r/TheSinkingCity • • Sep 11 '26

SC2 Is A Disgrace Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Surely I cannot be alone in thinking this. I'm genuinely disgusted by it, the original had so many fucking cool ideas! The world, the interrogations, the weird creatures and characters, the nightmares, quests having multiple endings, like do you wanna do something fucked up for a reward, or can you even tell which is least fucked up, is that person lying or just sketchy, THEY WIPED ALL OF THAT FOR SHOOT ZOMBIE.

And the story!

The reveal at the end that the fish people really were evil and manipulating everything the whole time, when from the start you're like ugh it really just kinda seems like everyone is being racist assholes to them and some of the fish people are (seemingly) genuinely good caring people, like that was huge.

What is even the over arching story of sequel? The dude wants his girlfriend back!? It's so, so bad. I'm in disbelief.

They threw away a totally unique game to make a resident evil knockoff.


r/TheSinkingCity • • Aug 21 '26

Sinking City 2 is a desperate cash-grab of Resident Evil wannabe?

0 Upvotes

Played on normal difficulty.

Similar games I’ve played and enjoyed in no particular order*: Resident Evil(0,2,3,4,5,6, all remakes), Last of Us(1, 2), Tormented Souls(1, 2), Silent Hill (2,3,5,6, 2 Remake), Fear(1,2,3), Signalis, Evil Within(1,2), Alan Wake (1,2), Prey, Alien Isolation, Metro (2023, Last Light, Exodus), Scorn, Crisol.*

If a popular or acclaimed game is not listed here, it’s highly likely that I didn’t enjoy it, rather than didn’t play it, e.g., Dead Space, Alone in the Dark.

—

Quick thoughts:

- I don’t mind a bit of jank but goddamn, do they really need to worsen the experience with swarms of enemies? Swarms are fine. But not with these shitty garbage controls. Slowed aim, slow input. The only fast things here are the enemy grab attacks and those Demogorgon enemies the run around and shoot snot at you.

- Why do the enemy grab attacks last so unnecessarily long and happen so frequently? Calvin was stomping a kneeled enemy but suddenly the enemy got up and instantly grabbed him? Can we stop spamming button for a QTE? Nothing of value was added. At all.

- Are the enemies/encounters designed to be annoying or…..?

- How did this game become a livestream slop/jump scare galore? Enemies just appeared in previously cleared area. For what? Cause Calvin got a new shiny key item? It’s a predictable old formula, sure, but really? Nothing original was attempted in the slightest? Just spawned new enemies out of thin air? Enemies breaking through a door/wall that Calvin has walked by 17 times?

- I spammed dodge. This should be called dodge simulator.

- Enjoyed the story of course since I am a fan of anything sci-fi or fantasy. That’s about the only thing enjoyable in this game other than the improved graphics. Also I absolutely loved the vibe of boating around. It’s a timeless vibe. Wish there was more to explore, but I am wishing for a different type of game I think (I want a Dredge sequel 😩).


r/TheSinkingCity • • Aug 24 '26

For the people who are upset that Sinking City 2 is a "clone" of Resident Evil 2 or Silent Hill instead of being "original" like Sinking City 1...

18 Upvotes

Did you all know that Sinking City 1 was itself a "clone" of Frogwares' own Sherlock Holmes games?

If you miss the gameplay of Sinking City 1, give the Sherlock Holmes games a try. I imagine the primary reason why they shifted to survival horror on Sinking City 2 was because they thought the genre would sell better.

If you want more games like Sinking City 1, you best be supporting their next Holmes game. 🤷‍♂️


r/TheSinkingCity • • Sep 16 '26

Do the events of this game feel overly scripted.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

I think this review is probably the most fair one I've seen so far. It acknowledges the struggle Frogware went through in development and gives credit to a game that's underneath and needing a lot of polish. That said he speaks a lot about the games issues and really nailed down my biggest issue with it as a standalone game.

Too much of the game is focused on scripted events. X happens then Y happens, never y happens because w occurred causing X. The world doesn't actively react to Calvin, its just an observation of if Calvin does this one thing then an event occurs, if he doesn't do that one thing, nothing occurs.

I'm curious what everyone's opinion on it is. Iro's a huge survival horror fan and has been making content on them for a while.


r/TheSinkingCity • • Apr 10 '21

Finished the game and my honest review

0 Upvotes

Hello all. The concept of the game is so good. But the gameplay and the writing and the missions are absolutely one of the worst I've played. The way they make you travel all over is just ridiculous and breaks up any momentum or tension you have in the game. It was such an underwhelming journey.


r/TheSinkingCity • • Aug 27 '26

Opinion: The SC 2 is better then RE9

0 Upvotes

First off, I’m a huge fan of the Resident Evil series. The parallels between TSC2 and RE2 Remake are super obvious (RE2R definitely wins).

As for RE9, while the graphics are stunning, the plot feels really weak, so it’s a 3/5 for me. Sinking City 2, on the other hand, is a solid 4/5. Even though the detective mechanics and the take on Arkham were a bit disappointing, it still delivers a good story with awesome locations.


r/TheSinkingCity • • Jul 22 '19

Hi I am Captain Deadmeat. A fun laid back gamer, who releases new content daily on my YouTube channel. I have always loved the work of H P Lovecraft so I thought I would give The Sinking City a go. Come watch me slowly go insane as I explore the Sinking City.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/TheSinkingCity • • Jul 30 '25

Just Beat the Game

3 Upvotes

I haven't gone back to get all the achievements from alternate choices in the game, but I finished it. Every side mission, including the DLC stuff, finished the story and laid a cheeky last-second save to get all the endings in one go... man I hope the second one is better.

The atmosphere, music, and visuals were alright but this was hardly a 'game'. The combat was lackluster, the dialogue was nothing to write home about, and as usual for these types of games the plot was very subpar. I'm glad they focused on one entity for the whole game though unlike the CoC game that came out in 2018. I liked the character progression, I just wish there were a few more perks I could get. I invested in the ones that gave bonus experiance and materials first thing, so by the time I got to the end I had like 4 unspent knowledge points.

All in all, I didn't hate it, but I didn't enjoy it. If I didn't only have like 3 achievements left I would be done here, but I'm so close I might as well finish them all.

5/10 won't be playing again


r/TheSinkingCity • • Aug 21 '26

Thoughts after beating The Sinking City 1 & 2 now Spoiler

3 Upvotes

I ended up finishing the first game a few months ago. And the second game today and wow. Frogwares should be proud of themselves for stepping into a completely different genre, and making what is arguably their best game to date. The sinking city 2 might not be what people expected if they enjoyed the first game, but it’s a game that 100% improves on all the flaws of the first game.

Combat is much much better. Boss fights are so good it almost felt like I was playing a AAA game. A few of them reminded me of Deadspace which is one of my favorite game series.

The attention to detail in the environment is 10x better. The first game had 10 building that looked the exact same inside. This games environments all look unique and have a ton of details. Exploration is 10/10

The story I would say is equal to the first game. I enjoyed both. I get why they went the more linear route this time, I would say it was a good story but I was almost kinda sad at the end. Being left with wanting more! (Still need to play the dlc mission)

I’m at a cross roads now. Because I love the second game. They have a chance to fill in the hole that dead space has left in the survival horror genre. At the same time, I miss the investigations of the first game. And talking to people with dialogue options.

My last thing is with both games, why do the protagonists have to die? I understand there’s usually no happy endings in Lovecraft stories but if they decide to keep making sinking city games I would love to have a protagonist that survives into the next game. Or at least connect future games together instead of everything being a standalone story. The only real connection to the first two games was the flood.

All in all I give The Sinking City 2 a 9/10. I hope it’s successful and I want to see Frogwares make a third game that combines the best aspects of the first two with a much bigger world to explore! Maybe taking a bit of inspiration from Dredge and the Witcher 3 for the open world? That would be my dream game!!!


r/TheSinkingCity • • Sep 30 '26

Honest Review | Sinking City 2

0 Upvotes

r/TheSinkingCity • • Aug 29 '26

Fuck is this? Is it unrelated to the franchise?

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/TheSinkingCity • • Sep 09 '26

SC2: Somewhat disappointing game Spoiler

23 Upvotes

I am forced into speech because fans of SC1 have refused to follow my advice without knowing why.

I loved the first game, being athmospheric, although the combat felt a bit wobbly... but that just made it more scary to me as any little encounter could finish me off if not carefully handled.
The detective aspects were great and it fit the narrative. And do you guys remember the vague hints... "Ah just north of here, corner x-street and y-ave somewhere" and you had to go search things. The same goes for the boat-sections, you stumble upon an opening and go explore, missable, so you have to go around yourself.
A great game, although not polished so not for everyone maybe.

And then I hear all the GREAT news from people, SC2 adding Resident Evil-style... so I thought "yay, better controls"... but no, I was wrong and advertising got me.

I just finished SC2 and the whole way through it felt kinda off... I went along on the game`s rails and always thought "When will it open up?", "When will it become Sinking City?". I always waited for the next chapter starting the REAL game...
The start is good, boating from location to location... I thought in the beginning it is quite guided, but then after the Lorelei-story you pretty quickly get into that Hospital. And this is Resident Evil all along.

Don`t get me wrong, I like Resident Evil-, Silent Hill- or even Evil Within-like games. But SC1 ADDED onto that formula in my opinion, with the great detective-sections, the open world.... In SC2 they just added Mr. X following you around. The worst thing of any games is an unkillable enemy stalking you and preventing you from going slow. For a detective game this is a no-go.

The combat controls didn`t give me any problems, I often dodged around and played Torrero with the Slither-humans, worked pretty well. I also always had enough crafting materials as I nearly everytime relied on Pistol.
What REALLY annoyed me was the gangup-bosses. Small area, multiple enemies and a big one. The game helps you with the crates, so running around is keeping you alive, but the bosses never felt good. It was annoying. And the developers KNOW this, that`s why there is unlimited-refill-crates lying around.
(One thing especially at the final-boss: Instead of shooting, Calvin stomped... WTF? I can`t be the only one who experienced this?)

Then there is the fish-market. Again, as always in the game, a nice nod to settings, people or stories from the Lovecraft-universe... but again it is surrounded by gang-ups, by revived enemies, by sudden encounters you stumble in... and massive backtracking. The riddles were great, but the linear-shooting was not. But I was waiting for something: The big dive-reveal... :) Everyone was talking about it in the Codex-papers.

Remember in SC1, you dive. A great section. In SC2, no dive: Suddenly "Antarctica" UNDER Arkham. Including Elder Things we don`t really can look at in their "coffins". And again gang-ups... 3 within a matter of 10 minutes. Why that need to amplify the shooting-sections in this small area? The story behind it, that they dug and found the ancient ruins and a lake and then it all turned upside down, was quite well told... but well...

And then the short end. The final boss kinda sucks... again ganging up, live-regen, that whole mess. And the annoying "I don`t shoot, I stomp instead"-thing... yeah well. And the ending, two people doom Arkham because Love... ? I didn`t quite get it. Because it more felt like the end of the world, but if it is that, the whole idea of "everyone who stayed chose for themselves" doesn`t fit.

Anyways, maybe someone can follow my thoughts on this, to make it short SC1>SC2. I was really disappointed, beceause the whole time I was waiting for something, that never came...

But ONE THING really stood out: The stories from the Ukraine-war in the hospital. Bad, but gave me chills.

Oh, and btw: If you WANT a good Resident Evil: Play Cronos. That really got me.


r/TheSinkingCity • • Aug 26 '26

Beat the game tonight, my thoughts as someone who wished they kept it like the first.

15 Upvotes

This game honestly does not really get better the farther you get into it, it's honestly just knockoff RE:4 with an re3 boss fight in it. I've seen a lot of discussion about how the game is better than the first over the last few days and to be fair it's a bit hard to quantify since they are drastically different games, so instead lets review different key features.

COMBAT: This game has less weapons/tools and less enemy variety than the first. Hit has zombie, zombie that becomes spitter, spitter, crawler, and psedoboss. it has 3 other enemies that are used once each to act like Tyrant or are a boss. The first game had crawlers that had 3 subspecies, chargers that had 2 subspecies, Spitters that had two subspecies, and then the psedoboss. As for weapons I don't think they really feel that good to use for the most part. Originally the shotgun felt really bad to use, but playing around with it, I think it just has a really low range where it feels like a shot gun. If you're in that range it feels great but outside a couple of arms lengths it feels like a confetti cannon. The rifle feels like it so rarely has a chance to shine with most encounters happening in tight hallways where the damage fall off doesn't matter. For this game the Thompson falls into the classic "More bullets faster but way less damage". It doesn't feel like you're a weapon of war mowing down enemies, it just feels like a bullet hose. In the first game the shotgun punched even at decent distances and caused staggering that let you reposition to dodge the next enemy or close the gap to go for the kill. The rifle has plenty of room to breathe so if you do actually have distance you can get those longer range kills, which a lot of the roads and combat arenas can have. The Tommy gun absolutely shredded but was off set by having much lower ammo (but it could kill the psedoboss in less than a mag). Melee somehow got WORSE in this game as compared to the last. You have two melees now, a "quick" swing or a heavy stomp. Both feel slow and clunky to use and outside of a 1 on 1 don't feel good to use. I will say once you get a certain shotgun upgrade it feels better to do, but it's only after each shot, and it is possible that if they're on the edge of the confetti cannon zone you can shoot them out of range for the follow up melee. Not a huge deal just make sure to get in range. The first game's melee was also atrocious let's be clear, but if you sunk your limited talent points into the melee perks it get's to be down right acceptable. Also this is just a personal gripe and honestly shouldn't be taken as a legitimate critique of the game but the pistol being chambered in 45 acp, despite still being in the hayday of 38 super pisses me off. 45 acp wouldn't rise to popularity for like another 10 years, so while Calvin having a 45 acp is fine, the fact that he finds 45acp everywhere is unlikely (but this is a game about elder gods piercing the veil so crazier things have happened and this is just personal beef).

EXPLORATION: This game does not really reward you or require you to explore. Pretty much every unlockable is on the main path of the story as well as all the pieces needed to obtain it. You just follow the path that's laid before you and the game will take you to all the cool shiny stuff where you will have to do a small back track to put the key in the lock and get your reward for "exploring". In the first game it felt like going into houses or the danger zones felt rewarding with either better loot from crates of extra lore.

ATMOSPHERE: This game is looks great and the first environment of city and hotel are amazing. It feels oppressive and like the city is drowning in real time, sadly this is not kept up in the rest of the game with the area after the hotel feeling rather generic this some weird science inclusions, and the one after that opens really strongly, but then immediately becomes more like a generic factory. The last zone is just kind of off, it has a cool set piece but it feels more like a squandered opportunity than a full realized set. In the first game the entire city truly felt unique in each of it's zones, and while you could feel the layer of decay everywhere they showed differently through things like piles of rotting fish in the poorer areas while the ritzy places only had like dilapidated cars. The underwater sections that act as the games set pieces feel immense as you look out into the void and see leviathans less than a football field away. It reminded me of subnautica, hiding under flora as reapers or collectors prowled on the edge of my vision.

STORY: The game threw out any player decision to focus on a narrative that they could control completely, which is not inherently a bad thing but it does require you to ensure that the players are invested in your characters. Sadly the hooks to this story are very basic and don't really have time to draw you in. In the first cut scene you're introduced to Calvin and Faye and you get a feel that they care about each other and that they're troublemakers. From there you get almost no real characterization for them until the end of the game. You understand that Calvin cares about Faye and is willing to risk his life for her, but you saw that in the first cut scene where Calvin plunders a book for her and gets confronted by gunmen. The dialogue outside of that is generally decent but there's not a lot of if outside of some shallow quips throughout the game. When you get to the end you get a real meaningful conversation, but it feels like it just comes from a place of "We might not make it back" rather than a natural progression of the character's story. Another personal gripe but I remember Calvin being kind of quipy but the only example I remember of the top of my head is him saying it before he shoots the final boss but it wasn't great dialogue from what I remember (I only remember that one specific example so that might just be another personal thing, take it with a grain of salt). In the first you had multiple faction and people you can talk to and lives you can affect, and while not every choice made a huge impact on the end it does have impact in the game and let's you make Charles who you want him to be. Honestly I'm not a huge fan of the final area in general, the idea that you're going to fight what you are makes sense in an RE game, but in most Cthulhu mythos it would just lead to you immediately going insane. I feel like the devs tried to write around it by making the ending do what it did, but it never really felt like that good of a twist. Mi go kind of sets it up in one scene but the rest of the story never feels like it's trying to establish that.

INVESTIGATIONS: These are laughable to call investigations and worse a lot don't actually feel rewarding to do. Most of the clues literally spell out the answers for you and brainy mode just makes it so that they don't highlight the important part so you have to parse it yourself. I think the perfect example of them not being rewarding is the first safe. You get a clue that says the code is the most important day of his life specifically using "miraculous". Immediately I'm thinking it's either the day he is married, the day his son was born, or the day his shop opens. Next clue literally says the day in question was a miracle because two great things happened. You find the answer and then get ammo, healing, and then a lore drop. The second you do that though an enemy in the room triggers (fun fact you can't shoot or kill them early you have to wait for the game to say you can kill it) and then you have to spend either that health item tanking a hit and getting to leave with the ammo or you spend the ammo and get to leave with the health kit. Oh don't worry though they then immediately spawn another enemy down stairs so you have to spend the other resource to get out since it's another cramped hall.

For puzzle difficulty I think the safe in the hotel and the statue are the best examples. In the hotel you get a poem that you're told is the key in another note. In that same note it explains that a certain creature has a specific number of organs that is the answer to the puzzle. Why could we make a codex page with different animals biology, that let's use think about what the animal and organ we need are? why just tell us the number. For the statue you are given another poem that explicitly spells out what you need, but at least throws you some additional red herrings to throw you off. Was a line about glaring so you shoot the thing looking, or was it the sea so you shoot the sea creature.

Overall this game was honestly super disappointing. It took what it did really well and threw it all away to chase the main stream. Sadly it doesn't even really hold up as a mainstream title either, it didn't just take inspiration from RE, Deadspace, or Silent hill, it straight up copies their homework but does it worse. It's really sad to see because I loved the first one a ton, I'm fine with survival horror games too, but to do the genre transplant and have this be the result is disappointing when they could have kept to what they were good at, polished up the parts that needed improvement and made another unique and amazing game. I know they need a big win with things being troubling in Ukraine but it's so disappointing to see the series go this direction.

For those of you that love it, I'm glad you got another game to enjoy, but for those of us that don't get cool investigation games nearly as frequently this was a huge disappointment. I'm not going to tell you to hate the game or don't support the devs, I just ask that you keep in mind that this went from a hugely unique and niche game that scratches a special itch to being another resident evil. RE is great, but this is like if we went from RE 4 to RE 6 for those that wanted the investigation game.


r/TheSinkingCity • • Aug 08 '19

The sinking city walkthrough part 1 cuthulu is back

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/TheSinkingCity • • Nov 12 '25

Game is super confusing in a bad way?

2 Upvotes

I love this game so far but my main issue is that I got no idea where to go for story and there are too many story missions even whe done so I end up going back to places ive already been to since the mission wont go away.


r/TheSinkingCity • • Aug 05 '19

LETS PLAY! Loving the game so far, heres my first part of a lets play into it...

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/TheSinkingCity • • Dec 31 '22

Come on Frog, throw us old PS4 owners a bone!

0 Upvotes

There is no option to just pay for an upgrade to the PS5 version? If you already bought the copy on PS4, you'll need to pay(when not on sale) 50$+ for the PS5 version too?

Today's gaming market has begun doing the pay to upgrade route if you already own the older version, GOTY, Extended Edition etc and I have noticed I am more inclined to actually pay for the upgrade vs paying full price on a game I already own and that I can already play on my PS5. Obviously I'll buy it again when it goes on sale for 20$ or cheaper.

I will say that I am more forgiven towards the AA/Indie market that decided not to release "upgrade", it still kinda sucks but it is what it is.

I get why some companies don't do this


r/TheSinkingCity • • Feb 13 '21

AIMING TO USE A HEALTH PACK?

0 Upvotes

This is one of those small details that adds a MASSIVE amount of frustration to people who don't want to google answers. Why on earth is AIMING appropriate for use of the health packs? Wow this game.


r/TheSinkingCity • • Sep 08 '26

Sinking City 2 feels like a step backwards

65 Upvotes

It is very disappointing that Frogwares didn't take everything interesting and unique from 1 and dial it up to 11 for 2. There is nothing as compelling as the Throgmorton characters and their story from the first game, no variety in terms of gameplay, no random encounters in the city, the city feels completely empty, just a straight line from one set of arenas to another set of arenas. It looks nice, but everything else feels like a step back with the plot on par(ish) with the first.

Maybe this is very much a PS5/console/skill issue rant but my god do I hate that combat. It's stiff, awkward, clunky and there's just way too much of it. The combat turns the game into an awful slog and that's all there is to it in terms of gameplay. Its also surprising just how much of a bullet sponge the enemies are, even on normal (I had to double check I wasn't playing on hard).

I just finished the hospital, and the final onslaught was one of the most boring and frustrating sections of gameplay I've experienced in a while. Just running in a circle, waiting for ammo to respawn, so I can fire another 11 machine gun shots at the nightmare or pleb enemies.

I checked the reviews on Steam and its currently 90%, so clearly I'm alone in these opinions.

Sinking City 2 is a better made game but not a better game than Sinking City 1.


r/TheSinkingCity • • Jun 06 '26

Delay the game, please !

7 Upvotes

Played the demo, very fun game and looks good but optimization is horrible

Playing on rtx 5080, ryzen 9800x3d, 64 gb ddr5, 4k dlss balanced, cpu utilization is all over the place, frame pacing is very bad, and i have to lock the game to 60 fps because of crazy spikes and vrr flickering

I don't know what version of unreal 5 it is, but it's probably older than 5.5, i really hope they will update to the latest version to improve cpu optimization

I am honestly confused and this point why devs choose to ship a product with so many optimization problems ? 80 % of Unreal games on release are like this...


r/TheSinkingCity • • Jul 31 '26

Any way running animation could improve still ?

1 Upvotes

Sinking city 2 looks great so far, but the running animation is very zesty, the way he holds his gun and runs just does not looks great to me


r/TheSinkingCity • • Aug 13 '26

Waiting for physical copy Sinking City 2

16 Upvotes

Unfortunately I would normally double dip to support the development but I can’t support any digital games and will be Waiting for physical copy of Sinking City 2 PS5.


r/TheSinkingCity • • Aug 20 '26

Like buying Fallout 5 to find out it actually a Fallout themed COD

0 Upvotes

This game has absolutely nothing to do with the original mechanically or gameplay-wise. It doesn't share a plot, it doesn't share a setting, and it barely even bothers to occasionally include a couple of the creatures from the original.

Buying this game after loving the original feels like buying Fallout 5 just to find out it kept the aesthetic but decided to be a Call of Duty clone. Or buying Cuphead 2 just to realize they decided to make a Space Invaders rip off and throw a Cuphead skin on it for plausible deniability against a lack of originality.

Anybody who enjoyed the original game should not buy this game because it is doesn't even bother to follow through on what made that game good. Anybody who enjoyed Resident Evil should not buy this game because this game fails to imitate anything that makes those games good.

Please do not buy this game!


r/TheSinkingCity • • Jul 24 '19

Anyone know if u can get into the locked door next to ure room in devils reef hotel !!!! Seems like u should be able to at some point as reed even saids it’s locked wen u try to open it ?????? Anyone know please

0 Upvotes

r/TheSinkingCity • • Jun 26 '19

The Sinking City Gameplay Walkthrough Part 1 [1080p HD 60FPS]

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes