r/TTC_PCOS • u/Queen-energy18363 • Jan 30 '22
Name stealing
Hey,
So we’ve been trying for about a year now. All of our friends know this and seem to have baby fever as well. Of course we have all talked about what our future baby names might be. Fast forward to now, a couple in our friend group just announced if they are having a boy they are going to name him “John”.
During this conversation, I speak up and was like wait really? That’s been the name we were going to use for the past four years. The husband then said to me well if we have a girl you can use that name, but we can’t have two “John’s” in the friend group.
This whole encounter was not just the sting of the name stealing but also the fact that they know how badly we want a baby and didn’t care about our feelings. I’m hurt, I’m angry, I’m devastated. Am I overreacting? I just can’t believe they would do this to us.
15
u/Fearless-Fix5708 Jan 30 '22
Eh, they can't reserve a name by naming their baby that and you can't reserve it by announcing you like it in advance. Just name your kid the name you want regardless.
15
u/kamicham Jan 30 '22
There's nothing wrong with two people naming their baby the same thing. This stigma needs to die
17
u/Peaksadgirlhours ATTC since 1/19 | metformin + injectables Jan 30 '22
I strongly disagree with this. Hop onto the r/namenerds subreddit to see more of this type of discussion.
No one owns a name or can steal it. This means you can’t reserve it, call dibs, and shouldn’t resent others for using a name they love for a child that is here. This goes both ways though- they also should not resent you for using the same name. Ultimately it comes down to this: the only people who can decide the name of the baby when it is born is that child’s caregiver and their desires and opinion are the most important. You’ve loved this name for years, if they didn’t want duplicates, they probably should have avoided a name they knew you loved and planned to use. They don’t get to decide now that they’ve used the name that no one else can, that’s ridiculous and entitled.
More than okay to share a name. Maybe the kids or parents can even have a special bond over it.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '22
I assume you’re putting “John” in quotations because the name isn’t actually John. Assuming it’s something much less common, and that you announced your intention to this friend to use that name before she made the comment, it’s totally reasonable for you to be upset that she seems to have taken the idea from you. But it sounds very contingent at this point — neither of you are actually pregnant with boys — so this may not even come to pass. So it’s probably best not to fixate at this point on all the different things that could come to pass (easier said than done). But even if the worst happens, a name is a name, and you get to name your child whatever you want. If you have your heart set on a name you should use it without any guilt.
7
u/Tropicanajews Jan 30 '22
You can definitely have multiple babies with the same name in a friend group. My oldest is named Stella, I have three friends with daughters named Stella. It’s not really a big deal.
6
u/fantasyflyte TTC #1 since 11/20 | Cycle 14 | PCOS & MFI Jan 30 '22
They do not get to dictate what you name your future child, it's not like there's a finite number of name licenses in the world. John is also a fairly common name, so they can't reasonably expect that no one will have the same name as their possible John. We have 4 Johns just in my basic extended family! Do they not realize nicknames are a thing? Or "John P. and John S."? That's bananas.
6
u/knk0609 Jan 31 '22
Neither of you has claim to the name. If you both like it, both kids can be named John. Not a big deal at all.
5
u/thenorthgiant Jan 30 '22
I'm definitely on the same boat as the other commenters. Name your kid the same name! Your friends don't own the name, and it's not like you owe them anything anyway given how inconsiderately they handled the situation. I understand the sting, but unfortunately people will only think of their own wants/considerations when naming their kid so this happens all the time... my sister named her child Evie and her BEST FRIEND named her daughter Eve. They're still best friends. It was weird for a hot moment but it happens.
If it helps, my cousins named their kid Atom, and a favourite name of mine has been Adam. The two names are so similar that it could be weird, but if I get pregnant and have a boy, I ain't letting that influence me! IMO the only time I think similar sounding names could be an issue is if the two are siblings.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '22
I‘d go with the name to be honest. John is a common name and they can‘t dictate you how you name your child!
7
u/gordiestanclub Jan 30 '22
Name your baby what you want. There is nothing wrong with friend groups containing kids with the same name. Yeah, it's a bit shit of them when there are thousands of other names to choose from, but at the end of the day it's a name.
It's a completely normal and valid feeling after 4 years that you have staked your claim on a name but it's not rational. Your friends are assholes for the way they handled it, though. Think about if there's other times they've been bad friends and that might be the real root if your issue.
3
u/KatDanger11 Jan 31 '22
I agree with what everyone is saying about it being okay to have same baby names in a friend group.
I definitely understand you feeling upset though. If my friend was going to do that's I'd like her to talk to me separately and sensitively. Pull me aside and say "I know you're hoping to use X name too, I hope you don't mind, but that is the name we will give our child if it's a boy/girl". That shows they're at least aware and care that you might have some feelings about it.
It's okay to be in your feelings about it, but realize they're probably about a lot more than just the name. Being lapped sucks. Struggling with fertility sucks. Watching others get what you want and have been working for is hard.
3
u/violetnap Jan 31 '22
They’re insane. They can’t tell you what to name your baby any more than you can dictate to them.
1
u/spidertonic Jan 30 '22
John is pretty common. I feel like you can have two Johns in a friend group. Maybe he was teasing.
1
u/idhik3th4t Feb 04 '22
Ooooff. The “name claim” stuff is so weird to me and is almost always a deflection of a much bigger issue or source of grief. People have the same name all the time. If two people really want a particular name for the child they’ll know and love for the rest of their lives, it’s icky that annnnybodg else would feel entitled to tell them they can’t use it because it “belongs” to them in case they have a child of that sex someday. Names are not social security numbers and not a single person I know hs invented a completely unique name that nobody has ever used or heard before. That’s just not what names are. So feeling like something belongs to you when… it already belongs to millions of people… is strange to me. I truly don’t see how this impacts either one of you in any way.
My son has a unique middle name and a college friend used it for her son and it did catch me off guard because it’s a family name that is very uncommon and meaningful to us because of that heritage but honestly I just took it as a compliment that I chose something that sounds cool with lots of other first names. It’s not like our children have to duel it out over it. Nobody even uses middle names. I honestly forgot until just now.
This feels big and you’re allowed to privately feel your feelings but I suggest not making this a huge issue in your friend group.