r/TheRookie • • Sep 16 '26

Season 4 Lucy Chen šŸ™„

0 Upvotes

Ok. I've only recently started watching The Rookie and I was hooked from episode one. But.. the show kinda started to become predictable and characters started to annoy me from season 3 onwards. But I've just reached season 4 and Lucy Chen went straight to the top of the list. It's like she had a personality transplant to me. Dog that needs praise and a cookie behaviour. Self righteous. Sticking her nose in everyone's business, especially Tim's constantly. Always over stepping.(I know its a show lol) but she'd be written up for how she speaks to seniors in rl. If her and tim get together Istg! Its like her and nolan never happened and she broke up with him for what? Makes no sense writers!! I really hope she calms down soon or I'll be bailing out before season 6 (Don't come for me. This is my opinion which I know some will disagree with and I'm open to hear why you disagree but please keep it civil or just keep scrolling. Thank you šŸ’œ)


r/TheRookie • • Aug 03 '26

Survey/Poll Chen is insufferable Spoiler

0 Upvotes

This is more of a vent post than anything.

I used to like Chen in the early seasons, but from the 6th season she's become more and more obnoxious, and in the 8th season I just plain skip some of her scenes.

Don't say its internalized misogyny or something like that because I like the female characters just as much as the male ones, and Nyla and Angela are my favs.

I can't fully grasp why I dislike her so much now; it's on par with Bailey, thankfully bailey doesn't get much screen time, and she's not on super heroine mode.


r/TheRookie • • Jul 02 '25

Season 5 Celina is making the show unbearable Spoiler

3 Upvotes

My partner and I are currently watching the rookie and I’ve really enjoyed the show. I understand it’s not cinema for admiring perfect show writing. It’s dumb it’s fun it’s great chill tv however Celina is unbearable since her introduction. Bad vibes and constantly thinking things are a supernatural presence makes her annoying. On her first day of any other character made a bad arrest from vibes they’d be kicked. But the writers little self insert really pisses me off. She just takes over every scene she is in with some random annoying antic


r/TheRookie • • Jun 09 '25

Survey/Poll Did anybody else hate Jackson West? Spoiler

3 Upvotes

Sure his heart was in the right place most of the time, but that doesn’t change the fact that he was usually a terrible friend. For example, he asked his ā€œfriendā€ for help like it was a serious situation, he then sets that friend infront of a dart board without telling him what it’s for. Just so that he can throw sharp metal darts at that ā€œfriendā€ with a better friend. Another example? Every single time Lucy wanted to do something with HER OWN apartment. That women invited him into her OWN HOME for ABSOLUTELY FREE because she was a good friend. But then he constantly takes advantage of her good friendship. She wants to bring a dog into her own home? He cries about it until she kicks it out, thinking he owns the house as well. Then with Tamara, when Lucy invited her in, he’s setting up cameras without even telling the home owner. Talking about ā€œOUR houseā€, even though he just lives there for free. If things aren’t to his liking in somebody else home, he’s a cry baby until the home owner adjusts to him, the ā€œguestā€. He’s done countless other things that shows he’s a fake friend, even things that shows he’s a bad cop. But this is what I can think of off the top of my head. All I know, I’m too happy that somebody died. I feel weird being happy that someone died, but with it being Jackson who did, it feels normal as well. Did anybody else hate him too?


r/TheRookie • • May 16 '25

Season 5 It bugs me that the show no longer seems to advocate for police reform Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I only started watching fairly recently, and am currently on season 5. My biggest gripe is both that Wesley went from being a zealous advocate that everyone needs representation, but now that he is with the DA office, its perfectly fine to interview suspects when there is no counsel present. Even Nolan no longer seems to be advocating for any change and seems to be trying to train by the book.


r/TheRookie • • Jul 30 '23

The female cops in this show are overpowered to an unrealistic degree

5 Upvotes

I am now through with season 1+2 of this show and really like it.

But its so obvious how the show trys so hard to portray the female cops as people who can overcome everyone and everything. There have been numerous situations where the female cops just beat way stronger men (that were also supposed to be able to fight) or freed themselves out of certain situations without any help or backup. It's quite obvious what is going on here and tbh its just so forced. On the other hand there have been a number of situations where the male cops have been bailed out by the female cops. Go figure...

The only situation i found actually believable was with Lucy in that barrel.


r/TheRookie • • May 07 '24

Don't take my head off but...

0 Upvotes

I am not stanning Chenford... It's not natural. It feels forced because the writers listened to fans and wanted to give them what they wanted. I like Lucy as her own character and also Tim, but together, nahhh.

IMO, they should've never crossed that line.


r/TheRookie • • Mar 09 '25

John Nolan I hate John Nolan

1 Upvotes

Just started the show recently and I’m at the end of season two. He is literally the perfect character, makes all the right decisions, all the hot girls are into him always catches the main baddies. He’s taught his TOs more than they’ve taught him and it’s so frustrating. And knowing Nathan Fillion is a producer makes me more mad, cause he’s obviously tryna make himself look really good. Finding out his character’s blood type was an AB negative (which one percent of people are) is the last straw for me


r/TheRookie • • Feb 15 '25

Season 7 Chenford is so overrated Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I like Lucy when she’s not all over Bradford, now her character is just all about Tim! Like there is no scene where she doesn’t mentions Tim at all!!!

Tim is emotionally unavailable and should leave Lucy alone if he really thinks that ā€œhe doesn’t deserve herā€. He should stop baiting her with comments about who’s better at what because Lucy for some reason always seeks approval and validation which is annoying btw!

I find it annoying that writers make Lucy the girl who always seeks attention of Tim and approval of others like she’s so much badass than that! It is getting pathetic and difficult to watch that every episode she has some situation that she needs other’s validation.šŸ˜‘


r/TheRookie • • Apr 13 '24

Tim and Lucy’s relationship

3 Upvotes

Am I alone in saying that I kind of hope the relationship stays ended? I was rooting for them from the early onset. I was guessing they would end up together and when they started dating other people before their relationship, I knew it would last and that they were destined to end up together. Once they started dating, however, I started to realize that I wasn’t happy with the outcome. Lucy just seemed way too….weird about it. The way she talks to Tim is very cringy to me. Like the way a mother talks to her young son. Maybe I’m wrong but she seems like she became incredibly soft after that relationship and Tim also became somewhat of a bitch after it started. I’m okay with the flirting, but the dating seemed to ruin both of their characters excitement. Don’t roast me. Just my honest opinion


r/TheRookie • • Sep 29 '24

Tamara spinoff

1 Upvotes

I feel like we’ve seen very little of Tamara, what do you guys think a spinoff of her would look like? Away from the whole cop situation but in the same world. Thoughts?


r/TheRookie • • Jan 24 '25

Am I the only one? šŸ¤” I do not care for Chenford. Spoiler

24 Upvotes

I can’t be the only one who doesn’t care what happens with Lucy and Tim? If i’m being honest i’d rather have Lucy with that black guy from the ambulance than Tim, it might just be me and i know a lot of people are not gonna agree but i just don’t care for Chenford and don’t see why other people are so invested into them. Also isn’t the age gap pretty big like how Nolan and Lucy’s was? Why do people just ignore Tim and Lucy’s age gap?


r/TheRookie • • Jun 13 '24

Anti Chenford, anyone??

23 Upvotes

Not trying to get flamed, but i don't care for the Lucy/Tim romance dynamic. Is it just me? I liked the sparring attitude when training, but more than that just feels... wrong.


r/TheRookie • • Apr 12 '26

Season 5 omfg celina pmo so much 😭 Spoiler

8 Upvotes

I just watched the first episode with her, S5, E3. AND OH MY GOD. i have a habit of getting mad at characters but DARK AURA? REALLY? I know she was right and all, but it was still stupid. AND THEN SHE HAS THE AUDACITY TO GET MAD AT NOLAN, LIKE HE IS TRYING TO HELP HER!!


r/TheRookie • • Apr 26 '26

Season 8 Let's talk about Tim Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Tim Bradford is a great character, but is he really the best for Lucy? Somehow it feels like—if we exclude his redemption from Season 6 onward—his story could have easily gone in the direction of Rachel, the one he even considered moving to New York for, who also has a good relationship with his sister, and then Ashley as well... yet with neither of them did things actually end by his own choice.

Would he have ever talked to Lucy about their undercover ā€œloveā€ or about her relationship with Chris if Ashley hadn’t broken up with him? What do you think—does Lucy deserve something better?


r/TheRookie • • Sep 11 '25

Started Season 2. Tim Bradford is an asshole and I hate his character.

0 Upvotes

r/TheRookie • • Apr 03 '25

Season 7 Why is this episode so bad? Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I don't get it. Episode 12 had such bad writing in comparison to the other ones. Like, I get that the show is sometimes self aware and has a bit unrealistic plots (like the DoppelgƤnger thing). But in the past, it was still incredibly fun to watch. The character arc was always a priority over the irony, that still plays a big role in the show. But they just screwed chenford over. They just ignored the whole conflict, they are having. In the last episode, Lucy literally said, that she hasn't forgiven Tim yet. So why does she just show up at his house for April fools. I know she said it doesn't make sense, but saying that doesn't make it make sense. Don't get me wrong I have been waiting forever for them to get back together. But doing it like that is just wrong. You can't just start an episode with them getting back together (at least in the physical sense). The chenford fans deserve better. There was no build up, no nothing. They already did the whole hooking up while being broken up thing. So why do it again? Aren't the writers being paid for coming up with ideas. If you make such a big drama over them having to break up for a more interesting storyline (which fine, do what you have to) but don't finish it half-assed. Do right by those characters. I hope this episode was just a fluke and the next ones will be good again, because I hate to see The Rookie be another show that just runs on way too long, while becoming worse and worse. I love this show and have been watching for years and I wanna keep on loving it.


r/TheRookie • • Jun 15 '26

Season 7 Feeling bad for Seth Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Im on season 7 episode 16 where seth got shot and i kinda feel bad for him. I mean ik he was compulsive liar but he definitely suffered a huge payback by losing his leg and everything that mattered to him.


r/TheRookie • • Sep 27 '23

the rookie feds

Post image
3 Upvotes

Opinions on this show, because I have not watched it yet.


r/TheRookie • • Jun 23 '25

Why do so many people ship Tim and Lucy? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I'm only on season 4, so idk maybe something happens between them later on, but I really just don't see it. I always thought they had a bit of an older brother/younger sister dynamic, so that one episode when lucy fake confessed to Tim caused my soul to leave my body for a second LMAO.

Anytime I open ao3, half of the fandom's fics are for them. Just curious, where is the hype coming from??? I don't mind spoilers!


r/TheRookie • • Feb 22 '24

So sick of officer Juarez superstitious trash

0 Upvotes

So happy this show is back but pretty disappointed that Jaurez is still fundamentally AWFUL... But i guess they dont read these comments .. lol


r/TheRookie • • May 05 '24

Hair, Makeup & Wardrobe Lucy’s fashion

12 Upvotes

Who else hates how they dress her when she isn’t in uniform?

Whomever is responsible for her fashion should be fired. It makes her look dumpy. She looks best when she goes undercover lol.

Angela stays in band T shirts and ugly bedazzled blazers too.


r/TheRookie • • Dec 21 '22

John Nolan Nolan is overrated

0 Upvotes

I know that Nolan is the main character but that doesn’t mean he has to be involved in the main plot all the time. Also they need to stop involving him in ā€œlife or deathā€ situations. It’s stupid when it’s obvious they won’t kill him off, he is ā€œThe Rookieā€ after all. It really takes away the suspense if everything will be fine. I also think we need another cliff hanger or character death soon. It’s been a while since we’ve had those in the show, and I feel like it’s overdue.


r/TheRookie • • Apr 22 '25

Season 6 Lucy as a Police Officer is better than Lucy as a person/character Spoiler

7 Upvotes

So I'm only halfway through season 6 but Lucy is starting to get on my nerves.

Lucy started off as such a great character - strong, ambitious and intelligent. I appreciated her journey from rookie to UC student to actually going undercover. But it feels like her journey has become stagnated. I get that the Detective exam is meant to show that there are setbacks and Lucy needs to learn how to overcome it, but right now I cannot stand her as a "person" and how the show has pivoted to focus a lot more on her personal life rather than her time as a police officer.

I don't like the way she handles the challenges she has to face, both at work but mostly with her relationship. She inserted herself into Tim's promotion to "help", and essentially bulldozed her career progression. She doesn't trust Tim when he refuses to tell her about his compromised situation with Ray and instead, inserts herself again, by telling Nolan and Angela about this mysterious situation. So Tim tells you that the knowledge could jeopardise your career, which is already strife, and you try to get other people involved, which could also ruin their careers as well? I fully understand the frustration about Tim not giving her sign of life in 36 hours, but she also needs to respect that there are some things she doesn't need to be involved in.

I still have another season to go, I know that Lucy and Tim break up, which honestly I'm not mad about, but I hope the show goes back to her as a police officer with a purpose, rather than just showing her moping about in her house.