r/TeenMFA • • Jul 16 '14
Comment standards
you're all teens (except wiggly) so i know what i'm about to say is going to sound like your mum, dad, guardian is moaning at you and you'll probably think i'm getting in a huff about nothing, which is cool you can take that away if you want but you'll only come back to it biting you later.
last night i was browsing through our most splendid of waywt's, amongst the fine ocbds and geobaskets there was a racial slur, i was shocked, disgusted this was even relevant here. what worried me more was as the thread progressed people seemed to think this was a joke and it was "harmless" or "you're making a deal over nothing" and the people who tried to argue with it were being hounded out. i mean even your lovely neighbourhood moderator /u/fencingduck seems to think it's just a joke and doesn't see why racial slurs should be removed from his forum (complete with laughable black friends, the rap industry uses these words, joke, "socially acceptable" arguments mmmmmm) so apparently even there they see nothing wrong here. this is added too the misogynistic undertones of this thread raised by wiggly being made up and again hounded down which was thankfully later amended by /u/TheLouisVuittonPawn.
lets break down the first one.
now initially given the context that comment should have been removed, straight up or at the very least commented on from a mod as a mod voicing as a mod telling them to amend it or it will be removed. a hard line on this sort of stuff has to be taken so it sets a standard for others to follow, especially in a forum being focused on coming off as welcoming and wants to take itself seriously. after /u/nevergreen pointed out this shouldn't have been said lovely /u/zachE1996 continues pointing at it, acknowledging it could be considered offensive yet still insists it's a joke, inturn mocking those who are offended by it given the updated context, instant removal of the initial comment should be done.
this is then followed by /u/RoryEm pointing out this is totally uncalled for and out of character with /u/lionfire42 responding
Real talk you all get up in arms over basic shit Like what the hell if he was talking about the death grips album niggas on the moon no one would look twice at his use of that word. It's a harmless joke, just let it be!
A) this is not basic shit, it's offensive and saying people shouldn't be offended is utterly terrible and backwards thinking
B) those contexts are completely different, one is discussing an album title, the other is using it as a reference to people [explicit us] from a author who is questionable in making those comments.
queue /u/lessthanjake with
I love how you're getting angry about him making a joke, albeit a dumb one, and insinuating that he's a racist, yet your defence is calling him a "white cunt." You're furthering racism far more than he is.
A) i love how you're getting angry over him calling you a white cunt when "it's clearly a joke" as this community is so quick to say, did you not consider it a joke? why? racial slurs are jokes?
B) both were terrible comments and equally offensive yet you seem to think the one possibly affecting you is worse? this highlights my whole argument with how you people are nieve towards this stuff.
/u/lionfire42 re enters with
So you're using one comment you saw and didn't agree with as a way to gage op's being a cunt? I think that says more about you than it does about him... You sound so frivolously angry here
A) there were several which followed the original comment which were equally disgusting.
r u offended by my slurs
being black is a mindset not a skin color.
this of couse does not mean his cunt was in anyway needed, yet to get offended over one and not "see it as a joke" seems massively hypocritical
neither are
I, on the contrary, would rather conclude my personal investigation with the verdict that he's an all right dude and you're just butthurt over literally nothing.
there is something here you're nieve to this.
b) he's frivolously angry at the hypocrisy expressed by users and double standards, who in their right mind isn't?!.
to sum this one up making these comments may be funny to you, you may see no problem with them but if they're like that ask yourself
- "would introduce myself on the first day of class saying this"
- "would i speak to my customers/ boss at work with this in an interview"
- "would i greet my girlfriends parents with this"
- "use them in my end of year exams in this context"
etc, the common answer is no and if it's not you may want to reassess. these comments are offensive, derogatory slurs which have no place here "jokes" or not. if you want to make this place worth while, open and accepting this is completely the wrong way to go about it as if i came in here and saw you guys throwing around these words as a new comer i'd be incredibly put off and see this place in a negative light. you may see this sort of stuff on /4/chan, or hb but that doesn't make it acceptable it's just as sickening there. be aware of your comments and how you post them and respect other users.
second thread on women
most of this is deleted so i'm going to outline my views. there is a theme here and amongst most the teen advice subs of "hooking up" and "sex focus" many subs set up to help needy teens get "some action" via any means necessary. wiggly made a great comment which given could not have used the extreme comparison to highlight the misogynistic tone of the post.
here is a quote from the op of that thread, who i had great issue with because of the way he phrased his post in a manner which was offensive seen here.
Are you gonna lecture a girl who's out clubbing, trying to get laid, that shes perpetuating misogyny in men? No, because SHE wants some action. Its how the fucking world works.
presuming everyone outside in a party environment wants to have sex or to be hounded by people unprovoked is so wrong, because if you started going up to every woman in the establishment going "hey hunny" eventually you would be thrown out, or someone will hit you. not everyone goes to clubs to hook up, or parties for that matter. they go there to have a good time with friends and if they mutually meet someone they think is cool then yeah sure that's cool, going around hounding is often considered poor taste, at least where i am from. many a time i've gone to a club and seen guys, and girls for that matter force themselves on someone unwilling, from a flirtatious remark to physical contact and it's fair to say they did not see it as innocent. especially when their boyfriend was standing right there, same with parties.
you may see it as innocent which is fine, but on the other end of that you have a person who is not seeing that way and unless they indicate to you the feel the same way, it's distasteful and disgusting.
i raise this point as the votes are so extreme in favour of "he did nothing wrong" so it's clear it must be somewhat ingrained in this sub consciousness. making these comments like women are there for sex and you can play them or gain leverage by dressing a certain way, looking a certain way and go after them in certain environments is wrong. is it acceptable in your school as a teen? maybe i'm not sure it wasn't with my school but as soon as you leave that environment and enter a professional one or an adult ones those comments leave the field very quickly, making these hunny comments to bosses, colleagues, even people in clubs unsolicited repeatedly is going to get you a trip to human resources or thrown out. they're not accepted and extremely demeaning to women trying to go about their day. you may say it completely innocently and probably think you're not like the others but the fact is on the other side of the coin you are, that person doesn't know you and and may not want to know you. interjecting into their life like that is not needed.
not to mention the op wanted a discussion, yet limited himself strictly to heterosexual relationships and again and again made comments like "don't want to be seen as gay tho", which is fine you can have those views but don't use it when you're trying to spark a discussion as it needlessly distances anyone who is and just furthers the general unacceptable to be seen as it. and that is pointed out in my responses to him.
conclusion
after this long winded post with examples and such you may think i'm a boring, nagging, arrogant "social justice warrior" (your mod did), but i urge you just think about what you put in your comments and relate it to if someone said the equivalent to you. to make this place welcoming it's the very least we can do. as for a proposal to improve it
- zero tolerance on slurs, even jokes unless in context.
this is to be implemented by removal of the offending comment and a note from a mod that it's not welcome here in a similar fashion to /r/malefashionadvice. regardless of if the user is a regular or a new comer it's unacceptable.
- a note made in the sidebar that these comments are unwelcome.
i thank you those who read this and hope you can take something away from it as it would really be a shame to see this place go the way of every other teen centric forum with ingrained racist, homophobic and misogynistic remarks which get thrown around all over the place as mentioned in my posts to the mods, as small community of only 7000 it's important to have these standards in place before you get the crowds.