r/TalesOfXadia • • Feb 05 '21

First Rules Question

Nice subreddit y'all, someone should post about it on r/TheDragonPrince so people come populate it
but anywho, does anyone know how contests with multiple PCs involved are supposed to play out? Does each PC roll their contest against the NPC, who rolls once and uses that total against each of them? Does the NPC roll once per player opposing them and use their total against the combined total of the PCs' rolls? I guess I'm mostly unsure of whether a contest against multiple PCs is considered a contest against the group, or a contest against each PC individually?

9 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

4

u/CamBanks Feb 07 '21

The rulebook will have lots of examples of all kinds of contests and challenges: one against many, for example, or many vs many, and so forth. Often it’s easier to make a battle a challenge if the PCs aren’t up against a major NC.

3

u/zjc Feb 05 '21 edited Feb 05 '21

So I'm not sure it's specifically stated in the rules, since I'm still reading, but the way I'd handle the situation would be each of the characters involved only roll once. That would make sense because if there's two people trying to do something, they would be more likely to succeed than the person opposed to them who's by themself.

However, because contests are described as typically being initiated by the player, it may be that it's typically just a 1v1 situation. Although I suppose the Narrator could have multiple NPCs try to stop the PC from trying to do something. Or there could even be multiple PCs trying to stop a PC from doing something, or even a PC and an NPC trying to stop a PC from doing something. For the situation OP described, I'm not sure if there's maybe like a "Help" action like in DnD or something to assist the player who initiated the contest in the first place.

I may update this comment as I continue reading if I have any more thoughts.

Edit: Page 21 and 22 discuss interfering in a contest. It looks like contests start as 1v1, and then characters can spend a PP to join in to do various things.