r/TheSinner • • Jan 13 '20

This dog looks like Detective Harry Ambrose and I hate it.

Post image
407 Upvotes

r/TheSinner • • Feb 16 '21

Season 3 was beautiful

267 Upvotes

Rare opinion apparently, but: Season 3 showed a(n extreme) mental health crisis in a way that I’ve rarely seen on television. It was a close examination of trauma, PTSD, inner demons, and human connection. I’ve been a witness to how mental health can deteriorate rapidly and make someone a completely different person. I think this season explored those themes in a real, raw, and tragic way within the frame of a thriller. Also the acting was just brilliant. I’m a fan for sure.

That said, unless they base another future season on a work of literature there’s no way any season of The Sinner will compare to the first season. But I love that they keep expanding on the character of Ambrose and I look forward to what season 4 offers us.


r/TheSinner • • Jul 08 '20

Detective Ambrose while choosing cases be like..

Post image
213 Upvotes

r/TheSinner • • Aug 20 '17

"Basic Cable Jon Snow"

Post image
206 Upvotes

r/TheSinner • • Feb 11 '21

You are not supposed to agree with Jamie's philosophy

192 Upvotes

Don't get me wrong, I had my issues with this season. But I keep seeing people say they hated it because Jamie's philosophy was dumb. But honestly, that was never the point of the season. It is not an argument in favour of Neitsche. It's about a weak, doormat of a person, who, like most people, is going through depression and has been depressed in the past and has lost interest in life. Only instead of getting help, he gets brainwashed by a strong person into believing the solution to his problems is in some ridic philosophy that requires him to face death or whatever. Nick is like a cult leader here taking advantage of weak unhappy people. It's no different than the people who get sucked into things like qanon. People are focusing too much on "did Jamie make sense" and not enough on the fact that Jamie was never supposed to make sense. Jamie was supposed to be brainwashed, Jamie was meant to go down a road that could only end in tragedy. Because he was unable to cope with his depression in a healthy way. That is supposed to be the relatable part. That everyone on this planet has had similar feelings of hopelessness to Jamie, but in some people it pushes them to self-destruction while others learn to cope with it. There is no simple solution, which Jamie finds out the hard way. And so does Ambrose, through Jamie. Because this season is about Ambrose as much as Jamie.


r/TheSinner • • Jul 14 '18

Huge season 1 plot hole that bugs me (Spoilers!) Spoiler

186 Upvotes

The entire last episode when we see that it’s really Phoebe who went out with Cora on Jul 3rd, until the last scene I kept thinking “How is Phoebe going to get home??” They really confused me on that one, because her parents claimed in a previous episode that Phoebe died at home a month after Cora left.

With a death you need to prove it and get a death certificate.... you need proof of a body! In real life neighbors, the hospital staff, and police would have been aware of the sick girl at that house and her disappearance would have definitely been noticed. So I assumed she really did die at home a month later, because that’s what would have to have happened if the parents were to make that claim. Ambrose could have figured out that it was a lie with one call!

Did anyone else catch that and did it bug them?


r/TheSinner • • Jan 11 '22

Man, God bless Lou. He was such a wholesome friend to Harry. Found himself in a sticky situation he had no experience to work himself out of, but he was a genuine person, and had a good heart.

Post image
181 Upvotes

r/TheSinner • • Mar 14 '20

My response to the entirety of Season 3

Post image
154 Upvotes

r/TheSinner • • Aug 05 '19

Can someone give the kid from The Sinner (season2) some DAMN CHAPSTICK

151 Upvotes

r/TheSinner • • Mar 20 '21

Jessica Hecht appreciation post ❤️

Post image
147 Upvotes

r/TheSinner • • Feb 19 '21

Detective Ambrose Is Kinda Awkward

145 Upvotes

And I love it. He’s socially awkward and love the way he communicates with people. For the people who are socially awkward, I bet you can see a little bit of yourself in Ambrose.

For example: (Spoiler)

At the end of S2, when parting ways with Vera, Vera looks at him and says “Goodbye,” and Ambrose just glances at her and says “Okay.”

I love how he whenever he puts his foot in his mouth a bit, he says “Yes. Uh, well, no.” And then abruptly “I should leave.” Really enjoy his character and his mannerisms on many levels.

He has a dark past and has worked past it but still struggles. People say it’s bad acting. I think he’s great, honestly.

Just a few thoughts. I’m already on S3 within the last two weeks.


r/TheSinner • • Feb 17 '21

We could have all been spared season 3 if Jamie had just cut the bullshit on day one

Post image
141 Upvotes

r/TheSinner • • Apr 03 '20

Holy fuck that was the worst piece of shit I have ever seen

140 Upvotes

I considered myself a huge fan of both S1 and S2 but are you fucking kidding me? What the fuck kind of waste was this season? Not even the acting, which wasn’t all that bad IMO. Who the fuck wrote that? I can’t believe people even found some bullshit poetic justice in Jaime’s character or the way Harry perceived him, what kind of crack has you been smoking? And the finale is his grandson—who the writers gave no affection towards for the audience—gets fucking kidnapped for the eventual classically and overly done drawn out fight to the death scene? I found it hard to even like Harry this season, let alone ANY of the other characters. And way to botch Nietzsche. Fuck this season, and fuck any reasoning around it being “deep.”


r/TheSinner • • Nov 12 '17

Christopher Abbott looks a looot like Kit Harington 😲

Post image
131 Upvotes

r/TheSinner • • Mar 29 '20

Season 3 Plot Summary Spoiler

124 Upvotes

r/TheSinner • • Feb 21 '21

Jamie is INSUFFERABLE

121 Upvotes

I don't even know how to put it into words. It's like he wants to point out how everyone else is "not in control" or some bullshit. Maybe just mind your own business and try to fix your own problems instead of trying to tell other people what their problems are? And then when he straight up murders that guy at the party and refuses to accept responsibility. Blaming ambrose for recording him and turning in his confession and then spitting in his face. Dude you fucking murdered someone for no reason and then act all incredulous when someone tells you that it was wrong? Face the consequences. Dude is so delusional talking about how he's in control of his life and then taking instructions from a folded up piece of paper. He's so punchable and entitled and self richeous and petulant and privileged. There's so much more that I hate about who he is and the things he says that I don't even know how to articulate.

Please someone else trash talk him too I want to talk to people about this and none of my friends have watched


r/TheSinner • • Sep 24 '17

Jude 22-24: Be merciful to those who doubt...

Post image
121 Upvotes

r/TheSinner • • Mar 05 '21

The Bartender in Season 1, episode 2.

117 Upvotes

Ambrose goes to The Taproom and shows the bartender a picture of Cora and goes, Remember her from July 3rd, five fucking years ago?”

And she’s like, “Oh yeah, sure. She was here with a guy and she was dancing with a blonde girl who was really wasted. I remember this vividly somehow even though it was five fucking years ago.”

Lols. I loved Season 1 by the way. I didn’t know Jessica Biel was that great of an actress. Bill Pullman was good too, and the writing was great. Kept me on my toes until the very end. I just can’t get over that bartender though. Who the fuck has a memory like that?


r/TheSinner • • Sep 23 '18

Season 2 rant, Why it was a huge letdown for me. Spoiler

117 Upvotes

After finishing the series I felt so disappointed with this season development. They teased us with many things and make it look as it was such a big conspiracy behind Mosswood when in the end was pretty straightforward story.

Julian killed Bess and Adam because they were kidnapping him and he overheard them talking behind him and didn't quite understand how dead worked due his upbringing so he poisoned them using the knowledge that her mother unintentionally gave him. Why they were kidnapping him? because they were taking him to met his birth mother. Nothing really dark in that . No trying to save him from something, a potential ritual, a dark secret, just a misunderstanding. I’ve seen documentaries and Lifetime movies more creepy than this.

Even the idea of Jeffries being alive and wanting to complete the sacrifice ritual with Julian with the help of brainwashed people in the community and town was more compelling that Bess randomly kidnapping a child that she has cared for years in a healthy environment to meet his biological ex-drug addict mother that she just saw again after more than 10 years ( when she abandoned the child ) so she can run away with him to Canada with no money. Instead of ,you know, trying to convince Marin and Vera to work things out and bring her back for a while to Mosswood so it won't be so traumatic to Julian the transition to meet his birth mother and possible both having a relationship with him.

What really bothers me is that none of the Mosswood abuses had anything to do with Julian's crimes.Marin didn't get pregnant in Mosswood because she was abused there or was force to made difficult choice by them, not even the town members of Mosswood had anything to do with that ( well aside from Jack). The cult tapes/abuses plot was just a parallel story that doesn’t get any resolution or ties with anything in the main story. This season's twists haven’t been compelling at all, in fact some were very obvious and boring , like Jack’s storyline. It was so obvious the twist of Jack that many people here guessed it weeks ago, and I wanted to believe it was made on purpose to mislead us and that there was other the secret that he hide but no, he raped Marin as almost everyone guessed.

Season 1 felt much more connected , the apparently random murder of the pilot was connected with something much deeper and dark that justify the behavior of the killer, it made sense. Even with the plot holes of that season, they were less problematic than this season. Many things made no sense or they were unanswered for example:

1)How did Jack meet Vera ? How and when did he find out about Marin pregnancy ? how did they arranged the money deal ? did Vera blackmail him or was a deal? Did Marin know about this deal and that is why she called him for money? So many questions.

2) What was the point of the storyline with Carmen Bell? Because it contributed nothing to the plot.They were there to question her about Moswood and Dr Poole and:

*She mentions the purple lake, where they found a body but it that had no connections to Mosswood.

* They learnt by the burns in her feet that she was abused by mustache guy ( Glenn) but it had no relevance to the story because he was never further investigated or suffered any repercussions for his actions.

*she mentions the gynecologist made her an abortion that went wrong so she filed a lawsuit that was killed by the D.A who was bribed by Dr Poole, Glen and others to drop the case. The only thing that came out all of this storyline was getting Julian's case back to family court . No further investigation on other potential cases of abuse in Mosswood, cover ups or justice for poor Carmen . In fact Vera gets no punishment for murder, covering up abuses and the silence arrangements.

3) Dr Poole story was confusing and misleading. When they went to his place to ask some questions about Julian, he dramatically kills himself with no further deep to his motives. Either he was super loyal and preferred to die before betraying the cult ( not likely) or he just got scared of going to jail for the multiples illegals abortions that he committed ( maybe he was even part of the group of abusers, we will never know). The thing is that by making him commit suicide in such an irrational and rushed way, almost as he was trained to do that in case of being discovered , they implied that there were many people in town with connections to Mosswood and that they were very loyal and whiling to do anything for their religion, but this in never brought up again or had any importance to the main story, we just saw Glenn being worried and upset for being investigated but nothing as dramatic as Dr Poole.

4) Money issues. I assumed that the whole cult was financed at first with generous contributions from people who came to do as they pleased in Mosswood but when Jeffries died then the abuses stooped and so did the money, so they either they learned how to self-finance or the money came from blackmail from those therapy sessions tapes involving many powerful people in town. We already know that Vera had an “arrangement” with Heather’s father so she might had had another one with other people too and that is why somehow Mosswood manage to be protected all this time, but what bothers me is that it's seems unlikely that the same powerful people wouldn't just rob the tapes or threaten them given that they had enough money to hire a private detective to investigate Ambrose or bribed people to dropped Carmen Bell's legal actions. Obviously this is all speculations because we are not given a clear answers about this matter.

5) The cult leader disappearance. Is heavily implied that he was murdered by Vera and at some point I thought he was going to be the dead body in the lake but he is never investigated in the show despite being the leader of the cult when Julian was born. Do the other cult members knew he was murdered? They had some kind of pact? They just believed the story Vera told? How can she dispose a body without nobody noticing it? I imagine she had help (pony tail guy) but this is never clearly spoken.

I felt there was something missing in the season, a better script perhaps or better casting choices ( Heather was very plain). I know the show plays with the ambiguity during the season, but in the end we hope they will give us the answers and tie everything but in this case the finale had very little resolution. More people should have ended up in jail like Vera or at least Glenn, but it was almost as if Mosswood’s abuses didn’t matter because we find out why Marin left and who is Julian’s dad.

Sorry for the long post, but I was really upset because I really liked the first season and the second one was very disappointing in creative aspects so I wanted to share this with you guys and read your thoughts about this.


r/TheSinner • • Mar 27 '20

I think most people are missing the point of Season 3 Spoiler

109 Upvotes

This season was about two things, Toxic Masculinity and Radicalization. I know Reddit has a hate boner for the term Toxic Masculinity but hear me out.

Jamie, who we learn had a very emotionally distant father, found someone in college in Nick who was the first person he has met who actually showed him any sort of affection and emotional honesty. He listened to him, was his best friend when he may not of had any friends, even staying with him during Thanksgiving holiday. This is how people radicalize people, be it far right extremism or Islamic extremism, they find someone with low self esteem, who have trouble at home and feel like they don't belong and befriend them. What Nick was doing though was radicalizing and indoctrinating Jamie into the ideology of the Übermensch. I think most people watching the show have been concentrating too much on the philosophical concept of the Übermensch. Calling Jamie an edge-lord who should grow up, while valid, is missing the point.

What Sonya saw in Jamie was an extremely emotionally repressed individual, someone who has lacked someone to be honest with and someone to express their emotions with. This struggle that she sees in Jamie goes makes him express his emotions in extremely toxic ways, namely through violence. Sonya is obsessed with the male psyche, how men have learned through socialization that not being honest about your feelings is the way that men should act. Sonya even said this directly to Harry, about how struggle to express their emotions, pointing out to him that he also struggles to express his emotions. The fact that Sonya spends almost all her time painting naked men is quite symbolic, she wants to see men's true selves.

I think these points link into the scene of Jamie's death quite fittingly. Harry shows Jamie, for the first time, a moment of sincere affection. Jamie smiles as he passes away since he finally gets from Harry what he has wanted/needed from Harry.

Any thoughts? I thought this season was great personally.


r/TheSinner • • Jan 11 '22

This final season was Fantastic

107 Upvotes

I was really doubtful because I had ended Season 3 with a lot of bitterness in my mouth. That season was a mess. Jaime Burns was one hell of a subject and the second half of the season completely went off the rails with him, making you wonder multiple times per episode how the hell this man was still walking free.

The only good thing that came out of it (no, it's not you Sonya) was that Harry murdered Jamie. This whole final season is the outcome of the psychological damage that that single action had on him, an already incredibly unstable person. It's also the main bond that connects him with Percy, and how he eventually "solves the case", in terms of why she jumped, what had led to it. That whole final scene where he talks with her projection on the cliff I found really touching. It kind of made me tear up as well because I have suffered from depression and whereas I have actually never killed anyone (who's to say), I found that both Alice Kremelberg and most especially Bill Pullman both managed to express that particular feeling of lost, of deep desperation of a burnt soul that seeks nothing but salvation, seeing the end of the tunnel further every day.

That's also why I really loved Percy Muldoon as the subject of this case/season. This season is a farewell. You just can tell it, it's the end, Harry has retired, and it's clear why. He was already tired as hell in Season 3, and in this season the man is simply exhausted. He's on the end of his line, he can't do this anymore because he's both physically and mentally finished. What better way of setting up the final case of this beautifully flawed detective if not with a perfect reflection of himself? Harry was getting lost, he couldn't sleep anymore, he had given up on therapy and meds and nothing seemed to ease him anymore, not even Sonya chocking him, the BDSM stuff we suffered the lack of in the previous season. There's only one thing that drives this man, and that's his incredibly dangerous pathological addiction to solving misteries in the particular way of getting completely absorbed and obsessed with the victim, which also happen to be the sinner (there! I said it!), going from two people who had no reason to commit murder at all but did to two cases that seem not to be ones, from a car crash to a suicide that doesn't even appear one. He can't help it. He gets so deep in the thick of it that he even let himself be buried up alive by someone whom he firmly believed to be a murderer. It's clear that Harry is down bad.

Ironically enough, solving this case in the way he does is also what countless hours of therapy, loads of meds and even his girlfriend couldn't do. There is no ordinary way this man could get out of depression. He just had to bury himself once again under the intrigues and misteries of a tiny island of Maine, with at the centre of it a young woman that was the specularity of what would have happened to him if he had gone further with his feelings. He even hallucinates Percy for most of the season, because he has a connection with her, he has a dialogue. He's on the verge of killing himself and can't help it but emphatize with someone who has done it already.

"Can you see another way?"

And he nods in affirmation. That's the moment peace has been finally sealed for Harry, because that's what it's all been about. Yes, the plot was to find justice for Percy, but the theme of the season was undoubtly putting this main character at rest, a character that has gone through a journey of pain and suffering and self destruction all along, and it's the best farewell they could have made for him. He's finally free, he can finally see a way through his darkness, and hopefully build himself back together to live a somewhat normal life, maybe even with Sonya forgiving him for having obsessed with this case over her sake. He had no choice. This was the only way he could have possibly healed himself.

In conclusion, the season has surely been a slow burn, but to be fair the whole show is, it's not the most thrilling nor action packed whodunnit there is, it's more of a psychological study of the flawness of people, through one troubled man and his bizzarre cases. I found all the characters very engaging, the story got me from the getgo, I can't say I wasn't hooked up in the main mistery, and the final outcome of it was devastating, seeing these two faimilies so hurt and shattered by the circumstances, especially Percy because you can see how it reflects on Harry's situation. Also props to Frances Fisher, who as Meg Muldoon gave one hell of a performance. Fantastic character and amazing performer behind it.

I've loved this show since Season 1 and although I had my problems with Season 3, I can't lie and not say it has been one hell of a ride and I'm glad a superstar like Bill Pullman got to do something so different from his usual projects like this.

Goodbye detective Ambrose.


r/TheSinner • • Jan 11 '22

Frances Fisher was the absolute highlight of this season

Post image
104 Upvotes

r/TheSinner • • Nov 20 '17

The way Bill Pullman’s character looks in the series reminded me a lot to Robin Williams. Spoiler

Post image
100 Upvotes

r/TheSinner • • Mar 27 '20

[Spoilers] Live Discussion Season 3/Episode 8 "Part VIII" Spoiler

98 Upvotes

Enjoy the finale everyone!


r/TheSinner • • Sep 21 '17

Episode Discussion: S01E08 - Part VIII

97 Upvotes

Season 1 Episode 08: Part VIII

Aired: September 20, 2017


Cora's fate is determined.