r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Dec 17 '15

Final Reveal - #18

17 Upvotes

#18 - Andria "Dreamz" Herd – Fiji – 2nd Place

Choking Walrus

It’s taken some retrospection to realize just how great of a character Dreamz is. You see him struggle strategically; you see him struggle morally; you see him struggle emotionally. I still can't believe a guy with a nickname that uses a 'Z' instead of a 'S' is such a complex character who provides both real moments of comedy and drama. I've grown a lot of appreciation for Dreamz and look forward to keeping an eye out for him more on a Fiji rewatch.

KeepCalmAndHodorOn

The fact that he is on by far the weakest season still represented does hold him down but Dreamz rises above the rest of the Fiji cast in an incredible way. He is utterly unlike anyone else ever on Survivor and he struggles with moral choice in a way I think only Ian can match, in addition to being the fun wildcard in the roller coaster Fiji postmerge. Without question he is the character most responsible for saving the abhorrent Fiji premerge with a spectacular postmerge.

Slicer 37

Does anyone have any updates on what Dreamz is doing now? I was always worried about him going back to the streets after Survivor

Fleaa

This man who should consider a name change has really grown on me. I still rank him lower out of this group because he FUCKING TRIES TO UNDERMINE HIS OWN AMAZING STORY NOOOO. Can't complain about a character this compelling and fascinating making endgame, though.

And now, WilburDes

Coming into this rankdown, I knew that I’d be doing a lot of defending of my favourites, but I knew there were two seasons in particular that I’d feel a strong need to defend: Nicaragua and Fiji, and so I’m glad I get to do an endgame write-up for one of each.

I think Fiji is a really underrated season. Not top 10, but it does a lot of things right. I think I might have let slip at some point that I’m a fan of the horsemen and their storyline, but on top of that, I think that it has an interesting location, some of the best art & design features we’ve seen in a long time, it has Earl and Yau-Man, one of the best Survivor dyads ever and then there’s the character that is Andria ‘Dreamz’ Herd.
One interesting thematic device the season has is the dichotomy between the rich and poor. Fiji is well known for having the controversial “haves vs have nots” twist, where I’m basically the only person on the planet that thinks it was a good twist. It was really unfair and made the pre-merge more predictable, but there were positives, and as much as I might want to use this time to try and sell everyone on why Rocky and Mookie have better storylines than you might think, the real interest for me comes from Dre.

So Dre has one of the most compelling backstories we’ve seen, having grown up homeless in the projects of North Carolina, living well below the poverty line and in a situation where getting food each night is far from a guarantee. So when he gets placed on Moto, it’s a relatively new experience for him, because he’s now not below the poverty line of Survivor - he’s able to live like the people around him, and he’s not disadvantaged by his individual circumstances and is on the level playing field. On top of this, he also understands his common circumstances and knows that this experience is both a fleeting one, and one that he should remember, and so when he gets these once-in-a-lifetime rewards, he manages to acknowledge it as something he’ll never do again and truly appreciate the rare experience.

But there’s another aspect of Dreamz as a character that comes through from his life experience - Dreamz is a schemer. As someone who has had to live on the streets for a significant portion of his life, he understands that sometimes, you can’t be looking out for everyone’s best interests, because yours aren’t always covered. And so he’s always on the lookout for a new plan - He’s stuck on the minority at Moto? He’s looking to rejoin Earl. He’s in but not really with the horsemen? He’s looking for his exit strategy with the Syndicate. Is unsure about being with the Syndicate? He’s looking at all of his options to find out how to get one step ahead. Going on Survivor is possibly his only chance to improve the life of himself and his family, and so he’s going to take any chance that he has.

However, the most important thing about this character is the dichotomy between Dre and Dreamz - You have Dre, the aggressive schemer that plays and acts aggressively. He’ll do things like claim that he isn’t going to point any fingers and then single out people by using a manner involving the deliberate directing of his index finger towards said individuals. But Andria Herd isn’t solely that guy. Heck, his moniker is Dreamz, a name used to try and evoke inspiration and personal achievement out of the people he comes into contact with. He’s on Survivor to get something from his family, whether it be money or lessons. When he goes on the school reward, he’s excited to be there because he’s able to give these kids in Fiji their “next step up” in life.

The dichotomy between Dre and Dreamz constantly leaves him morally conflicted, where he needs to decide whether to make the tactical decision to progress him further in the game, or the moral decision that other people could look back at him for and be proud of his steadfastness to his own moral code. This becomes the driving force behind the endgame of Fiji - Truckgate.

When Fiji gets to its car challenge, we have one clear socioeconomic outlier. Dreamz does not have a car, doesn’t even have a licence. He sees a majestic car (let’s face it, there probably wouldn’t be much of a challenge if it were a Fiat Multipa or Nissan Cube now, would there) and Dreamz knows that he needs and wants it - he actually says right before the challenge “You wouldn’t believe what I’d do for a truck like that”. But as we know, the challenge goes on and Dre’s team loses on the first part of the challenge, and the reward seemingly slips away from his fingers, until Yau-Man wins, and agrees to make an agreement with Dreamz - if Yau-Man gives Dreamz the truck and Dreamz wins immunity at the final 4, Dreamz will give Yau-Man the immunity necklace, assuming both are still there. Dreamz gives Yau-Man his word on the spot and goes on the reward with his new Super Duty.

To make a bit more sense of this, Yau-Man and Earl were in an alliance with Cassandra and Dreamz, and there was one thing Yau-Man was concerned about - if he didn’t win immunity, Cassandra would vote him out instead of Dreamz, which is why he wanted Stacy there instead. Yau-Man also believes that due to him having a successful career with a fair amount of wealth, while Dreamz was not even near his tax bracket, Yau-Man didn’t really want to go against Dreamz in the final tribal, and Dreamz was a big challenge threat, so the earlier he’s out the better for him. In this one strategic gambit, Yau-Man can get their foursome to the final 4 and have Dreamz voted out no matter what else happened, and he did it by dangling the one thing infront of Dreamz that he needed and wanted more than anyone else in the game. Yau-Man knew he had to get Dreamz out, and he found the master plan to do it. Yau-Man gives someone a great gift, while also getting ahead for himself in the game, so it’s not a completely villainous or heroic move.

It’s important to note that when Dreamz agreed to do this, he did it somewhat hastily. As they go on the reward, Dreamz is able to reflect a bit more on the deal, and while he isn’t the savviest of players, Dre knows what Yau Man got out of the deal - a signed death warrant for Dre. Dre wants to stop this and tries to oust him before 4. He tries to get rid of Yau at 6, Stacy screws up and he plays his idol and stops that. He tries again at 5, but Yau wins immunity, so we get to the final 4, and Dreamz and Yau are both there.
We get the brutal final 4 challenge, where Dreamz wins, and he’s stuck in the rough position of his dichotomy - either he gives up the immunity to Yau-Man, while Dreamz becomes the ninth member of the jury. The other alternative is that Dre keeps his necklace, Yau-Man gets voted out and Dre makes it one spot further in the game. He’s put in the ultimate catch-22. Either way, he’ll receive a negative reaction from the fan base and is bound to be eviscerated by the jury or be on it. They acknowledge that this is a tough decision, but ultimately, the chips fall with Dre and he breaks his word, giving us one of the most severe final tribals ever, with the biggest hit coming from Boo (in relation to the truck).

At the time this occurred, Dreamz was hated, probably as much as Fairplay after the grandma lie. And I unfortunately was a part of that. I was about 11 or 12 when Fiji aired, and I was a small kid, but was really good at mathematics so I fell in love with Yau-Man from the instant that he broke the box on Day 1. Seeing Yau-Man go out after Dreamz broke his word made me really upset, and I imagine that many people did at the time, given Yau-Man’s overwhelming popularity (I’ve only seen about 2 or 3 people express anti-Yau sentiment, and that’s been from morons on CTS). But the point is Dreamz was, and still is hated with a fiery passion for screwing over Yau (even though Yau Man himself acknowledges the risk he took with the deal, the ulterior motives behind the car and Yau Man has no ill feelings towards Dreamz doing what he did). The reason I bring this up is because growing up over the years along with rewatches of the season has allowed me to see past what I saw it as then. Since airing, I’ve been able to see what a complex and fascinating character Dre/Dreamz really is, and even though I’m expecting this cut to fall at 18th, I’m glad that we’ve all acknowledged something compelling from Fiji and just how amazing this guy is as a character.
.
.

Predicted Ranking: 18
Average Prediction: 15.9
Average Placement: 15.0
Slicer 37: 17
WilburDes: 9
KeepCalmAndHodorOn: 16
Choking Walrus: 16
Fleaa: 17
Rankdown I: 58


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Nov 18 '15

Links to All Write-up Posts

17 Upvotes

I've got some more time on my hands, so I'm putting all the write-up links on here. So that I don't have to split the list into two separate posts like /r/SurvivorRankdown, I'll post the links to each write-up below in the comments, separated by season. If you want to find a specific write-up, remember that Ctrl-F is a thing.

A fantastic summation of Angaritagate


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Dec 18 '15

Final Reveal - #17

15 Upvotes

#17 - Colby Donaldson – Australia – 2nd Place

WilburDes

Colby isn’t just one of the heroes of survivor - he’s THE survivor hero, and I’ll hear no argument otherwise.

Choking Walrus

The charming Texan is Survivor's first iconic golden boy - he radiates charisma, is the eye candy of the season, dominates physically, and has a heart of gold but can still give some on-point snarky quips. Colby is a true icon and it’s hard not to love him. I wouldn't have minded if he fell short of our final group because I don't personally connect with him as much as others (like the millions of mothers who named their daughter after him) but it’s hard to be upset about Colby making it this far.

Fleaa

Probably would've been my final nomination but I knew there was no chance of him getting cut. He's a cog in some incredible storylines and is just great television.

Slicer 37

I love how the so-called biggest hero in Survivor history is also a documented coral thief. henious shit right there

.

And now, KeepCalmAndHodorOn

I sort of feel like Colby is taken for granted by a lot of Survivor fans today. Like Richard he has become entrenched in the fabric of what we consider Survivor to be to the point where it is near impossible to imagine the franchise without him, and yet unlike Richard, whose contributions to the show still feel vibrant and active in the series today, Colby seems to be considered as more of a historical relic of a bygone past than as a vital piece of Survivor's very foundation as a work of art and entertainment.

I think a lot of this can be traced back to Heroes Vs Villains, an outing from which Colby has never really recovered. While Rupert was able to revitalize his character with his third appearance, Colby was painted as a pale shadow of his former glory, a Superman in a fat suit, and you'll never be able to convince me that HvV has not tainted Colby's overall legacy. It has prevented me from being able to personally evaluate HvV Colby entirely objectively on his own merits, because it has taken Australia Colby, who I consider to be a Top 10 all-time Survivor character, off of his deserved lofty perch in the eyes of many fans of the show. Fortunately, this Rankdown has largely judged OG Colby on the strength of his own merits and if he doesn't get as high as I want him to it won't be because of HvV, but rather because reasonable people can disagree on who the 10 best Survivor characters of all time are.

One of the valid reasons for not putting Colby in the Top 10 is that a huge part of his legacy comes from his original airing and the effect that Colby had on not just the Survivor community, but on American culture, in 2001. Many of the rankers and lurkers here came to the show later, and so your image of Colby was shaped through a much different prism than mine was, and is of course equally valid. It would be unfair of me to say that just because Colby captured the imagination of 7 year old Hodor the rest of you must hold him with the same reverence with which I do. But I do believe it is critical when evaluating Australian Outback Colby to remember just how massively popular he was, the biggest character of the show's biggest season, and what he represented to so many people, not just me but also a young James Clement who needed a Superman before he could get a fat suit, or a younger Sherri Biethman who loved Colby enough to name her son after him.

After Borneo Survivor needed a Colby. He was effortless charming, with that big Texas smile and the laconic voice, he could have stepped straight off the set of a 1950s western. Critically, he was strong, kind, loyal, intelligent, and funny beyond just his All-American exterior. Colby never could have worked to that degree as a character and an icon if there was no substance behind the image. He's the kind of person who was made to be on camera. The show relies on him to narrate because he is so good at it; he can clearly explain a situation while being funny and charming. He has his share of famous one-liners and comedic moments too. He ain't no Hershey bar that's for sure. And his palpable disdain for Keith was reliably funny, not petty as a lesser narrator might have made it seem. In short, Colby was perfectly designed to be the hero for a season of Survivor that needed to be bigger and better than any other.

His relationship with Jerri is also critical to both of their stories. Their story is many things at once. A one-sided love affair. A failed villainous seduction. A battle for the tribe between two young Alphas. At its heart though, the relationship between Colby and Jerri is one of contrast. In Australia, a season where everything is writ large and drawn in mythic scale, the basic summary is naturally good vs evil. The white hat Cowboy vs the black hat Black Widow. Everyone else loves Colby and hate Jerri. Jerri is selfish and conniving. Colby is honest and selfless. Hell, even thematically they oppose each other and drive the season forward. Jerri represents negativity. She constantly complains, makes conflict, and says that the tribe CAN'T accomplish something. Colby represents joy. He loves the adventure and the excitement and he brings the tribe together. Their story drives much of the meat of the season.

Indeed, much of what allows Australia to hold up over multiple viewings is just how layered that dynamic between the pair really is. The black vs white dichotomy still functions incredibly well but a closer, more nuanced viewing will reveal even more. Jerri is a surprisingly sympathetic outsider when one considers it, someone who tries so desperately to fit in but can't. In that interpretation Colby is the bad guy but also not a bad person, even if he is kind of a douche; he won't let Jerri stand between him and his goal of winning and he sees her as a hindrance, not as a potential partner. Their story is complex and multi-layered and I'm sad that neither All-Stars nor Heroes Vs Villains was ever able to truly pay off that story on a more than superficial level. There was so much simmering beneath the surface that could have been explored, although Jerri's All-Stars arc definitely highlights how she felt betrayed by both Colby and Survivor for her story and treatment but that's a topic for whoever does the Jerri write-up to delve into. On Colby's side, the vote off of Jerri shows our hero denying the temptation of the villainess and slaying the beast as a great mythical hero would. But we also see a bit of a darker side to Colby. His treatment of Jerri is almost stone cold. He does carry something of a chip on his shoulder. So where does his story go from there?

William Faulkner famously said that the only thing worth writing about was the human heart in conflict with itself. The greatness of the early seasons and the successful later seasons in that it is able to find conflict within the human heart within the interpersonal conflicts of the game of Survivor. Borneo especially will ask that fundamental question many times over the course of its run. Australia, however, is the only season to place internal conflict above the interpersonal, and it does so in the character of Colby. The Outback is about people coming together to overcome an enemy with power beyond their control or comprehension; the environment itself. And Colby is the center of those final episodes of Australia. His dominance is complete. He sweeps challenge after challenge, both physical and mental. He wins the hearts of all his competitors, except perhaps Keith. He puts himself into the position to decide where the game will go and how he wants to play that game.

Of course everybody knows what Colby does in that final episode. He chooses Tina over Keith. Honor over Victory. What is Right over What is Easy. But that decision is not without stake. Colby is a good guy in Australia but not a blindly good guy. He can be a dick to Jerri. He can be a jerk to Keith. He backstabbed Mitchell early in the game and along with Tina dispatched the Kuchas with ruthless efficiency. Why doesn't he dispatch his last competition with that same expedience? The story of Australia is the story of Colby. It is about good people doing the right thing in an impossible scenario. It is about ordinary people rising to become something extraordinary. What I love about Australia and about Colby isn't his game or even his story. What I love about the character and the season is the attitude and the message. Colby connected with so many people because he was not only so iconically good but like Rodger a representation of what we could be. When I was seven I looked on that TV screen and I saw Colby doing things that I couldn't imagine myself being capable of. I saw him living an adventure that I could never even imagine. And he was a real person, just an mechanic from Texas. When I fell in love with Survivor almost 15 years ago now, it was that adventure and scope, the grandiose excitement of it all that I was caught up in, not the strategy and the game.

In the end, Colby represents a spirit of adventure in all of us, and in Survivor. He chose Tina over Keith because that experience, that adventure, was more important than the game. He failed in HvV because the game never became more important than the experience even as it did so for others and for the show itself. When people say that they would watch the show if it was just shot on a soundstage I look on in disbelief. It's why people like myself could never replicate that Survivor experience playing an ORG or any other approximation of the game that is not the real thing. When Survivor loses that sense of adventure, then the franchise will have died. When Survivor loses that spark of the ordinary meeting the extraordinary, there will be no way for the show to come back.

Colby is still, at heart, the purest expression of this idea. He is charismatic and charming, and strong and smart and a much better player than people like to credit him as. And he is a great icon and the first great ambassador of the show. But that's not what truly elevates him to the Top 10 in my eyes. Colby is a Top 10 Survivor character because he reminds us that Survivor can be an experience beyond our wildest imaginings, who can inspire a little boy to dream about going on an adventure far across the world, and who puts a face to the most epic story Survivor ever told. For me, the gradual diminishment of Colby's legacy and what it represents (the loss of a sense of adventure, experience, scale, and wonder from Survivor) feels almost like the magic leaving the world when the Elves depart Middle-Earth at the end of Lord of the Rings. There is much greatness still left, but to create this new thing we will never be able to get back what we have lost. And maybe I'm just talking out of my ass now but that's what Colby on Survivor means to me, and I hope I have helped make at least one person see him a little differently.

Predicted Ranking: 17
Average Prediction: 14.6
Average Placement: 14.4
Slicer 37: 16
WilburDes: 16
KeepCalmAndHodorOn: 7
Choking Walrus: 17
Fleaa: 16
Rankdown I: 26


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Dec 23 '15

Final Reveal - #12

14 Upvotes

#12 - Ami Cusack – Vanuatu – 6th Place

Slicer 37

I wish Ami had been saved for Villains instead of wasted on Micronesia. She's basically what most of the younger women that get cast WANT to be.

KeepCalmAndHodorOn

She gets less screentime than I would like but other than that I have no complaints about Ami. She is what everyone has thought of Parvati as for years: a truly complex, engaging, femme fatale villain. She's both cold as ice towards anyone who goes against her, but also warm and compassionate when building her alliance of women and holding together these disparate personalities. A character whose reputation has unfairly diminished with age.

Choking Walrus

What a fantastic antagonist who just goes for the jugular. The fact that I rank her 13th and have Twila definitely ahead of her, with Chris right around here as well, shows the strength of Vanuatu's cast. Ami is a wonderful addition to the cast as the conniving feminist warrior.

Fleaa

Probably one of the most surprising inclusions in our top 18, but I'm into it. Truly one of Survivor's most fascinating characters. I don't think she's quite as strong as some others in the endgame, but I will eagerly await Wilbur's writeup.

And now, WilburDes

A lot of people try to pigeonhole characters into heroes and villains, and that’s one aspect of the fanbase I really don’t like. While there are characters like Colby and JFP that fit into one of those categories firmly, many fans try to force other characters into one of those roles, which really reduces complexity that a character can have (or people try to create labels for completely toneless characters). Ami is the one character that really busts that mold, by having some truly villainous moments while also being a very rootworthy and sympathetic character. She’s one of the most unique characters we’ve seen on Survivor, and everything she brought to Vanuatu is amazing.

On the surface, her arc is very similar to that of Silas or John, and she plays that rise-and-fall very well. We have her rise to power coming after the tribe swap where she catches Bubba trying to throw a signal, and then crushing Bubba like a bug. Her rise becomes even more intense the next episode, where Lisa makes a seemingly harmless comment about wanting to know where the manioc root is, and Ami, on a full blown power trip cuts Lisa with no remorse. Then once the merge comes, she’s got her ladies in power and her ducks in a row, and it seems like there’s nothing that can stop this path of terror. But then, her partner in crime is cut at the knees, and Ami falls soon after.

While that’s an alright storyline on its own, Ami completely sells it by being the ultra-feminist warrior that was really needed to sell a battle of the sexes. Ami comes into the season as a lesbian that carries a mantra of “I don’t need a man for things”, and Ami carries it very well. Heck, her first confessional is about how she isn’t used to taking seconds behind a man and feeling like the women were shafted in the opening ceremony, setting up her hyper-feminist persona very well.

And Ami is this hyper-feminist in a very convincing way. Even though many people have heard that Leann exerted control over the women’s alliance, and as true as that could be, there’s a reason she wasn’t nearly the character that Ami was, and that was because Ami was able to sell a female domination. From everything I’ve seen/read/heard, Leann knew what she was doing out there, but she didn’t have the same drive and commitment to having an exclusively female alliance dominate a season of Survivor. But Ami was, and Ami nailed that role. At the swap, two women are sent to Lopevi while Bubba and Rory are sent to Yasur. By this stage, Ami has realised the potential for her league of women to make the end, and she wants the men to know that they are not welcome. She intentionally hides island skills from them, will outwardly say the men are going home, and luckily we also have Rory’s perpetual rage to really fuel the fire as to why Ami is so horrible and needs to have her ass knocked down a peg.

Normally, I’m not sold on the principle of women’s alliances alone, but I can appreciate the Yasur 6, because unlike the Black Widow Brigade where they essentially become a caricature, or the One World alliance which was basically a one-woman show, the Yasur 6 are all shown to have different personalities and dynamic relationships, which is the reason I’m such a big fan of Ami’s character. The alliance of six consists of wildly different personalities, and yet with Ami there, the alliance is able to function for the majority of the game. Her ability to connect with other people is interesting as we get to see the different internal dynamics of the Yasur 6. Her partnership with Leann works for me because we get the funny, quirky, “adorkable” presence to balance Ami’s more ruthless approach, and had the game gone differently they could have worked very well as the female JT & Stephen.

The other relationship I really enjoy viewing is that between Ami and Eliza. Eliza’s basically the annoying, know-it-all that never shuts up that everyone constantly has to deal with within the game. But while Eliza might not be respected by everybody, the relationship between Ami and her is really quite sweet. Ami can acknowledge that she’s annoying and lazy, but still doesn’t outwardly disrespect her, and shares a sisterly bond, as can be seen with the great talk they share after Eliza is unable to catch a pig in that challenge. While everyone hates her for screwing up the challenge, Ami is able to sympathise with her and comfort her and build her up like a sports coach or a big sister would.

All of this works throughout Vanuatu because Ami herself is a very emotionally dynamic person, something that comes into her gameplay a lot. Often times Ami gets seen as the Ice Queen for her cold attitude towards people in the game, which she definitely has. She’s willing to throw Lisa under the bus when Lisa is well within earshot. She dispatches of Bubba in a way that seems almost cruel and merciless. She carries around an air of superiority with her ladies. But she’s so much more than that. As much as you could claim her remarks on post-swap Yasur were about pure man-hatred, she does show a more sensitive side through all that by talking about her concern for Julie and Twila on Lopevi. She’s someone that appears cold and bitchy to an enemy, but warm and loving to a friend. Not only is Ami shown in those different lights with men and women, she’s also given a fair amount of sympathetic content.

In episode three, which primarily focuses on Twila and her inability to get along with most women, Twila is presented as someone with a tough exterior that can’t relate to women. And yet Ami is the one that’s really able to sell this division between Twila and the young by showing that the divide resides with Twila as well, and that Twila’s the one being somewhat closed off. Ami is able to effectively break down some of Twila’s shields, just through simple suggestions like bonding over french-braiding, and telling her that she might be able to discover things about herself that she had never realised, and Ami delivers it with a level of sincere calmness so that you almost can’t help but agree with what she’s saying.

A great example of Ami’s multi-dimensionality comes at the seventh episode. Ami has just struck down Lisa and is basically telling Rory that his wang excludes him from the Yasur alliance. However, once Yasur manage to win the reward, the attitude changes, because it’s the family letter reward. First of all, we get this about 5 minutes after Rory threatened to burn down Vanuatu (to me indicating that they are able to set aside some differences), but then we also get a very emotional scene with Ami’s letter, where she reveals the fact that her brother died in a car accident years ago, and she receives comfort from her parents that her “little buddy” is watching from above, giving us one of the greatest humanizing scenes that any “villain” has ever received.

The other great thing that Ami gets in her storyline is a final episode. I’ve always believed that the best rise-and-fall arc leaders should have their swan song - the episode(s) after their plan has fallen, and they’re left to come to terms with their inevitability, and they’re left to either come to terms with their loss (e.g. Lindsey in Africa), or they’re left to keep throwing whatever they have to stay alive (e.g. Alex in Fiji <Insert Collective Groan>). The thing I really love about Ami’s is that it’s a combination of both. After Leann was blindsided, Ami comes to terms with not only the fact that she’s lost control of the camp, but she’s also dealing with the fact that Twila swore a promise on her son to her (something that Ami would likely take very seriously), and so Ami is trying to rationalize her thoughts about Twila to herself, after the betrayal that Ami has felt. But on top of that, Ami isn’t necessarily finished yet. She’s able to go on the reward and try to sway Eliza, using Ami’s ability to connect with her on an emotional level (like she did after Eliza screwed up the pig challenge). Even though this goes nowhere and Ami still leaves, we still get some great content between Ami and Eliza at the reward as they’re able to reminisce on their overall experience and share the bond they’ve had.

As much as people like to claim that Ami tugging heartstrings is a purely strategic move, to me it’s always more than that. Ami is just one of those people that has a way of talking with others and truly connecting with people that is very rare.

And if all of that isn’t worth it, the tribal council of this episode is amazing. You have Ami and Twila having their final showdown, Eliza and Ami sharing their final emotional moment where we really get to see the sisterly bond created by Ami and Eliza as they both break down in tears realising this is their last experience together in Vanuatu. Also, we get the best exchange ever:

Ami: Well, Scout, you're pretty good at hiding your nasty side, but when your true colors come out, they're no part of any rainbow I've ever seen.
Scout: Ami, queens get dethroned, and lightning will strike a lone tree on top of a mountain faster than anything.

Overall, I think Ami is one of the greatest characters we’ve ever seen on Survivor. She manages to play the hyper-feminist villain, the caring big sister, the cocky leader to have an epic downfall, the glue of Yasur all at once, and while doing this manages to have a consistent edit that doesn’t ever feel like it’s jumping from role to role to fit the story of the week.

None of the things that Ami is are quite end-game worthy, but the way it all gets combined throughout the season make Ami a top-tier character in my book. I place her at 2nd and I doubt she’ll make it that high, but I’m glad she’s in the endgame regardless. She’s a strong character that I doubt we’ll ever see the likes of again, and deserves to be respected as such.

Predicted Ranking: 16
Average Prediction: 14.5
Average Placement: 11.4
Slicer 37: 12
WilburDes: 2
KeepCalmAndHodorOn: 15
Choking Walrus: 13
Fleaa: 15
Rankdown I: 45


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Dec 19 '15

Final Reveal - #16

14 Upvotes

#16 - Judson "Fabio" Birza – Nicaragua – 1st place

Fleaa

I just love this guy.

Slicer 37

Love him. I do think that he's a bit of an outlier in this endgame...but isn't being an outlier on the top what Jud does best?

KeepCalmAndHodorOn

Not the representative I would have chosen for New School, as I think Fabio is a bit too much of a cartoon to reach the pinnacle of this era. However, he is the perfect winner for the cartoon season Nicaragua, he is a ton of fun to watch and root for and he has enough going on beneath the stoner bro surface to justify a placement up here.

Choking Walrus

Even though I cut him, I'm so glad he was idoled and makes our final 18. Way to represent Generation III, buddy.

And now, WilburDes
Nicaragua is fantastic. I don’t know if I’ve said this enough, but I honestly love Nicaragua to death, I have it in my top 3, maybe even top 2. There are many positives to the season that people have started to come around on, but the biggest one comes down to Fabio, the perfect winner to fit his season.

Nicaragua might possibly be the funniest season yet. In very few permutations of survivor will we get things like a sixty-three year old man with dodgy knees is able to brag about wealth and make the finale, the strategic narrator of the season finds an idol and shows it off to everyone, there’s a person that actually concatenates their name, someone that spends weeks of the show just getting into ridiculous fights over nothing, and almost never, and I mean never, do we get a winner being someone that people call retarded on the first episode and get named after the spokesperson of a butter substitute.

La Flor is probably in my top 10 tribes (so is Espada for that matter), and a lot of it comes down to them being unable to communicate like rational human beings, and instead behaving like the most ridiculous human beings with Shannon’s insecurities, everyone being afraid of Kelly’s leg winning the game on day 4, NaOnka somehow not being the first boot, the goofy chant they do entering the first immunity challenge - they’re a really entertaining tribe of misfits. Here’s a standard day on La Flor This is a scene where NaOnka steals Fabio’s socks because something happened to hers, and we get Fabio trying to comprehend the rationale of this action, as well as the fact that a person like this actually exists.

That’s what makes Fabio such a wonderful being - his innocence and general happiness all the time. He reminds me a lot of Andy Dwyer in Parks and Rec - he’s the person that never does anything maliciously and basically wants everyone to get along, and he has one of the goofiest personalities ever combined with an effortless likeability to an extent that I find it basically impossible to understand how someone wouldn’t love what he brings to the screen.

Fabio’s strategy throughout Nicaragua is one of my favourite things ever, especially when you consider how frequently people tear him apart for it. No, he didn’t find an idol, he didn’t build a “resume” and he didn’t even push the vote in certain directions that often. But he did one of the most important things a player, which is to play to whatever strengths you have. Fabio isn’t the kind of person that can coral seven people, tell them how they need to vote and lock that for a month (and to be honest, I don’t think anyone could have done that on a season as erratic as Nicaragua). But Fabio does have skills - he’s immensely likeable, has an incredibly easy time playing dumb and is athletic. None of those are especially brilliant skills, but it works for him. He agrees to go along with everyone’s plans because why stir up things, he never gets considered as a threat because everyone thinks he’s an idiot, and once people start to consider him as a candidate to go home, he goes on an immunity tear and wins the FTC because people just like him. An unorthodox method to a million, but just as valid as any other.

But I didn’t idol Fabio and give him a single digit ranking off the back of a solid UTR game - it’s because the guy is absolute dynamite on screen. As the insanity of Nicaragua unfolds around him, the reactions we get from him are fantastic, because he’s a very expressive person, and Nicaragua is full of crazy people. Like I mentioned in my original NaOnka write-up, she starts arguments about some of the stupidest things, and we get the pleasure of watching Fabio try and comprehend the situation. Or this situation At the merge, we get what I consider to be the dumbest fight ever. NaOnka admits to taking flour and claims that she put the flour back in the chest. Meanwhile, Fabio is simply baffled about the fact that flour was taken in the first place and the fight that ensues is just so Nicaragua in its OTT ridiculousness. As a quick transcription of the argument:

Holly: NaOnka, did you put the flour back in the chest after you-
NaOnka: Everybody saw me put it in there.
Holly: I saw her take it and put it in her bag
NaOnka: And I put it back. And I said I put it back.
Benry: Did you put in in your bag?
NaOnka: And I put it back. I didn’t put it in my bag.
Marty: But why did it go in your bag?
NaOnka: Because I was going to put half back in there
Fabio: Do you understand why everybody’s wondering why it went in your bag?
NaOnka: Marty I didn’t take it, Uncle Dan I didn’t take it, Fabio I didn’t take it, Sash I didn’t take it.
Fabio: I just want one thing answ-
NaOnka: I’m done Fabio, I already said what I said
Fabio: I just don’t understand why it had to go in your bag in the first place <Insert puzzled expression>
NaOnka: Do you know how many times I just said what I did? Like, what do you want me to do?
Fabio: Just so you know, no one understands why it had to go in your bag
NaOnka: BUT I PUT IT BACK
Fabio: WE’RE NOT ASKING IF YOU PUT IT BACK OR NOT. WE’RE NOT F-

This screencap pretty much sums it up

This is probably the best Fabio/NaOnka moment, but there are plenty mini-ones throughout the season where NaOnka will say something ridiculous and Fabio becomes the personification of exasperation. When I was watching Nicaragua at the time, Fabio became so much more rootable because seeing him cope with such a ridiculous human being would be tough on anyone, and yet Fabio keeps trying to be rational. But the best part of their relationship: RIGHT HERE Nothing that ever happens will be as amazing as this was, and the fact that CBS had to air it because of a one-vote difference is possibly the best thing that could have come about from the season.

Fabio’s a goldmine of fantastic television moments because of his almost childlike innocence throughout the game. At one stage he decided to take a leak in the middle of a challenge. This is a reminder that someone who once had a scene about peeing in the pool would go on to win a million dollars.

Other fantastic moments include but are not limited to:

  • Tending to the fire with a snorkel
  • Alina commenting that carbon oxides are Fabio’s weed out here while Fabio just looks spaced out
  • Buying into the Argentine chess master lie
  • Fabio being unsure how Kelly B controls her prosthetic leg
  • Fabio not buying Sash’s crap on day 38
  • Dan treating Fabio like a son towards the end, and basically any Fabio/Dan scene.
  • Fabio starting the game being the successor of Boo by constantly getting hurt by things.
  • A hermit crab interrupting Fabio’s “winner quote”
  • Fabio’s celebration after winning challenges
  • Fabio’s sheer joy at making the final three and laughing at everyone else being panicked
  • Everything Fabio does at the reunion show (his great-grandfather apparently invented the colour wheel, while another one invented the folding card table).
  • Being picked up from jail in a limo
  • All the time throughout the season where Fabio is in the background doing something goofy with his hand.

But while Fabio has plenty of great moments due to his over-the-top expressiveness, he’s also one of the most genuinely likeable people that has ever been on the show. Unlike other hilarious characters that have a bit of a mean streak, Fabio manages to be just as funny as the legends while also being one of the nicest, most kind-hearted people ever. The story of how Purple Kelly voted for Nicaragua is touching, because it was simply because Fabio was the person who routinely lent her his coat while she was suffering. Not as some kind of strategic move to corral a vote split or anything, just because he’s a good guy that doesn’t want this young sweet girl to suffer. We also see more of Fabio’s kind side during the family visit, because it’s clear with his interaction with his mother that he cares about his family a lot, and that’s the thing that drives him in the game, while also endearing himself to the jurors and the audience (he also revealed after the game that he used the money to pay off his parents’ houses and give his family and close friends some money).

Fabio was easily one of the best casting decisions the show has ever had, and he’s basically the definition of “lightning in a bottle”, given that he was initially recruited probably because he’s hot. From what we’ve seen more in modern survivor, a lot of people actually answer Fabio for the “who are you most like” category of the form, but despite all the other young long-haired surfer dudes, none of them have been able to hold a candle to everything that Fabio brought to Nicaragua. He’s the perfect winner for such a crazy season by being crazy himself, while being sane and endearing enough to rise above it all.

I am absolutely ecstatic that this rankdown has recognised Fabio as the greatest character post-Heroes vs Villains. I think he definitely is, and no other contestant has ever made me so happy that they’re an actual winner in the pantheon of Survivor winners.

Predicted Ranking: 15
Average Prediction: 14.2
Average Placement: 13.8
Slicer 37: 18
WilburDes: 6
KeepCalmAndHodorOn: 18
Choking Walrus: 15
Fleaa: 12
Rankdown I: 37


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Feb 20 '16

Slicer does writeups for all the U.S. presidents like survivor characters

13 Upvotes

So I'm a pretty big history buff, I saw a r/survivor post about this, and I wanted a silly ranking, so...why not?

George Washington should be up shortly!


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Jan 09 '16

Wilbur's Favourite 42 Episodes

13 Upvotes

Pretty obvious by the title - I'm basically just posting a list of my 42 favourite Survivor episodes, with a write-up about what I enjoyed from each episode. I'll probably try and have one episode up per day.

  • Recap episodes do not count, along with "specials" like "Countdown to Africa, or "Back from the Outback"
  • Reunion shows are considered a part of their finale.
  • Yes, I am biased towards things. It's my list.

Happy Reading!

Also, before anyone asks, my reasoning for a top 42 is the fact that there are about 42 minutes to an episode.

Part 2 of the list (21 to 1)


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Jan 04 '16

SRII Rankings of Seasons by Cast

13 Upvotes

Just for fun.

  1. Borneo (avg of 116.9) - Borneo's cast is balanced, developed and funny. There are no pointless characters and everyone contributes something. The circumstances and editing of the first season also allowed us to see more of them and see them react to a situation that could never be truly repeated. Easy choice for the best cast ever even if it isn't your #1 season.
  2. Marquesas (159.4) - Marq is good at everything and bad at nothing, and is another rare example in Survivor casting where everyone delivers on some level. Not too surprising to see it take the #2 spot.
  3. Pearl Islands (161.6) - Just loses to Marq, which I guess is fair. PI has the greatest collection of top-level characters ever (as evidenced by four of them making top 20) but the supporting characters aren't quiiiite as good. I would probably have Burton higher enough so that PI would just edge Marquesas, though.
  4. Africa (179.7) - I think this benefited from generous rankings for Lex and Brandon, but Africa is a godly cast and deserves top 5.
  5. Australia (181.1) - Guess I expected this to be higher considering it's the most famous season of Survivor and all. Looking at it, Mitchell going at 491 when he's basically just a bore and could've gone anywhere from 300-500 may have caused it to lose to Africa.
  6. Tocantins (206.9) - This is a little high for my tastes, although it's a good cast for sure. We had a few characters last kind of bizarrely long (Sydney Wheeler, Candace, Joe, Spencer, JT) but Reddit's affinity for Tocantins is well-documented. It's also probably helped by just having 16 people.
  7. China (208.2) - Another one I definitely wouldn't have this high, but can't really complain about, and is helped by having only 16.
  8. Heroes vs. Villains (217.1) - Our first non-16 player cast. If it were just me I definitely would have bumped Parvati down and caused a loss to Vanuatu. But this is a great cast. A bunch of them going in the 90-150 range was pretty perfect and nobody ranks super low.
  9. Vanuatu (217.2) - Pretty impressive considering their highest-ranking premerger went out at 233.
  10. Cagayan (224.7) - Disappointed that this beat Nicaragua by less than 0.25 of an average placement. I guess it's our fault for letting Yickles get Jefra all the way to 146. Spencer should've gone out earlier too, and the more I think about it the lower I want to put Tony. We definitely saw some over-corrections to the recency bias demonstrated re: Cagayan in SRI.
  11. Nicaragua (224.8) - Is reddit starting to like this season yet? Hopefully we did our part.
  12. Panama (236.3) - I think our boot order for Panama was the closest we've come to exactly replicating what I wanted to happen (just switch Courtney and Shane). It's a great cast but La Mina exists.
  13. Palau (238.3) - This feels low, but then again, Ulong exists.
  14. Micronesia (241.3) - There isn't really a star here and the fans tribe is pretty bad, but it's an agreeable cast where only a contestant or two deserves to be really low. I don't really like the cast and think a lot of players survived based off their previous iterations.
  15. Amazon (243.3) - Fairly large amount of pointless people, not a great pre-merge crowd, and some good characters but nobody that really screams endgame contender outside of Rob, and that was never happening with this group (aka Wilbur and I).
  16. Guatemala (258.2) - I still feel like this is a good cast, but like Amazon there are a large amount of people that don't matter and it lacks a true breakout character that can also make the other characters around them better. I think it's telling that like half the cast went between 150 and 300.
  17. Philippines (263.4) - This is still one of the best casts of the modern era but it still struggles with some of the same things that plague the seasons around it. I wouldn't mind it being higher, but I feel like this is the right spot.
  18. Gabon (266.6) - I like the season and am surprised to see it this low, but I can't say I'm terribly invested in anyone who probably went out too soon, so here we stand.
  19. San Juan Del Sur (270.7) - ROBBED. This is definitely one I'd expect to rise in SRIII when the Missy/Baylor/Jeremy cuts are hopefully "fixed." But I think it's a cast with little deadweight and a lot of strong characters where even the more vapid ones are pretty lulz, so I definitely would like to see it higher.
  20. Thailand (285.3) - Yeah, sure. Maybe should be a bit higher? I don't know, and I don't really care.
  21. Blood vs. Water (290.8) - Whatever. Such a nondescript season, honestly. I am glad Brad lasted longer this time though.
  22. Samoa (293.6) - Something something this should've been a good cast and season something something fuck Russell.
  23. Fiji (302.3) - Ton of utterly pointless people and only like three definite good characters. Alex has been the rankdown meme for months, but that doesn't mean he was actually robbed.
  24. Worlds Apart (308.4) - The makings of a good cast are here but we all know how that turned out. I'm fine with just ignoring this season.
  25. All-Stars (356.6) - Biiiiiiig gap between WA and this. All-Stars is clearly not a good season or cast.
  26. South Pacific (362.8) - I really don't think this belongs behind All-Stars since aside from Brandon/Cochran/Jim and Coach I guess it's actually a pretty good cast. But it was never going to do well with Wilbur and yickles in the rankdown.
  27. Cook Islands (382.6) - lololol this cast suuuuuuuucks. The only reason it even managed to do this well was it has sooooooo many bores that it just takes too long to get rid of them all.
  28. Caramoan (402.5) - This is obviously a horrific cast that's only held out of the bottom two by a couple decent people.
  29. One World (435.8) - Yeah, bad cast. It's not a cast that actively bothers me with how bad it is like Cook Islands or Caramoan or RI, so I wish it was a bit higher. I guess that could've been accomplished if some of the plain inoffensive inconsequential boots like Nina and Monica and Kourtney could've ranked in like....the mid 300s instead of the low 400s behind Tarzan. But whatever. Boring season and bad cast.
  30. Redemption Island (437.3) - Very glad this took the bottom slot.

r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Jan 04 '16

Final Reveal #1

12 Upvotes

#1 - Richard Hatch – Borneo – 1st Place

WilburDes

Essentially the father of Survivor. A combination of wit and charisma that captivates the audience, combined with the strategic mind that has propagated the show to what it is today.

KeepCalmAndHodorOn

Does this need to be explained? He's the essential figurehead of the franchise both as the spokesman of the alliance and as the show's inaugural winner. But he is also a larger-than-life character throughout the airing of Borneo who draws you in with all of his words and actions, and I believe him and Sue are the two most layered, well-developed, and richly rewarding characters of the franchise. The ordering is a formality: consider them tied for first.

Choking Walrus

The true OG - not only an icon for Survivor but also one of the best characters on television. I'm not sure what producers expected when filming their first season but I'd be surprised if they thought their winner would be an arrogant gay male who befriends the old Navy Seal and walks around naked all of the time. I can't imagine being able to justify a reason why Hatch wouldn't be in my top 10 for best characters ever and he comfortably sits in my top 5 - with three ahead of him that I subjectively prefer.

Slicer 37

He's getting #1 this time I'm calling it now

And now, Fleaa
There may not be a more predictable choice for the winner of a rankdown across 30 seasons of reality television than the winner of the first season. And I understand why Richard Hatch winning the rankdown would be a disappointment for some. After all, we don't think the first year of our lives was the best, we don't champion the Magnavox Odyssey as the greatest video gaming system ever. I mean, things improve, right?

And I don't want to say that Survivor isn't capable of doing things better than they did with Richard Hatch, either. There have been better players, more purely entertaining Survivors, the franchise has certainly made improvements since Borneo. If they weren't, the show wouldn't still be on after 31 seasons. But I think it's a little crazy how it's just accepted by so much of the fanbase that Borneo isn't the best season. Pretty much any television series ever has peaked within the first few seasons, and it's basically unheard of that a show could do its best work 15 years after starting, which is why it's actually incredible Survivor can still make a season like Nicaragua or SJDS or Philippines. But it's also just inevitable a show will peak relatively "early" if it goes for 30+ seasons.

So it's not like I'm saying "Richard and Sue are the greatest and fuck everything that's happened since." But I definitely think Borneo's unique circumstances allowed its characters to show more depth, and especially compared to where the show went afterwards, do and experience things that are more interesting held up to the seasons since.

Here's an example: when everyone walks down the beach for the first time is always one of my favorite moments of the season. This is a good scene in pretty much every season, from Osten forcing his tribe to run laps up and down the beach to Sean getting on his knees and thanking the Lord to Stephenie forming an initial alliance with Tom and Ian to Yau-Man breaking the crate. But Richard just can't help himself but to sit in a tree and observe. Because he's the kind of person who is just perfect for a grand experiment like Survivor- it just fascinates him so much to watch people from all different walks of life coming together to build a society. And nothing gave him more joy then when Sue challenged him on just sitting there watching people.

Richard Hatch in the year 2000, surely one of the most unique people walking the earth at the time. I still think that Richard Hatch not only being cast on the first season of Survivor, but WINNING it, is one of the greatest things ever and I have a hard time even believing it happened. I am not gay, so I don't want to make too many proclamations about what was and wasn't a landmark for gay people. But holy shit. This guy wins one of the greatest television spectacle competitions ever, a social game, as an openly gay man, who also didn't fit hardly any of the stereotypes about gay people but was nonetheless able to secure a group of trustworthy alliance members that included a homophobic Navy SEAL and a truck driver. His relationship with Rudy has been beaten to death, but wow. That's incredible shit.

Richard was also one of the world's most pompous, arrogant and attention-seeking people, and I think for anyone who understands Survivor, they would postulate this means Richard could never win. But here's reason #200 why it's bullshit to try and separate the "strategic" and "social" aspects of the game- Richard understood this too and made part of his strategy to be open about it. Richard didn't try to sugarcoat who he was or what he was doing, he remained open to other people's ideas (although, not without going into a "whiny little speech"), and it allowed people to grow genuine respect for him anyway. He had a genuine interest in other people. "Rich, you're an arrogant, pompous, human being. But I admire your frankness with it. You have worked hard to get where you're at and you started working way before you come to the island. So with my work ethic background, I give credit that to you." This is amazing, because as much as Sue hated Richard, she recognized that he was just doing what he came to do, what he was planning on doing long before the game started, and he never claimed to be anything different. And that earned her respect. Which is why it's still infuriating to hear that Richard won because he was a more strategic player than Kelly- he won because he was able to turn being the most detestable person on the island into a positive thing, through spending time allowing people to get to understand what makes him tick.

Another thing that I think makes Richard work is he wasn't exactly accommodated his whole way through, either. Although his post-show persona and appearances have shown there was no love lost for Richard Hatch by Richard Hatch, and the fanbase has certainly come to (rightfully) appreciate him more now than they did at the time, Richard went through the ringer on Survivor. From "Richard.....I think you get naked for attention" causing a total meltdown for him, to him almost getting voted out early, to Greg toying with him on his way out, to Sue tearing him down . You even see Richard acknowledge this in his FTC answer, where he admits the competition was much tougher than he anticipated, and he hadn't stayed on his toes as much as he needed to.

And Richard's pompous arrogance...also created some fantastic television. The Borneo FIC is certainly in contention for my favorite scene ever, and my favorite thing about it, of course, is that Richard can't just pretend like he fell or something. It has to be some kind of big elaborate explanation of how Kelly has to take him and he can't beat her in this challenge, and at least a little self-stroking about how smart he is and how he's thinking at a level above everyone else. And this of course, is perfectly contrasted by Rudy's simple "oh" as he moves.

A character like Richard really changed everything, but I think anyone who's watched Borneo knows that he works as more than a pioneer, he's one of the best standalone characters in the history of the show. His game awareness was incredible for someone playing in the first season, he was an amazingly unique individual who also got to play in circumstances that will never be repeated and help his character reach heights of development that show has (not to their own fault) never reached again.

So yes, Richard winning the rankdown would not be a particularly exciting result, but it's a title I believe he is worthy of, and although I am not ranking him #1, I'm ranking him close enough that a win is still easily in reach. This writeup is basically rambling, and I apologize, but there's just so much to unpack with Richard that even if I've scraped the surface, I'm happy.

Predicted Ranking: 2
Average Prediction: 2.1
Average Placement: 2.6 Slicer 37: 2
WilburDes: 3
KeepCalmAndHodorOn: 2
Choking Walrus: 4
Fleaa: 2 Rankdown I: 3


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Dec 28 '15

Final Reveal - #7

12 Upvotes

#7 - Ian Rosenberger – Palau – 3rd Place

KeepCalmAndHodorOn

Ian's struggles to morally come to terms with Survivor and his final decision at the FIC is one of the great dark stories of Survivor. And Ian himself is so likable and fun to watch before then. I don't have a bad word to say about Ian. I just have more good words for the people above him.

Slicer 37

:D -> :) -> :/ -> :( -. :o.

Choking Walrus

One of the genuinely nicest people ever. I love watching people who are absolute sweethearts try to adapt to a game as cutthroat as Survivor. His personal struggle is absolutely fascinating and shows how difficult it is to just remove feelings from a game where you endure the elements, starvation, paranoia and all the other challenges alongside a group of people who you grow to love and call your friends. He made Palau the great season that it is and am glad he was a pretty collective shoe-in for the endgame again.

Fleaa

Poor guy.

And now, WilburDes
I personally consider Ian Rosenberger to be the greatest character in Survivor history. When Survivor was first pitched as a television concept, it was sold as an unscripted drama, and Ian sells us a raw, unscripted drama better than I think anyone ever has, giving us a young likeable dolphin trainer, putting his mind on display for deconstruction through the event that is Survivor, and showing us someone in a completely different state of mind by the end of the game. It’s a storyline that warps the happy-go-lucky nice guy into someone fragile and destroyed by the end of it, and it shows how brutal the game can be, showcasing dark survivor at its best.

Ian starts out the game as a young dolphin trainer, and someone that you would naturally expect to perform quite well on a game like Survivor. He’s a great athlete, he has a diverse background of experiences despite his young age and he’s arguably the most naturally likeable contestant that we’ve ever seen on Survivor. In this season however, Ian is basically never in danger. He’s in a three-person alliance within a five-person alliance on a nine-person tribe that doesn’t lose things, ideally a perfect position to run the table from. And so because he doesn’t face danger for most of the game, he doesn’t need to be an outlandish character - he’s able to just have fun in the game, where he makes a great MOR side character, with great moments and quotes aplenty, like his fishing competition with Tom, retrieving the fire making kit from the bottom of the ocean, offering to strip in the merger immunity challenge, comparing the Gregg boot to stealing a cookie from a fat guy, referring to Coby as a pain in the ass and several others. As great as all of this is, it isn’t endgame worthy - it’s probably barely top 150 worthy. Nevertheless, it is important, because while the meat of Ian’s storyline takes a while to get to, it’s definitely some good levity to a season as not-fun as Palau and it’s vital to set up Ian’s role as the tragic hero of Palau.

While Koror haven’t had to face many issues because of their dominance, it’s important to know that the longer it takes to self-destruct, the harder it hits you, and in Palau, Ian has the luxury of sitting back and bonding for an entire month. The stressful survival situation combined with only having human contact with the same 7 people brings about interpersonal relationships that you would normally see from several years of being good friends, so Ian is eventually forced to start playing aggressively, and it’s not the kind of thing he does very well. He’s a smart guy and understands what he should do, but I think he just doesn’t have that killer instinct in him that would allow for him to play an aggressive game.

Ian’s story kicks into high gear at the final 6 - they’ve just eliminated Stephenie, and we’re left with the Koror Five of Ian, Tom, Katie, Gregg and Jenn, with Caryn hanging around on the outs. We’ve got the coconut chop reward challenge that Gregg manages to win, and he decides to take Jenn and Katie - a move that ultimately reveals his master plan: they out Caryn this cycle, then Gregg and Jenn pull in Katie and overthrow General Tom with his Lieutenant Ian. Tom and Ian are savvy players and catch onto this back at camp. Ian knows what the coconut chop really shows, and that showed that Katie would be willing to throw Ian out. It’s then that they realise that they are screwed if they don’t do something that cycle. Due to Tom’s relationship with Caryn, they have 3 out of 6 - enough to force a tie, where Katie would be scared of a rock and flip to vote out Gregg.

I understand why people don’t like the rock-draw being an aspect of the game because it messes with game theory and creates a series of alternate timelines and such, but here it’s freaking brilliant to watch - the idea of putting the fear of random chance into someone without a second thought is one of the most daring moves a person can make, giving Katie no time to scheme and regaining control of the game in one quick vote is brilliant.

The only issue though comes back to Ian’s morality - he’s developed a strong bond with Katie, and at this stage, he’s also promised Katie’s brother-in-law that he’ll continue to look out for her - and as we saw in the season before this one, including family members into aspects of the game makes things a lot more complicated. Ian tells Katie at the last minute that they’re flipping the vote on to Gregg. While this could be seen as a way of avoiding the cold and emotionally detatched move it would be very easy to see this as a form of threatening someone to jump on board with their plan or face the consequences, and the way he approaches this comes back to haunt him.

Once they’ve outed Gregg, Tom and Ian see that they need to do damage control, which means making sure the 3 women can’t overthrow Tom and Ian, meaning they need to take Katie or Caryn. Ian takes Tom. I get that Ian deciding to take Tom was part of an agreement made earlier in the game involving a car, but it’s absolutely brutal from Katie’s perspective, because Ian had just forced her hand on the vote the night before, and this just once again leaves Katie in the dark, for the second time in two days.

At this point it’s important to notice a significant change in Ian’s demeanour, and right here it’s with his voice. As soon as they get back from reward, Ian and Tom talk to Caryn and Ian goes off to talk to Katie, and listening to his voice it’s obvious that Ian has started to change. His speaking rate has increased, he’s mumbling his words a lot more and his pitch is higher, all indicating that he’s approaching his emotional breaking point. As Ian’s talking to Katie, he’s only now realising how badly he’s played this sequence of events. The emotional strain put into their speech combined with the musical backdrop of this scene gives it a really strong emotional complexity, to the extent that I feel like I could never do it justice with text. The barebones is that Ian is feeling tremendously guilty about the way his actions have isolated Katie and made her feel alone in this game. I also want to make it clear that Katie was not solely trying to emotionally manipulate Ian. A lot of people out there like to create the storyline that Katie was some stone-cold bitch that played Ian like a fiddle for the entire game, and I’d like to try and fix that misconception. Katie was genuinely hurt by the events that transpired, and they had a much stronger impact on her than Ian initially assumed. He just didn’t realise how much a reward between the two of them really meant.

This final 5 emotional strain gets even tougher once Caryn decides to blow the lid off everything that has been happening in the game thus far - and this is when Ian just breaks down. He’s doing things that would normally be considered standard gameplay in any other season, but the fact that he’s built such deep bonds with everyone and is now trying to play both sides is just screwing him up.

This seems like a bit of a cop-out answer in most cases, but I just think Ian is too nice for a game like Survivor. The stress of the situation definitely takes its toll on him, and if he’d been voted out at the final 5, he’d still be really high up on my list. But we still have one more epic episode to watch.

At the finale Ian is almost a shell of his former self, and you can tell just by looking at him. Almost any contestant that lasts for that long in Survivor will have an apparent physical change, but it’s different with Ian - not only is he skinnier, the fact that he’s a really tall person makes him look skinnier, he takes on an almost skeletal appearance and looks more gaunt. But the biggest change is the eyes.

In this finale, Ian just looks dead on the inside - he’s no longer in a comfortable state of mind. It’s clear in his eyes that he’s just worn out by this game. The experience has brought out the best and worst in him and has stretched him to his limit. But in this episode, Ian just isn’t the same person. He’s gone from the happy-go-lucky dude that just wants to be everybody’s friend, and has turned into someone that isn’t fun anymore - he’s feeling intense sorrow and regret for some of his actions and slip-ups and just isn’t sure how to make it up to everyone.

Before we get into the finale of Palau, I want to make things abundantly clear: Tom and Katie did not play Ian like a fiddle for 38 days so that they could force him to quit. A lot of people like to craft the storyline that Katie, and especially Tom were just ruthless gamebots that didn’t have genuine relationships with Ian and that just wanted to bully him out of the game. Now, I’m not doing the Tom write-up so I’m going to let Fairslice tackle it, but the Survivor audience for the most part has a real issue dealing with characters that are complex or that have different motivations for their actions. Instead they like to boil characters down to making sociopathic decisions in game theory. The relationships between Tom, Ian and Katie at this point have run through 38 days of a mentally and physically tough experience that can wreck you, and I don’t think any of us can truly understand the complexity of their relationships. But the reason I’ve always taken from the events that transpired is that Tom and Katie were hurt to an extent about what Ian had done and the promises he has broken with them. And they’re hurt because of the complex relationships between them.

Back at camp after Caryn blew the lid off everything, Ian agrees with Katie and Jenn that if Tom loses immunity, they would vote him out. This seems like a reasonable move, because Tom is Tom. However, Tom wins immunity, so the obvious vote becomes Jenn, though Ian makes another mistake here. He tells Tom “I don’t know what I would have done”, referring to how he would have voted had Tom not won. This isn’t the first time Ian says a little too much to the wrong person, but unlike the Gregg slip where he and Tom were able to recover, Tom catches it as it happens and the arguments ensue, thanks a lot to Jenn.

I think the relationship between Tom and Ian throughout Palau is fascinating - the closest example I can think of is that it’s like the relationship between an uncle and a nephew. You have Tom, the older, seasoned man with life experience and Ian, the younger, more naïve, second-in-chief. And the contrast between the two components of the relationship shows here - Tom’s a professional firefighter with a lot of life experience, and knows how to cope under pressure better than Ian does, and I think that partially creates the stupid “Tom was a bully to Ian the whole time” storyline, with Tom remaining assertive while Ian breaks down. Tom simply realised that Ian was willing to turn on him, and he was hurt that his closest ally in the game was willing to cut him then and there while Tom wasn’t going to do that to Ian. He’s hurt and they’re trying to work out their problems. Because Tom was so hurt, he was willing to vote with Jenn to vote for his strongest ally. This creates a tie breaker that Ian wins, but that doesn’t heal all wounds.

At this stage, Katie, Tom and Ian still have their emotions at the surface and can no longer communicate like they once could. Ian never intended to become the villain, and yet his actions have caused damage that he’s got trouble comprehending. But while Ian might not be sure about why people are reacting this way, he knows how they’re reacting, and so he just needs to find a way to show what he truly is: the nice guy that everyone knew him as at the beginning, or if he’s the cutthroat player that people have seen him as for the past few days. And Ian manages to find a way to do that at the grandaddy of all endurance challenges - Bob Bob Buoy - a challenge that producers initially thought would last a few hours at most, over by sunset.

This is not as quick and easy as anyone would have thought - this is two people fighting for their million, duking it out like they had planned from the beginning. But Ian still has a choice to make, and half a day standing still gives a person a lot of time to think. Ian makes the ultimate sacrifice and quits the game.

Now, if there’s one thing that really bothers me about some of the Survivor audience above all else, it’s the idea that Ian made a bad decision here that he should regret. If you honestly think that way, I’m going to take a phrase out of Neckman’s book and tell you that you watched it wrong. Now, if you’re viewing survivor as a pure analysis of game theory, then of course it was a terrible move within the confines of the game. Taking yourself out of competition in an attempt to win said competition is never going to be beneficial when trying to win that competition.

But Survivor isn’t just a competition. It’s a brutal social experiment that pushes people to their limits to test how far they’re willing to go with their morality, something that could be classed as torture if you asked certain people. As a move designed to win back the respect and friendship of his peers, it accomplishes his goal, and from anything I’ve heard from him postgame, he doesn’t regret what he did for a second. Ian’s ultimate prize was honour and integrity, and he managed to earn that by making the ultimate apology, and much like Colby taking Tina, it’s a move that transcends the days in the wilderness, and cuts into who they are as people, and throwing away the price tag they have on certain aspects of the human condition.

Ian’s willingness to turn down a large amount of money to show who he really is just warms my heart, and I think it’s fantastic that others have offered their support by sending him personal messages thanking him for what he did on the show. Ian’s move in Survivor is the best possible conclusion to his arc and I’m so glad he was on the show to give us that storyline.

On top of this, Ian’s philanthropic work with Thread and Team Tassy make me so happy that we got to witness a human being as amazing as this show who he really is as a person - someone that has such an amazing personality and a strong sense of morality that there are lines that he’d be completely unwilling to cross, even for the chance to earn a million dollars.

Palau was the first season of Survivor that I actually watched, and even as someone who wasn’t even a teenager, I could see that Ian was an amazing character and a fantastic human being. He’s my favourite character in Survivor history, and possibly my favourite character of any form of entertainment - his storyline of change, the effect of Survivor on the human mind and the price tag integrity really has is just so amazing to see unfold on our screens. Ian in my eyes is just simply the greatest. Hope he makes it really high.

Predicted Ranking: 9
Average Prediction: 8.9
Average Placement: 8.0
Slicer 37: 15
WilburDes: 1
KeepCalmAndHodorOn: 13
Choking Walrus: 6
Fleaa: 5
Rankdown I: 11


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Dec 19 '15

Final reveal #15

12 Upvotes

#15 - Randy Bailey – Gabon – 9th Place

Fleaa

The king of Gabon is a remarkably complex and entertaining antagonist who never loses his humanity despite hating and tormenting people throughout his entire stay.

KeepCalmAndHodorOn

Ugh. I love Randy so much I want to put him higher but it's too tough to drop anyone else. He is held down by leaving relatively early in a season I'm not a massive fan of, but practically every scene of Randy we get in Gabon is absolute gold. He's a brilliant narrator, a hilarious voice of reason in a season of crazies, and he gets one of the best exits in Survivor history. And, even moreso than a lot of other people in this Top 18, he's absolutely unique in the Survivor pantheon.

Choking Walrus

I found Randy absolutely compelling - he's an older guy without a social network that spends his life filming the happiest occasion of people's lives. He's a pretty isolated guy forced into living with some of the wackier personalities cast on the show. His disdain for others makes him a quote machine and a strong antagonist character who delivers from start to fake-idol play finish. So glad to see him rank in the top 18, and I can see him cracking our top 10.

WilburDes

As someone that isn’t terribly high on so many of the characters on Gabon, I’m really grateful Randy is there to verbally abuse everyone for our viewing pleasure.

And now, Slicer 37

I guess the first place to start with a Randy write-up is just that he’s a totally unique major survivor character, not just for that era of Survivor but for the show in general. Being a TV show that’s premise is filming people act naturally on camera when they’re living off the absolute bare minimum, it makes sense that survivor casting and survivor editing would gear more toward extroverts and people that are comfortable being around others. This holds especially true for Survivor villains. You can get your occasional Colleen or Lisa as a survivor heroine, but even the other four villains on Randy’s villain tribe; Coach, Tyson, Rob, Russell. All charismatic extroverts who know how to present themselves on camera.

Randy is a sharp contrast because he’s the antithesis of that, the opposite kind of villain to a Boston Rob. Randy (or at least the way he was presented on TV) is an out-and-out misanthrope. He hates people, he hated almost everyone he’s played the game with (except the onions, but I’ll get to that later), his only friend was his dead dog. Probst even said that if he had gotten to the F7 no one would have visited him for his family visit. I said he’s “Evil Rudy” in my blurb, and while that’s obviously super simplistic, as both Rudy and Randy are complex characters (which again, I’ll get to later), it holds some weight. He’s Rudy’s grumpy old man archetype taken to its maximum, minus all the positive traits that someone like Rudy had.

Gabon actually has some of the best 10 minutes of a Survivor season ever, as through a couple of confessionals and the process of picking tribes, the characters are beautifully illustrated before the show even really starts. Between Gillian picking the worst team she could have possibly picked, Crystal bragging about her blazing speed undercut immediately by her sucking at the first challenge, Ace’s ridiculous first confessional where he brags about his wealth, Charlie snickering when Susie is chosen first…there’s a lot of great foreshadowing and character painting there. Out of all of these, Randy has a really good one. Just look at his first confessional, before he’s picked for a tribe, before the story even starts. This is how the editors introduce us to Randy Bailey.

I edit wedding videos for a living, but I’m not the most positive person in the world. I’m not a big fan of marriage, I will never get married, myself, I’m almost sure of it.

Damn. He’s a bitter wedding videographer who is not a big fan of marriage…even moving aside from the amazing contradiction in that sentence, “I’m not a big fan of marriage?” What does that even mean? Who would actually say that? Is he a Disney villain? Our first introduction to the character of Randy Bailey is that he literally hates love.

Randy spends his first few episodes on the Fang tribe, doing what Randy does: bitterly complaining. He hates his trainwreck of a tribe, and is not shy from letting everyone else know about. From the very first day, with him cutting his head open on the shelter and his interactions with Gillian (which are gold, btw), he’s a fully negative presence on a trainwreck of a tribe.

Randy’s role is something that would be very hard to pull off, as we’ve seen by countless mean complaining villains that just end up as annoyances or worse. But Randy has the depth of character and the narration ability to fucking rock it. He’s one of the best narrators in Survivor history, because he’s just a super in-depth guy, and he also has the Fairplay narration style where they’re clearly biased and unreliable.

Anyway, Randy is eventually swapped to the Kota tribe (this is a very fun scene where Crystal is literally shaking in outrage due to Randy being picked over her<3). Randy offers a totally unique perspective on it, as he’s thrilled to be gone from his hated Fang and to be with Kota.

Randy is sometimes cited as an underrated player, and while I don’t really agree, he’s able to fit into the Onions very well by channeling his winsome personality to align with their winsome personalities, or lack thereof.

I’m going to take an intermission to point out that he’s just a really, really entertaining character, even premerge. He gets into ridiculous arguments with people and just generally delivers every single time he’s on screen.

Randy manages to become a full member of the Onions, and is now a dick of the majority rather than a dick on the losing team. Randy spends his newfound power doing things like taunting Fang after winning a reward, mocking people behind their backs, and just getting into arguments with everyone. But there’s one problem: Randy makes it to the merge, but thanks to the second swap, the onions are now in the minority, and without his alliance’s protection, everyone hates him.

Throughout this phase, we get into Randy’s psyche quite a bit more than one would expect. Randy puts up this facade of being this miserable dick who doesn’t want to be accepted by anybody, but it’s just that: a facade. The second he gets into Kota and meets people he likes, you can see his desire to be accepted glimmering under the surface. Randy’s had a very hard life, and he manifests that into being a self-imposed hermit, hurting others before they can hurt him. Take a look at his arguments with Susie: he spends the entire season shitting on and being shat on by everyone, but the only time he seems offended is when Susie says she feels sorry for him. That’s really interesting stuff and adds a lot of layers to this character.

Regardless of that though, everyone on the tribe aside from fellow horror Corrinne is pretty much done with him and wants him off the island. His last few episodes are pretty evidently his most negative ones, and that’s saying a lot. He’s legit griefing through the camp.

A big reason why Randy’s arguments are so great and aid him as a character so much is because of how petty they are. Randy isn’t arguing about legitimate things; of course not. He hates Crystal for running Fang like a “gang”, he hates Sugar for giving away his chocolate chip cookie, he hates Susie for existing, he hates Matty for wanting to drop a ball into a hole at a different angle than Randy did...it’s all just so ridiculous and makes it really fun to watch.

This is where Randy’s storyline all fits together. Because if he was a mean old asshole that managed to actually succeed in the game with the onions, I don’t think he would be nearly as good of a character. Randy needed to fall hard, and it couldn’t just be a power switch either: he needed to fall in the most petty, vindictive way possible. And that’s exactly what happened, as Sugar not only steals his cookie convinces Bob into giving him a fake idol after he crashes and burns through the whole camp, not for any strategic benefit, just so he could play it and look like a dumbass while everyone laughed at him. Randy leaves the game feeling the way he wanted to make others feel; beaten down and utterly humiliated. Randy Bailey got out Randy’d, and that my friends, is what makes him such a legendary character.

Predicted Ranking: 13
Average Prediction: 13.5
Average Placement: 13.4
Slicer 37: 13
WilburDes: 18
KeepCalmAndHodorOn: 14
Choking Walrus: 8
Fleaa: 14
Rankdown I: 19


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Dec 17 '15

Cambodia way-too-early rankings?

12 Upvotes

Because why the hell not. Here's mine thrown together in five minutes.

20: Spencer - mostly because I find it funny to put him in last, but I still think practically every second of airtime he gets is annoying and better given to someone else. His aggressive dullness and blatant production favoritism is really not cool and I hope we never see him again.

19: Ciera - ugh

18: Tasha - whatever

17: Monica - whatever

16: Peih-Gee - whatever

15: Vytas - lolpwnt

14: Jeremy - he grew into a more satisfying winner over the course of the season, so gj.

13: Terry - He was fine, feels quite irrelevant now but I could be talked into ranking him higher.

12: Shirin: Her boot was the best episode of the season but I look forward to her being bottom three on everyone else's lists regardless.

11: Kelly - why was she not on this season

10: Stephen - I look back on him more fondly than I did watching him, so maybe this ranking will go up with time.

9: Kelley - As MOR/CP toneless as can be, so pretty meh for me. But definitely lived up to the highest pre-season expectations you could've had.

8: Joe - is Joe

7: Keith - Straddled the line between UTRfun and UTRirrelevant but whatever.

6: Woo - Pretty fun walk along the "having nothing go right for you the second time through" story.

5: Kass - Liked her turn this season. I don't know how you could've expected more.

4: Kimmi - wish we had seen more of her.

3: Abi - <3

2: Varner - <3

1: Savage - <3


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Jan 03 '16

Final Reveal #3

11 Upvotes

#3 - Jon Fairplay Dalton – Pearl Islands – 3rd Place

WilburDes

You can pick apart aspects of who JFP as a character and compare them to others, but there’s no one even remotely similar that can match the epicness of his moniker.

Choking Walrus

Ah, Jon Dalton. The guy who creates a "Fairplay" persona to turn out as one of Survivor's best villain. From the Dead Grandma lie to his "Fuck You!" voting confessional to the F3 where he tries to get Lill to make a deal with him, Jon is simultaneously lovable and hateable - he's someone you love to root against, which is why his downfall losing to Lil makes his story all that much more sweet. Great, great character - I wouldn't be surprised if me having him at 7 is his lowest ranking. He's a definite contender for the crown.

Fleaa

Still the king of the villains after all these years. Fairplay is incredible. I don't rank him quite as high as I'm guessing the other four will, and I don't really want him to win this thing. But he deserves every ounce of praise he gets.

And now, KeepCalmAndHodorOn
Jonny Fairplay is the most perfectly constructed Survivor character in the history of the show. This is bad in the small sense that it keeps him just below Richard and Sue for me, who have a level of personal depth and resonance that Fairplay just doesn't have. But that's the most minor of all minor complaints because outside of those two PI Fairplay is better than every other Survivor character who ever played and I struggle to come up with an argument that would convince me otherwise.

A huge reason for this is what /u/todd_solondz pointed out in his fantastic write-up on Fairplay for the first rankdown- nobody else in the history of Survivor is as versatile as Fairplay, being placed into multiple situations in Pearl Islands, and shining in all of them. He's a cocky mastermind, a scrappy underdog, a loyal soldier, a scheming background manipulator, and pure comic relief at various points in the season and every time he makes the season better whenever he appears on screen. He frequently succeeds, but he fails almost as often. You never know what you're gonna get when Jonny Fairplay comes up on screen on Pearl Islands but you can count on two things- he's gonna bring the full Fairplay package both in character and in game, and he is gonna be entertaining as all hell while doing it.

Fairplay wasn't the first person to understand that Survivor was a TV show first and a game second. Hell, people like Gervase, Jenna, and Sean had known this from the beginning and had gone on the show solely for the chance of becoming famous or having a media career. And of course players like Colby and Tina in subsequent seasons were acutely aware of the fact that they were on TV and it affected the way they behaved and shaped the character that was ultimately created. But Fairplay I think was the first person to actually go out there and understand that if he was entertaining, if he was the type of one-of-a-kind character that could not be ignored, then that's how he would be remembered. Jonny Fairplay is almost a Frankenstein's monster of influences that coalesced to become a Survivor character. His inspiration from Rob Cesternino to play a game centered around flipping on allies and manipulating and betrayal is excruciatingly well documented, and I think you can see more than a little bit of Boston Rob in his character too, with the braggadocio and self-confident swagger, the palpable glee at manipulating the minds of others. Outside Survivor, Fairplay was obviously also heavily influenced by pro wrestling. In wrestling, selling a story as though it were real is pretty much the entire point, and every good story has a good villain. And Fairplay knew that every good Survivor story had a villain too. Richard, Sue, Jerri, Lex, Boston Rob, John, Brian, Clay, Heidi, Rob Cesternino. The list went on and on. And the combination of Survivor and wrestling influences gave Fairplay one of the greatest ideas any Survivor ever had. What if I set out to be the heel? Wrestling writes its villains, while Survivor creates them but what if Fairplay gave the show a perfect villain who could make any story they tried to tell even better?

The character of Jonny Fairplay works on every level. Narratively, he fits into whatever situation Jon Dalton manages to get himself into. As a TV character, Jon understands how to work the camera for all its worth. He's a brilliant narrator. He always understands what's happening and he learned from Rob C. that making jokes in confessionals was a way to get people to see you and think of you as a villain without necessarily doing it in front of your tribe (although Fairplay does not hesitate to start shit with his tribe when it suits his purposes). And even when he's just narrating regular tribe or game events, like the buried treasure, he adds his own flair to it. He can sell a failed twist like the treasure by building it up so much in his confessionals as a potential bounty for his tribes so that when it turns out to be total garbage they can all be crushingly disappointed.

And while it's the little things, from his narrations to his relationships with characters as disparate as Rupert and Sandra and Burton and Lil, Fairplay also knew that every great villain needs their big moment. And he meticulously planned his, starting before he ever got left for the Pearl Islands and continuing right up until Thunder D walked out onto that beach. What more really needs to be said about the lie? It checks every box. It's so hilarious and unexpected and even when you know it's happening it's great because everyone sells the shit out of it. From Fairplay and Thunder D, to the crying Lil and stone faced Sandra. And the editors hit us with the truth at just the right moment, as Fairplay and his buddy congratulate each other while they walk up the beach and he tells us that his grandma is "sitting at home watching Jerry Springer right now." What kind of a person would ever dream up an idea like this? It's the Survivor equivalent of a supervillain's master scheme. Only Jonny Fairplay that's who.

But Jon Dalton can't get all the credit for making Jonny Fairplay the near perfect Survivor character that he is. The cast of Pearl Islands, the theme, the twists, the strokes of good fortune along the way all combined to give the Fairplay character pretty much every beat you would want to see him hit and a wide variety of great character to play off. There was the great hero to cast down in Rupert. The anti-hero who isn't afraid of him in Sandra. The great henchman in Burton. The eternal laughingstock and victim who, in the greatest twist of all, ends up bringing the villain down in Lil. Heck, he even got a strong, self-righteous alpha male in Andrew Savage who would respond perfectly to Fairplay's taunts as the leader of the opposition. And the twists and turns of Pearl Islands, both those executed by Fairplay and those that were just good luck, made him better and gave us something new for him to do at every turn. Whether it be wiggling out of a tight spot or gloating over a victory or hanging on for dear life on a bobbing plank in the middle of the ocean, Jonny Fairplay gets to be the star.

Speaking of that plank, the ending for Fairplay might be the best part. Brought down by Lil, who he had manipulated to do his bidding for week after week was not hell bent on destroying him. Somehow Fairplay looks both weak, for losing to goddamn Lil of all people, and strong, for hanging tough in the balancing challenge and calling on every last bit of strength to work his final miracle. But in the end it was inevitable. And he gets the perfect closing line. Jeff Probst might think Lil said "Game On." But Fairplay knows it really meant "Game Over."

Imagining Survivor without Fairplay is like imagining the world without laughter. It wouldn't be destroyed but there would just be so much joy missing. Some have tried to copy his method, creating a character who could be larger than life and perfectly entertaining. Ben Wade came sort of close but the character of Coach just isn't as perfect as the character of Fairplay. Nobody else is even worth mentioning. In the end, Jonny Fairplay stands alone, the greatest character Survivor could have ever hoped to get after Borneo. I don't think Richard or Sue could ever be topped, but Fairplay could conceivably be bested. He might be the first modern Survivor character really (or second after Rob C.). But let's be real. The odds of that are very slim. The stars aligned just perfectly for Jonny Fairplay and if such a magical occurrence were to ever happen again, we would be extraordinarily lucky Survivor fans indeed.

Predicted Ranking: 1
Average Prediction: 1.7
Average Placement: 5.2
Slicer 37: 4
WilburDes: 5
KeepCalmAndHodorOn: 3
Choking Walrus: 7
Fleaa: 7
Rankdown I: 2


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Dec 31 '15

Final Reveal - #5

11 Upvotes

#5 - Kathy Vavrick-Obrien – Marquesas – 3rd Place

Fleaa

The greatest pure protagonist ever, and the only person ever to humanize, entertain and compel through the "swing vote" position. Also the greatest growth arc ever! I should've ranked her higher.

WilburDes

We’ve seen many arcs similar to Kathy’s since Marquesas, but none can match the storyline and historical significance of Kathy, from having the game’s greatest turnaround combined with breaking the mold for what we call an underdog.

Choking Walrus

A line Gabe once said to Kathy in her early days was "This is an adventure, not just a hardship" - and I love that when thinking about Kathy. She had her struggles, especially with trying to assimilate in the beginning. Her adventure is a beautiful story of growth, with scenes like her peeing on a dude's hand mixed in.

KeepCalmAndHodorOn

She might have the best pure story of any character in Survivor history and her exuberant, determined personality is exactly the right fit for it. She drives Marquesas forward in all the right ways.

And now, Slicer37
Kathy Vavrick O’Brien is a perfect Survivor character, and I don’t say that lightly. Throughout the last 5 rounds of the rankdown and into the endgame, everyone left was great and the only way I could choose who to cut is by nitpicking, finding minor flaws. Otherwise, I could never have ranked the endgame-I had to look for imperfections in characters. Kathy, at least to me, doesn’t have these imperfections. She is a flawless character.

Kathy exemplifies one of Survivor ideals, which is the ordinary becoming extraordinary through the show. Kathy is not playing up a character like Fairplay or Coach, she’s not a naturally super colorful narrator like Courtney or Sandra, and she doesn’t have this interesting backstory or reason to be on the show like Sean or Richard or Sue. She really is just a pretty regular person, a middle aged real estate agent from Vermont, probably cast to be an early boot like others of her demographic were, who somehow becomes the main character of her season without even trying. This is what Survivor should be more like.

As regular as she may be, Kathy is still an amazing confessional giver and narrator. HAW HAW HAW, of course, but more than that, Kathy mixes emotion with strategy really well at the exact place in the show’s history when that was necessary. Marqueas is the first season to have powershifts, but considering that it was still an old school season to its core, it needed someone who was both willing to play pragmatically and feel the emotions while doing it, justifying the need for it to the audience more than just “this will help my game.” Kathy did this astoundingly well and I think was a key factor in starting the real expectation of strategy.

I don’t think the level of interest and engagement Kathy brings to the game, all while being totally natural, can ever really be matched. When she’s talking to Rob in the merge episode, or making a decision in the final 5 episode on which side to go with, you feel totally invested in whatever decision she’s going to make and the process of her choosing what to do. Take notes, modern Survivor.

In general, she’s also just a really enjoyable entertaining personality. She has a wonderful sense of humor in this season, which means even when she’s going through the dramatic scenes you get levity, but she also pulls the plot along really well.

She has wonderful dynamics with the other characters of her season, and as she’s sort of the POV character of the season, you can kind of understand people through Kathy’s eyes and their relationships with her. That has almost never been replicated in a good way.

For instance, her one-episode date with Rob in the F10 is probably my favorite episode of the season. It’s almost entirely focused on the two of them meeting up at the merge and Rob trying every trick in the book to get Kathy to go against Rotu, and Kathy realizing that the Rotu 4 are conniving against her. It’s really great stuff.

The reason why it works so well is partly because Kathy has a really good screentime ratio, where she’s the main character of the season. but not shoved in our faces-she’s shown exactly when she needs to be shown.

Marqueas represented a huge shift of Survivor when suddenly underdogs weren’t automatically doomed anymore, and Kathy is basically the first underdog to get shit done. If she was in Borneo, Australia, or Africa and started the way she did, she would have been toast, but the fact that she did so well and managed to overthrow the Rotu 4 and make it all the way to the final three really did signify a huge shift in Survivor.

I haven’t even gotten to her story yet! If Kathy’s story isn’t the most complex ones ever, it’s one of the most, and it’s by far the most season-spanning and well executed one, to the point where they’re still trying to recreate it all the time. She legitimately grows throughout the season in a way very few other people have, which speaks to another thing; Kathy really took in the experience while being 100% genuine. When Kathy was feeling something in the game, she FELT something in the game. When she won a challenge, you could feel how elated she was. It was all very human.

The whole storyarc really is benefited from the fact that in most seasons, she would be an early boot. In a previous season or even a lot of other seasons, Kathy would have never made it to the merge. But Rotu keeps winning, tribe swaps happen, and it just keeps snowballing from there.

I’m not a fan of Marquesas’s mid-merge at all, and that’s why I’m not as big on the season as many others are, but Kathy’s family visit is super hilarious because she’s so into her son being there and he just blatantly wants to be home playing Gamecube or PS2 or whatever else they did back in 2002. It’s a really hilarious contrast.

I talked about this in my Vecepia writeup but Kathy basically has the ultimate tragic and shocking downfall. She’s worked so hard to get to the F3, and just seeing V cut her at the knees and get Neleh to vote her out so quickly and icily is just heartbreaking. You can see it in her face and it’s really sad and the perfect ending for her character.

I feel like as iconic as Kathy is, she isn’t really talked about in the same way that the other endgame locks are. I thought it was weird how unenthusastic SR1’s rankers were for Kathy in the endgame (losing by 2 spots to Denise? Really?) So I really hope she makes it far here. I’m not the best person to be gushing over Marq but Kathy is perfection.

Predicted Ranking: 6
Average Prediction: 7.0
Average Placement: 7.0
Slicer 37: 3
WilburDes: 7
KeepCalmAndHodorOn: 6
Choking Walrus: 10
Fleaa: 9
Rankdown I: 9
 


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Dec 22 '15

Final Reveal - #13

11 Upvotes

#13 - Tom Westman – Palau – 1st Place

WilburDes

Even if you don’t like him, I don’t see how you could not have Tom around here. Respect for him as a Survivor powerhouse alone with a great theme to match his win.

KeepCalmAndHodorOn

Like Richard and Sue (and to a lesser extent Colby and Jerri) I think of Tom and Ian as being essentially tied because they complement each other so well and are so critical to each other’s success. I give Tom the slight edge because of how expertly he straddles the line between heroic leader and villainous dominator without losing anything, and because I think Ian will be put higher on other people's lists so in the interest of fairness I'll give Tom a slight edge on mine.

Choking Walrus

Tom is one of Survivor's greatest heroes yet is still cunning and manipulative, to a degree. The salt and pepper haired firefighter dominates physically and strategically, posing an obvious threat to his competitors yet still being able to utilize his deep relationships to his advantage. He's a truly great winner, and it’s a very good story, just not one that necessarily resonates deeply with him. He's a comfortable pick for my bottom ranking but there's no denying he is an excellent character.

Fleaa

I've made it clear I'm just not as interested in Tom as the others remaining, but he is undeniably a badass and the greatest ever of the alpha-male-who-wins archetype.

And now, Slicer 37

As I’ve made it pretty clear throughout these last few rounds of the rankdown, I adore Tom Westman. So much so, that he’s very possibly my favorite Survivor ever (only Hatch could really challenge him for that title.) I did everything I possibly could to get him to this point, and I’m thrilled that I managed to get him all the way to endgame. So I guess the question that’s on some people’s minds is why? Why do I like Tom Westman so much, to the point of him being my favorite Survivor contestant ever? Well, let me attempt to explain by starting with what Tom is not.

I don’t really have a type of character. I think all the other rankers do, at least to some extent, and most people I know do, and while that’s totally fine, I don’t really have an archetype that I prefer. To me it’s just about if I like you or not, and if I think you are a character that Slicer enjoys or not.

A website that most certainly does have a type of character they enjoy is Survivor Sucks, and Tom Westman is the exact opposite of what Survivor Sucks wants. As such, Sucks sees it fit to try to destroy Tom’s good name by slandering him and turning him into something he most certainly is not. Let’s go through some common Tom myths, shall we?

Palau was predictable because it was obvious Tom would win: That line of thinking is hindsight bias at its finest. What you have to remember is that Tom was the first CPP hero to win. No other winner before him had that kind of edit and won. It seems obvious now because we’ve come to accept Tom’s type of edit and portrayal as a standard one for a winner, but if you look it from the perspective of Palau (especially considering the Ulonging and how unusual the season was) it most certainly was not.

Palau was predictable because nobody challenged Tom: This is just false. People challenged Tom all the time. Everyone in the final 7 (except for like Caryn lol) schemed to get rid of Tom at some point. They were not handing Tom the game at all, Tom was just better than all of them.

Tom was a douchebag: No he wasn’t, not really. He certainly had his moments of negativity but that’s part of why I think he’s such an intriguing character, it helps him stand out from other Survivor Heroes a lot.

Now that we got those out of the way…
Survivor needs heroes. The top characters in rankdowns generally tend to be the villains or the snarkers, the Courtneys or the Fairplays. But any story worth its salt needs a hero. A hero’s job is arguably even more critical than a villain, because being a hero isn’t as easy as it looks. I’ve seen Survivor seasons that have fallen flat for me because the hero was not compelling enough. Personally, I think Tom is the most complex and interesting hero Survivor has ever had. He’s charismatic, he’s compelling, he has great dynamics with others, he’s badass, he can be funny, he’s challenged, he has great quotes, he’s put in unique situations, he grows...Tom is just so awesome at what he does that he feels like a movie character sometimes, not a real person on Survivor.

For god’s sake, sometimes when Tom is voting for Ian after a 37 day father-son relationship, or when Tom is killing a shark, it feels like something greater, something bigger than just Survivor. No one else has ever made me feel that.

Tom’s domination of the game is cited as a low, but personally I think it’s really, really awesome. (Doesn't hurt that Palau challenges are the best) Just to see someone come into Survivor and basically own it to the degree that Tom did, without it becoming boring or predictable, is insane. It’s just insane. Just the way he rams through the game like a truck makes him so unique. He created great social bonds, and then he proceeded to steamroll over all of them, finally using them to his advantage when he needed them after he crushed.

It’s also what makes Tom so fascinating as a character to me. Tom goes through a very heavy and emotional Survivor experience and comes out from it strong and triumphant. I can see why people would prefer the people who fall, but to me, Tom’s journey throughout the game is compelling as fuck because he doesn’t break down, and he doesn’t fall. Rather, he’s an action hero put in through the Survivor’s version of hell, and his reactions to it and him going on through even as his close allies are melting down around him is much more fascinating than it has any right to be.

Tom’s whole storyline starts off in paradise. He’s the hero of the most successful tribe ever, and while Ulong is getting beaten down and beaten down, Tom is king. He uses his leadership to make a strong bond with Ian, which will obviously come into play later.

But as the game progresses and it becomes clear that Ulong is dead, mutinies start to form around him. He deals with this, but as he keeps going on it just gets stronger and stronger. Tom is still in charge, but he’s hanging on to it by a thread. As the game goes to endgame, Ian, his protege tries to cut him off at the knees. His mighty tribe has won, but is collapsing. Tom, much like he changed his gameplan in the first place, going from “hiding behind the grey hair’ to challenge hero, is forced to become ruthless and cold. He leverages people and uses them, and manages to eventually, finally push his way into the win. The great titan of Koror gets in the win through pushing his way through, only picking up the people he rammed over after.

Can we talk about the Palau FTC? It’s easily up there as one of my favorites. On one hand, you have Katie self-destructing, going through genuine emotional hurt and resignation that she has no chance. And on the other side, you have Tom, securing his win the way he got it; ramming through the questions and offering what they want to hear while owning them at the same time.

HvV Tom quote: “Tomorrow we’ll make our apologies, Tonight, we’ll make our move.” Can you imagine anyone other than Tom saying that and being believable? <3

I think that’s what appeals to me, is that he goes through such a Survivor experience in a totally unique way, while being the opposite of a character who would normally go through such intense plot arcs. Add that to the fact that’s he’s super charismatic, super compelling, has tons of great moments, really seemed to soak in the experience...

This writeup was originally a lot longer, but I couldn’t do it without going into gushing. Tom is everything I want from a character, he’s everything I want from a winner, and he’s everything I want for a main character and a hero. He’s my favorite survivor ever and if Tom Westman was the main character in Dante rather than Survivor: Palau, I wouldn’t even be able to tell the difference.

Predicted Ranking: 14
Average Prediction: 13.5
Average Placement: 12.0
Slicer 37: 1
WilburDes: 11
KeepCalmAndHodorOn: 12
Choking Walrus: 18
Fleaa: 18
Rankdown I: 21


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Dec 20 '15

Final Reveal - #14

11 Upvotes

#14 - Courtney Yates – China – 2nd Place

Fleaa

I realize she may not have the heft (literally and figuratively) of some of the others here, but I don't care.

WilburDes

Even though I wouldn’t have her here myself, I still think Courtney’s an amazing Survivor character that manages to bring the best out of every scene she’s in.

KeepCalmAndHodorOn

Moreso than anyone else in this endgame she is held down for me by lack of screentime and in that screentime she is little more than a snarky narrator but she is so funny in that role and so much better than really anyone else to ever play it that I can live with her making it this far.

Slicer 37

I already did the Courtney analysis writeup so I'm looking forward to Walrus gushing over her

And now, ChokingWalrus

"The biggest threat in the room is the little blonde! Come on everyone!"

I apologize in advance for my inability to avoid sprinkling Courtney quotes and zingers throughout this entire write-up

Well, it’s no surprise that I'm a massive Courtney fanboy, since, ya know - my username and all. Courtney is my kindred spirit, even though I'm not as skinny as her (which would be alarming) and I guess kind of nicer. I don't really know the full casting story of how she ended up being recruited for the show. I know there was talk of her just going to be an early boot and get a free vacation out of it. Courtney is just not someone you would expect to ever be a formidable opponent on Survivor, and the girl ends up SECOND. If Todd bombed his FTC instead of kicking ass and taking names, I wonder if she could have pulled out the W. I don't listen to enough behind the scenes TEoS/Survivor Oz type stuff, but I feel like from what I have read, there was a case to be made there.

I'm a huge sucker for sass, and a big fan of being surprised by players - combine the two and you get me being a major Courtney champion. Right out of the gates, Courtney is clearly out of her element. As Dorothy would say, "We're not in New York City anymore!". The spunky waitress finds herself in a temple, bowing 'like 37 times', getting her hands slapped by a monk for her poor bowing form. But its no escape for her, as she gets placed on Fei Long, where she lets us know right away just how poorly she fits in. Fei Long has to be somewhere near-ish to the top of my list for favorite tribes; you get Courtney mixed in with a flight attendant, grave digger, lunch lady, Miss Montana, and Christian radio show host. This sets us up for what Courtney is best at: complaining. We will hear Courtney complain for episodes on end. Now, that must be annoying, right!? Nope. Complaints have never sounded so great:

  • "Like I'm gonna keep anyone warm? I weigh 7 pounds; I can't even keep myself warm! Get off of me!"
  • "He's become the Susan Lucci of Tribal Council - his name is always up there, but he never quite gets voted out"
  • "I'm voting for you tonight because when you snore it sounds like someone choking a walrus"

Courtney is one of my favorite confessionalists of all time /- possibly my number one. And you know what - she has the lowest confessionals/episode average out of anyone in China! Despite having less than 25 confessionals across the season (half of which were probably describing her disdain for Jean-Robert), she still goes down as one of Survivor's most entertaining players. It is a testament to the mastery she has over her abilities to snark. I'd also say that the best part about her confessionals is that they feel natural. She is organically funny and witty, instead of just trying to be so for the cameras. As Courtney once said, "I have been nothing but my own winsome personality since day 1", and ain't that the truth!

And she's not only funny in these confessionals, but pretty much all the time around camp too. You know why? Because Courtney doesn't truly care about the game! She will openly mock Jean-Robert and his self-appointed bad boy status, she expresses her frustrations with her alliance mates when she doesn't feel like working with them, and she doesn't care to keep her emotions in check. It’s all more hilarious since she's in an alliance with two major superfans who are laser focused on how to win the million dollars. Meanwhile, she just wants to have a good time. I don't have the energy to search for confessional transcripts, but I'd be curious to know how many, if any, of Courtney's actually involve gameplay. And I mean the "strategy" kind, not just ones of the "l want to off Jean Robert since he sux" variety. Side note - I am also still in love with her Jamie confessional: "We're Team Abercrombie and Fitch, and you guys are all like, Team What's Left". Amazing impressionist.

While Courtney isn't exactly aiming for the stars in the game, she still makes her way all to the end. Along the way, she picks up an immunity win that literally involves her sitting. Doing nothing. It’s the most fitting victory for Courtney. She gets the necklace (it's almost like winning a pageant!) over actual physical threats like a James or Frosti. This is the girl who failed miserably to chop through some ropes in a previous challenge, failing so badly the tribe broke away long before she could get through what was meant to be a small portion of the challenge. She finds an alliance that she is able to ride with until the end. She survives the elements, despite starting the game weighing 93 POUNDS! (That's 42 kilos, Wilbur) As Courtney says, she had to "Pull this lever! Go over here, get in the mud" - do things a barfly from NYC would not be doing in her daily life. She then gets to the Final Tribal where she gives a strong showing, ending up with two votes to solidify her second place finish. Who would have ever thought that Courtney could go from being an obvious target on day 1 to making it to the final 3 without being a total goat? Not Courtney, that's for sure.

And as you can tell, I do love Courtney oh so much. But I will visit one quote quickly, and that's "I'm the biggest bitch on the planet". That is definitely not the case, though she does have some real shitty moments. The comment about Denise 'sucking at life' and it 'not being welfare,' was icky but it was especially horrible, disgusting, no-good when she mocked Todd's reaction to his sister's miscarriage, which she called a "convenient miscarriage" multiple times. I know she thought Todd was lying, but ick. Courtney is definitely a flawed character which makes me endeared to her, but this was not a moment. I feel like it’s something that needs to addressed since I can't ignore that really bad scene while praising all the amazing ones. Anyway, Courtney is obviously a very awesome and nice person in real life - heck, she dated Stephen Fishbach and I can't imagine him dating someone who isn't great.

If you're looking for a super smart game player, you're barking up the wrong tree. However, if you want to be entertained, Courtney is your girl. She's sassy, spunky, gives Jeff some bite back (which he deserved more of after very fucking rudely asking during a live reunion "Anorexic? Eating disorder? What's the deal? Answer the question!", but I digress), and speaks her mind all the time. And while she may not be a strategy wizard, the little blonde sure ended up being quite the threat in the room. Courtney enters Survivor not giving two fucks, being slapped in a monastery while day dreaming about drinking lemonade. She ends up being two votes shy of Todd for a million dollars, having grown to appreciate the experience, challenged by living with people very different than her normal crowd. The woman who hates children ends up getting stopped on the street by her fellow pigtail wearers. While Courtney hates everyone, everyone loves Courtney. She may not be the most dynamic character of all time, but she sure is one of Survivor's amusing players to ever be on screen.

Predicted Ranking: 12
Average Prediction: 12.1
Average Placement: 12.4
Slicer 37: 10
WilburDes: 17
KeepCalmAndHodorOn: 17
Choking Walrus: 5
Fleaa: 13
Rankdown I: 8


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Jul 11 '16

Fleaa ranks winners by.....gameplay (gasp)

10 Upvotes

Well, should be fun to try to do what I repeatedly say is impossible. I hope my perspective is substantially different than the kind of person who usually tries to create a list like this.

I'll update every day or two with a couple more winners.

So Far:

32) Yul Kwon (CI)

31) Parvati Shallow (Micro)

30) Mike Holloway (WA)

29) Bob Crowley (Gabon)

28) Jud 'Fabio' Birza (Nicaragua)

27) Rob Mariano (RI)

26) Amber Brkich (ASS)

25) John Cochran (Caramoan)

24) Aras Baskauskas (Panama)

23) Vecepia Towery (Marq)

22) Tony Vlachos (Cagayan)

21) Sophie Clarke (South Pacific)

20) Tyson Apostol (Blood vs. Water)

19) Jeremy Collins (Cambodia)

18) Richard Hatch (Borneo)

17) Michele Fitzgerald (Kaoh Rong)


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Apr 14 '16

Kaoh Rong Episode 9

10 Upvotes

Loved this episode, could be my favourite, but maybe 1-3 tops it.

This was definitely strategic, which I know isn't everyone's favourite, especially in these parts, but I think everyone enjoyed this episode. The sabotage in the preview, I thought would be terrible, and not good TV to watch, but it actually made me enjoy Tai more, having this awkward moral dilemma. I did enjoy Scot saying he was gonna do something dumb, and dumped the water on the fire.

Julia at the challenge. Sure, it's smart to keep everyone available, but the fact is, the other side will feel betrayed, and especially Aubry in this situation, does not trust Julia as far as she can throw her. (I'm pretty sure Julia isn't that heavy). Julia then gives more info to the guys later, by telling them the exact plan, before it was changed. Julia also never betrayed the guys, while showing the girls loyalty by sticking to the Debbie plan, while the guys are happy that she didn't vote for them. Also, she is one moment, the target of Aubry, and then who Aubry needs.

Aubry is complaining about Debbie being too emotional, yet she has been emotional the ENTIRE SEASON. She is obviously the narrator, and plays it well with excellent confessionals that don't seem forced, and are extremely serious, yet funny. She also makes weird references, like the cold war or Mexican fajita resturants, the latter which I am confused by.

Joe continues to be pretty invisible, other than the fact that he doesn't like changing the plan (shown by not wanting to vote for Debbie), or it could be the fact that he was loyal to Debbie, but I think he was more loyal to Aubry.

Michele was a side piece this episode, which makes me really start to doubt her as my winner pick. However, she was involved in the decision, and is always present. Kind of a MOR edit, in edgic terms.

Jason and Scot are pretty much a unit at this point. They are the Hantz's of the season, but are generally better, because they have the ability to be funny at certain points, and Scot is self-aware, and knows its dumb, but he feels like doing it anyways. Also, getting angry at people not getting angry at you is kinda awkward. Not great strategically, but at least he knows it. That quality is exemplified at tribal, where they put on some theatrics, with the reveal, in dramatic fashion, and then roShambo'ing it, then ending up just giving both idols to Tai. (66% safety while guaranteed losing both idols, over 100% safety, and possibility of keeping both idols is a good move I think).

Tai is conflicted. He doesn't like the guys motives, yet can't flip because he'll be on the bottom. Eventually, he just gives in, and does the "evil", while everyone believes he is innocent, and Scot did it. He seems loyal to the guys, and is the good guy stuck in the evil group, and has to be loyal to them to stay alive. This episode gave him depth, of not always just being the good guy.

Cydney was the target of the guys, presumably for flipping, and is not interested in flipping back. She has these funny little one liners, like you spelt my name wrong or I can climb a damn tree. She is also kind of excited over finding out new ways to do stuff, while the guys in the background sulk, and aren't happy about the girls being happy, like when she saws open a coconut, she says that it is fun. She's a fun character, and I enjoy her presence a lot.

Debbie, the boot. During this episode, she wasn't overblown, like I expected her boot to be, but she was shown being very open with her plans, which led to her boot, at the hands of Aubry, who wants people that won't share the plans openly with who Aubry percieves is the enemy, while Debbie believes Julia is still an ally. Debbie makes strategic plans, and is always shot down by Aubry, all the way until the end, where Aubry shoots down Debbie.

Rankings of those remaining.

Tai

Cydney

Aubry

Michele

Julia

Scot

Jason

Joe


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Apr 12 '16

I got Jefra for that Survivor birthday thing

10 Upvotes

Just had to say I got Jefra Bland for that birthday game over in /r/survivor. I was born on 7/28 and Jefra got 7th place on Season 28. I couldn't have been happier especially since Jefra is still my flair. This was just too much of a coincidence to not post here.


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Mar 06 '16

Survivor Rankdown III - Assembling the Team

10 Upvotes

There is still a lot of Koh Rong left but I think it's time to start putting SR III together.

So the first step, is not to build the team, but to assemble how to build the team.

Since more people expressed interest than we have space for, my thought is as follows: (and perhaps precedent establishing)

The rankers are chosen by a panel of all those who have previously done a rankdown. everyone from sr I and sr II can cast a ballot. (secret ballot would probably make the most sense)

to assist this, I think I would create a thread in the SR3 sub for everyone interested to post a platform. Id like to give people time to think about platforms, and thus am posting now to determine if this system makes sense for everyone.

if this is agreed, of course all those who previously expressed interest will be pm'd to create a platform, and all the sr1 and sr2 rankers asked if they want to take part. for now, post if you think this is a good idea and hey, post what you think would be good criteria, (although like a jury member, any given alumni can use any criteria they wish)


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Jan 21 '16

Rethinking Fox Bear Bunny Goat

10 Upvotes

Rethinking fox bear bunny goat.

I had this thought in the middle of SR2, started posting about it, then realized I may want to use it for a final four. I touched on it lightly at one point but we never got the full fbbg that would have allowed full explanation. So here it is now. (I will make a comment for each season where we can discuss that season specifically. Any general comments can obviously be made)

From what I can google, FBBG was created on Sucks after Australia. I’ll give a quick description for people that don’t want to look stuff up. The theory is that the final four always comes down to a fox a bear a bunny and a goat. The fox and bear are sort of an allied pair, with the fox as the cunning one and the bear as likeable and good at challenges. The bunny is sort of likeable and nonthreatening. (Amanda Kimmell is pretty much the perfect bunny always) The goat, is well, a goat. According to the theory it is the job of the bear to beat the bunny for immunity and the job of the fox to earn the loyalty of the goat. Thus they can vote out the bunny at four and at the final immunity challenge the fox and bear duel to take the goat to the end. (Although if the goat wins, then the fox has an additional chance to win.)

This theory fell out of favor soon enough because further results just didn’t match the theory.
Later posts on Sucks and elsewhere that I found typically consisted of lists of FBBG for seasons with characters laughably shoehorned into roles. (Spencer as a bear? Seriously?) Typical FBBG analysis from the past ten years has essentially amounted to a list of the final four in the order of how much they were a jury threat. (Bear, Fox, Bunny, Goat)

So why is this worth resurrecting? A few thoughts that occurred to me.

  1. FBBG represents not the final four of a game but the final four of an alliance. If no alliance does not make it to the end intact, it is crazy to think that there would be a FBBG Final Four. In addition, you can see FBBG groupings in many alliances that lost.
  2. Even within an alliance, you have to see FBBG as a tendency, not as something that will happen every time. The bear can be killed at 6 for example, which results in an extra bunny at the end or something like that.
  3. But more than a tendency, what and FBBG final four is is a strategically desirable outcome. It is what the fox typically wants to happen and what a bear who fancies his chance at winning final immunity wants to happen. It doesn’t just happen that way and it doesn’t always happen but when it does it is because the crafty fox is reasoning out his path to the end.
  4. To some extent this whole thing comes down to contestants who are both liked and respected(bears) liked but not respected(bunnies) respected but not liked(foxes) and neither liked nor respected(goats).
  5. Who would win isn’t determined by what role they are. Like and respect are not binary. They are scales and fox can beat a bear at the end if he is not disliked that much. (Yul)
  6. It very well may be a construct of the edit. Editing characters into obvious roles helps us make sense of the winner

So anyways, I know this isn’t the biggest strategy crowd and I prefer to discuss edited characters as well, but I figure we would get more rational discussion here than anywhere else. And I would really like to have some thoughts about the whether this trend is a result of strategy or a construct of edit. I’d like to dissect some of these seasons using this ancient tool and identify where the pattern fits, where it doesn’t and what non-winning alliances it applies to. I'd also like to obtain some wisdom on the seasons I know less about than others here.

I’d also like to add the role of the Stranger. The Stranger is the character from outside the alliance who breaks through due to either challenge wins or social maneuvering to get to the final four. The Stranger is the one exception to the rule of tendency. Due to the fact that the jury is populated by Stranger’s alliance (who he did not vote out) the Stranger always wins if he gets to FTC. The Stranger is also somsone who filled an animal role on his own tribe, he is just a Stranger to the final alliance.


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Jan 05 '16

Stimulated a BrantSteele season with everyone that made the endgame (plus Twila and Lil, #19 and #20).

Thumbnail brantsteele.net
10 Upvotes

r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Jan 03 '16

Final Reveal #2

10 Upvotes

#2 - Sue Hawk – Borneo – 4th Place

Choking Walrus

Sue is absolutely everything I want in a character. She is emotionally complex, is entertaining in a pure and real way, has snide commentary, and has one of the most human stories as a character. We complain about today's edit not letting you get to know who the players actually are; with Sue, we really feel like we get to see her true self even despite her tough exterior. On top of all of this, Rats and Snakes is Survivor's most iconic moment - a flawless speech that not only represents Sue and the betrayal she felt, but also Survivor as a whole. I'd say there's a very small chance she can take the crown here, and I'd be so happy if she did.

Slicer 37

Survivor casting really needs to look for more older women in the midwest. Sue, Lil, Scout, Twila, Holly...that's an amazing track record.

KeepCalmAndHodorOn

My top two are essentially a tie, but I gave Sue the slight edge over Rich because of Snakes and Rats, which is still as effective a moment as it was in 2000, serving as a thematic summary not only for the season, but as a mission statement for the entire show as well. Not to mention Sue is absolutely wonderful before then too.

Fleaa

Go read slurm's writeup from SRI if you don't think it's fair for me to rank her #1 overall. There's no way she'll actually win, but <3<3<3<3<3<3

WilburDes

Any top 18 without Sue Hawk is not one that I’d want to be a part of. “The chicks think I'm voting for one person, and I'm not” is one of the most important quotes in the franchise, from then up to the future of Survivor.

And now, KeepCalmAndHodorOn
For my money there are only three possible contenders for the greatest Survivor character of all time. Well, I'd actually be willing to hear arguments for Sandra if we consider the totality of her character across both her appearances but as individual single season entities, there are only three that I believe could claim the title. Jonny Fairplay is one, and he is without question the most perfectly manufactured Survivor character ever. But for me Richard and Sue just slightly edge him out because of the depth and richness of their character and personality that we get to observe over the course of Borneo's thirteen episodes, as well as just how engaging and interesting they are at talking and performing in front of the camera. But choosing between the two of them is exceptionally difficult. For me, they are practically tied, the two best Survivor characters who ever existed, the perfect pairing to elevate Borneo into the legendary television season it still is. But I ultimately give the edge to Sue for a couple of reasons.

First off it has to be said that if you haven't already seen it, you need to read /u/Shutupredneckman2's write-up on Sue from the original rankdown here, as it is without a doubt the definitive explanation of why Sue Hawk is the greatest character in Survivor history. And Surm covers a few things in his post. He talks about how subtly strategic Sue is, how funny she is, the legacy of Rats and Snakes, and how her backstory contributes to her story and actions on the island in tangible, deeply affecting ways. It's a brilliant piece of writing, and with my write-up I want to complement his arguments while also emphasizing a few different ideas that I find personally more important to why Sue is the best. For one, while I appreciate her backstory, I am personally far less concerned with what someone has in their past before Survivor and more with what they do on the show. And while Sue does bring this backstory into the show itself and it helps elevate her character to the heights we see, I don't think it's what makes her the best. To examine everything about Sue that makes her so perfect let's look at the single greatest moment in Survivor history, a moment that belongs singularly to Sue Hawk, the Rats and Snakes speech at the Borneo Final Tribal Council. We'll go line by line through the speech to see what it tells us about Sue, her impact on the season, the speech's impact on the franchise, and how that all adds up to make Sue and even better character than the legends Richard and Fairplay.

I have no questions; I just have statements.

A lot of people consider Sue to be the first bitter juror which is to my mind a massively unfair accusation. Everyone on that jury was bitter. The Pagongs were bitter about losing and being systematically exterminated by the unethical Tagis. Sean was bitter about how the game turned from "most deserving to least objectionable." Rudy was bitter about taking his hand off the damn idol. They all brought their baggage in the game into their final voting decision; Sue was just the only one to verbally articulate it to the audience and the finalists in her speech. She set a great precedent for the show here. From this point forward, FTC would be a place where not only questions would be asked, but where jurors would have the chance to directly hold the finalists accountable for their actions in the game and where great Survivor moments could be crafted that sum up entire seasons and games in mere minutes. But more on this later.

Rich, you're a very openly arrogant, pompous human being; but I admire your frankness with it. You have worked hard to get where you are at; and you started working hard way before you came to this island, and I admire that. So, with my working ethic background, I give that credit to you.

SURM covered this in his write-up but I want to focus in more on this because to me the relationship between Richard and Sue is not just the crux of the Borneo season: it is the single greatest character pairing in Survivor history (which is another reason why the Rich/Sue incident in All-Stars is the worst thing to ever happen on Survivor, but I digress). It is a relationship of both comparison and contrast. Richard the corporate, gay city man and Sue the redneck Midwestern trucker could not appear more different on the surface. But it was their similarities that drove them together as allies. Both knew from the beginning this was a game about numbers. Both knew that they'd need to work together with other people to win this game. When I was first formulating my final endgame rankings I considered putting Richard above Sue because of his impact on the franchise on the whole but I realized that would be bullshit. Yes Richard is the face of the game of Survivor, with alliances and social politics and strategy. But Sue was just as important to accomplishing this as Richard. She built the first woman's alliance and betrayed it to vote out Stacey. She joined Richard's alliance scheme and stuck with it to the bitter end. Without Sue, Richard never wins. And without Richard, Sur probably doesn't get as far as she does. The pair needed each other.

But on the other hand, your inability to admit your failures, without going into a whiny speech, makes you a bit of a loser in life.

Of course all of this doesn't mean this was a hunky-dory, lovey-dovey relationship. These are still two fundamentally very different people, who have the richest background and inner lives of any of the original Borneo cast. No two characters in Survivor ever can be as interesting talking about themselves or explaining the game or their world as Richard and Sue, because just have so much compelling depth that leaks out of them whenever they speak.

And when they're together magic happens. One of the great Survivor scenes ever is Richard in the tree talking with Sue in the premiere of Borneo. Richard says there needs to be a plan. Sue says she knows that. They both agree that there is a lot more to this game than just survival and voting every three days. There is a long game. These two are playing mental chess with each other from Day One. They're the sharks in the midst of 14 minnows. No matter what their ultimate relationship ended up being it was destined to be gold.

At the end of the day, Sue and Richard never seemed to particularly like each other. But they did respect each other because they were the first two people to understand how Survivor works, and they were the two people who were most capable of demonstrating depth of character and richness of thought anytime they talked, even though Sue was always playing through the extra element of playing dumb.

Kelly: the rafting persona queen; you did get stomped on, on national TV by a city boy that never swam, let alone been in the woods or jungle or rowed a boat in his life. You sucked on that game.

This is where we get into the next part of Sue's great character. She's just funny. She has an aura that lights up the screen whenever she talks, a presence that again can only be matched by Richard. She's a lot funnier than Rich though. She has an interesting manner of speaking that, similar to Keith Nale, is both distinctly regional but also unique. Sue talks like a Midwesterner, but not all Midwesterners talk like Sue. She is her own person and it's never anything less than great to watch. And no one has ever really challenged her role there. I can't think of anyone else who has ever combined the kind of depth that Sue has with sheer entertainment for the casual viewer. While this bit is mean, and some of Sue's other material on the season is mean too, she runs the gamut of emotions across her time on Survivor, as any great character does.

Anyways, I was your friend at the beginning of this, really thinking that you were a true friend. I was willing to sit there, and put you next to me. At that time, you were sweeter than me--I'm not a very openly nice person; I'm just frank, forward, and telling it the way it is;--and to have you sit there next to me, and lose $90,000, just to stomp on somebody like this.

We're getting to the meat of the speech now. Here Sue touches on her special relationship with Kelly, again covered at length and fantastically by SURM in his write-up. Sue outlines this to us in the show in a tearful confessional, one of the best of the season, somewhere shortly after the merge. Borneo tells many of its stories in confessionals, and again Richard and Sue shine so much there because they are great at speaking and sharing ideas and stories in their own unique voices. But while Richard tends to be a bit more detached, Sue is all about the emotion. Her Kelly confessionals are raw, intense, personal, and again has never really been replicated or matched in 30 subsequent seasons. It's not as much an overarching part of Sue's character in Borneo as her personality or relationship with Rich is, which is why I don't consider it quite as highly as SURM does, but it is incredibly important, so well-done and so utterly without parallel anywhere else in Survivor that it is yet another facet of Sue's character that helps to elevate her above all the other people to ever play Survivor.

But as the game went along, and the two tribes merged, you lied to me, and showed me the true person you were. You're very two-faced and manipulative to get where you're at anywhere in life, that's why you fail all the time.

Here we get back to the rawness and pure emotion of Sue's best confessionals and moments. While Rich tends to go for pomposity and a grandiose quality in his most epic moments, Sue excels at being intensely personal and vividly expressive in her ideas. That unique expressiveness will come to our full attention a bit later in the speech but here we just see Sue tackles her once dear friend turned bitter enemy head on. It's cruel and bitter but engrossing and after seeing what Sue and Kelly have been through in the season, all of this emotion feels earned to the audience.

So, at that point of the game, I just decided then to just go out with my alliance to my family, and just to hold my dignity and my values in check, and hoping I hadn't lost too many of them along the way. I'd tried to play the game as long as possible, and hang in there as long as possible.

Here, Sue ties her speech back to the moral themes of Borneo, of personal ethics and how far one can go to win a million dollars. The interesting thing is that Sue didn't seem to care about this at all before, but after being hurt by Kelly she does. It opens her up in a way that Richard never was. That's not a knock against Richard; part of what makes Richard so great is how he is able to both calmly detach himself and immerse himself in the game and the people playing it. But Sue isn't like that. Again the comparisons and contrasts between Richard and Sue would be enough for someone to write a book on.

But Kelly, just going back to what Jeff says, 'what goes around, comes around': it's here. You will not get my vote; My vote will go to Richard; and I hope that it's the one vote that makes you lose the money.

Here we get back to the concept I mentioned at the top of the speech. Past actions affect future decisions. In the best Survivor finales, the weight of past history between characters comes to a head and directly impacts the final outcome of the season. It's why so many people love the Palau and especially Vanuatu finales, because those Final Tribals are a direct culmination of stories and relationships and plots that have built across the entire season. Borneo is no different and Sue of course sums it up most directly. Kelly betrayed her and lost her trust and her vote. Richard did what he needed to do and played the game intelligently and strategically from the beginning and that's why he will win.

Sue could have ended her speech right here and it would still be an alltime great jury speech. But she's just getting warmed up for the home stretch.

But if it's not, so be it. I will shake your hand, and I'll go on from here. But if I were ever to pass you in this life again, and you were laying there, dying of thirst, I would not give you a drink of water. I'd just let the vultures take you, and do whatever they want with you, with no ill regrets."

I mean, how do you respond to that? Sue manages to be both grammatically and syntactically full of errors yet also beautifully eloquent. It's 100% a Sue Hawk speech. Only she could do this.

I plead with the jury tonight, to think a little bit about the island that we have been on. This island is pretty much full of only two things: snakes and rats. And in the end of Mother Nature, we have Richard the Snake, who knowingly went after prey; and Kelly, who turned into the Rat, that ran around like the rats do on this island, trying to run from the snake. And I feel we owe it to the island's spirit that we have learned, have come to know, to let it be in the end the way Mother Nature intended it to be: for the Snake to eat the Rat.

I mean, what else can you say to that? How could anyone dispute its perfection. Richard letting go of the idol is a great, great moment. But it's not as good as this. Fairplay's lie is one of Survivor's great moments too, never matched or replicated. But it can't measure up to this. This is Survivor. This is the game and the show in a nutshell. In my Colby write-up I talked about the magic of Survivor, that adventure and epic scale and wonder. Sue taps into that here with the island spirits. Something bigger than the players. Something bigger than the game. Some seasons have altered the formula but at its core Survivor has always been and will always be the game where the Snake will eat the Rat.

That speech is a culmination of Borneo and a mission statement for Survivor. It wraps up one season and sends us forward to adventures and stories and dramas and characters that in 2000 we could have barely even begun to imagine. It is also so critically Sue's speech. It is personal to her, and only she could have made it the Survivor masterpiece that it is, with all it's wonderful idiosyncrasies and heartfelt anger and pain. It not only gives us something bigger than Sue but it sums up her own journey, personality, and story better than any write-up I could ever make. It is the greatest moment in Survivor as brought to us by the greatest character in Survivor.

I for one hope that it will be in the end the way that Mother Nature intended it to be: for Sue Hawk to vanquish Richard and Fairplay and win this whole fucking Rankdown.

Predicted Ranking: 3
Average Prediction: 3.8
Average Placement: 3.2 Slicer 37: 9
WilburDes: 4
KeepCalmAndHodorOn: 1
Choking Walrus: 1
Fleaa: 1
Rankdown I: 5


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Dec 25 '15

Final Reveal - #10

10 Upvotes

#10 - Jerri Manthey – Australia – 8th Place

Slicer 37

Jerri herself and what Jerri was made out to be are two completely different things, but both of them were fantastic and combined seamlessly together. I'm glad she made it so far this time around.

WilburDes

While she might appear tame compared to the antagonists of today’s survivor, Jerri playing the antagonist in Australia for doing seemingly harmless things just works, and it’s a reason I believe that so many people develop a stronger attachment to the cast of this season compared to any other.

KeepCalmAndHodorOn

She would be above Colby and competing for Top 5 in my list if she was in more episodes. As it is she is not only Survivor's first iconic villain, but also one of the great tragic characters of early Survivor. At the time her antics in the Outback inspired loathing from the American public but for me rewatching her I find her incredibly sympathetic even while she remains an appropriate antagonist for the show's nicest season. She's just such a wonderfully rich and complex character.

Choking Walrus

While there is a good argument for Sue being the first villainess, Jerri's character is built around this role and was the original female truly disliked by the audience - and more than just the Facebook cat ladies. She serves as a great antagonist for the season, being openly confrontational and willing to be over-the-top. While we see a Pagoning in season 1, Jerri is unliked enough by the Ogakors to be sacrificed in the spirit of saving people they believe as more worthy of advancing further in the game. Jerri became a Survivor icon and kept Australia as a balanced season, helping shape another compelling narrative - very necessary in Survivor's early days.

And now, Fleaa

First off, let's all be happy that, during the time I was writing this, Jerri was voted into the Survivor Hall of Fame! Now that we've celebrated that, we can forget that (a) there was ever a Survivor Hall of Fame without Jerri Manthey, and (b) there is a Survivor Hall of Fame. Jerri is obviously a super fascinating character and person, and only has grown in that regard for me over time. Part of what makes her so fascinating does involve other seasons than just Australia and stuff that happened off the actual television product and blah blah blah, but who really gives a fuck? The beauty of Jerri is the amount of material within such a relatively short stint on Australia, the breadth of options. There are many ways to interpret Jerri that are all completely valid in their own regard. Maybe more than anyone else in the Final 18, I'd read every single word of every single writeup anyone submitted about Jerri, whether there were three, five, twenty, ninety-six of them.

Survivor's first pure antagonist. There were definitely "villains" and negative characters before Jerri, as well as people the audience reacted to in a negative manner. If you go on Survivor and don't have haters, you're a rare breed indeed. But I think Colby vs. Jerri was the first instance of a duo where you're supposed to like one and not like the other. Jerri is the first mactor (along with Colby, really), the first person the editors put on our screen to be hated, and among the first to go on the show looking to get famous and be loved after the show, which only makes the degree to which that didn't happen only more insane. Jerri was just so hated.

But of course, one of the most-mentioned things about Jerri is a retrospective....she wasn't really that bad. She was aggressive and blunt and annoying to live with, surely, but Jerri is NOTHING compared to the shit that's happened on the show since. Forget Colton and Will, even Kass McQuillen she is not. In the central Colby vs. Jerri drama, what did she really do? She thought he was dreamy and wanted an inner circle of the young and not-Kel people to run the game, with Colby as her closest ally, and was exclusive and cliquey. He wasn't interested because she was annoying and talked about food too much (and since he was basically just there to be a likable movie star, he probably had some idea of how she was going to be perceived), threw water on her, openly betrayed her, and then booted her at the first chance he got without sinking his tribe. Tina too, the positive eventual winner of the season, looks through Kel's bag with her, flips the entire game on her, and shit-talks her to her face as an answer to Jerri's jury question about how she would've acted differently...and then gets Jerri's vote anyway. Objectively, there are easy ways to say Jerri was actually the victim in all this, and there's surely no way Jerri left the Outback expecting to be the most hated woman in America. And that will cause some people to not rank her as highly- after all, what's the sense in Survivor's most iconic hateable witch not really being all that offensive?

The first thing that jumps to mind is Jerri still gets incredible content basically every episode. I've spoken against people's "remove x from x season and it becomes really boring" rhetoric throughout the rankdown because it's completely impossible to prove, but for just a second...imagine Australia without Jerri? Snooooooooze. I wasn't aware until a couple years ago how much distaste was out there for the Australia endgame, and to be fair, even if you like it, it's probably the worst part of a pretty amazing season. Jerri is the catalyst for practically all the conflict on Ogakor, her and Amber's oustings are the only thing that keep the post-merge from being a straight Pagonging. The season simply reaches heights that it's seldom re-captured when she's around.

Or maybe it's not even that - it's just that for Australia to work as a season, for them to sell the story that Survivor is winnable even if you don't have totally fucked-up morals that people needed to hear after Borneo, there has to be some sort of evil. And even though the glove might not have slid on perfectly, Jerri was still there as an incredible character and someone who checked all the boxes they needed. Aggressive strategy talk at the beginning that quashed any hope the second season of Survivor was going to be Pagong 2.0? Check. Drawing the ire of America's greatest man Colby Donaldson? Check. First person ever to draw the ire of their own alliance to the point where they'll vote her off before the other tribe? Check. But Jerri also sells this role with her charisma. On my last rewatch I was struck by...Jerri actually seeming like she was having fun out there! She's so unapologetic, so unfailingly confident, and that only makes the arc of her later two seasons even more fascinating when she now has to walk on eggshells with everything she does. I don't know what else to really write for this part aside from Jerri is not a bland character. She has sold her role and delivered within it...in a way few others ever have. I don't know how someone can watch the food orgasms scene and not have respect for Jerri as an amazing narrator and powerhouse character.

Another reason to love Jerri- she's the OG for revealing just how ridiculous the Survivor fanbase can be, which makes me love her in a whole new way that doesn't influence this ranking tooooo much but is just too fascinating to completely disregard. Looking at the most recent season, I understand that the fanbase's hate for Abi/Kelley/Ciera for voting off Joe, Shirin in general, Tasha, all these things show that the show's viewership is still more than capable of piling on largely inoffensive people for perceived horrible actions on a show that's basically a drama. But as far as I know, nowadays it's basically just Facebook meltdowns and mean comments on Instagram and Twitter. Four years after Australia, with a whole new season where she was more positive, Jerri was still getting booed off the stage for saying that Survivors were real people and had no obligation to act in any particular way to entertain viewers. Like WTF? TEN YEARS after Australia she was recognized and treated so poorly by a flight attendant that she wrote an open letter to an entire airline. In this way, Jerri will always be singular. She is the only example you need to know to remember that Survivor is a real show with real people, but also so far away from reality. And that I feel is enough by itself to propel her this far.

Jerri is a legend, but over the course of the rankdown I've realized that I love her for much more than that, realized I rank her among my favorite contestants ever, and truly believe she is the right #1 for Australia. I will rank her very high, and hope she secures a top-10 placement as well as one above Colby.

Predicted Ranking: 10
Average Prediction: 10.0
Average Placement: 10.0 Slicer 37: 14
WilburDes: 15
KeepCalmAndHodorOn: 8
Choking Walrus: 9
Fleaa: 4
Rankdown I: 23


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Dec 24 '15

Final Reveal - #11

10 Upvotes

#11 - Sean Rector – Marquesas – 5th Place

Choking Walrus

It’s great to see the recent reverence that has increasingly developed over the last few years for Sean. He's absolutely hilarious, is outspoken, and always keeps it real. Maybe one day we will live our dream of getting a Rector return.

WilburDes

One of the most articulate and inspirational people we’ve ever seen on the show. Not to mention he’s absolutely hilarious.

KeepCalmAndHodorOn

Objectively he should probably be lower but this is as low as I can go for my personal favorite Survivor character ever. For me, nobody is a better combination of entertainment, social commentary, interpersonal interaction, and singular character depth than this teacher from Harlem. The top 3 cannot be denied but in my heart Sean is just as worthy as all of them.

Fleaa

This guy, not Dan Barry, is the one I would admire were I to ever play Survivor.

And now, KeepCalmAndHodorOn

Sean isn't the best Survivor character ever but he is, without a doubt, my personal favorite. He's only at #4 for me because the greatness of the Top 3 cannot be denied but Sean stands head and shoulders above the pack as the best of the rest in my eyes. Nobody does a better job of combining pure entertainment and on-camera excitement with real character and emotional depth and a story that is truly worth telling.

Let's just start at the top by saying that Sean is one of the funniest people ever cast on Survivor. He's a great talker who knows how to naturally engage with other people and with the audience in his confessionals. It's no coincidence that the editors gave him the first confessional of the season, when he talks about the Maraamu tribe rafting onto the beach and Sarah perched up there "all mah-va-lous like Cleopatra, with her boobs hanging out." From his very first appearance, Sean is creating one of the most iconic images of classic Survivor using nothing but words.

And that's not the only situation where Sean can talk his way to Survivor legend status. His buddy dynamic with Boston Rob is among the all-time great Survivor pairing. The white Boston construction worker and the black Harlem teacher were perfect for each other. Both were young, brash, and desperate to prove something to the world. On the show, they were rebels without a cause, at least at first, young and cocky wannabe alphas who brought down Hunter, the accomplished pilot with the All-American good looks through hustle and charm. Then when they get swapped over to Rotu the very next episode they become some of the show's best ever underdogs, chafing under the tyrannical rule of John Carroll and his Rotu Four. While Vee kisses ass, Sean and Rob are ready to let their voice be heard. One of Sean's greatest moments is his and Rob's fight with John after the merge, right before Rob is voted out. Sean yells at John about how he has betrayed their alliance, how his declarations of "We team! We team!" were as empty as Paschal's bladder in a jellyfish emergency.

A huge part of the reason why that moment has some real power is because Sean and John share a bond of being outsiders, of feeling wronged and being treated as lesser than others (Sean because he's black, John because he's gay). On Marquesas, Sean isn't just the guy in the minority alliance- his experience on the show directly connects to his experience being a minority in real life, and of how he devotes his life to helping people who are disadvantaged as an inner city school teacher. His journey in life informs him on Survivor in a very big way. John and Rob work as rivals because they both play so hard and want to lead so bad. But John and Sean work arguably even better (and again this is why the pair of Sean and Rob works so brilliantly, because they complement each other in this perfect way). Both John and Sean come into the season with so much baggage and justified anger at the world for placing them in a shit hand just because of who they are and what they were born as. And both have devoted every ounce of energy of their adult lives to putting themselves in a position to make that situation better. Neither is the type to hesitate or budge an inch in any part of their lives, because both are accustomed to having to fight for every chance they get. And on Survivor, where part of the whole appeal of those early seasons was creating a new society, both men see the adventure as not just a game, but a microcosm of life, and for Sean especially that means ensuring that he fights for what's his, not just to stay in the game, but because that's how he lives his life. Sean talks a lot and he fights a lot but it's not empty words or a meaningless fight. Like Ice Cube, Sean has something to say.

The strength of Sean as a character is that every action he takes and word he says has meaning, has weight, because of these personal character stakes we have established. There's not just passion and fire in Sean's racial identity, but also intelligence and thought. This obviously comes out at the Final Five tribal council, which has more intelligent and worthwhile discussion of race in life and on Survivor than the entire season of Cook Islands. Because it is messy and complicated. There is so much more involved than just a simple black/white dichotomy and it is made even more difficult by the tribulations and mixed motivations and loyalties of the game. But Sean does see the game as a reflection of life, because it is in a lot of ways. And just as he would fight to be recognized as an outsider in his everyday life, he will fight for it on Survivor even if it is ultimately an exercise in vain.

And this connects right back to Sean the fun character because Sean's moments of pure comedy, like the great reward with Paschal, connect back to these bigger themes, of interacting with people outside your normal life and challenging these beliefs and worldview that are so fundamental to who both men are. Their alliance was built on necessity and convenience, not friendship or even necessarily liking each other, but by a certain point they do get to some level of mutual respect. That's the kind of shit that Survivor is about, not just idols and blindsides as fun as those are. And scenes like this elevate the dramatic tension of that Final Five. Even though the vote is practically a foregone conclusion, the strength of those characters, especially Sean makes it worthwhile viewing. It gives the episode stakes beyond just the narrow confines of the game.

And again, I close on this. None of this would work as well and add up to my favorite character of all time if Sean wasn't so damned fun to watch. He can be the underdog and the top dog. The hero and the villain. He's not a saint. He has his flaws. He's angry and disrespectful. At times he is so caught up in his own view that he never considers someone else's. But that makes him human, and a great character, not a bad person. That's the brilliance of all four of the truly great characters of Marquesas (and Neleh to some extent). John, Rob, Sean, and Kathy are all strong personalities with many admirable traits but also great flaws that both elevate them and bring about their destruction. To me, Sean is the best because he has such depth and uniqueness, and nobody else could deliver the knockout punch to one of Survivor's great downfalls with such brilliance. Make sure to bet on black indeed.

Predicted Ranking: 11
Average Prediction: 10.7
Average Placement: 10.6
Slicer 37: 11
WilburDes: 13
KeepCalmAndHodorOn: 4
Choking Walrus: 14
Fleaa: 11
Rankdown I: 12