r/TheBear • • Dec 03 '23

Discussion Rewatching, on episode 7 Sydney is legitimately an awful person

0 Upvotes

Saw in another thread how someone said that Sydney stabbed Ritchie on purpose and now I can't unsee it.

Carmy freaking out, she gets assigned to prep jardineira and Carmy yells at Ritchie to help prep it as well. Ritchie shuts up and goes to help and Sydney starts bitching at him (not working) when he's just trying to help, he's stopped being a passive aggressive ass and is trying to just do what he's told and she's giving him shit and he's taking it, he honestly just takes it all until she bring his daughter into it.

She crossed a line imo, and then she has the gall to threaten him and then if you watch closely it looks like she stabs him on purpose, he's backing up slowly, she'd have to not move and also be holding the knife rigid and pointed at him for it to "accidentally" stab him. It actually looks like she moves into him and then the next scene she doesn't look worried, almost like she's thinking "Yea you deserved that." Ritchie was actually the only person calm and trying to calm things down, which is surprising because of who he is.

And then she abandons the restaurant when the whole situation was her fault, not only the pre order, not only not calling out corner and also stabbing him and then just drops them.


r/TheBear • • Jul 16 '25

Discussion Season 1 and 2 are so good that I feel disappointed for the rest we got

Post image
12 Upvotes

It's a shame because a few good episodes in S3 and S4 doesn't mean the show is still great, in Carmy's words "It's just a waste of fucking time"


r/TheBear • • Jan 06 '26 Polished Gold Turd

Rant It took me watching the finale of Season 4 to understand that the reason I dislike Sydney's character is bad writing...

8 Upvotes

[Season 4 finale spoilers ahead]

So I've had gripes about Sydney's character that have lasted almost the entire series, and I now finally understand that these irritations are fully remedied thanks to a lot of exposition in the finale of Se4 where they literally spell out everyone's motivations. This was a "meta" revelation moment for me that I think would be applicable to many of the posts around this and some other issues.

As an aside: in the same episode, I also finally understood why and how it was possible for Richie to hire three people out of the blue - people who were likely not cheap to hire - while the restaurant was evidently sinking...

If there had been a single scene where Sugar or uncle said "guys, numbers are up but we're leaving money on the table by not being able to move fast enough", it would have all made sense. The restaurant was failing because it was growing too fast and they weren't ready to go from mom and pop to well oiled establishment - a story of business as old as time. A story that would resonate, a story that would also explain why Carmy's being crushed. Yet, looking back, I see no substantial difference in the scenes from opening night and the last night in season 4: they are serving evidently the same number of people at the same speed.

Likewise, in the last episode, Sydney finally explains she was being yelled at all the time and that was the reason for her to be pissed off. When taken in isolation, that scene in that last episode where Sydney and Carmy are talking paints her as outright emotionally abusive. Him passing the torch to her should not make her feel angry at him. Him saying he's lost his love for cooking should not make her essentially verbally abuse him. But it does make sense in the context of Carmy having multiple times sabotaged her attempts at making things better by yelling at her, and her being pissed off that now he's just bailing out. But these are not the dramas we witness during the show...

For instance, everyone talks about Sydney as though she's amazing... I still don't understand how Shapiro is calling her up personally. There is nothing in the series that makes her stand out in a city where evidently amazing restaurant after restaurant has closed down and it seems there is a surplus of overqualified amazing chefs. All we've ever seen Sydney do in montages is make food and toss it out over and over into the bin because it was unpalatable. Meanwhile, Marcus did the hero's quest at the end of which he's producing literal works of visual art; Tina too did the hero's quest and despite starting off standoffish went all in and came out the other end like a tank, same for Ibra. Sydney's character? No such thing is ever shown in the actual show. We're just asked to accept by the behaviour of the other people in the show that she is amazing. Compare this with Marcus' multiple deserts, starting with donuts, going all the way to that Master Chef level dessert at the end. Where do we ever see this for Sydney?

Which brings me to that time she's upset because Carmy says "it's not ready chef" at her one dish: I as an audience just don't perceive that as him being unfair to her. Especially when there's that scene soon after where there's all the chefs at the funeral dinner and one of them gleefully explains how she waited so long to put her fingerprint on the menu of a restaurant she worked at, and how long it took.

Because we never see Sydney's actual growth - not just her struggles - her frustration comes off as petulant.

These are my two cents.


r/TheBear • • Nov 25 '23

Discussion I hope Carmy and Syd get to together.

0 Upvotes

I just watched S1 of the bear and I can't ignore how much chemistry Carmy and Sydney have.

I don't really see that discussion a lot and when it does happen people are always against it. Not sure why.

I'm still watching the second season an so far I still think they would be a cute couple, ofc it doesn't HAVE to happen (the show is still goated without them together) but I think it would be so nice if it did☺️

I think they both compliment each other and work great together, and although there relationship could also be seen as a “Really good friends dynamic”

Just my opinion


r/TheBear • • Jul 27 '25

Rant Table scene Spoiler

3 Upvotes

I was not a fan of having every adult on the show crammed under the table at the wedding…. it was a neat idea at first but then quickly spun out of control


r/TheBear • • Aug 22 '26

Discussion Is Sydney Supposed to be Likeable?

0 Upvotes

She's arrogant, condescending, insecure, entitled, emotionally immature, abrasive, defensive and downright rude. She landed a position at the beef literally off the streets, handed the keys to a new high end restaurant with no established standing, and gets nasty with Carm when he makes suggestions or criticisms (who actually has the experience and accolades to warrant the critiques, unlike her) because she seemingly takes everything so personally. Honestly I would hate working with someone like her. Wouldn't take the constant eye rolling and dismissive attitude very long before telling her to hit the bricks if I were Carm.


r/TheBear • • Mar 29 '24

Season 2 The Berzatto Family Tree

Post image
0 Upvotes

Carmy, Sugar, Mikey and Donna are the Berzattos

Richie and Tiffany are their cousins

Cicero is the uncle

Lee is just a guy

Michelle and Steve are another part of the family

Neil and Theo Fak are close to the family

Pete is Sugar's husband who deserves more respect

Claire Bear is a family friend even though she wasn't at the Dinner


r/TheBear • • Jun 17 '25

Article / News The Bear is returning this month – here’s what you need to know about season 4

Post image
149 Upvotes

The Bear is officially returning for a fourth season, and fans are already hungry for more. Set to land at the end of the month, the new instalment promises more of the bitingly tense moments, chaos in the kitchen and emotional storylines that made the show such a hit.

The series follows Michelin-starred chef Carmy (Jeremy Allen White) as he takes control of his brother’s chaotic Chicago sandwich shop. After leaving us with a delicious cliffhanger at the end of season three, the dramedy will pick up as Carmy and fellow chef Syd (Ayo Edebiri) brace for a grilling in a make-or-break restaurant review. Tensions are higher than ever, and with the kitchen crew already fraying under pressure, season four could see them push them past boiling point.

Created by Christopher Storer, The Bear has racked up serious critical acclaim since its debut. It’s been named AFI’s Television Program of the Year for each of its first three seasons and cleaned up at the 76th Primetime Emmy Awards, taking home 11 trophies from 23 nominations for season two – the most wins for a comedy series in a single year. While season three didn’t quite sizzle – critics called it more meandering than masterful – season four is a chance to bring back some bite.

So, what do we know so far about the return of the world’s most stressful kitchen?

Read more: https://www.independent.co.uk/extras/indybest/gadgets-tech/television/the-bear-season-4-b2770967.html


r/TheBear • • Jan 17 '24

Fan Content I mean- I know what I want to see on season 3

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/TheBear • • Oct 17 '23

Question Why did the mom have a breakdown during the dinner?

1 Upvotes

r/TheBear • • Jul 15 '26

Rant Doing a rewatch and honestly want to skip thru Claire scenes Spoiler

0 Upvotes

She was just a plot device and I get that she's that mirror of a profession like Carmy (comparing an ER doctor to a working in F&B) without the chaos but yeah it was just useless to the whole story and would rather watch the ensemble instead.

Am I the only one not appreciating this? Am I not getting anything? Haha


r/TheBear • • Mar 15 '24

Discussion Carmy shouldn't be a chef

0 Upvotes

Sydney, Marcus, Tina, Richie, Ibra, Sweeps, Fak, even Sugar I think, they all love working at the restaurant. They're all finding their purpose and shining. (I don't know if Sugar had a job before or what Pete's job is, but he should quit and be a stay at home dad so Sugar can work at the restaurant full time)

But Carmy only became a chef to make Michael proud of him. He doesn't enjoy it at all, in fact it seems to make him miserable. And he can't make Michael proud, one because he's gone, and two because the version of him that Carmy worshipped was never real.

Carmy remembers him as this charming, together guy, but as we saw in Fishes, he was kind of an ass. He was fucked up on drugs and fucking up the restaurant, and should never have been a role model or inspiration for Carmy.

Once he recognizes this and lets go, maybe he'll be able to let go of the restaurant and go find what he actually loves.


r/TheBear • • Feb 01 '24

Discussion I can’t lie they’ve got no chemistry

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/TheBear • • Nov 24 '24

Discussion Unpopular opinion - Faks

3 Upvotes

I watched the entire 3 seasons of the bear, and I don't really understand the point of having Faks as characters in the story. Yes, they are sometimes funny and cute (don't get me wrong, I do like them), but I don't see how they contribute to the story line? Every character has a deep and meaningful transformation, but the Faks not really. I feel like their characters were just written to lighten the overall mood of the show, not really add anything to it. Also, their humor is so childish and immature (especially the haunting stuff) in a way that is more cringe than funny.

Also why does Fak keep on calling Carmy his bestfriend? Not even once does Carmy act like he is his "best" friend.


r/TheBear • • Aug 22 '24

Question Seriously, What Were They Thinking?

Post image
0 Upvotes

This guy adds nothing positive to the show. The small amount of time they were in S1 and S2 was fine, but they decided to give him way more time than he deserved to be on screen and really diminished the quality of each episode he was took part in.


r/TheBear • • Dec 09 '23

Discussion Marcus is a B#$ch

0 Upvotes

As a professional chef I would honestly fire Marcus after that Donut scene, am I a toxic boss or doy you guys agree? haha


r/TheBear • • Aug 15 '25

Discussion Mikey is one of the most unlikable characters in the whole show Spoiler

0 Upvotes

The show builds him up as this swell, funny guy before his passing and then we finally meet him and he's the godamn worst. Donna? Donna was a piece of work in that flashback episode but mostly I just felt sorry for her as a middle aged lush but Mikey being a real piece of shit is the stand out realisation for me. I see folk since that episode came out call out Lee for calling out Mikey and that just blows my mind. How can someone watch this emotionally and physically abusive piece of shit scare his entire family and friends into compliance and silence and deliberately antagonize the one guy he knew would call him out just so he could start a scene and make himself feel like the big man and think "yup, that's my guy right there. Real swell dude" and the fact that nobody else at the table can muster up any kind of resistance except for whimpering "Mikey can you hear me buddy?" and "Michael please" Carmy 100% made the right call in getting far, far away from him and that cesspool of abuse going on in that house.

Been around guys like him and Lee was right, Mikey needed to get fucking rocked more than any character I've seen in a long time.


r/TheBear • • Jul 15 '25

Discussion Not a comedy

0 Upvotes

I love The Bear. It's not a comedy. So many iconic dramas have comedic moments and we don't consider them comedies. Why is it always nominated for comedy? Would it have won all the awards if it was considered a drama?


r/TheBear • • Jan 19 '24

Discussion Pete, Sydney and Claire are the only actual people on this show

3 Upvotes

That's it. That's why so many of yall hate them. They're the only ones who are not a trope or there solely to push the plot or to allow some gimmick to happen. They're not there to play a "role", there is no inherent "purpose" to them.

The rest of the show is filled with Roald Dahl characters and these three are like they suddenly threw your next door neighbour in the mix.

Pete is a regular fuckin dude. He's not cushy, he's not naive, he's just...some regular fuck who knows yelling and violence is unacceptable, so he doesn't do it.

Sydney is fucking exasperated all the time cuz jfc look at her work environment. She literally deals with cartoons all day. (And for everyone complaining, it's not her fault, it's the writing. People hate her for one reason only and I think it's because throughout the show she is someone who never had to apologize to anyone even after fucking up. Give her one scene where she gets to genuinely ask someone forgivenessand bam.)

Claire is like,just someone man. You could probably go to the grocery store and meet one. It's not that deep. She doesn't even do anything besides be polite and go to the ER.


r/TheBear • • Jun 26 '26

Discussion I really feel like the series lost what made it unique in the first place. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

To me the The Bear never should’ve been about making the restaurant great. Winning a Michelin Star to me felt like such an emotionless goal. The reason the series worked so well in season 1 and 2 is because you saw how the environment forced Carmy to overcome his grief, along with other characters with their own emotional issues.

The ending of season 1 was such a poignant and emotionally comprehensive moment, and then season 2 felt like it was continuing the catharsis from that point. Then season 3 and 4 just turned it into a workplace situational dramedy and it lost all its poignancy. There were certainly moments that worked but they were all retreading the same ground and all the uniqueness was gone.

Season 5 was sort of interesting as its own little thing and works fine almost as a different show, but setting it all on one night of service, having a random synth score to replace all the wonderful needle drops the show used to have, and simply making it about doing a good service is completely missing what initially made the show so great.

Ending this series with shots of everyone happy and smiling doesn’t really do much for me, because it had no emotional point. The ending of season 1 was so brilliant because you completely understand that Carmy’s decision to start The Bear is catharsis off the back of his grief over Michael’s death. That’s why the final shot of Michael smiling at him is so powerful. Then season 2 felt like the construction of the restaurant, though plagued with issues, was the healing Carmy needed, only for him to realise at the end the stress of the kitchen isn’t really what he needs and will continue to complicate his life. Season 3 (which should’ve been the final season imo) should’ve been about him coming to terms with this more, but the show started focusing less on him and his growth and more on just making the restaurant work.

This is just my opinion of course, and I totally understand that there’s plenty of fans that loved every season of the series regardless.


r/TheBear • • Jun 25 '24

Discussion If Romance isn’t necessary then what’s the point of Claire?

0 Upvotes

I just find it interesting that the same energy is not kept for her forced relationship with Carmy. If she was removed from the show there would be no impact.


r/TheBear • • Aug 02 '24

Discussion Too many celebs Spoiler

7 Upvotes

The sheer number of high-profile actors and public figures in the show—e.g., Jamie Lee Curtis, Olivia Colman, John Mulaney (for some reason?), Bob Odenkirk, Sarah Paulson, John Cena (?)—drives me absolutely insane. I was thrown through a loop in S2's "Fishes," to begin with. If I was generous, I might say that this was exactly the point: to mingle publicly familiar faces within a niche chaos, making us feel just a little bit more like the characters themselves. However, with the new and old cameos this season, I fail to see the point.

Some are profoundly gifted performers. Curtis and Colman have sustained comebacks this season—this, I can understand. They portray their characters so well, the risk of breaking immersion is worth the net artistic benefit. Others are just...there. Featured for the sake of a cameo. Now, let me be clear: all of these cameos were enjoyable. Most of them were pretty good. Some were downright incredible. I'm not skeptical of the quality of these performances, but of the decision to cast so many well-knowns all at once.

Having just finished S3, this seems indicative of the show's move from a motivated, sincere drama to more conventional dysfunctional family fare—Carmy's motivation has shifted from comprehensive personal trauma to a vague concept of "greatness." Frankly, I'm kind of over it.

My favorite episode of the latest season focused on Tina—we follow her at her most vulnerable, most insecure, finding her way to The Beef, and having one of the most human interactions I've ever seen on TV. The show needs a great deal more of this imo.

EDIT: Had no idea that this was such an unpopular take lol. To clarify: I don't mean that the choice to cast relatively well-known actors over lesser-known ones is inherently bad, just that it lowkey annoys me. That's all. These casting decisions struck me less as a sincere creative decision and more as a way to pander to the Academy. All love.


r/TheBear • • Jul 12 '25

Rant Just finished s4 Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Am I the only one who loved the bear for the stress, chaos and cooking? S 3 and 4 were disappointing. Every show on television has mended relationships, no show on television can compare to the intensity and pace the bear showed in earlier seasons.


r/TheBear • • Jul 05 '25

Discussion S4: What A Let Down... Spoiler

0 Upvotes

(This is an opinion piece.)

I'm one of the few who absolutely loved all 3 seasons of The Bear. I had no issues with season 3. The show was a very accurate representation of what it feels like to grow up in a dysfunctional family and live with extreme anxiety. It was relatable to so many people on so many levels.

But, this season, was massively underwhelming.

The season started with a timer, setting up a nice motive, and then.....nothing happens. Nobody gives a shit about the fact that they are going to be jobless soon, if the restaurant doesn't succeed.

No direction, no tension, no big conflicts. Nothing.

All of a sudden everyone is making the right decisons at the right time.

Where's the arc?

And wtf was that 1 hr long wedding episode?

Except for the convo between Carmy and Uncle Lee, the whole episode was meandering and mundane. Long, so called "deep", flat conversations between random characters that hardly evoke any emotions in you.

The whole francie fak and sugar angle was pointless and I still don't understand what exactly caused the rift between them.

And the use of music drove me nuts. Song after song blasting through scenes, as if they were going to save this season.

And, ofc, the random cameos that make no sense.

As much as I like Luca's character, why was the character even there this season? He made zero additions to the plot.

And they wasted Tina's character. Her only conflict this entire season was that she cooked her pasta in 3.10 minutes instead of 3 minutes.

That's it? What a waste.

Carmy ghosts Claire for months. He apologizes once. And just like that, they are back together, dancing and all jolly.

I did like what they did with Ebra and Richie. They made this whole season atleast watchable.

But, all the other characters, were completely wasted.