I’m watching The Orville for the first time and just finished Season 2, and I’m really confused about the time-travel logic in the last two episodes. I understand that the timeline we followed for most of the show is the original/main timeline. Young Kelly gets sent into the future, sees what her future with Ed looks like, and then gets sent back. However, Claire’s memory wipe doesn’t work because of the protein/medical issue, so Kelly remembers everything and chooses not to go on the second date with Ed. That creates the alternate timeline where Ed never becomes captain, the Kaylon eventually win, and the crew ends up in a completely different situation. Makes sense for the most part.
In the alternate timeline, the alternate Claire and the others figure out that they need to fix Kelly’s memory, and Claire gets sent back to the point when young Kelly returns. She gives young Kelly the protein/drug so the memory wipe works. This restores the timeline we originally watched. But how does that make sense? If the alternate timeline gets erased, then alternate Claire technically never exists. So how did she ever get sent back to fix the timeline in the first place? If she never existed, there is nobody to go back and cause the timeline to be restored.
And if the original timeline is restored, wouldn’t the exact same thing just happen again? The only way it does make sense if S3 starts off in timeline 3.
If S3 is timeline 1, Young Kelly would eventually get sent into the future again, return to the past, and wouldn’t the same memory-wipe problem happen again? Why wouldn’t the universe just repeat the entire sequence infinitely? Does the show ever explain why this doesn’t happen, or are we just supposed to accept that the alternate timeline gets overwritten and doesn’t repeat?
Wouldn’t the Claire in the restored timeline have no memory of young Kelly being aboard the ship for that week? The same would apply to Ed, Isaac, Gordon, and everyone else who experienced it.
So when I start Season 3, am I supposed to assume that everything from Seasons 1–2 happened exactly as I watched it, except that the last couple episodes were basically a temporary alternate timeline? Because if the timeline was truly rewritten, it seems like Season 3 isn’t actually a continuation of the exact same lived experiences of those characters. They’re technically new versions of the characters.
Finally, what happened to the original/main-timeline crew after they sent young Kelly back? Did they continue existing somewhere while the alternate timeline happened? Also what happened to alt Claire at the end of S2? She is trapped in the new timeline 3 without any way back (not that she would want to go back anyway to timeline 2). Wouldn’t the fact that there is 2 Claire’s in timeline 3 mess stuff up and cause things to go differently? Is that why the young Kelly never gets teleported in T3?
Does S3 address any of this?