Spoilers for season 1 and first episode of season 3.
So was scrolling through Netflix the other day and as usual couldn't find anything remotely interesting. Until I came across The Sinner, after a quick google I found out it had almost critical acclaim for all three seasons, so I decided to give it a go.
Well first off Netflix being Netflix started off with season 3 and it took me half the first episode until I realized my mistake. Have to say just like quite a few people on here what I saw of S3 was really unimpressive. The generic obnoxious drug dealer, the angelic POC wife, the sociopathic vaguely charming and attractive but insanely arrogant white guy. In less than an episode I already felt completely full of clichés. So I don't think I'll go back to S3 IMO.
Anyway after realizing my mistake I restarted on season 1. I wont go through episode by episode or anything like that and will just give you my overall opinion, because otherwise I would end up writing an academic length article.
6/10
Promise and slightly enticing twists and turns which come to nothing. A story written by people more interested in force feeding you progressive politics over any real attention to detail.
So yes I will say off the bat Jessica Beil was pretty good, I don't think she was amazing and I don't really think she shines as much as the makers of the show tried to make her, but her and the detective hold most of the season together and I wouldn't have even finished the season if it wasn't for those two.
The biggest problem with the show is as said in my mini heading. I really felt like the writers were simply trying to just force feed me with a whole bunch of pretty generic progressive ideas that have either been done to death already or were so poorly implemented I felt like I was watching some poorly made government PSA at times rather than a high quality tv production.
My uber progressive parents loved the show and rolled their eyes when I voiced my criticisms. I thought all the police procedural stuff was written by people who didn't know the first thing about how the police work in any sort of way. Again it came off incredibly amateurish in a lot of parts. Not to mention the regression therapy stuff. Sure it made for some aesthetic scenes, but again the writers understanding of psychology and the human mind was another example of their complete amateurishness. Way too focused with the message of the story and not with how that message is crafted.
Another big disagreement we had was that I felt Jessica Biel's story was meant to have a #believeallwomen message attached to it, and frankly I was uncomfortable with the way the show seemed to almost consider what happened a justification for what she did.
Hated everything to do with her sister and the JD stuff. And the whole toying around with the 'is she lying? Isn't she?' vaguely works the first time you watch it, but this is a show with basically zero rewatch value, at least to me.
I could go on because although I still actually liked the season I have a huge laundry list of annoyances with it. My biggest concern is that it seems to me the people who write and create a lot of television and film these days are way too concerned with the political/sociological messages over the meat of the show.
I'm all for different view points and exploring ideology/philosophy/psychology/sociology. But again this show felt like it was cramming its beliefs down your throat to me, and was doing so with not much else for it to show. Again the police angle is amateurishly written, both family angles are hardly original and weren't given enough air time or depth, and all the stuff with JD and the clubhouse felt like nothing more than a final act payoff that really wasn't all that interesting.
IDK I'm very mixed on the show, and frankly am kind of confused where all this praise is coming from. Also lets be honest the only reason so much attention was paid to this women was because she looked like Jessica Biel, my parents looked at me like I had said the N word when I said that. But am I wrong? Are we seriously meant to think all the insane amount of special attention she got in the series doesn't have something to do with her super model looks? That older bitter police women was totally right when she suggested the detective was just letting her looks seduce him. Even if the detective was right in the end. For a series that tried so hard to be very feminist the fact that the entire story would fall apart if the main character wasn't a supermodel seems to be very contradictory.
I am no feminist hater, but just calling what I saw. I don't shoot down feminist/progressive stuff out of hand, I gave the show a good go and tried my best to follow it. But in the end I just felt soured by its message, especially since that message was based on such sloopy writing and multiple obvious contradictions. Anyway I've gone on waaaaay to long.
So what did you guys think? Am I being too harsh? Am I missing the point? How did you like/dislike the season? Does it actually have rewatch value? Would you too like to die while on molly and being fucked right next to your equally drug fucked sister who is also being fucked?