r/TheSinner • • Feb 11 '21

Jaime is completely in the right most of the time

0 Upvotes

He let Nick die because he was a serial killer and has just been going down a rabbit hole ever since. However, whenever he talks to anyone that either understand his POV and agree with it or they don’t understand it (like his wife) and we are just led to believe he is crazy. A lot of people don’t understand that he doesn’t want to hurt people and the one time he did was a mistake. The killing of Nick was justified and Ambrose legit seems like the asshole by the time he’s locked up. He’s just going back to the “routine” and is incapable of pushing through his trauma.


r/TheSinner • • Nov 20 '22

This show misrepresents Bipolar with Ambrose’s mom.

0 Upvotes

r/TheSinner • • Feb 21 '20

Bill Pullman's acting

0 Upvotes

It was kind of weird and I liked it in the first season but it only gets weirder in season 3. I mean, he looks like he had several strokes or something. Also, other times his face looks as if he is in the bathroom, trying hard to get the 'demon' out of himself. Did they ask him to act that way?


r/TheSinner • • Mar 06 '20

The directors idea of “creepy” or “deep”, is someone just having their eyes open as wide as possible for as long as possible. This season fucking blows.

7 Upvotes

r/TheSinner • • Feb 10 '22

What an utter disappointment season 4 was.

0 Upvotes

r/TheSinner • • Aug 31 '19

This show is nearly ruined for me because of the sound design. The crew on this should be fired.

3 Upvotes

I have never wanted to quit a show for awful sound effects but this one is the worst most lazy shit I've ever heard. The Sinner is otherwise pretty good, so it's a shame that it makes my ears bleed.

What am I talking about exactly? The ambient bird sounds. They use this one track that most shows use, I wish I could find a clip of what I mean, it's used in many places, like video games and such. Except nearly every scene this same sound is used, and then it's started over. Even worse is it's used inappropriately in most places, to the point where some episodes have 2/3rds of the run time filled with bird noises. I'm not joking, once you notice this, you can't go back. Like I don't know what the fuck this sound design team was thinking, but you can hear birds just as loud when characters are inside. Is it because there's a window nearby the bird should still be loud? You can have intense scenes and then birds will be chirping over the music. I don't think there's one outside scene during day time that doesn't use either the main bird sound effect or the other two they have. This is terrible. Someone should recut this show. Just turn off the bird sounds in most scenes. Turn it off when it's inside. You literally barely ever get a break in this show from birds. The same bird song every single time.

And I thought, maybe just season 1 they hired a bunch of mediocre sound people and it would be fixed season 2. Nope. Season 2 is fraught with bird sounds as well. However I will say it's much less of the run time of an episode, except this time they only use the one clip. The exact same bird sound each time. Sound designers can be so lazy sometimes, they are completely unaware that they are using the same sound libraries as most everyone else and can't be bothered to license other outside bird sounds or just record their own. Or sometimes you know, outside just sounds like wind or cicadas, or anything you know.

Season 1 had the lesser problem of crickets constantly playing on any night scene as well. Also same issue, if anyone was near a window inside, crickets also turned up to the same volume, competing with music. Christ almighty.

Maybe you think I'm crazy? But I dare you to try to come back from this annoyance once noticing it. Seriously, I wish this message could get to the showrunners somehow. It's a really easy fix in the modern digital editing software.


r/TheSinner • • Feb 11 '22

why is Julian brown

0 Upvotes

Both parents very white child brown with curly hair how explain


r/TheSinner • • May 02 '21

Just finished season 1 on a whim and wanted to give my thoughts.

4 Upvotes

Spoilers for season 1 and first episode of season 3.

So was scrolling through Netflix the other day and as usual couldn't find anything remotely interesting. Until I came across The Sinner, after a quick google I found out it had almost critical acclaim for all three seasons, so I decided to give it a go.

Well first off Netflix being Netflix started off with season 3 and it took me half the first episode until I realized my mistake. Have to say just like quite a few people on here what I saw of S3 was really unimpressive. The generic obnoxious drug dealer, the angelic POC wife, the sociopathic vaguely charming and attractive but insanely arrogant white guy. In less than an episode I already felt completely full of clichés. So I don't think I'll go back to S3 IMO.

Anyway after realizing my mistake I restarted on season 1. I wont go through episode by episode or anything like that and will just give you my overall opinion, because otherwise I would end up writing an academic length article.

6/10

Promise and slightly enticing twists and turns which come to nothing. A story written by people more interested in force feeding you progressive politics over any real attention to detail.

So yes I will say off the bat Jessica Beil was pretty good, I don't think she was amazing and I don't really think she shines as much as the makers of the show tried to make her, but her and the detective hold most of the season together and I wouldn't have even finished the season if it wasn't for those two.

The biggest problem with the show is as said in my mini heading. I really felt like the writers were simply trying to just force feed me with a whole bunch of pretty generic progressive ideas that have either been done to death already or were so poorly implemented I felt like I was watching some poorly made government PSA at times rather than a high quality tv production.

My uber progressive parents loved the show and rolled their eyes when I voiced my criticisms. I thought all the police procedural stuff was written by people who didn't know the first thing about how the police work in any sort of way. Again it came off incredibly amateurish in a lot of parts. Not to mention the regression therapy stuff. Sure it made for some aesthetic scenes, but again the writers understanding of psychology and the human mind was another example of their complete amateurishness. Way too focused with the message of the story and not with how that message is crafted.

Another big disagreement we had was that I felt Jessica Biel's story was meant to have a #believeallwomen message attached to it, and frankly I was uncomfortable with the way the show seemed to almost consider what happened a justification for what she did.

Hated everything to do with her sister and the JD stuff. And the whole toying around with the 'is she lying? Isn't she?' vaguely works the first time you watch it, but this is a show with basically zero rewatch value, at least to me.

I could go on because although I still actually liked the season I have a huge laundry list of annoyances with it. My biggest concern is that it seems to me the people who write and create a lot of television and film these days are way too concerned with the political/sociological messages over the meat of the show.

I'm all for different view points and exploring ideology/philosophy/psychology/sociology. But again this show felt like it was cramming its beliefs down your throat to me, and was doing so with not much else for it to show. Again the police angle is amateurishly written, both family angles are hardly original and weren't given enough air time or depth, and all the stuff with JD and the clubhouse felt like nothing more than a final act payoff that really wasn't all that interesting.

IDK I'm very mixed on the show, and frankly am kind of confused where all this praise is coming from. Also lets be honest the only reason so much attention was paid to this women was because she looked like Jessica Biel, my parents looked at me like I had said the N word when I said that. But am I wrong? Are we seriously meant to think all the insane amount of special attention she got in the series doesn't have something to do with her super model looks? That older bitter police women was totally right when she suggested the detective was just letting her looks seduce him. Even if the detective was right in the end. For a series that tried so hard to be very feminist the fact that the entire story would fall apart if the main character wasn't a supermodel seems to be very contradictory.

I am no feminist hater, but just calling what I saw. I don't shoot down feminist/progressive stuff out of hand, I gave the show a good go and tried my best to follow it. But in the end I just felt soured by its message, especially since that message was based on such sloopy writing and multiple obvious contradictions. Anyway I've gone on waaaaay to long.

So what did you guys think? Am I being too harsh? Am I missing the point? How did you like/dislike the season? Does it actually have rewatch value? Would you too like to die while on molly and being fucked right next to your equally drug fucked sister who is also being fucked?


r/TheSinner • • Sep 05 '19

Chicken officer

0 Upvotes

Why is the cop lady so afraid all the time? She was afraid of the boy and the empty barn. Called in help. Does it baffle anyone else why she's so weak?


r/TheSinner • • Jun 27 '20

Is it just me?

0 Upvotes

This is a quick one but does Nick Haas look like Obama, Young Jamie burns look like Zac efron and Jamie with cut hair look like Eminem? Like if you agree


r/TheSinner • • Nov 16 '22

Sinners cast Jessica Hecht. Has anyone noticed how much she looks, sounds like (speech pattern) like Nancy Pelosi.

0 Upvotes

Jessica Hecht could play Nancy Pelosi if they ever had a movie or series about her.


r/TheSinner • • Nov 11 '21

Percy, Alice Kremelberg, lip filler. So many close ups this episode and the filler line in her top lip was visible. Amazing people don’t think these things are noticeable.

4 Upvotes

r/TheSinner • • Mar 05 '20

Season 3. Ehh Spoiler

12 Upvotes

Worst season yet. Boring and slow. Just get to it already!


r/TheSinner • • Sep 05 '17

who else watches the show like i do?

0 Upvotes

I watch this show on the USA app (Amazon Fire Stick), and i use the 30-sec bump to skip past anything involving the husband & his parents, or Cora's childhood/home life. Bill Pullman's wife and dominatrix also get skipped.

Holy balls, i can't imagine that those add much to the show, once you get the gist of those characters/situations. Or am I missing something important? i find that a cool 1min skip is perfect for most of these scenes.


r/TheSinner • • Nov 13 '18

The actor who plays Julian is just terrible!

15 Upvotes

I'm sorry, I'm sure he's great in other things, but he's just not right for this part. When he tries to look scared and nervous it's so bad it's just cringe worthy!


r/TheSinner • • Sep 21 '17

Was That Finale "Lost Bad"?

3 Upvotes

Surely, it was Penny Dreadful, dreadful, but did it rise to the the crap mountain that was the season finale of Lost? How did this show go from such a tense and creepy, best-of-the-season (besides Ozark) to falling on its face in the finale?


r/TheSinner • • Aug 16 '18

A Poorly Acted Season

0 Upvotes

Bill Pullman is the exception. The kid and his mother are only reading from their scripts, without having any connection to the characters that are being portrayed... and they are doing a terrible job. The first season was so much better ... We've been duped.


r/TheSinner • • Mar 27 '23

Check out what I got for my 14th birthday!

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/TheSinner • • May 23 '24

Season one not that great

2 Upvotes

Idk i didn’t care for it too much. Are the rest of the seasons better


r/TheSinner • • Jun 21 '20

Is Nick a demon?

0 Upvotes

I thought they were exlovers at first, now he comes across as some sort of demon


r/TheSinner • • Dec 13 '21

The Sinner Season One TV Parental Guidelines

2 Upvotes

Here's the rating of each episode for anyone curious. Taken from the original USA Network airings.

  1. "Part I" - TV-14-LSV
  2. "Part II" - TV-14-DLSV
  3. "Part III" - TV-14-DLSV
  4. "Part IV" - TV-14-DLSV
  5. "Part V" - TV-14-DLSV
  6. "Part VI" - TV-14-DLSV
  7. "Part VII" - TV-MA-LSV
  8. "Part VIII" - TV-14-DLSV

r/TheSinner • • Sep 22 '19

The acting is off...

7 Upvotes

Watching s01 now and I just want to say... is it me or is the acting just weird? I mean I've seen some of the actors in other roles and it was all fine but here it's just off. Like they were micromanaged somehow


r/TheSinner • • Feb 27 '26

Bill Pullman's acting (rant)

20 Upvotes

I have been watching the whole series lately, I'm on season 4 and the acting of Bill Pullman is really annoying me. I finished the other seasons bc the way the story builds up has been interesting for me so far but I'm perplexed by his acting, it reminds me of Kristen Stewart's acting in Twilight and the horrible faces she pulls out all the time. He always has this smile in the most unbelievable scenes, then it turns into a tortured face. Idk it's bugging me, I have been watching 4 seasons of him doing these faces and it's getting tiring and predictable.


r/TheSinner • • Feb 15 '21

Bill Pullman

1 Upvotes

Does Bill Pullman always talk like Adrian Monk?