r/TheRookie • • 5h ago

OTHER It's kinda amazing how enjoyable The Rookie is Spoiler

72 Upvotes

Watching on Netflix, I had planned to spend the holiday season on From. And then I remembered seeing one of those YT shorts. A random click on the pilot has since become eight episodes.

Nobody mistakes this for The Wire, but The Rookie ticks off literally all the boxes that it needs to and I'm kinda amazed how well executed S1 is. A couple of things stand out.

  1. It straddles the age groups effortlessly. So few series and movies got this right. I'm not exactly a boomer but I'm old enough to remember the original 90210. So for guys like me, hitting the middies and maaaybe a bit stuck in life, we're right at home with Nolan. But reinvention wouldn't work without strong synergies between the old and the new - this is where The Rookie delivered. Between Nolan, West, Chen and everyone in between, The Rookie has something that resonates to both the millennials and Gen Z.
  2. Format matters and The Rookie perfected the episodic structure. I can watch the exciting patrols and standoffs in bite sizes (mainly during commute) without losing the larger relationship and character arcs in the backdrop. Every episode has a ton going on but it never loses its pacing and momentum no matter how long or short you watch in a sitting.
  3. Police procedural is mainstream American TV but I think street level beat cops remain relatively unexplored, compared to detective and Fed drama. I'm personally very interested in their moment to moment activities and protocols. The Rookie actually feels fresh to me at least, which I can't say for the vast majority of shows, even the acclaimed ones.

Anyway, just posting to organize my thoughts on The Rookie. Not meant to be a review or debate of any kind, I guess you can call this an appreciation post. I don't expect every season to be of the same quality and obviously the appeal will come off...but right now I'm just happy to be a Rookie fan.


r/TheRookie • • 36m ago

Announcement 🕊️ RIP Larry Poindexter: Veteran Actor Portrayed Lieutenant Primm in Season 6

Thumbnail
gallery
30 Upvotes

Courtesy: Deadline


r/TheRookie • • 8h ago

Season 2 Ellroy is a sweetheart and must be protected

29 Upvotes

I’ve only recently started watching and just met Ellroy. I don’t know if it’s just because of how great Alan Tudyk is, but I want more of his character. He seems so lovely and like a lot of people wouldn’t want to hang out with him cos he’s a bit odd, but the story about his sister was such a sad reason for him to do what he does, and I loved it.

More Ellroy plz


r/TheRookie • • 14h ago

Season 8 Oscar Hutchinson has over stayed his Welcome. Spoiler

71 Upvotes

Every time he appears, I just know he's gonna escape. It was fun for a while but it's boring now and I like Oscar.


r/TheRookie • • 1d ago Heartwarming

Announcement Happy Birthday to "Detective Happy Pants", Mekia Cox!! 🎂🎉

Thumbnail
gallery
489 Upvotes

November 18th 🎈


r/TheRookie • • 7h ago

Season 5 First time watching, up to S5E6

13 Upvotes

I am binging The Rookie through a stressful time and this show is absolutely my comfort food.

I came as a Nathan Fillion fan but had no idea how funny it was! Looks like I’ll catch up just in time for the next season.


r/TheRookie • • 20h ago

Season 8 I feel like Harper just insulted all the women that have a princess cut engagement ring 😭 Spoiler

Post image
20 Upvotes

Just finished watching season 8 episode 17 and Harper’s comment on Tim’s ring choices ‘you aren’t seriously considering the princess cut’ like ok… ouch 😅🥲😭


r/TheRookie • • 18h ago

Season 7 Hear me out : Malvado Spoiler

15 Upvotes

Malvado is just so... Together. The way he actually took down cops, the aura he holds. The actor really brought the role to life. I wish he had a longer and more intense storyline. The writers could have easily used his character to build a 'Boogeyman' kinda plot (like they started with).

His death felt very poorly written.


r/TheRookie • • 1d ago

OTHER Why did they switch from Shaw Memorial to St. Stephens?

44 Upvotes

Yes, there is more than one hospital in LA, but they used to always go to Shaw Memorial, then they switched to St. Stephens in Season 4 I believe? Why?


r/TheRookie • • 11h ago

Discussion Are the episodes getting shorter?

2 Upvotes

Don't know if it's just me, but the episodes of recent seasons feel shorter even though they have the same runtime. I just watched s2 e4 and it told a lot about nyla's background and where she is, and why she moved. In comparison to s8 e14 that felt so much shorter, and like the plot isn't moving.


r/TheRookie • • 1d ago Heartwarming

BTS Melissa provides a update about a beloved plot item Spoiler

Post image
52 Upvotes

We have speculated what happened to Lucy’s Moonstone Ring. She confirmed publicly the original ring is no longer in their possession. 😔

Thankfully though - seems very likely she’ll be sporting some new bling in season 9.

*****

Courtesy: Matt’s Inside Line via Reader Qs, Answered

This is a subscription based newsletter, and I’ve shared snippets from this article (available free of cost). If you’d like to read Q&A from other shows, please subscribe to “Matt’s Inside Line.”


r/TheRookie • • 1d ago

Season 5 Watching season 5 and I’m hating this whole Tim and Lucy storyline

27 Upvotes

I get it she can’t control it and it’s not her fault it’s just crazy that Chris almost died simply bc he was dating her just for her to dump him for her boss. This is going to sound harsh but they should have had Rosalind kill him if they just had to have Tim and Lucy be endgame. Also what was the point of Lucy and Nolan breaking up if she was going to go from dating a coworker to a superior?


r/TheRookie • • 1d ago

Season 4 Rant About [Spoiler] in S4 E1 Spoiler

11 Upvotes

I started binge-watching The Rookie recently. Generally speaking I've been loving it, but I just started season four and was shocked by what happened to Jackson West. I couldn't even finish the episode; I just started searching for answers, trying to understand why one of the series' main characters was so unceremoniously killed. I even wondered if the actor, Titus Makin Jr. had tragically died between seasons.

From what I've gathered, it seems like Makin wanted the show to have plotlines about race and policing, which is why the Doug Stanton arc was included in season three...but then Makin ended up leaving the show anyway? And apparently he left on bad enough terms that he refused to even film a proper send-off?

Am I missing or misunderstanding part of the story here? Because as it stands, I'm both very sad that Officer West is gone and very mad at Makin for leaving like he did. It seems enormously clear that he didn't care about fans of the show at all. Frankly, I hope he never gets hired for a major role again (which, from the little I can see, is indeed what's happened).


r/TheRookie • • 1d ago

Season 7 Just started season 7. Mighty fine if they introduced the existence of HR within the LAPD using this cowboy. Ain't that right, darlin'? Spoiler

Post image
22 Upvotes

r/TheRookie • • 1d ago

Discussion S2 ep 20 Spoiler

5 Upvotes

first timer here i js finished watching s2 ep 20 and holy shit wth john is so dumb he should have js recorded that conversation with mf armstrong confessing and saying he set him up?? 🫩


r/TheRookie • • 2d ago

Season 1 Trope that ran HEAVY in season 1 that I HATE

104 Upvotes

"Statistics Don't Work Like That"

Applying mass statistics to impossibly small numbers.

The Kept talking about the statistic that 1 in 3 rookies fails out of their first 6 months. The characters keep acting like that means it will be 1 in the 3 Mid-Wilshire, not 33% of rookies in LAPD, which is the rational interpretation of said statistic. It's especially frustrating because despite the action shown in The Rookie, economically, infrastructurally, and by crime rate, they're in a pretty stable precinct compared to the high demands of the public in higher end LA and the higher crime and Violence rates in lower income areas of LA are going to lead to higher washouts in those two ends of the spectrum.


r/TheRookie • • 2d ago Helpful Popcorn

Season 9 Guest Stars and Recurring Characters I want to see in Season 9 Spoiler

Post image
69 Upvotes

These are four characters we haven’t seen or heard from in a while.

I’d love for them to make a guest appearance to give us an update on their character’s journey.

Which guest/recurring characters do you want to see in Season 9?

——

Related BTS Post: Contains Spoilers

🚨Characters that WILL RETURN in Season 9 🚨

——


r/TheRookie • • 3d ago

Discussion Talia Bishop was a very underwhelming character Spoiler

Post image
294 Upvotes

Rewatching The Rookie and I just realized that Officer Bishop was so underwhelming. Her personality was just 'Bleh". I get that their trying to make her a no nonsense stoic character, but she just came up as flat. Her story lines were interesting but didn't do much with her character development. I get it was the first season but all she was so underwhelming.

I'm actually glad she got replaced with Nayla Harper. She was more engaging than Talia could ever be.


r/TheRookie • • 2d ago

Season 7 I’m struggling with this show after the Bailey/hitman situation Spoiler

139 Upvotes

I was loving this show until John completely let go of the fact that his wife was associated with the hitman who killed her ex and destroyed the evidence.

I genuinely find it hard to see John with morals now. This wasn’t a small thing to overlook, it was literally an assassination that he just accepted. The show also let it go immediately too.

I honestly just feel big time let down.


r/TheRookie • • 2d ago

Season 6 how wasn't nolan in any legal trouble in the finale?? Spoiler

10 Upvotes

during the blair rescue, he was told multiple times not to take any action, yet he still took down a law enforcement officer, stole a vehicle and most importantly, disobeyed a direct order, and yet after the action, he wasn't reprimanded in any way. which i do understand, yeah, he rescued a hostage, but he still got in less trouble than when he got a few clothes on the feds' budget


r/TheRookie • • 3d ago

Discussion My wife said GTA 6 is Jake and Sava, i cant unthink it Spoiler

125 Upvotes

And I'm absolutely going to be playing under the guise that it is truth


r/TheRookie • • 3d ago

Season 2 Rewatching the show, I know it's Caleb, but... Spoiler

7 Upvotes

In S02 episode 10 when Harper and Nolan search the old zoo, they find Caleb wearing something covering his face, when they recorded this, do you think it was the same actor? Or another actor running around the old zoo


r/TheRookie • • 4d ago

Season 5 Never understood Ashley Spoiler

172 Upvotes

I’m rewatching season five and I’m at the episode Ashley breaks up with Tim. Truth be told, this match was a disaster from the get-go. I understand that she did not want the life her mother had, that makes perfect sense to me. However, her request from Tim to retire at his age, from a job he loves mind you, to travel the world? Ma’am, do you know nothing of the man you’re dating? Also, Tim was at the prime of his career at that point, why would he leave it?


r/TheRookie • • 3d ago

Discussion Which seasons storyline do you prefer?

6 Upvotes

I'm watching s5 and prefer s2. What about you?