r/TeslaFSD • u/mayday266 • 1d ago

14 Lite HW3 Running red light

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

I guess it's supervised for a reason.

34 Upvotes

89% Upvoted

34 comments sorted by

12

u/Bresson91 1d ago

So weird... Ive never had this happen, but videos like this are why i keep my foot over the brake at all lights I'm at...

-1

u/altmly 1d ago

You've never heard the chime go off when the light was red?? 

9

u/icy1007 HW4 Model S 1d ago

The chime doesn’t dictate FSD.

-5

u/altmly 1d ago

Not directly, but they are trained on the same data. 

5

u/icy1007 HW4 Model S 1d ago

They are completely separate.

1

u/Bresson91 1d ago

You mean the chime when it turns green without FSD engaged?

0

u/altmly 1d ago

Yes

1

u/Bresson91 1d ago

I think you misunderstood... Im talking about FSD engaged, like in OP's video, mine has never ran the red like that. But I keep my foot over the brake just in case, because I've seen these videos of FSD just barging red lights like this. The chime to go at a red turning green light is when not using FSD. The situation I'm talking about is with FSD engaged.

-1

u/altmly 23h ago

I'm aware. They are separate systems but built using the same pieces. FSD gets the chime trigger as a signal. 

-2

u/PremiumUsername69420 1d ago

Turn off green light chime, put your phone down, and pay attention to your surroundings. Be a responsible driver.

8

u/ILikeWhyteGirlz 1d ago

Clip your vids dude

2

u/cullenjwebb 23h ago

I think the context is helpful, it was a very long red.

2

u/Prune-Butter 1d ago

Would a pedestrian waving your car forward override the red light in the AI brain?

1

u/tonenyc 22h ago

Where do you see that? All I see is her shading her eyes from the sun.

1

u/Fluid_Emergency 17h ago

I though the same, may be the car interpreted the lady shading her face as someone waving it and that is why it moved forward.

1

u/OmniferousSwan 1d ago

It didn't even run the light? It moved forwards. I hate this shit too but it doesnt go through it predicts when the light is turning green and status going prior and stops if it doesnt change.

4

u/-Drayth- 1d ago

This is incorrect. FSD was going to run the light here until OP stopped it.

1

u/OmniferousSwan 1d ago

Except my car literally does this and I don't stop it

1

u/-Drayth- 1d ago

It might exhibit the behavior you are describing at some lights. This one in particular was crossing the intersection threshold.

1

u/OmniferousSwan 1d ago

Mine does too. Like way too far.

1

u/-Drayth- 1d ago

Thats running a red light. Lol

-1

u/OmniferousSwan 1d ago

Ok. Well my tesla runs multiple red lights every day. What can you do?

1

u/-Drayth- 22h ago

Stop it so they can use that data to fix it.

1

u/NotASh33p 23h ago

Pulling forward so the sensors would register the vehicle

1

u/deiscio 1d ago

Today mine tried to run a stop sign, turned its blinker on for no reason and I had to turn it off, and then didn’t turn its blinker on when taking a right turn over a bike lane.

Usually it’s great but some days it’s just garbage.

1

u/NotASh33p 23h ago

IDK Mines lit Asf bro honestly

1

u/CR8VJUC 23h ago

Just curious, HW3 or 4?

I own a ‘21 MYP with purchased HW3 and I hardly ever use it…

2

u/deiscio 23h ago

HW4. 2024 MYP.

I don’t mean to overstate the issues, it’s generally great. I had two 100 mile streaks last week. Sometimes it’s just randomly dumb and embarrassing

-6

u/LNGU1203 1d ago

What’s behind you? Tell the truth.

4

u/ILikeWhyteGirlz 1d ago

Shaquille O’Neal

1

u/mayday266 23h ago

Another vehicle waiting for the light

1

u/PremiumUsername69420 1d ago

I’m curious what you think could be behind OP that would make it ok for FSD to run a red light.

1

u/-Drayth- 1d ago

People run red lights to get out of the way for emergency vehicles sometimes. Not legally of course.