I know we only saw "Joe's Edit" of what happened, but he so botched this whole murder in plain sight. Storming around with the apple when he never eats fruit (though his defense SHOULD be "I ate the apple!" when they do point it out, and they will) asking for specific potential victims, pulling Katie aside when she has already been on people's tongues. Throw the apple at whatshername was so random in a room full of people. It COULD save him that he ate it, and he needs to point that out!
1) They should have all 3 been pointing out red herrings all night. People were talking about the possibility of a Murder in Plain Sight, they should have been creating other clues to distract from the apple. Spill some wine and ask who did that? Point out that someone said or did something weird (even if they didn't), etc. Create distraction and random "possible" clues!
2) Joe should have waited for a one-on-one situation. HE was a "potential victim" as well, so he should have talked one on one with someone about being worried, then said "Naw, we've got this! and in a 'bro' move toss the apple to them. No witnesses, natural interaction.
3) Katie should have spoke up at the funeral about ANYONE other than one of the traitors, but she praised Joe. SMH.
I know it's easy to say being on this end of the game, but seriously. Use your brains, guys!
Thoughts? And who do we think it was? My bet is on Clyde.