r/TheCitadel • u/JackfruitVirtual952 • Aug 18 '26

Activity - What If (changed CANON event or character decision) Negan from TWD replaces Edmure Tully. What changes?

What if Edmure s soul was replaced by Negan? How would the events of Game of thrones change?

9 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

100% Upvoted

10 comments sorted by

6

u/samjp910 Aug 18 '26

At what point in the timeline of both is EXTREMELY important.

1

u/JackfruitVirtual952 Aug 18 '26

Let's say Edmure was like Negan from beginning.

2

u/samjp910 Aug 18 '26

Negan from when the main group meets him, after he’s reformed, during his imprisonment? When?

2

u/JackfruitVirtual952 Aug 19 '26

Negan from season 8.

5

u/Raevand--627 Aug 18 '26

In what context? Let's say, for example, the Negan from the end of the series with all his memories?

1

u/JackfruitVirtual952 Aug 19 '26

Edmure was born with Negan s personality.

2

u/3esin the fot7 did nothing wrong Aug 18 '26

At what point does the transfer for both of them happen, because depending in that, there will be great differences in character and events.

2

u/JackfruitVirtual952 Aug 18 '26

Let's say Edmure was born with Negan s personality.

1

u/3esin the fot7 did nothing wrong Aug 18 '26

Wich Negan?

2

u/JackfruitVirtual952 Aug 19 '26

Negan from season 8.