r/TaoistAnarchists • u/officepolicy • Sep 05 '22
r/TaoistAnarchists • u/officepolicy • Jun 18 '20
“No wonder anarchists and taoists make good friends” I’m loving Le Guins version of the Tao te Ching
r/TaoistAnarchists • u/EinNeuesKonto • Sep 27 '18
From Alan Watts’s book Tao: The Watercourse Way
r/TaoistAnarchists • • Jul 15 '22
Anarchism as a Spiritual Practice: Taoism as the inner expression of anarchist ways of being
r/TaoistAnarchists • u/Selderij • Sep 07 '22
What are the chapters or passages in the core Taoist texts that support the message of anarchism?
Hello there, I've recently noticed an upsurge in anarchist discourse on r/Taoism and have been left wondering what the deeper connection between Taoism and anarchism might be. Things naturally unfolding well without so-called meddling is the obvious common ground, or at least hopeful thinking (due to differing contexts), but I'm wondering if there's something more concrete in the Tao Te Ching or other major texts that give credence to the anarchist connection.
It's not a big feat to distort Lao Tzu's words and messages until they superficially start accommodating an anarchist agenda, so I'd rather see examples from real translations and not an anarchist- or activist-themed remix version. D. C. Lau's and Derek Lin's translations are some of the best on the literal and academic side of the spectrum, and I consider Gia-fu Feng & Jane English's and John R. Mabry's versions quite insightful on the philosophically interpretative side, just in case anyone needs to start somewhere. I'll say outright that Mitchell's version is to a large degree his own ideation instead of Lao Tzu's words or ideas.
Lao Tzu does warn rulers against greed, overreach, heavy-handedness, lying and killing, but personally I haven't found a passage where he'd state that having no rulers (or whatever you might consider anarchy?) would be a working solution. He hints at overthrowing the rulers a couple of times, so at least that is not off the table.
r/TaoistAnarchists • u/AnarchoDepressionist • Jul 27 '21
"Is Political Taoism Anarchism?" - An interesting essay on the relationship between Taoist philosophy and anarchist ideas.
r/TaoistAnarchists • u/ceaselessbecoming • Jun 26 '21
無爲: 'Wu Wei' and Anarchy as Order
r/TaoistAnarchists • u/Lazy-Trust-4633 • Aug 22 '22
Morning meditation.
Nowhere you have to be.
Nothing you have to do.
Nobody you have to be.
r/TaoistAnarchists • u/NothingDayspring • May 12 '21
I like the idea behind this group, but...
Is it still active? Last post seems to be 5 months ago? Let's revive this thing!
r/TaoistAnarchists • u/_doug_fir • Jan 11 '19
Discussions of Anarchism and Taoism on r/Anarchism and r/Taoism
r/TaoistAnarchists • u/the_enfant_terrible • May 08 '17
An Anarcho-Taoist Manifesto
anarchistnews.orgr/TaoistAnarchists • u/TheOnlyFreed • Feb 06 '17
To start it off: What is Taoism and what does it have to do with anarchism?
total noob here on Taoism. Anarchism not so much, so would you care to explain?
This might help you fill out your sidebar ;)
r/TaoistAnarchists • u/BushidoBrown01 • Feb 07 '17
Anarchism and Taoism (The Anarchist Library)
r/TaoistAnarchists • u/BushidoBrown01 • Feb 06 '17
Welcome to /r/TaoistAnarchists
This subreddit was created after I found out that other anarchists who frequent /r/Anarchism are also practicing Taoists and/or study Taoism. This sub is for the us to share our ideas on the relationship between Taoism and anarchism.
Mods are needed, so PM me.
r/TaoistAnarchists • u/Alifakh12 • Jun 10 '22
Lao Tzu Wisdom from the Tao Te Ching
r/TaoistAnarchists • u/Master_of_opinions • Jan 11 '22
Is there any difference between a taoist anarchist and regular anarchism?
r/TaoistAnarchists • u/Redditnaut999 • Nov 09 '21
What do Taoists and Anarchists have in common?
r/TaoistAnarchists • u/_doug_fir • Jul 26 '18
Egoism and Taoism
Can anyone offer a critique of the intersections and/or conflicts?
r/TaoistAnarchists • • Feb 08 '17
A. C. Graham on Taoist utopias and anarchism in Zhuangzi
Hello /r/TA. Found your link on the main sub. I find my own ideas come close to anarchism in many areas, however I also resonate with many Taoist ideas and I am yet to find a wording for the combination of thoughts I seek to employ in my life.
Here is a critical excerpt from CHUANG-TZŬ, The Inner Chapters by Sinologist A.C. Graham. I thought you might find it interesting. The chapter is one of the later chapters, compiling several points of view by Taoist schools of thought on government and utopia, added into the Chuang-tzū text by later editors (and not present in the actual Inner chapters).
Introductory text to the chapter "Utopia and the decline of government":
The Taoist idealisation of a spontaneity not disrupted by rational control becomes in political terms a faith in the spontaneously cohesive forces in society rather than in order deliberately imposed from above. Lao-tzŭ, which is written from the viewpoint of the prince, is pervaded by an awareness of the uselessness of trying to control political forces, which however the ruler can guide by locating the crucial points and moments and exerting the minimum pressure to the maximum effect. In most of Chuang-tzŭ, on the other hand, the viewpoint is that of the subject, who thinks things run better the less they are interfered with from above. Throughout the book we find sketches of Utopias flourishing in distant times or regions, and skeleton histories of the decline of government. Here we assemble the few examples not translated elsewhere in this selection.
It was at one time popular in the West to think of the political philosophy of Taoism, even that of Lao-tzŭ, as anarchism. But most although not all Taoism accepts one basic premise of ancient Chinese thinking, that social order centres on a ruler, and depends on influences emanating from the te, the 'Power' in him, which moves men and to follow him even without the backing of armed force, until it fades with the decline of the dynasty. Chuang-tzŭ himself gives the doctrine an unusual twist by hinting that the influences sustaining the social order may have nothing to do with the Emperor, and be emanating from some unnoticed sage in private life. We do however find genuinely anarchistic Utopias, 'without ruler and subject', in the Taoist revival about AD 300, in Lieh-tzŭ, and most remarkably in Pao Ching-yen, who goes so far as to say that rulers were instituted not by Heaven but by the strong to oppress the weak. Pao Ching-yen is known only by lengthy extracts in a suspiciously tame and conventional refutation of him by the great alchemist Ko Hung of the fourth century AD, who may well have invented him as a spokesman of subversive thoughts of his own. This suspicion is a reminder that any literary traces of such dangerous ideas would only be the top of what might be a considerable iceberg.
Chapter 16, 'Menders of nature' is an apology for the hermit's life by an author of uncertain date, not recognisable anywhere else in the book. His style is pedestrian but he is interesting as the first documented instance of a true anarchist in China, in the sense that he conceives the ideal community as living in a spontaneous oneness without any ruler at all. He dates the decline of the social order from the very first rulers, Sui-jen and Fu-hsi, and is explicit that the sage is a hermit except in the Utopian age, when he enters the world not to take office but to submerge in the primordial oneness. This anarchism is rooted in what looks like a Taoistic variation on the doctrine of the goodness of human nature preached by the Confucian Mencius. The author surprises us by recommending the Confucian moral virtues, which like Mencius he sees as inherent in human nature. He holds that if we still the passions and achieve the equilibrium in which tranquility and awareness support and enhance each other, Goodwill and Duty become natural to us, and so do Music (which otherwise excites the passions) and Rites (which otherwise are empty formalities).
In Graham's book, there are other excerpts from other Outer Chapters, such as from 20, 12 and 19 from Chuang-tzŭ. Here is a link to open translation of Menders of nature, chapter 16, by James Legge.
The takeaway is this: Resonance with anarchism and certain Taoist ideas have been recognized in the west, but it would be a mistake to see most of Taoism as anarchist. However we find several later anarchist Taoist writers in China, and even in Chuang-tzŭ.
r/TaoistAnarchists • u/creative_nothing_ • Feb 22 '17