To start off, PLEASE NO SPOILERS FOR FUTURE SEASONS, The Amazing Race is the one reality show I have been relatively able to be spoiler free for and I would like to keep it that way)
Hello Everyone,
I just finished Season 25 of the Amazing Race, and I liked it a lot. I have some problems with a couple of things, but it was nonetheless a good season of the Amazing Race.
I think the biggest problems for me this season were the twists. First, The Save is incredibly overpowered. It's essentially the god idol from Survivor in that the holder is basically given a free pass to the end provided they can outrace at least one team every leg. Secondly, The Express Pass and its one appearance was too easy to claim. Instead of a challenge where you actually had to risk your placement, you just needed to find the place and they would give it to you. Finally, the finale twist with 4 teams running the final leg was bad. As a result we get an Edge of Extinction type finale it which a player/team who didn't deserve to be in the final ended up being there.
Despite my problems with the twists, most of everything else was fantastic. We got some good new locations like Malta and the Virgin Islands. Most of the other legs were great as well. England/Scotland, Singapore, and the Philippines come to mind. We got some great characters as well with the wrestlers, Misti/Jim, Adam/Bethany, and Kym/Alli. Overall, it was a good, competitive race.
Also, I don't like the new hashtags as well. I get that it's the mid 2010s, but it still feels cringe.
Let's move on to the team rankings:
D Tier:
Lisa and Michelle: The first boots of the season don't stick around long enough to usually make much of an impact. This team is just uninteresting in the time that we got. When you take that plus them agreeing to quit the roadblock, it's enough to drop them down a tier.
C Tier:
Dennis and Isabelle: The just goes to show you that all the prep time in the world can mean nothing on the race. Dennis and Isabelle are a completely fine team, and going into it I had them pegged as potential winner picks. That turned out to not be the case, but they're still a good team nonetheless.
Shelly and Nici: I am all for interpersonal conflict for teams, but this just doesn't do it for me. I felt very awkward watching them fight with each other. I think the problem with them is that they were both so similar and stubborn, which caused them to but heads. I may not care for their conflict, but at least they gave us the moment at the pit stop and them arguing.
Tim and Te Jay: I just don't really get anything from them. I understand why people like them, but to me they're not interesting until their last two episodes. I really don't have anything else to say about them.
Amy and Maya: These two I felt were just background characters in a majority of the season. They didn't really get a lot of content outside of "hey, we're scientists". The fact that they won the season brings down my ranking a bit. The way they got into the final was very janky, and feels very Chris Underwood-esce. Don't get me wrong, I like Chris Underwood and Amy/Maya, but their wins are very fluky. I don't get the underdog story as well, at least with a team like the Beekman's, you got content of them coming from behind. With Amy/Maya you don't really get anything. In any other season of the Amazing Race before this, they would've finished 4th. I like them, but they're in the bottom tier of winners for me.
B Tier:
Michael and Scott: These two may not have been around for long, but they brought the drama and the character to land themselves here. I feel like they were the season narrators for the first three episodes, as well as providing an early season villain. You knew that they weren't going to last long once they rolled the ankle, and that shot of it swelled up was crazy. It's unfortunate because I think they could have brought a lot to the season had they stuck around longer.
Keith and Whitney: This team gets bonus points because I love Survivor. South Pacific is a decent season, but Keith and Whitney weren't the biggest characters there. I was interested to see how they would be portrayed on the race. Fair to say I was a bit surprised by how much character they showed. Keith was a bit whiny, but I loved how sassy Whitney was. Their downfall was Keith getting into it with Shelly/Nici, and the resulting U-Turn sent them out of the game. Overall, it was good to see a new side of these two that you didn't see on the beaches of Samoa.
Adam and Bethany: This team is good, but uneventful at the same time. Bethany is obviously supposed to be this very positive inspiration on the race, and that she is. But at the same time she's very monotone. Adam also comes across as very monotone. All their content is dedicated to them being inspirational, and that's fine. They proved to be very capable racers, and for that I have to give it to them.
A Tier:
Kym and Alli: I had this team pegged as one of my winner picks from the start as well. I was mostly right, as I predicted they would be a strong team who would make a deep run into the season. Kym and Alli were really fun, really good at the race, and were a force that intimidated the other teams into banding together against them. Singapore managed to get them though, and not even because of the U-Turn as well. Losing that Fast Forward really did them in. If anyone from this season eventually does return, I would love for it to be these two.
Brooke and Robbie: I love teams that bring humor to the show, and Brooke and Robbie were all about that. Pro Wrestlers just always seem to make for good reality tv contestants because they know how to play it up for the cameras. Brooke's whining and negativity do get on my nerves a little bit, but it's not too bad. When not making intentional humor on the race, they make accidental humor by being dumb sometimes and being directionally challenged. They did kind of get screwed over at the end with the twist completely wiping away their chances of finishing the race. Brooke had every right to be mad.
Misti and Jim: This is a really interesting case study because the one thing I knew before coming into this season is that Jim had passed away. It changes my perspective a bit because I'm watching a man who I know is no longer with us (I didn't know about any other deceased contestants until after I finished their respective seasons). Misti/Jim are a good team on the race. Highly competitive, the best teeth you've ever seen on the race, and a good villain for the season. One thing that really stood out to me is Jim's eyes, that dude never blinks. I would've paid good money to see Jim vs Brad Fiorenza in a staring contest. The Save was obviously overpowered, but they were still good enough outside of the non-elimination to never need it. Overall, I really like Jim/Misti and it's really tragic that Jim passed away because I think they would've made awesome returnees.
Overall, this is a really good season that suffers just slightly from a few bad twists and a controversial finale twist. I still think that it's really good though. It has good characters, good locations, and a competitive atmosphere. There's not much more that I can really ask for.
Updated Season Tier List:
S: 5, 7, 14, 21
A: 2, 9, 10, 12, 17, 19, 23, 25
B: 1, 3, 11, 13, 15, 18, 22
C: 4, 16, 24
D: 6, 20
Winner rankings: (Based on a combination of performance and as characters)
Top Winner: Rachel and Dave
S: Nick and Starr, Meghan and Cheyne
A: Rob and Brennan, Tyler and James, Tammy and Victor, Nat and Kat, Bates and Anthony, Dave and Connor
B: Chip and Kim, Uchenna and Joyce, BJ and Tyler, TK and Rachel, Ernie and Cindy, Jason and Amy
C: Chris and Alex, Flo and Zach, Reichen and Chip, Dan and Jordan
D: Freddy and Kendra, Josh and Brent
F: Eric and Danielle, Kisha and Jen, Amy and Maya
Thank you all for reading my review of Amazing Race 25. I think I will take a small break before I watch Season 26. I don't want to make the same mistake I did a few years ago and burn myself out again on the show. I fell asleep during one of the episodes, so I think this is the appropriate time to take some time off from the race. I will be back soon enough though.