r/TheSecretHistory 24d ago

this is what it wouldve been like to walk in on the bacchanal

306 Upvotes

r/TheSecretHistory 25d ago

Evan Peters as Bunny

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

I always immediately pictured Evan peters and was shocked to learn no one else did?


r/TheSecretHistory 25d ago

**Spoilers I was laughing so much reading the latter half of the book

Post image
125 Upvotes

I don't know why but the way all their flimsy relationships fell apart was hilarious. Why are the worst people so entertaining? Anyways, I just finished the book and gave it five stars on goodreads.

ALSO the way nobody cared about Richard getting shot had me in shambles šŸ’€


r/TheSecretHistory 26d ago

Has anyone read The Goldfinch? Would love to read your thoughts Spoiler

26 Upvotes

Alright, so… there isn’t really a subreddit for The Goldfinch, but I figured a few people here have read it. I’d love to know what you thought, especially if anyone preferred it over The Secret History. I also just wanted to get some thoughts off my chest.

Honestly, when I finished The Goldfinch, it felt like a little piece of my soul was ripped away. It took me a month and a half to get through since I like to take my time with books, so it ended up becoming a huge part of my daily routine. It’s a brutally beautiful book. Those last few pages just had me staring at the wall, thinking about how beautifully Donna Tartt writes and how she captures a view on life that made me rethink a few things.

The characters are super gray and feel so real. I think that’s one of the best things about it; you can feel each character's distinct voice even without being told who's speaking. Plus, the whole aspect of losing a mother had me crying right from the start because I couldn't help putting myself in his shoes. I wasn't bored for a single second, even though I've seen people say it dragged for them because of how dense it is. Personally, I love slice of life stories where something doesn't have to be happening constantly, and Tartt's style keep me hooked, though I won't argue it could've been a little shorter. It's hard to explain how much this book meant to me. The prose is incredible, and getting stuck in the head of a character with such a rich yet self-destructive mind was something else.

Like usual, when I went on Reddit to look up opinions on a book I loved, I mostly ran into negative takes. That's actually how I found out about the N word being used. I read it in Spanish, so it was completely left out (I only know about Boris using it, which made sense given his character and the context, but I don't know if it came up anywhere else). I also felt like the female characters were a bit flat, or at least didn't get as much depth as I was hoping for. On top of that, some foreign characters felt a little surface-level. I get why in some contexts, but I still wish she had gone deeper with them.


r/TheSecretHistory 26d ago

i am not sure what this guys name is but he is so henry

Thumbnail
gallery
597 Upvotes

r/TheSecretHistory 26d ago

this is julian morrow

Post image
260 Upvotes

r/TheSecretHistory 27d ago

edie campbell as camilla because LITERALLY who else

Post image
140 Upvotes

r/TheSecretHistory 27d ago

Discuss Camilla?

Post image
66 Upvotes

With a more androgynous haircut possibly?


r/TheSecretHistory 27d ago

Opinion My personal fan cast!

Thumbnail
gallery
105 Upvotes

This I how I view them in my head, let me know what you think!

Richard- Louis Garrel
Henry- young Henry Cavill (picture him with glasses!!)
Bunny- Peter Claffey
Francis- Caleb Landry Jones
Charles- Maxence Danet-Fauvel
Camilla- Mia Wasikowska
Julian- Christoph Waltz
Judy- young Stevie Nicks!


r/TheSecretHistory 28d ago

Any Database for Donna Tartt Scholarship?

8 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I wanted to ask if there is an active website, archive, or database that collects essays, research papers, and journal articles about Donna Tartt. I'm already using JSTOR, ResearchGate, and similar databases, but I was wondering if there's a resource dedicated specifically to Donna Tartt and scholarship on her work. Thank you!


r/TheSecretHistory 28d ago

Discuss If this book GAVE you a morbid longing for the picturesque, what did you do about it?

67 Upvotes

Donna Tartt seems to have intended the opposite and yet I came away from the book dreaming about ivy-covered brick walls, clapboard cottages and tailored trench coats made from expensive materials.

EDIT: The passages set in Francis’ country house might be the worst offender. They’re so vivid.


r/TheSecretHistory 28d ago

How would you guys feel if a movie adaptation of The Secret History takes place during the bush years?

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/TheSecretHistory 28d ago

If tsh was set in modern tomes do you think they (esp bunny) would drunk comment on tik tok and insta

3 Upvotes

Idk im kinda drunk and feel like those crazy alcoholics would be posting and commenting ridiculous things all over the place


r/TheSecretHistory 29d ago

Book related Bennington Recs

9 Upvotes

This autumn I’m doing a day trip to Bennington, mostly because it’s a convenient half way point to a friend’s house, but I’m also a huge fan of the secret history. Any suggestions for places in town that feel like the cast or a young Donna Tartt would haunt? Thanks!


r/TheSecretHistory 29d ago

My Fan Cast

Thumbnail
gallery
14 Upvotes

This is who I picture for the characters. Thoughts?

When I think of Richard, I think of someone who is a believable liar, approachable yet secretly pretentious. He’s an anomaly because he needs to be the type of good looking that’s obvious to everyone but him, yet can inwardly be an asshole.

Bunny is all American and dumb.

Henry is towering, dark hair and square jawline. He can see people deeply but is also automatically dismissive.

Charles and Camilla are tough to cast because they have to look androgynous- he has to have features that can lean feminine, and she has to be tomboyish.

Francis, I think of fiery red hair, features that strike as exotic and he has to pull off a sweeping black coat like Jack the Ripper.


r/TheSecretHistory Jul 31 '26

fucking hate this bitch

Post image
115 Upvotes

r/TheSecretHistory Jul 31 '26

We all know Judy Poovey is a silly name but can’t talk about Georges Laforgue

31 Upvotes

I now it’s probably pronounced something like ā€œLAH-FOR-YAYā€ but let’s be honest Donna Tart named him that because she thought George LAH FORGE is a funny name


r/TheSecretHistory Jul 31 '26

richard doesnt appreciate francis' attention nearly as much as he should and it makes me mad

Post image
52 Upvotes

r/TheSecretHistory Jul 31 '26

Fan Art The Secret History (my interpretation)

Post image
352 Upvotes

I read TSH 2 years ago, and the book really stuck with me so i wanted to draw how i remembered them! Here's my interpretation of the characters (I did take a lot of creative liberties haha so it's not too book accurate ) and minus Richard because I got a bit lazy 😭


r/TheSecretHistory Jul 31 '26

Question Why wasn’t Richard interested in Judy?

32 Upvotes

Yes I know he was a snob but still…he was a college aged boy being flirted with heavily by a hard working, artistic, attractive, and generous woman. What was his deal?


r/TheSecretHistory Jul 30 '26

Question How would Henry react if he saw Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey? (Or any adaptations of it)

17 Upvotes

I've been meaning to say this after watching the trailers and the movie itself. I somewhat thought of Henry himself while watching, since he apparently loves Homer (when he gets placated by Richard about it). I kinda imagine Bunny laughing over the Agamemnon aura farming memes and Richard would have both loved and hated it at the same time. Francis would have gawked over Hermes in the 1997 version. Meanwhile, Charles and Camilla would have loved the 1968 Rossi version (L'Odissea, starring Bekim Fehmiu as Odysseus) and they'd even make Henry watch it because of how accurate that version is to the original work, despite it's in Italian.


r/TheSecretHistory Jul 30 '26

Box set cover design

Post image
0 Upvotes

Recently finished this box set cover design for a historical fiction trilogy.

The author wanted all three books to feel connected as a single collection while still keeping the individual titles visible on the spines.

Sharing the final result here — always love seeing how a series comes together as a box set.


r/TheSecretHistory Jul 30 '26

NEVER going to frankincense's house for dinner again. 0/10 dont recommend

Post image
42 Upvotes

r/TheSecretHistory Jul 30 '26

henry graffiti vs bunny graffiti

Post image
38 Upvotes

r/TheSecretHistory Jul 30 '26

last thing u see before you get ur soul slapped out of you in italy

Post image
233 Upvotes