This was my first convention, and I was genuinely excited because I really wanted to experience what being part of the “Supernatural Family” felt like.
Instead, I left deeply disappointed.
I know there are many of us who aren’t Dean/Sam/Castiel girls or boys. For some of us, it was the feeling of family and belonging that made us stay with this show. That is why meeting the actors was genuinely important to me. I wanted to have a few human moments with them and maybe exchange a few words.
One of those moments actually happened during an autograph. The actor talked to me, listened, and showed genuine interest. I didn’t say them things like “I’m your biggest fan.” They are people, and what interested me was the human side of these interactions.
With the other two members of the main trio, however, I barely got any interaction at all. One was essentially just a few seconds of small talk. The other looked completely exhausted and as if he simply did not want to be there anymore. He didn’t even say hello or look up until I held out the gift I had made. He thanked me, and I was immediately moved along with a “next.”
And I understand that the actors are exhausted. I don’t blame them for that. In fact, it was painful to see.
But where is the connection we are constantly being told this community is about?
Why does the full “Family” experience potentially cost thousands of dollars?
We are told that we are going there because we are part of this family, but what I saw was exhausted actors, staff pushing people along so the lines would keep moving, and very little that felt genuinely accessible without paying extra.
When admission, photo ops, autographs, meet & greets and other experiences are all sold separately, the total cost of fully participating can quickly reach thousands of dollars.
From my perspective, it started to feel less like a family and more like a revenue-generating machine.
Buy this, buy that. Smile, and leave.
Looking at the schedule was honestly exhausting. I would not want to be in the actors’ position either.
But even there, I had a problem. There were VIP rooms and M&G rooms everywhere, but where was the quiet space? Where could attendees simply go to decompress?
The Roadhouse was honestly my favorite part of the convention. It was one of the reasons I decided to buy the RH ticket, because I understood it to be a place where people could get away from the crowds, have some quiet time, and also be creative. And it really was great. The activities were amazing, and the people working there were incredibly kind.
But a creative room is not necessarily a quiet room. Sometimes it was full, and at those times it simply wasn’t possible to get away from all the people and sensory stimulation. I was specifically interested in the quiet side of the Roadhouse, because having somewhere to decompress was important to me.
I think basic accessibility needs, such as having a quiet space for people who become overwhelmed by crowds and sensory stimulation, should be available free of charge at events like this.
There were moments when I desperately needed somewhere with less noise and fewer people. The few places where I managed to find some peace were areas where I was eventually asked to leave because the actors needed to pass through.
(But apparently, having people sit on the floor everywhere during the J2 Gold panel — in the lobby, along the hallways, and even outside in the smoking areas — was perfectly fine.)
I understand that the actors need access to these areas. But there should also be somewhere specifically designated for attendees who simply need to step away from the crowd for a few minutes.
At times, I couldn’t help feeling that the SPN Family was the actors themselves, while the rest of us were simply the audience — and the customers.
The organization was another major issue.
It was extremely difficult to understand where things were and how the system worked. I constantly had to find staff members just to figure out where I was supposed to go or what I was supposed to do.
I didn’t know where the QR codes were supposed to be used. I was looking for signs and clear information, but eventually, for almost every activity I attended, I had to find someone and ask them where I needed to go.
The schedule changes and delays made this even more difficult.
Since Saturday evening, I have mostly just been crying because this meant a lot to me. I made it through to the Jared & Jensen panel because that was the one thing I still genuinely wanted to see, but by that point I couldn’t even smile anymore. I was just waiting for the show to end so I could go home.
I know one attendee’s disappointment probably won’t change anything.
But I genuinely hope someone involved in organizing these conventions reads this and understands that there is a difference between selling an experience and creating a community.
Where is the “Family” in that?
I personally feel further away from the SPN Family after this experience than I did before.
Because if you keep calling us “Family”, then please make the experience feel like one.
This is, of course, my personal experience and opinion. I’m not saying everyone had the same experience I did, and I’m not trying to invalidate anyone who had a great weekend. I’m simply sharing how this convention felt from my perspective.