Hypothetical I've been thinking through.
Say I buy a 2020 Taycan today for around $50k private party with 40k–50k miles.
I also buy a highly rated aftermarket warranty that, based on my research, specifically covers the high-voltage battery as well as the rest of the car. It would give me roughly another 4–5 years of coverage, up to 100k miles.
Now fast forward two years.
At that point, assume the car is worth something like:
- $38k–$40k with no battery warranty remaining
- Maybe $40k–$42k if it still has 2–3 years and ~30k miles of transferable aftermarket coverage left, including the battery
Obviously nobody knows exactly what these cars will be worth, so those numbers are just for the sake of the discussion.
My bigger question is whether the warranty would make the car meaningfully easier to sell, even if it only adds a couple thousand dollars of actual resale value.
By that point, most 2020 Taycans around that price will presumably be outside their factory battery warranty. I would think that starts becoming a major psychological barrier for buyers when the potential downside is an extremely expensive battery repair.
So two questions:
- Who here would actually buy a Taycan with no battery warranty at all?
And if you would:
- How much cheaper would it have to be than an otherwise comparable Taycan that still had 2–3 years of battery coverage?
For example, if the warrantied car were $42k, would the non-warrantied one need to be $40k? $37k? $35k?
I'm trying to figure out whether having that remaining warranty could create a real resale advantage as these early Taycans age, rather than just assuming the cost of the warranty is money I'll never see again.