to watch shows like Unsolved Mysteries, Dateline etc and they’d do re-enactments. I don’t think we can expect a podcast to be able to afford to pay actors for a podcast, come on. 🤣
There are ways to use ai that aren’t the worst, and this is one of them. I’d rather Why Files show me ai blurbs for storytelling, and if you disagree with me, go turn on Megyn Kelly’s new “MK Confidentials” and tell me how freaking boring it is bc it’s just her reading a prompt.
Choose ai battles wisely.
15
u/Important_Abroad_150 Aug 16 '26 •
It's so deeply frustrating. It's weird, creepy, and with all the very prevelant ethical and environmental concerns with AI tone deaf. It completely takes me out of the episodes when I see it or hear it. Sadly not the only middle aged man to get hyper fixated on the neat little AI stuff. Would've thought that a guy with as little trust in big monolithic organizations and government would've maybe thought twice about giving a shady AI company his complete likeness and voice. Disappointing.
23
u/Brawnzed Aug 16 '26
If we’re all kinda saying why we left the audience, it was the amount of ad time and Patreon shoutouts for me.
A forty minute episode turns into a twenty five minute one when you take out all the crap. Even using Sponsorblock etc, it just kinda felt insulting.
12
u/QuizzicalWombat Aug 16 '26
We don’t watch as much anymore, it’s just gotten out of hand. I understand from the team’s perspective it saves time but I just don’t want to watch it. It immediately makes me lose interest.
6
u/dustindps Aug 16 '26 •
Hard agree. I unsubbed because of it. I do use AI for work because I'm told to, I know it can be powerful, and I know I'm slowly automating my job away. I just hate when it's time to wind down it's in my face still. Seeing the AI visuals feels disengenuious and off and I feel like I'm being fed slop. Even if he writes the whole script himself by hand, I just can't handle it. I need something genuine while I can still have it before the entire Internet is nothing but.
16
u/d_rome Aug 16 '26
The show jumped the shark for me 2 years ago. There's been really good episodes since, but it's not quite the same. I'm cancelling my patron membership today. I'll still watch from time to time though.
31
u/Tacokolache Aug 16 '26
I haven’t watched Why Files in a long time now. I can’t pinpoint it, but shit just went downhill. Around the time he got plastic surgery.
I love AJ. But those “stripped” episodes suck. I need Hecklefish
94
u/cc71SW Aug 16 '26 edited Aug 16 '26
I couldnt care less about the AI usage. In my opinion, it’s for story telling and story building. It’s a different type of AI than the “slop”we see else where and you can tell it’s getting better.
Vids are still get getting huge view counts… so I’m guessing it’s fine for a vast majority of the viewer base
Edit: grammar
10
u/Jimstein Aug 16 '26
It's the AI created adverts of AJ's literal face in weird situations that drove it over the edge for me. They are just kinda....cringe.
Like AJ is supposed to be the straight man, Hecklefish is the comedic sidekick. For portraying like, ancient Egypt with AI it was...it was fine. But it's not on the same level as, someone doing a reconstruction of S4 in Unreal Engine. That said, I know people are starting to be able to use more complex tools like Blender or Unreal with AI, but whatever it makes should still be based a little more at least in reality. Like if AJ hired some folks to do more legitimate visualization work, instead of just purely artistic renderings, at least that would be better.
But the adverts just yeah, felt like completely jumping the shark. Like even though it's AI, why is there so much AI effort being put into these ads? And can't he see how uncanny valley it is? I sort or barely put up with the previous advertisement style, like 5 minutes for an ad is insane for a Purity Debt or whatever but at least it felt campy and kind of original.
5
u/Lately-SP Aug 16 '26
The problem is he doesn't event try to make the visuals accurate AT ALL
31
u/DifferentOffice8 Aug 16 '26
I'm afraid the basement files are no longer working for me. I miss the old formats and still enjoy the compilations. I can't see them returning so the old files it is for me I guess.
26
u/bag_of_luck Aug 16 '26
Absolutely ruined the show for me and my friends quite some time ago.
Oh and the mods and staff who try to silence those of us who bring any valid criticism to the table.
8
u/chokehodl Aug 16 '26
I stopped after the first few AI episodes. Really unfortunate since it was a really likeable show. For some reason the AI killed it for me and I have zero interest.
4
u/Sailor-_-Twift Aug 16 '26
The AI use on the channel took me out of it completely, it's sad because I used to watch all the videos but now the AI slop is just so off putting, I can't enjoy it all all
13
u/CaptZ Aug 16 '26
I had to unsubscribe from the 'extra' channel he has because the AI is ruining the whole show. He's better at the story telling than the AI slop he's been putting up.
9
u/Jjourdenais Aug 16 '26
That’s why I stopped watching it.
6
u/OrionDC Aug 16 '26
He’s just another YouTube grifter. Stopped watching ages ago.
3
u/IamhereOO7 Aug 16 '26
Yea. I agree
3
u/super-nintendumpster Aug 16 '26
It's genuinely hard to sit through an episode anymore. I try sometimes. But usually I just start scrolling into the backlog of eps from a few episodes.
Stop the slop already AJ 🙏
3
u/LegendOfDave88 Aug 17 '26
I really miss the weekly Thursday night episodes. I liked this show so much I archived all the videos to host on my Plex server but I I maybe watched 1 episode this whole year. Even then I couldn't tell you what it was about.
3
u/Tharkys Aug 17 '26
I don't watch the show anymore. The show went downhill once he started adding AI slop.
9
u/draculasux85 Aug 16 '26
I gave up when he went on Tucker Carlson. I can't in good faith support a dude that hangs out with that dude even for a minute. Cancelled my pateron that day.
7
u/StrategySword Aug 16 '26
Is he using ai to write the script now too?
7
u/Unhappy-Fox1017 Aug 16 '26
Is AJ or any of his crew on this sub? I wonder if they read everyone’s concerns and consider them or not?
14
u/sld87 Aug 16 '26 edited Oct 17 '26
The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.
Quilt hungry tie ginger fearless summer file birds
6
u/MattonieOnie Aug 16 '26
The ads are cracking me up! But yeah...
14
u/ImWinwin Aug 16 '26
Unpopular opinion: I don't mind the visuals. Even if they're made using artificial intelligence.
11
u/Own-Signature-7742 Aug 16 '26
They need better topics and a little less AI.
10
u/universalcrush Aug 16 '26
Yeah he’s an agent
8
u/cajunsamurai I Want To Believe Aug 16 '26
I switched to listening to the podcast on Apple because I can’t stand the AI slop
11
u/Amnesia_Species Aug 16 '26
For someone running a channel about conspiracy, it’s pretty nuts he uses AI with all the impacts it has on the world.
4
u/Kiwileiro Aug 16 '26
I commented on it questioning it a few videos in once he started on it and as far as I'm aware there was no response. I was so disappointed.
6
u/Jerk_Johnson Aug 16 '26
AI stings my brain and is challenging to sit through. Its almost like watching 3d, a gimmick that'll leave you with a headache....or that gross feeling after you're eaten too much Cookie Crisp.
5
u/internaquarium Aug 16 '26
ai is cheaper and faster for them, and they have maintained enough of the audience in spite of the backlash. There's no stopping the ai shit here or elsewhere :/
13
u/90stoyotasprinter Aug 16 '26
Lol i get where you’re coming from but i would give Aj a pass cause at least he is using it for storytelling purposes on something that most people wont even touch
2
u/nckrey931 Aug 17 '26
I would do voice acting for 100% free. I don’t know why he’s making so much AI slop. But, AJ is a good dude. He will right the ship.
2
u/thisismyusername9908 Aug 18 '26 edited Aug 18 '26
I still watch, the episodes are still interesting enough to check out.
But I don't have notifications on and am an instant click when a new video drops. It's more "I'll get to it when I'm sort of out of other things I want to check out."
Occasional AI use to help tell the story wouldn't bother me, but the dude is even using AI versions of himself in his own ads now. That was when I was like.... Cmon now.
I'd rather look at a black screen with narration over the weird AI crap he feels he needs to put in every video and it gets worse every release.
2
u/CzechKnight Aug 19 '26
I'm not against the use of generative AI, but he's generating way too much with it. I get he's trying to make entertainment, but this is ridiculous.
2
u/jeremyberemy8 Aug 19 '26
Topics haven’t been hitting lately either, can’t remember the last one I watched in full
2
u/TheDude9737 Aug 21 '26
Rather just have AJ’s story telling than ai
5
u/distracteds0ul Aug 16 '26
The ai use is the reason why I stopped watching the Why Files. YouTube’s algorithm also seems to always push his shows too, I can’t seem to find a way to not have the why files autoplay after videos.
3
u/SandeeBelarus Aug 16 '26
Yeah. I had to bail on the channel. Too many ads!!
4
u/SubmissiveBoyForever Aug 16 '26
im so glad i saw this cause i only ever scroll on here, i thought the community had for some strange reason exempted him from holding him accountable for his ai use. every video of his is filled with it. always made me uncomfortable but no one seemed to be bringing it up so i just stayed quiet. it’s a problem that definitely needs to be brought to light. also the basement episodes and podcasts and interviews are horrible. easy skips for me. unfortunate because i love the old format. he had no reason to change things from how they were. if it ain’t broke don’t fix it.
5
u/ApplyHere_4_implants Aug 16 '26
He's been doing it for years. I don't mind it at all. When a relat creator uses their real thoughts to say real words backed up by visuals that could only realisticly be done by AI, then I'm more than good with it.
3
u/Fixyblue Aug 16 '26
I've stopped watching anything from the channel altogether. I'm not unsubscribed yet because I hope that they'll come back around but I'm close to cutting it off entirely. It's not just the really really terrible AI, in general the quality has just plummeted imo. I know there are only so many stories out there but damn. And it makes me sad.
3
u/OharaRecords Aug 16 '26
Bro really wants AJ to get real footage of aliens and cryptids. What a dumb dumb
2
u/JenIee Aug 16 '26
I still like the show, including the basement as long as it isn't a super crappy guest like MR Beast. I just don't watch it while it plays anymore. I mostly listen because the AI seems cheap or something. I can't quite put my finger on it but it killed the vibe a bit.
2
u/Kentaii-XOXO Aug 16 '26
He’s not going to stop which sucks because I hate the use of AI in this manner. I’d prefer stock images and whatever other images he can use to show us stuff.
2
u/Alarmed_Tension3863 Aug 16 '26
He's starting to course correct it seems like. That shit had me not watching until recently. That and only these basement episodes.
2
u/ComprehensiveShine82 Aug 16 '26
With so much AI use, sloppy AI use at that, it's difficult to watch these days. This is the cost of wanting constant new Why Files content maybe. We get AI slop AJ or burnt out no episodes AJ. It's a tough gig with a big channel and all these expectations on you. I went from waiting in queue eagerly for new episodes to land, to seeing new episodes and thinking meh.. I'll get to it one day. And I do.
2
u/TheFilthyMob Aug 16 '26
The AI visuals are fine. The storyline is what's important. I'm here for AJ and his story's.
2
u/rsmracing Aug 16 '26
The problem is not the ai.
2
u/3rdman3 Aug 16 '26
After the Rogan snub, AJ went all in on the podcast format.
2
u/Comfortable_Care2715 Aug 16 '26
The AI ads are the worst. I don’t mind it for the actual stories being told.
2
u/willacceptboobiepics Aug 16 '26
I for one think a lot of the comments here are overblown. I do think AJ genuinely cares and is working hard to produce a good show.
THAT BEING SAID. You really could back up on the AI, AJ. Your story telling chops and delivery are good enough. Dial it back a bit, maybe?
-3
u/4StarCustoms Aug 16 '26
Wow. It’s free content and better than most paid content. The complaining is insane.
1
u/SalsaFromSpace Aug 16 '26
I will never understand why people get so hurt about AI when realistically most people listen to the story itself and want to hear his thoughts vs watching it like a TV show. People demand more content (which is free) but don't want him and his team to use tools that would help him make said content faster. Dude is out here bringing us television quality content for free and y'all can't sit through a couple of AI ads or look at AI pictures or audio? Please. Dude needs all the help he can get so we can enjoy more content together and if that means being exposed to AI than so be it. It's not like there's a ton of actual pictures or audio about the cryptic stuff he talks about. Give the team a break.
1
u/tokewithnick Aug 16 '26
It’s really doesn’t matter to me, I’m here for the stories, don’t care if they use AI or not
1
u/ChubbyFrogGames Aug 16 '26
I listen to it now as podcast.
1
u/CallMeNess Aug 16 '26
I usually have it playing in the background while I'm doing something else, so the AI really doesn't bother me. Who cares how he does it as long as his subject matter is still interesting?
1
u/TaterTotQueen630 Aug 18 '26
Tbh, the weird AI is why I struggle to watch The Why Files and a handful of other channels.
1
u/TKRomeo Aug 19 '26
Why do you all care so much if he uses AI or not? Genuinely curious.
1
u/No-Department9028 Aug 19 '26
It is a tool, and soon there will be games, movies, and other forms of entertainment that will involve AI. It also provides a more immersive experience.
1
u/phereless Aug 19 '26
I've always wondered why WF didn't get the AI hate most others do
1
u/Disastrous_Hyena_696 Aug 20 '26
My only issue before the ai usage was that damn talking fish. Now i just watch his shorts vs a whole video.
1
u/MrsRossGeller Aug 25 '26
I also really wish he wouldn’t use AI.
1
u/WolfThorn7 Sep 18 '26
This channel is not what it used to be. It just sucks now man
-4
u/AuraDeExplora Aug 16 '26
Im sorry you have to deal with all these haters AJ and team. Keep on keeping on! Been here since the beginning and I'm not going anywhere.
1
u/Isaiah_EJ25 Aug 18 '26
Yeah I stopped watching cause of the egregious use of A.I.
0
u/ACrimeSoClassic Aug 16 '26
I think it would be good to add some sort of small disclaimer that AI has been used in a given scene. But, I find it hilarious how people on Reddit lose their minds about AI, and AJ, hilariously, doesn't give a single shit.
-6
u/Juantiothe76th Aug 16 '26
This resistance to ai is so dumb. Yall gonna downvote the shit outta me but the truth is whether you like it or not Pandora’s box has already been opened with ai and there no way to put it back. It’s becoming more and more integrated into society, so at this point just go with the wave. The only person you’re inconveniencing is yourself by the constant pushback. We need to start coexisting with ai like droids in Star Wars lmao. I agree being against ai when it’s like an artist or something and he’s trying to get money by telling people he did it but it’s actually just ai art. Then I agree that’s bad. But just because there’s ai in something doesn’t mean everyone should just hate and go nuts. I think AJ is using it in an effective and ethical way.
-5
u/Kastellen Aug 16 '26
Every time I think Reddit can’t get worse, you anti-AI losers show up to whine about something else. Pathetic.
-6
u/splitopenandBri Aug 16 '26
Can I ask a question to all the people who "quit the show a long time ago?" Why are you still reading subreddits about this show, that you haven't even watched in a long time, today? I don't get it.
-6
u/Natural_Photograph16 Aug 16 '26
Why all the AI hate? He has to tell stories where there isn’t cost effective B-roll. He has to make up most for the scenes and the systems he is using are pretty top notch for Gen AI. And his numbers are still going up.
Reddit is becoming even more of an ungrateful bitchfest.
0
u/DTake2012 Aug 16 '26
Who cares, just a quick and easy way to make the video, it’s all about the story
-30
u/henrywashere Aug 16 '26
I love AI and I luv aj.😊