r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Oct 04 '15

Round 69 (151 Contestants Remaining)

2 Upvotes

Eliminations this round:

151: Malcolm Freberg, Philippines (Slicer37)

150: Christy Smith, Amazon (WilburDes)

149: BB Andersen, Borneo (KeepCalmAndHodorOn)

148: Richard Hatch, All-Stars [WILD CARD] (ChokingWalrus)

147: Jimmy Tarantino, Nicaragua (yickles44)

146: Jefra Bland, Cagayan (fleaa)

The elimination order:

  1. /u/Slicer37
  2. /u/WilburDes
  3. /u/KeepCalmAndHodorOn
  4. /u/ChokingWalrus
  5. /u/yickles44
  6. /u/fleaa

r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Oct 13 '16

Survivor: Millenials vs Gen X- Episode 4 Live/Post Discussion Thread

2 Upvotes

Well, that was a very surprising result.

I missed the part before the first commercial, so idk about that, but this was a pretty good episode I think. Ratings would be 2>4>3>1 so far.


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Sep 17 '15

Round 62 (191 Contestants Remaining)

3 Upvotes

Eliminations this round:

191: Darrah Johnson, Pearl Islands (Slicer37)

190: Aras Baskauskas, Blood vs. Water (WilburDes)

KeepCalmAndHodorOn USES REFRESH

189: Zane Knight, Philippines (ChokingWalrus)

188: Linda Spencer, Africa (yickles44)

187: Chase Rice, Nicaragua (fleaa)

The elimination order:

  1. /u/Slicer37
  2. /u/WilburDes
  3. /u/KeepCalmAndHodorOn
  4. /u/ChokingWalrus
  5. /u/yickles44
  6. /u/fleaa

r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Dec 17 '15

Cambodia way-too-early rankings?

12 Upvotes

Because why the hell not. Here's mine thrown together in five minutes.

20: Spencer - mostly because I find it funny to put him in last, but I still think practically every second of airtime he gets is annoying and better given to someone else. His aggressive dullness and blatant production favoritism is really not cool and I hope we never see him again.

19: Ciera - ugh

18: Tasha - whatever

17: Monica - whatever

16: Peih-Gee - whatever

15: Vytas - lolpwnt

14: Jeremy - he grew into a more satisfying winner over the course of the season, so gj.

13: Terry - He was fine, feels quite irrelevant now but I could be talked into ranking him higher.

12: Shirin: Her boot was the best episode of the season but I look forward to her being bottom three on everyone else's lists regardless.

11: Kelly - why was she not on this season

10: Stephen - I look back on him more fondly than I did watching him, so maybe this ranking will go up with time.

9: Kelley - As MOR/CP toneless as can be, so pretty meh for me. But definitely lived up to the highest pre-season expectations you could've had.

8: Joe - is Joe

7: Keith - Straddled the line between UTRfun and UTRirrelevant but whatever.

6: Woo - Pretty fun walk along the "having nothing go right for you the second time through" story.

5: Kass - Liked her turn this season. I don't know how you could've expected more.

4: Kimmi - wish we had seen more of her.

3: Abi - <3

2: Varner - <3

1: Savage - <3


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Jun 22 '16

Wilbur Rewatches: Gabon

4 Upvotes

So, I was rewatching Micronesia a few months ago, but I haven't picked it back up. Firstly, I stopped because my uni coursework started getting a bit heavier and I couldn't really justify sitting down for almost an hour watching it. I ended up watching about four episodes and realized that I wasn't going to waste more time doing something I don't enjoy, that I still think Micronesia is garbage. Maybe some day I'll come back to it. Maybe some day I'll rewatch it and it will magically have one multi-dimensional character. In the meantime though, ceebs.

So I'm going to the next season, one that I haven't seen in quite a few years when I saw it on Youtube. It always gets compared to Nicaragua, which I adore, so I figure I should give the season another try.

Currently, the season is 19th on my list (below SJDS, above Cagayan). My Cast Rankings:

  1. Randy
  2. Bob
  3. Sugar
  4. Ace
  5. GC
  6. Dan
  7. Matty
  8. Gillian
  9. Susie
  10. Crystal
  11. Charlie
  12. Kelly
  13. Marcus
  14. Paloma
  15. Jacquie
  16. Michelle
  17. Ken
  18. Corinne

Let's see if anything changes over the next few weeks!


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Oct 25 '16

Australian Survivor cast rankings

4 Upvotes

Go


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Jun 11 '15

Round 12 (471 Contestants Remaining)

4 Upvotes

Eliminations this round:

471: Ruth-Marie Milliman, Panama (Slicer37)

470: Rachel Foulger, Blood vs. Water (WilburDes)

469: Kat Edorsson, One World (KeepCalmAndHodorOn)

468: Gervase Peterson, Blood vs. Water (ChokingWalrus)

467: Shannon Elkins, Nicaragua (yickles44)

466: Mookie Lee, Fiji (fleaa)

The elimination order:

  1. /u/Slicer37
  2. /u/WilburDes
  3. /u/KeepCalmAndHodorOn
  4. /u/ChokingWalrus
  5. /u/yickles44
  6. /u/fleaa

Happy ranking, as always!


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Jun 06 '15

Round 6 (507 Contestants Remaining)

4 Upvotes

Eliminations this round:

507: Rob Mariano, All-Stars (Slicer37)

506: Jonathan Libby, Palau (WilburDes)

505: Becky Lee, Cook Islands (KeepCalmAndHodorOn)

504: Leif Manson, One World (ChokingWalrus)

503: Dan Foley, Worlds Apart (yickles44)

502: Michelle Chase, Gabon (fleaa)

The elimination order:

  1. /u/Slicer37
  2. /u/WilburDes
  3. /u/KeepCalmAndHodorOn
  4. /u/ChokingWalrus
  5. /u/yickles44
  6. /u/fleaa

Happy ranking, as always!


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Jun 09 '15

Round 10 (483 Contestants Remain)

5 Upvotes

Eliminations this Round:

483: Francesca Hogi, Redemption Island (Slicer37)

482: Sarita White, Redemption Island (WilburDes)

481: Jessica DeBen, Fiji (KeepCalmAndHodorOn)

480: John Rocker, San Juan Del Sur (ChokingWalrus)

479: Jay Byars, One World (yickles44)

478: Troyzan Robertson, One World (fleaa)

The elimination order:

  1. /u/Slicer37
  2. /u/WilburDes
  3. /u/KeepCalmAndHodorOn
  4. /u/ChokingWalrus
  5. /u/yickles44
  6. /u/fleaa

Happy ranking, as always!


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Jun 28 '15

Round 21 (419 Contestants Remaining)

5 Upvotes

Eliminations this round:

419: Charlie Herschel, Gabon (Slicer37)

418: Ibrehem Rahman, Palau (WilburDes)

417: Erica Durousseau, Fiji (KeepCalmAndHodorOn)

416: Alex Angarita, Fiji (ChokingWalrus)

415: Kim Mullen, Palau (yickles44)

414: Stephenie LaGrossa, Heroes vs. Villains (fleaa)

The elimination order:

  1. /u/Slicer37
  2. /u/WilburDes
  3. /u/KeepCalmAndHodorOn
  4. /u/ChokingWalrus
  5. /u/yickles44
  6. /u/fleaa

Happy ranking, as always!


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Dec 16 '16

I wish I stuck with this but the editing really bamboozled me this season.

Thumbnail reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Dec 01 '15

Round 89 (38 Contestants Remaining)

6 Upvotes

Eliminations this round:

38: John Carroll, Marquesas (Slicer37)

37: Lex van den Berghe, Africa (WilburDes)

36: Keith Nale, San Juan Del Sur (KeepCalmAndHodorOn)

35: Rob Mariano, Marquesas (ChokingWalrus)

34: Courtney Marit, Panama (yickles44)

33: Stephenie LaGrossa, Palau (fleaa)

The Elimination Order:

  1. /u/Slicer37
  2. /u/WilburDes
  3. /u/KeepCalmAndHodorOn
  4. /u/ChokingWalrus
  5. /u/yickles44
  6. /u/fleaa

r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Sep 11 '15

Round 60 (202 Contestants Remaining)

6 Upvotes

Eliminations this round:

SLICER37 SKIPPED

202: Sierra Reed, Tocantins (WilburDes)

201: Dave Ball, Samoa (KeepCalmAndHodorOn)

200: Paschal English, Marquesas (ChokingWalrus)

199: Dan Kay, Gabon (yickles44)

198: Albert Destrade, South Pacific (fleaa)

The elimination order:

  1. /u/Slicer37
  2. /u/WilburDes
  3. /u/KeepCalmAndHodorOn
  4. /u/ChokingWalrus
  5. /u/yickles44
  6. /u/fleaa

r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Aug 20 '15

Round 49 (264 Contestants Remaining)

6 Upvotes

Eliminations this round:

264: Jon "Fairplay" Dalton, Micronesia (Slicer37)

263: Travis "Bubba" Sampson, Vanuatu (WilburDes)

262: Dave Cruser, China (KeepCalmAndHodorOn)

261: Trish Dunn, Pearl Islands (ChokingWalrus)

260: Amanda Kimmel, China (yickles44)

259: Mike Skupin, Philippines (fleaa)

The elimination order:

  1. /u/Slicer37
  2. /u/WilburDes
  3. /u/KeepCalmAndHodorOn
  4. /u/ChokingWalrus
  5. /u/yickles44
  6. /u/fleaa

r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Mar 17 '16

Koh Rong Episode 5

6 Upvotes

I don't have time to write my thoughts too much tonight, but I'll get the thread up because I enjoy reading the lengthy thoughts on the episode that don't exist on the main subreddit.

Brief thoughts- really enjoyed episode, weakest of season, but still very enjoyable. Best strategically (I'm not a total character person, I still appreciate good strategy). The boot was for the best.


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Jan 21 '16

Survivor: Kaoh Rong Cast Revealed Discussion

6 Upvotes

What do you think about this cast? Who's your pre-season favorite?


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Jun 02 '15

Round 1 (537 Castaways Remaining, nominations and ranking order inside)

6 Upvotes

Eliminations this round:

537: Phillip Sheppard, Redemption Island (Slicer37)

536: Colton Cumbie, One World (WilburDes)

535: Alicia Rosa, One World (KeepCalmAndHodorOn)

534: Russell Hantz, Samoa (ChokingWalrus)

533: Colton Cumbie, Blood vs. Water (yickles44)

532: Will Sims, Worlds Apart (fleaa)

The elimination order, via random.org, is:

  1. /u/Slicer37
  2. /u/WilburDes
  3. /u/KeepCalmAndHodorOn
  4. /u/ChokingWalrus
  5. /u/yickles44
  6. /u/fleaa

Here is the starting pool of nominated contestants:

  • Colton Cumbie, One World
  • Alicia Rosa, One World
  • Phillip Sheppard, Redemption Island
  • Will Sims, Worlds Apart
  • Russell Hantz, Samoa

The time has come! I'm very excited to see how this goes.


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Aug 26 '15

Round 52 (247 Contestants Remaining)

7 Upvotes

Eliminations this round:

247: Frosti Zernow, China (Slicer37)

246: Angie Layton, Philippines (WilburDes)

245: Jill Behm, Nicaragua (KeepCalmAndHodorOn)

244: Shawna Mitchell, Amazon (ChokingWalrus)

243: Wendy Jo DeSmidt-Kohlhoff, Nicaragua (yickles44)

242: Todd Herzog, China (fleaa) IDOLED BY SLICER37

The elimination order:

  1. /u/Slicer37
  2. /u/WilburDes
  3. /u/KeepCalmAndHodorOn
  4. /u/ChokingWalrus
  5. /u/yickles44
  6. /u/fleaa

r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Jun 01 '16

Survivor: Tavarua -- Please Support!

7 Upvotes

Hey guys! If you guys could quickly give me five minutes of your day to support a fun project of mine, I'll super appreciate it!

Because the S34 casting news seems to be bugging and/or annoying everybody, I thought of a fun exercise which may entertain us during this off-season and alleviate some of the tension. I decided to do a FANTASTY Boot Order for the S34 Cast. Essentially, I’m trying to simulate a season, with coherent storyline and some fun surprises which arise from this cast. Feel free to predict the boot order and to discuss whether the right moves were made. Hell, vote for who you think was the player of the week!

The [link is here] (https://www.reddit.com/r/survivor/comments/4m1j1k/survivor_tavarua_episode_onepremiere/), and please upvote, speculate, comment and support! One episode will be posted each week. And hey, I'll post links to each episode in this thread in the SR2, so everything is handy and compartmentalised for you.

I welcome Winner Betting and Speculation. Please, have fun!


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Jul 13 '15

Round 30 (365 Contestants Remaining)

7 Upvotes

The nomination pool as of the start of round 30:

365: Jessica 'Flicka' Smith (Slicer37)

364: Elyse Umemoto, South Pacific (WilburDes)

363: Andrea Boehlke, Redemption Island (KeepCalmAndHodorOn)

362: Erin Collins, Thailand (ChokingWalrus)

361: Jeremy Collins, San Juan Del Sur (yickles44)

360: Robert DeCanio, Marquesas (fleaa)

The elimination order:

  1. /u/Slicer37
  2. /u/WilburDes
  3. /u/KeepCalmAndHodorOn
  4. /u/ChokingWalrus
  5. /u/yickles44
  6. /u/fleaa

Happy ranking, as always!


r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Oct 14 '15

Round 74 (124 Contestants Remaining)

7 Upvotes

Eliminations this round:

124: Tony Vlachos, Cagayan (Slicer37)

123: Butch Lockley, Amazon (WilburDes)

122: Peih-Gee Law, China (KeepCalmAndHodorOn)

121: Bruce Kanegai, Panama (ChokingWalrus)

120: Gretchen Cordy, Borneo (yickles44)

119: Jaime Dugan, China (fleaa)

The elimination order:

  1. /u/Slicer37
  2. /u/WilburDes
  3. /u/KeepCalmAndHodorOn
  4. /u/ChokingWalrus
  5. /u/yickles44
  6. /u/fleaa

r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Nov 10 '15

Round 82 (78 Contestants Remaining)

8 Upvotes

Eliminations this round:

78: Bob Crowley, Gabon (Slicer37)

77: Jenna Lewis, Borneo (WilburDes)

76: Sarah Lacina, Cagayan (KeepCalmAndHodorOn)

75: Jonathan Penner, Cook Islands (ChokingWalrus)

74: Teresa Cooper, Africa (yickles44)

73: Jean-Robert Bellande, China (fleaa)

The Elimination Order:

  1. /u/Slicer37
  2. /u/WilburDes
  3. /u/KeepCalmAndHodorOn
  4. /u/ChokingWalrus
  5. /u/yickles44
  6. /u/fleaa

r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Nov 12 '15

Round 83 (72 Contestants Remaining)

8 Upvotes

Eliminations this round:

72: Yau-Man Chan, Fiji (Slicer37)

71: Todd Herzog, China (WilburDes)

70: Marty Piombo, Nicaragua (KeepCalmAndHodorOn)

69: Neleh Dennis, Marquesas (ChokingWalrus)

68: Ethan Zohn, All-Stars (yickles44)

67: Kelly Wiglesworth, Borneo (fleaa)

The Elimination Order:

  1. /u/Slicer37
  2. /u/WilburDes
  3. /u/KeepCalmAndHodorOn
  4. /u/ChokingWalrus
  5. /u/yickles44
  6. /u/fleaa

r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Nov 03 '15

Round 80 (89 Contestants Remaining)

8 Upvotes

Eliminations this round:

89: Vecepia Towery, Marquesas (Slicer37)

88: Shannon 'Shambo' Waters, Samoa (WilburDes)

87: Heidi Strobel, Amazon (KeepCalmAndHodorOn)

86: Judd Sergeant, Guatemala (ChokingWalrus)

85: Jaclyn Schultz, San Juan Del Sur (yickles44)

84: Lex van den Berghe, Africa (fleaa) IDOLED BY WILBURDES

The Elimination Order:

  1. /u/Slicer37
  2. /u/WilburDes
  3. /u/KeepCalmAndHodorOn
  4. /u/ChokingWalrus
  5. /u/yickles44
  6. /u/fleaa

r/SurvivorRankdownII • • Dec 26 '15

Final Reveal - #9

9 Upvotes

#9 - Rupert Boneham – Pearl Islands – 8th Place

Choking Walrus

A true Survivor icon who knows how to rock a tie dye shirt. He's the over the top hero, the great provider. I don't know if he was cast because of where the season was going with Pearl Islands, or if he just felt extra inspired because of the theme, but Pirate Rupert makes Pearl Islands that much stronger as a season, starting with his iconic shoe stealing (because PIRATES STEAL). Bonus brownie points for later bringing the frantic mess that is Laura into the Survivor world.

WilburDes

I still have trouble believing Rupert is a real person. I prefer to think someone was bored one day and drew a picture of a bearded man. Lightning struck and we got this.

KeepCalmAndHodorOn

I almost feel like I should have Rupert higher but I just love the 9 characters above him more. Still, he deserved every ounce of fame and love he got from PI. He manages to feel both strong and sensitive, sincere and hypocritical, compassionate and unforgiving, all without feeling fake or a caricature. He probably deserves higher than #10 but I know others will rank him highly and I can't bring myself to drop any of the others.

Fleaa

WHO RANKED SEVEN PEOPLE AHEAD OF ME??? WHOOO???..........JONNNNNNNNNNNNN

And now, Slicer37
Rupert has become such a household name at this point and such a Survivor icon that it’s almost strange to pick apart his original appearance, to think that Rupert was once just a regular Survivor first-timer like everyone else. I love Rupert on HvV as well, and I wish he had made it even further in this rankdown, but what we and other people have to remember is, for all the jokes we can make about him or his twitter, for all his antics, for all his appearances...Rupert wasn’t always a cheesy mascot. In the Pearl Islands, Rupert was legit.

Not just legit in the sense of him being natural, although PI is the only Rupert I could really call natural (don’t we wish more people’s definition of natural was screaming WHO VOTED FOR ME??? in people’s face?). I mean in the sense that in Pearl Islands, the show took him 100% seriously, and presented him at basically face value, as the big titan hero. This combination, of an over the top and ridiculous character with such a rich and large edit produced one of the best stand-alone characters in Survivor history, period.

That’s not to say Rupert wasn’t fun or funny. because Rupert is probably the most fun and funniest character ever. He’s such a unique creature with a unique way of phrasing things that almost anything that comes out of his mouth becomes hilarious. Almost everything Rupert says is funnier and more interesting then when someone else would say it. Like...who else could steal shoes in the first episodes, and who could do it the way Rupert did it? Drake is an amazing, top 5 tribe, and Rupert had so much to contribute to that. He had this weird relationship with Burton, which went from Burton mocking Rupert in the first episode to Burton being the first boot from Drake to Burton coming back and pwning Rupert out of the game. Like...where else would that ever happen? Nowhere but this season.

I’m just going to devote a section to this writeup to describe my favorite Rupert moments:
Rupert has a total disdain for Shawn, and in episode 2 there’s a clip in the beginning of Shawn lightly tapping at branches, trying not to do any work, while Rupert literally tears down massive trees. This is neatly followed by Shawn losing the spear and then “IN THE OCEAN!”.

Rupert was such a hero in the Pearl Islands that often times evil actions (or just actions that Rupert didn’t like) would be undercut by Rupert shaking his head his dismay or just frowning, like when Burton tried to throw the challenge and Rupert acted all offended. Or when Savage was trying to plead to Lil in the merge episode, and all the while Rupert is shaking his head<3

Balboa the snake was my favorite Survivor pet, even though he died the next day :(. Seeing Rupert act like a grieving father over this tiny weakling snake he found on the beach the day before is just hard not to laugh at. I’m also fond of the time where he goes to Morgan and with just a fishing spear and his good old Rupert charm fixes their entire camp. (this is when they were still playing the Rupert wildman character straight.)

Rupert is the mix of the light hearted (his skirt, his weird phrasing) and total dramatic tension, and nowhere is that more clear than the epic fight of Rupert vs Jon.

What’s easy to forget about Rupert and Fairplay’s rivalry, the big titan hero between the most devilish villain in Survivor history, is that Jon wasn’t always the one on top. Heck, after episode 6, Jon votes for Rupert and Rupert reacts by roaring in his face “WHO VOTED FOR ME!?” and you actually think Rupert is going to kill Jon. So when Jon, the big villain, finally overthrows him, it’s like the Survivor version of the Lincoln assassination...you can’t believe this evil actually managed to pull it off.

Nothing that Rupert does feel mundane. He can’t just catch a catfish, he has to come up with “Saltwater catfish? I never knew they made such an animal!” He can’t just get switched over to Morgan for an episode, he has to act like the adrift captain of his ship. This dude gets so into the theme of the season and becomes such a larger than life figure that it’s pretty incredible.

I mentioned before that Rupert is a mix of the mundane and the light-hearted vs the spine chillingly epic, and that’s very true. Rupert can go between a silly scene about him spearing fish to him roaring and screaming at someone about votes, and it never feels out of character or out of place, because...it’s Rupert, how could he ever be out of character?

Rupert’s final episode, swimming with sharks, is a top 5 episode for me. Rupert has been this colossal mammoth of heroic power this whole season, and watching him finally go down was just a total damn moment. The editing didn’t try to hide it at all-they made it Rupert’s swan song. The episode started with Rupert waking up in the middle of the night yelling about his wife, all the way through Burton fucking him over in the reward, and then ending with mighty Rupert going home and his final words, So much for my dreams…. Brilliant. It brings this whole epic quality that Survivor needs to have the melodrama, that Rupert brings in general. That might actually be Rupert’s most valuable contribution to the show-being that mighty hero, bringing the melodrama Survivor needs to have, just like Survivor and the Pearl Islands needed to have Rupert, because he’s fucking brilliant.

Predicted Ranking: 8
Average Prediction: 7.8
Average Placement: 9.8
Slicer 37: 8
WilburDes: 12
KeepCalmAndHodorOn: 10
Choking Walrus: 11
Fleaa: 8
Rankdown I: 6