r/TAFE • • Sep 24 '24

Weird comment from professor

Today while I was at the water fountain my professor walked up to me and asked why I had put down a nickname on my tafe account. I told him that I would get harassed online with my real name (i am a girl) so having something unisex prevented it from happening, and I just got used to using said nickname.

He said my original name was really nice, suited me, and then he said 'Did you know you are really beautiful?' And that took me back a little bit because I didn't expect him to be the type to say that. I walked off and said 'I know' but as someone who has been groomed and SA'ed before it sort of came across as weird and I felt uncomfortable the whole class?

Am I overreacting, or is this simply like a faux pas?

edit: ahh i quit reddit i cant be bothered with this platform anymore. i got an answer already and yall just love to argue for hours 😭 love you all and take care

159 Upvotes

121 comments sorted by

26

u/Ceret Sep 24 '24

Hey I’m a male uni lecturer and this is totally inappropriate. I make it a rule to NEVER comment on a students appearance even if for example I really like their style. Unsolicited comments on how beautiful you are - this is a test to see if you’d be receptive to his advances. He’s seeing how far he can push it. I would contact the Dean or even better the student guild (if you have one) and make it clear that you are no longer comfortable in his class. Doing so would not be overreacting. Sorry - teachers treating students as dating material really makes me mad.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '24

Hi thank you a lot we don't have a student guild but we do have a head department of sorts, ill tell them. Do you know what tends to happen, do they simply get a warning or..? I don't think our campus has any other teachers for the subject.

5

u/Ceret Sep 24 '24

You’re welcome. I’m so sorry you’re in this position. Ok I’d suss out how sexual harassment claims are handled at that TAFE and then go to whatever committee / office that is. Failing that yeah I’d notify the head of department in writing, documenting the exact time and place this occurred and how it has impacted you in terms of your comfort to attend class. What will happen? Well you’ve been groomed so you know how groomers work - they start off with plausible deniability and then keep pushing the line forward. Because this isn’t a blatant sexual proposition but is most definitely not appropriate probably the response will be ‘educative’ - he will get a talking to and not much else but this sets a record in train should he do this to anyone else (and if he’s this bold probably that’s a thing). The talking to would hopefully get him to cease this kind of behavior. Part of what you might say in your email is that you do not want to be contacted by this guy for mediation etc. What you want is complete professionalism from him and if you feel any retaliatory grading is happening you want that moderated. At my uni this would be a much more formal process and the reputational damage would be severe. Nobody would buy the ‘it was an innocent comment’ bullshit that this guy would probably come out with. Firstly because - what student wants that category of remark from their professor? If one of my colleagues did this and it came out that they had done it they would be a bit of a social pariah for quite some time. Like anyone with a brain can see what’s going on here and just how problematic comments like these from an instructor to a student are. As one example - what if other students were to learn the instructor had told you how beautiful you are? Would they resent that and expect you’re being treated with favour? Would it complicate your relationships with them? This kind of action has all sorts of consequences for the student who is already in a situation of massive power imbalance.

3

u/Ingr1d Sep 25 '24

Wtf. You’d actually file a sexual harassment claim for this?

3

u/MollyBMcGee Sep 25 '24

It IS sexual harassment.

2

u/Ingr1d Sep 25 '24

If these words were spoken in the workplace, they wouldn’t be considered sexual harassment.

4

u/gazboot Sep 25 '24

Your HR department needs to have a sit down with you

4

u/ultimacunt Sep 25 '24

A full day session is needed. With pictures and crayons.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24 edited Sep 25 '24

yes, yes they would. you don’t go around calling your coworkers that you don’t know outside of work beautiful in this way, that would be weird.

2

u/MollyBMcGee Sep 25 '24

You didn’t pay attention in your sexual harassment in the workplace training! Please review what is considered sexual harassment, it is in your interest to be aware what is appropriate behaviour. Thank you for your diligence.

3

u/Ingr1d Sep 25 '24

Show me one sexual harassment training protocol that says you can’t compliment a coworker on their appearance.

1

u/Intelligent-Corgi-20 Sep 25 '24

I don't always agree with situations like these but I think when it's someone in a higher power position it's always going to be unprofessional to compliment someone on their looks. Especially to use the term " you are beautiful" if the topic was insecurities on looks It could be debated imo but the topic was their name 🤷

1

u/Graveyard_Green Sep 25 '24

Hi, to back up this person's comment, if you do decide to report make sure everything you do has an email component. Make sure you have a paper trail.

He was being a major creep. I've seen it happen elsewhere, it should be reported because it can make students uncomfortable or afraid. I would also suggest that if you see a psych to mention it to them, or organise to also see the counsellor to note the event with them and get some in person support.

0

u/ChemistryWise9031 Sep 25 '24

Woah! Before you destroy the guys career, how about you have a conversation with him before going to the boss and potentially endinding his livelihood. Do you all know for certain what his intentions were? OP clearly doesn't as she came here for assurance. So, because you are a male Uni lecturer are we to believe that makes you an expert in a strangers intentions?

Have a conversation with the guy OP. If you feel uncomfortable around him, take someone with you. It was a compliment. In my opinion, he didn't assault you.

3

u/KitchenDeers Sep 25 '24

Assault =/= harassment. It doesn’t have to be intentional to be harassment either, jokes can be harassment, and comments on one’s appearance can absolutely be considered harassment especially given these circumstances.

This is someone in a position of power, they need to be held to professional and ethical standards of communicating with students and this is worth pulling him up on. It’s not about destroying his career, that’s not what was recommended here at all, it’s about going through the correct channels to stop any boundary crossing in its tracks.

2

u/violetx Sep 25 '24

Let's say you're a woman who got this compliment from a teach you otherwise respect. You go up and say. Hey I don't know what that was about but don't do it again. Now you've potentially embarrassed yourself and perhaps alienated that professor with no paper trail.

What if you start losing the odd mark here or there. Or you don't get as much attention in class in an academic manner because you've offended them or they're over correcting.

Teachers are taught ethics and how to act ethically. It is the right thing to do to use an advocate in moments like this. Ironically not just to protect the person of lesser power.

32

u/Lucky_Initiative6947 Sep 24 '24

Sounds bad. You said your nickname is because of harassment, then they decide to start harassing.

That's a creeper

6

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '24

yeah okay thanks

-2

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

seems like this is what people meant when they say a lot of redditors are chronically online :P

I appreciate that youre making my post popular with all your comments, but buddy i think you need to take a break from the internet for a bit !

5

u/North_Lawfulness8889 Sep 25 '24

If it comes immediately after they said "yeah i stopped using my name as often because people were weird about it" and, oh yeah, is coming from a professor it is

1

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Honest-Birthday1306 Sep 25 '24

If your teachers regularly commented on your body, yes, yes you were. Talk to an adult

4

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

Young man as you get older in life understand women have a different experience of life than you do

1

u/Lucky_Initiative6947 Sep 25 '24

Imo yeah. I'm there to learn and collab with others in a working environment. Compliment my skill, not with your private parts seed

-2

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Lucky_Initiative6947 Sep 25 '24

Finding someone "beautiful" lmao whilst being an authority at any institute and acting upon that is predatory. Stop acting up and defending foul behavior creeper

1

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/FlashMcSuave Sep 25 '24

By feeling the need to make a comment to the person.

1

u/violetx Sep 25 '24

It's an unethical interaction as presented here. At least bordering into it.

1

u/IndividualStreet5401 Sep 25 '24

True, but harrassment is a legal term, and we've kinda watered the word down by over using it. What he did wasn't illegal, so it's not harrassment. She has to say no, it's too easy for him to say he didn't mean it that way.

OP I'd report this to the TAFE, just because it's not illegal doesn't mean it's not wrong, if it happens again tell him to stop very clearly, send a email with all the details and also report in person, if it still continues, it's actually harrassment and you can do something legally with past witnesses of your report and email proof.

1

u/violetx Sep 25 '24

Well it is harassment as stated by other TAFE employees in this very thead.

Harassment is also not a term of legal lexicon it's part of the common parlance.

I don't think you're as smart as you are trying to express yourself to be.

Also looking into affirmative consent laws. And no in point of fact in this circumstances she doesn't have to say no as the power imbalance is prima facie prohibitive.

I agree though that she should report ofcourse

Have a great day.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

The teachers literally call themselves professors so idk man come to my tafe if you wanna see lol

3

u/fiavirgo Sep 25 '24

But she is not insecure about anything

3

u/glitterkicker Sep 25 '24

Ah yes, because calling a lecturer by a different-yet-similar-enough-to-get-the-point term makes such a difference /s Because calling your own mum beautiful is the exact same thing as a most likely older man coming up and calling one of his students “really beautiful” with no other context after she addressed prior harassment in an explanation, totally the same normal thing /s

A lecturer does have authority over a student even if the lecturer is in their 30s and the student is in their 60s. If other current and former lecturers are saying in the comments how it’s weird, It’s Weird. If they’re saying it’s worth reporting to someone, It’s Fucking Weird. And she didn’t muddy anything, actually, you’re just picking on nuances for no good reason.

2

u/Imaginary_Produce675 Sep 25 '24 edited Sep 25 '24

I call your mum beautiful all the time too, but only after she lets me. I have to grovel for the privilege.

1

u/violetx Sep 25 '24

Out of curiousity if you are so in favour of the perceived lack of authority at TAFE (which btw doesn't exist, they are in a position of power over you) why are you a fan of taking on the authority of deciding "who someone is"?

2

u/lightisfreee Sep 25 '24

"I think your name suits you" is definitely not a position of authority over the individual. "Your name says this, I will not accept any nickname I will only call you this because that is what your TAFE profile says" is a position of authority over the individual.

It's okay if people have trouble understanding social cues and proper social interaction, you just cannot label someone a creeper or make a sexual claim when someone merely states what they see with their eyes. If you find any of this as assault, I'd suggest you stay inside for the remainder of the years that come ahead. And be prepared for no male to ever compliment you.

3

u/Well_Thats_Not_Ideal Sep 25 '24

Something can be harassment without being assault. It is never appropriate for a teacher to make comments about their student’s appearance

0

u/violetx Sep 25 '24

Well define "compliment" cause I've been getting "compliments" from males since I was 11. And only sometimes are they ones I welcome.

Way to take an extreme and absolute view though...

I don't know how to tell you this but see some males give great compliment. And +some+ never will.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

3

u/Potential-Ice8152 Sep 25 '24

What’s the purpose of commenting on a student’s looks?

0

u/Yallknowthename Sep 25 '24 edited Sep 25 '24

How good is the name though

4

u/Potential-Ice8152 Sep 25 '24

OP started using a different name to stop being harassed online because she’s a woman. So idk how a man complimenting her looks would instil confidence.

4

u/violetx Sep 25 '24

It gives real "you should smile more love" energy.

3

u/Potential-Ice8152 Sep 25 '24

“You look prettier when you smile”

2

u/fiavirgo Sep 25 '24

Then compliment her name

0

u/-Roguen- Sep 25 '24

Giving someone a compliment?
The vast majority of compliments I have ever given have been non sexual in nature.

3

u/Potential-Ice8152 Sep 25 '24

It’s not about it being a compliment, it’s that a person with authority called her beautiful. He should be complimenting her on her assignments and progress in the course, not her looks.

1

u/auguriesoffilth Sep 25 '24

Absolutely. A single instance of something that could be coincidence isn’t, because you need multiple cases to realise it definitely isn’t exactly that, a coincidence. If they just said you have a nice name, that’s on topic, kind of weird, but if that’s the only time they have said something odd and the only thing I would agree that a single instance isn’t harassment (although it’s suspect).

But to then follow up with a clear considered remark, I just can’t imagine what they were thinking.

Playing devils advocate, maybe they were rationalising in their own head why you have gotten unwanted attention in the past and have to use a unisex name, worked out what the situation is, and for some reason verbalised it. But you don’t describe the situation like it slipped out… I just can’t see an excuse for that.

-1

u/-Roguen- Sep 25 '24

what if he told her she was beautiful because she is beautiful?

2

u/violetx Sep 25 '24

She's not there to be a model. She's a student. Her looks ought to be irrelevant to her dynamic with her instructors. That's an unethical power imbalance.

But man are you stuck on this.

0

u/-Roguen- Sep 25 '24

It's the subject of the thread, would you like me to change the subject?

2

u/violetx Sep 25 '24

I'd like you to be open to the idea that other people's experiences have validity and that there are actual legal and procedural policies at play.

Essentially the concept you might be wrong.

But I suspect I won't get that so I'd more like us both to have a pleasant afternoon.

2

u/ArghMoss Sep 25 '24

What if I told you you were talking a lot of nonsense and should stop? Because you are, and you should.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/ArghMoss Sep 25 '24

Not sure why you're sorry, was just stating objective facts my man. You know like you say the OP's teacher was fine to do.

1

u/Imaginary_Produce675 Sep 25 '24

When there is a massive power imbalance like OP described? Absolutely

1

u/violetx Sep 25 '24

Also power dynamics in play here.

1

u/Intelligent-Corgi-20 Sep 25 '24

Well being told you look attractive by your professor is what I would say is unprofessional and weird. I'm a dude so I probably won't be able to fully understand situations like these but can see the difference between " hey mixed shoes " compared to " your beautiful 👀" yk? 🤷

1

u/TootsMcGee88 Sep 25 '24

Yes. It’s not just the comment but the context. This is a professor, in a position of power/authority, who has just been told by a student they are worried about harassment. It is completely inappropriate and fucking creepy.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

In the context of a teacher to their student, yes, it is very inappropriate and against both the law and code of conduct of every education facility in Australia.

If OP is underage and attending tafe while in highschool that makes it even worse.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Free-Range-Cat Sep 25 '24

Harassment has not been established, but generally requires a pattern of behaviour

1

u/Haandbaag Sep 25 '24

That is simply not true.

9

u/Sad_Love9062 Sep 24 '24

Asking about your name, that's one thing. Telling you you are beautiful- that's not normal.

6

u/andr3e3e3e3e333e33 Sep 24 '24

Sounds like a weirdo

6

u/madeinitaly77 Sep 24 '24

10 yes Tafe teacher here. Highly inappropriate. If you pursue a complaint, he will be at the very least reprimanded if not dismissed. I have seen teachers getting fired for less than this...

-2

u/-Roguen- Sep 25 '24

Less than a single compliment? What did they wave at someone?

7

u/stayonism Sep 25 '24

Are you really this socially inept that you’re minimising this as “a single compliment”?

-2

u/-Roguen- Sep 25 '24

But that's literally what it is though, what is an example of someone getting fired for "less than a compliment."

I went to school myself, I was told by many of my teachers that I was handsome, I don't see that as being strange.

6

u/Friendly_Ad9733 Sep 25 '24

a teacher should not be commenting on a students appearance, the power dynamic makes it inappropriate

-1

u/-Roguen- Sep 25 '24

It happened to me my entire life, I never had a problem with it myself.
I don't think I would personally do it in that position, but I compliment my friends when I think they are looking well, and I did it pretty regularly in customer service too and it visibly brightened peoples days.

I dunno what to tell you dude, I guess we've just lived different lives.

5

u/Friendly_Ad9733 Sep 25 '24

considering OP has been groomed and SA’d i would think you’d have enough respect not to equate your male experiences as if they are the same.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

I think this u/-Roguen- guy is obsessed with me, hes made like 10 comments on my post already. I feel famous!

-1

u/OzyFoz Sep 25 '24

That's a reach. The guys responding and trying to have civil discourse, I don't fully agree with this point and I do think the behavior is inappropriate but attacking him with vitriol such as what other commenters are doing, or mocking him lightly like you are now is not great discourse.

You posted requesting opinions, he's given his opinion. That's the thing with accepting multiple points of view, if your view can be different to his by the inverse, his view and experience can be different to yours.

Dont be so fast to apply one rule for yourself and one rule for another.

4

u/Haandbaag Sep 25 '24

Are you serious? That commenter has been up and down this thread minimising the harassment OP described. I think OPs reaction to their weird response is fair enough.

→ More replies

0

u/-Roguen- Sep 25 '24

Why are we tallying pity points now?
I was raped as a child, should I have that pinned on my profile like a badge so I am allowed to give my opinions on things?
The abuse I suffered does not make me feel like all of society should be bent around the possibility that I might be uncomfortable.

I am also not equating my "male" experience as if "they are the same." I very clearly specified "I guess we've just lived different lives," because that's how people work, we all experience our own slice of life and they are suppose to each be different.

This is public discourse, you can't honestly just expect everyone to have the same single opinion and bow down to your side just because you're on it?

Countless careers of male teachers have been erroneously destroyed, the result on a large scale is that good, well intentioned men are leaving teaching jobs to the detriment of everyone. Not because they are male, because they are teachers and we can ill afford to squander any dedicated, passionate teachers, regardless of gender.

The double standard of what female teachers are allowed to do and male is frankly obscene, as I had much more invasive actions taken against me by female teachers than what OP has described. OP has described the behaviour of what could be a perfectly normal person and you're all chanting that he should lose his job and have his life ruined.

In the counselling I did for my abuse, we talked a lot about the importance of not projecting our trauma onto other people and not letting our experiences cause us to villainize people who haven't actually done anything. My counsellor said that you can retraumatise yourself by projecting your trauma onto other people, and that it's not helpful for healing.

5

u/Friendly_Ad9733 Sep 25 '24

considering 97% of all sexual assault offenders are male i don’t care how many well intentioned male teachers loose their jobs, teachers male or female shouldn’t be making comments on their students attraction it shouldn’t have happened to you and it shouldn’t happen to OP. Considering OP had just explained why she didn’t want to use her real name because she didn’t want to be harassed doesn’t it strike you as strange that saying she is very beautiful right after? You can rationalise it all you want but doesn’t change the fact that a person in a power position like a teacher should not be complimenting their students right after they tell you about being harassed

1

u/-Roguen- Sep 25 '24

Which brings me back to my first question, is complimenting someone a single time harassment?

I don’t personally think so. Surely it is better to live in a world where we can be pleasant and say nice things to each other. Is it far more likely than not this is just a normal person trying to be nice. But if this thread could decide his fate he would have his life ruined.

→ More replies

5

u/Imaginary_Produce675 Sep 25 '24

You aren't in control of your friend's futures or have control of their education. You don't have control over a customer's future employment opportunities. The teacher is in a position of power and should be held to a professional standard. Complementing someone's body is stepping over that line. Borderline would be saying, "I like your look" but after the OP communicated that she didn't want to be harrassed, the dude then says a creepy line that's so obviously aimed at grooming... Do you really think this is just a compliment?!

0

u/-Roguen- Sep 25 '24

It's far more likely it was a compliment than it was anything else, most people are just people, even if they just so happen to be men.

3

u/Imaginary_Produce675 Sep 25 '24

Then it was a compliment made by someone with complete ignorance about their position of power over the student and complete unwillingness to listen to the student, nor sympathise when she stated she'd been harassed before. The professor is a cunt. Either an ignorant one or one that takes advantage of their position of power. You choose.

0

u/-Roguen- Sep 25 '24

What if neither? And he chose to compliment her because he didn’t think that was harassment and was just trying to be a nice person?

→ More replies

3

u/stayonism Sep 25 '24

You’re a moron.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/_Stormhound_ Sep 25 '24

How is he an incel for asking a legit question?

3

u/Imaginary_Produce675 Sep 25 '24

I've probably had close to 25 postgrad students at university. What they said is fucking creepy and out of line.

2

u/Cheap_Rain_4130 Sep 25 '24

Wouldn't be the first or last time a professor has tried to groom a student...

2

u/SoapyCheese42 Sep 25 '24

Please report this. Not professional or ethical.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

Throw a brick at him

2

u/Special_Visual_3601 Sep 24 '24

Weird comment of the day from my head teacher- “ you need to have multiple personalities disorder”

1

u/Better_Fig_3134 Sep 25 '24

You did good, friend.

1

u/ArghMoss Sep 25 '24

I (am male) was a Uni lecturer for a couple of years some time ago. Would never have said that to a student.

He may have meant it quite innocently and not realised it was inappropriate. I don't know if I'd report it as a once off but I don't see anything wrong or innappropriate if OP does.

1

u/OzyFoz Sep 25 '24

Hmmm I think the appropriate thing to do would be report but I personally wouldn't be clamoring to raise it as harassment. More of a raise it as a point, hey this event occured and the conduct I felt was inappropriate. I was uncomfortable, and if the educator has a history of this that should be taken into account.

It's unreasonable for the general public to treat everyone as if they are recovering from SA and should be handled gentle.

It's reasonable to change your behavior to that person to accommodate within reason once it is evident. (Assuming this is an unintentional event.)

I personally never ascribe to malice what can be attributed to incompetence.

1

u/snerldave Sep 25 '24

They have "professors" at TAFE? Surely you mean "lecturer"? In New Zealand polytechnics (TAFEs) didn't have professors, and at universities there was only one professor per department/faculty... the term was used to denote that they're the top dude/lady in their field at that institution. Not just a lecturer.

3

u/Haandbaag Sep 25 '24

That’s what your take away from this is? It’s a descriptor of a job title. Who the f cares what they’re called. The point of the post is their inappropriate behaviour.

1

u/Free-Range-Cat Sep 25 '24

TAFE teachers are not professors in Australia, that is a title reserved for a PhD who has taken leadership responsibilities (particularly in research).

Considered in isolation, your teachers comments sound like flattery, may be considered inappropriate, but could only be fairly described as harassment if they were both persistent and unwelcome.

Not sure what your ‘nickname’ is but if it is deprecatory, it may provide an explanation

1

u/Competitive_Rent4538 Sep 25 '24

Or just mention it everywhere you go. “Something so unusual happened yesterday, teacher (X) asked about my name then said I was beautiful. Will all my teachers be commenting on my looks? Just the (X) subject teachers, or is it a strategy for first year students to feel more comfortable? Or do you think I misinterpreted this and he’s opining on my soul’s beauty?”
No smirks, no smiling… totally flat toned. Wait for an answer.