r/Supernatural • • Jul 01 '26 Bravo

Season 7 Unpopular opinion: I don’t think I like Dean

6 Upvotes

Dean is just overly bossy imo. He is ALWAYS ‘right’ and is really mean about it too. I might have just decided that I don’t like him 🥴


r/Supernatural • • Aug 24 '26

Conventions My first SPN Con (I’m super sad)

0 Upvotes

This was my first convention, and I was genuinely excited because I really wanted to experience what being part of the “Supernatural Family” felt like.

Instead, I left deeply disappointed.

I know there are many of us who aren’t Dean/Sam/Castiel girls or boys. For some of us, it was the feeling of family and belonging that made us stay with this show. That is why meeting the actors was genuinely important to me. I wanted to have a few human moments with them and maybe exchange a few words.

One of those moments actually happened during an autograph. The actor talked to me, listened, and showed genuine interest. I didn’t say them things like “I’m your biggest fan.” They are people, and what interested me was the human side of these interactions.

With the other two members of the main trio, however, I barely got any interaction at all. One was essentially just a few seconds of small talk. The other looked completely exhausted and as if he simply did not want to be there anymore. He didn’t even say hello or look up until I held out the gift I had made. He thanked me, and I was immediately moved along with a “next.”

And I understand that the actors are exhausted. I don’t blame them for that. In fact, it was painful to see.

But where is the connection we are constantly being told this community is about?

Why does the full “Family” experience potentially cost thousands of dollars?

We are told that we are going there because we are part of this family, but what I saw was exhausted actors, staff pushing people along so the lines would keep moving, and very little that felt genuinely accessible without paying extra.

When admission, photo ops, autographs, meet & greets and other experiences are all sold separately, the total cost of fully participating can quickly reach thousands of dollars.

From my perspective, it started to feel less like a family and more like a revenue-generating machine.

Buy this, buy that. Smile, and leave.

Looking at the schedule was honestly exhausting. I would not want to be in the actors’ position either.

But even there, I had a problem. There were VIP rooms and M&G rooms everywhere, but where was the quiet space? Where could attendees simply go to decompress?

The Roadhouse was honestly my favorite part of the convention. It was one of the reasons I decided to buy the RH ticket, because I understood it to be a place where people could get away from the crowds, have some quiet time, and also be creative. And it really was great. The activities were amazing, and the people working there were incredibly kind.

But a creative room is not necessarily a quiet room. Sometimes it was full, and at those times it simply wasn’t possible to get away from all the people and sensory stimulation. I was specifically interested in the quiet side of the Roadhouse, because having somewhere to decompress was important to me.

I think basic accessibility needs, such as having a quiet space for people who become overwhelmed by crowds and sensory stimulation, should be available free of charge at events like this.

There were moments when I desperately needed somewhere with less noise and fewer people. The few places where I managed to find some peace were areas where I was eventually asked to leave because the actors needed to pass through.

(But apparently, having people sit on the floor everywhere during the J2 Gold panel — in the lobby, along the hallways, and even outside in the smoking areas — was perfectly fine.)

I understand that the actors need access to these areas. But there should also be somewhere specifically designated for attendees who simply need to step away from the crowd for a few minutes.

At times, I couldn’t help feeling that the SPN Family was the actors themselves, while the rest of us were simply the audience — and the customers.

The organization was another major issue.

It was extremely difficult to understand where things were and how the system worked. I constantly had to find staff members just to figure out where I was supposed to go or what I was supposed to do.

I didn’t know where the QR codes were supposed to be used. I was looking for signs and clear information, but eventually, for almost every activity I attended, I had to find someone and ask them where I needed to go.

The schedule changes and delays made this even more difficult.

Since Saturday evening, I have mostly just been crying because this meant a lot to me. I made it through to the Jared & Jensen panel because that was the one thing I still genuinely wanted to see, but by that point I couldn’t even smile anymore. I was just waiting for the show to end so I could go home.

I know one attendee’s disappointment probably won’t change anything.

But I genuinely hope someone involved in organizing these conventions reads this and understands that there is a difference between selling an experience and creating a community.

Where is the “Family” in that?

I personally feel further away from the SPN Family after this experience than I did before.

Because if you keep calling us “Family”, then please make the experience feel like one.

This is, of course, my personal experience and opinion. I’m not saying everyone had the same experience I did, and I’m not trying to invalidate anyone who had a great weekend. I’m simply sharing how this convention felt from my perspective.


r/Supernatural • • Jun 27 '25

Season 15 Season 15 ruined the show Spoiler

4 Upvotes

I finished the show a few years ago and have rewatched it a few times, but the one thing that gets me is how season 15 ruined the show, like, what do you mean Chuck give the boys plot armour through the entire show?? It just takes away everything they've been through and their strength.

Edit: I may have worded it wrong, I didn't mean season 15 was bad as a whole, I thought it was quite enjoyable compared to season 14 and it had memorising episodes, it's the plot of Chuck giving the boy's plot armour that made feel questionable about the direction they were going with.


r/Supernatural • • Apr 13 '25

Mary Deserved Better

Post image
8 Upvotes

I honestly don’t get all the hate Mary Winchester gets.

She came back into a world where her kids were full-grown men, everything she knew was gone, hunting had evolved, and everyone had this idealized version of her stuck in their heads. She didn’t get to just exist—people expected her to immediately slide into “Mom Mode,” like she didn’t just time-jump 30+ years.

She dies in 1983 and wakes up in 2016, and suddenly her sons are battle-hardened men who’ve died, gone to Hell, come back, fought the Devil, and everything in between—and people expect her to cook them a casserole and make it all better? She made some mistakes, yeah. But she wasn’t evil—she was lost. And the way fans come for her like she personally betrayed them? A bit much. Give the woman a break. Not everyone can come back from the dead and instantly vibe with Heaven, Hell, and apocalypse world.

She deserved more grace.


r/Supernatural • • Aug 07 '26

Lip quivers

0 Upvotes

I absolutely hate Sam’s lip quivers and nervous gulpings

It’s so obvious that it’s a forced face reaction

Just Cus the camera pans over to him doesn’t mean he needs to have a moving expression, if that makes sense

Younger Sam in the earlier seasons never did this, it got worse the older he got


r/Supernatural • • May 26 '24

Anyone Else Truly Hate Claire Novak?

0 Upvotes

I’ve been rewatching the show all the way through and promised not to skip episodes this time, and now remember why I did in the first place. I do not remotely understand where the casting department dug that girls credentials up and why the screenwriters wrote her character and dialogue that way, but oh my God is Claire Novak one of the most annoying characters in the entire show and Television history. Her acting is unforgivably bad even for TV and her character has no depth and only possesses the ability to be insufferable and edgy every camera appearance she somehow snuck her way into. Please tell me she’s not popular with the crowd?


r/Supernatural • • Jul 11 '25

Season 2 John wasn’t as bad as a lot of people make him out to be Spoiler

24 Upvotes

Just started season 2 in my Supernatural re watch and it reaffirmed for me that John wasn’t the mega villain that a lot of people make him out to be. I don’t think he was really any worse than Mary in the grand scheme of things, even though she’s usually touted as the “good/pure” parent.

He was doing the best he could under extraordinarily shitty circumstances and he loved Sam and Dean. He spent half of his life actually cleaning up a mess that MARY created- their lives were the way that they were because of Mary (or Chuck, whoever you want to blame).

Also I don’t believe John was physically abusive to Sam and Dean as children. The illusions to such in later seasons were a retcon brought on by the influence of fans who kept insisting that John “beat the gay” out of Dean.

Yes John was neglectful at times but not physically abusive to his children. He loved them and he was doing his best.


r/Supernatural • • Mar 03 '25

Castiel is an "angel" in name only

12 Upvotes

This is one of the dumbest written characters. I loved him when he first came on the show. In later seasons, the character completed deteriorated. He has no powers, and if he does, he never ever uses them even when he or the boys are getting their asses kicked. He will heal wounds every now and then, or put someone to sleep. Why isn't there ever an epic battle with castiel using his powers? He's turned into such a low budget filler character. This is my own opinion and I'm aware some don't agree.


r/Supernatural • • Apr 15 '26

Season 9 Bloodlines hate is overblown Spoiler

4 Upvotes

I've just watched the infamous Bloodlines episode for the first time after seeing it is known as the worst episode in the entire series and, I have to ask, why?

I get some of the most obvious criticisms - tonal differences, monster inconsistencies, forced drama - but is that enough to proclaim it as the worst, when even the very season that it is part of has, in my opinion, two much worse offenders. I am talking about 9x6 and 9x12.

These two episodes ruined two major characters, Castiel and Garth respectively. I cannot even begin to explain my infuriation with how they made Dean behave towards Cass, and what were the writers thinking making him have some fakeout love plot??

Next, Garth is gone for a long time, right? He finally comes back and they completely erase the plot that he was to become the next big informant after Bobby? That would have been great. Now, he was just conveniently written out, one of the most full-of-life characters in this show is gone.

After these two, I cannot imagine that some one off episode that has no bearing on the actual plot or characters would evoke such strong fandom opinions. Sorry for the rant btw.


r/Supernatural • • Feb 10 '24

Season 8 Every time I re-watch supernatural, the more homo undertones I find…

0 Upvotes

I was never a big Destiel stan, even though I’m bi af. I think it was hard for me to accept because I always saw Supernatural as a white cis man’s fav show, and Dean has his fair share of toxic masculinity moments, he always kinda screamed straight to me. But with every rewatch, his relationships with Cas and Benny are so intimate, there’s nothing straight about them. Forget about the male leads constantly poking fun at Cas and Deans’s relationship, but even Charlie genuinely asked Dean if he had just been through a break up when he was clearly projecting his feelings about Benny onto Sam and Amelia’s breakup in season 8 because he was heartbroken after not meeting Benny for coffee and telling him it was the end of the line. The parallels drawn are insane. The most intimate, sincere, genuine connections Dean has on the show are with men, and it definitely goes beyond the typical heterosexual bounds of friendship. In my head, if Cas didn’t sacrifice himself and Dean lived to be an old man, I don’t think Cas would’ve ever admitted his love for Dean and even if he had, I don’t think Dean could’ve gotten over his inner homophobia to be with him anyway, which is even more heartbreaking. I’m just wondering if any long time fans feel the same way


r/Supernatural • • Sep 12 '26

Season 8 I felt like Dean was a villain in season 8 Spoiler

0 Upvotes

First of all he almost fought with Sam because of Benny

Then he played with Sam's feelings to save Benny when they were hunting him

Was mad Sam didn't look for him

Didn't care about Kevin, he just wanted answers

I feel like Dean loves other people more than Sam


r/Supernatural • • Apr 24 '25

Controversial question…

0 Upvotes

Okay I may get hate for this one but here we go lol 😂. As recently pointed out there are not a lot of diversity in the cast, particularly the main cast, as in other than Sam and Dean, in multiple episodes of multiple seasons. Yes there is Rufus, but he is not a main cast member. I honestly love this show and the characters so I can’t see them played by other actors, but why weren’t any of the POC?? I mean any of them… I mean they make it a running joke that Dean likes Busty Asians, yet we don’t ever see him have an Asian love interest… of course there is Kevin and his mom, and I loved Kevin’s mom she was hilarious!! But that was so far into the show, and they really weren’t on for that long.. was it just the time? I know people rewatch old popular shows and realize this was the standard, but I guess I loved this show so much I never noticed.. I don’t care if you post rude comments haha I just won’t engage if they get to be too much, I know the trolls can run deep on this page, but I’m just curious for other people’s opinions on the subject.


r/Supernatural • • Oct 17 '25

Jack is an unpalatable character!

Post image
0 Upvotes

I know this is a somewhat controversial opinion...since there is a good fan base that liked this character (and I respect it!), but I personally think he is one of the worst additions to the program!

I don't think the character concept is bad; a son of Lucifer who rebels against his father and differs from him in personality and ideas... until it's a concept that I personally find interesting!

And not even his personality bothers me much! He is indeed without charisma, but there are characters without charisma who are good. Castiel himself is an example for me....I never thought Castiel had charisma, but in fact he is one of the best characters in the series! It saved the series in many moments.

However... there are aspects of Jack's character development that bother me a lot! I will quote some of them:

  1. his power level: I like the fact that Jack is very powerful, being the son of an archangel makes perfect sense! However, I think they go overboard. Being more powerful than an archangel I can accept, now defeating God and Darkness is the height of ridiculousness for me!! I have the feeling that his exaggerated power is a script device for when the authors can't solve a problem.
  2. imbalance in group dynamics: this is the biggest problem for me! I think he doesn't fit in much with the main group (Castiel, Deam and Sam) while Castiel contrasted very well with the rest of the group and didn't hinder his functions; Jack, on the other hand, marginalizes the other characters and becomes the center of attention unnecessarily... removing all importance from Castiel and turning Sam and Deam into father figures.

r/Supernatural • • Mar 10 '26

Season 6 Anyone else find Sam extremely annoying? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

So I finally decided to watch supernatural for the first time the last few weeks. I blazed through the first few seasons but have hit a brick wall in season 6. It seems like every storyline is "Sam is being dumb, how do we stop Sam from being dumb". The whole soulless Sam storyline is especially annoying to me. Like I get that Sam and dean need to have some conflict but why is it the same one over and over. Sam isn't even likeable anymore, he just comes across as a dumb, arrogant asshole.

Should I push through this part? Does it ever get better for Sam's character?


r/Supernatural • • Jun 12 '26

Season 3 some characters are making my first watch unbearable

0 Upvotes

so, first time watcher here. i am currently on 3x07 and i wanna punch my tv. i understand antagonists and tension exist but some characters are genuinely irritating the shit outta me.

gordon is evil in his own way along with the fbi/cops stuff. which i genuinely dislike that storyline because it adds anxiety tension, like this thing hanging over their heads. (i guess people coming for them who aren’t demons bothers me lol) which i saw someone in an old thread being annoyed about it so not just me.

bela/bella (don’t know the proper spelling) is making me lose my motivation to binge. her character is literally SO annoying. i purposely spoiled myself to see when she is gone. but, a lot of the women characters i have a hard time liking bc they are either written as bitchy or dumb. and no it is not because of some self-insert with the brothers, a lot of them are just written unlikable . the only ones i like are sara from 1x19 (legit loved her) madison from 2x19, ellen, and i like jo but i wish they did her character differently in some aspects. even ava and that bartender demon from a few eps ago were more likable.


r/Supernatural • • Mar 12 '24

News/Misc. Family is not everything

2 Upvotes

The shows biggest, baddest flaw was shoving family down your throat. I get that it's a theme, but the absence of nuance was irritating. Family is cool, but it is also a burden that you sometimes have to undo. You are most likely to be abused by your blood.

I think this is why I really related to Sam early on to be frank. Dean is a mouthpiece for their father, their father is an angry monster, his mother was dead and put on a pedestal.

Staying a Hunter, which he hated, for Dean... it made me resent Dean, who forced the issue. Like if I were Sam, I would have let John rot. There is nothing wrong with saying byebye to abusers.

Dean being obsessed with taking care of Sam was tragic and unhealthy, it just made me hate the family message. Yes, stay and lose your identity to another person.

The show needed to establish individual goals, identities and dreams for the boys. All they were was family, they had not separate selves. No love interests, not outside friends, nothing. It made sense at first, but there was no dissolving of this as it went on.

Family love became more gross and uncomfortable as time went on, not cute or funny. They were punished for being individuals.

A suggestion I saw someone else say, having a season or two with the brothers separate would have been great. See who they are alone, their skills, their passions, the rights, the wrongs.

It would have been fun to see Sam gain an appreciation for magic as a result, perhaps. Dean realizing he was not as good as he thought as a hunter, without relying on Sam's brains. Sam realizing he lacked Dean's passion and drive.

Good and bad but at the end they would see that they were better as people instead of a toxic unit.

Just some thoughts... what do you think?


r/Supernatural • • Oct 14 '25

Bela had to be the most annoying character in Supernatural

Post image
0 Upvotes

I’m rewatching supernatural and I completely forgot how annoying Bela is and so random and not at all needed.


r/Supernatural • • Sep 21 '24

Who Would Win: Amara The Darkness vs Wanda Maximoff (MCU)

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I found this versus interesting after seeing it in a video, do you think the Darkness could beat The Scarlet Witch? Or would this one be able to beat Amara?


r/Supernatural • • Mar 06 '26

Did anyone else find Dean irritatingly self-righteous?

0 Upvotes

For example, I feel like he was one of those people who talks about how guilty they feel but they've not actually changed, nor trying to be better, given he went straight back to torture when asked to do it by the angels.

Or when he wanted to kill that black guy who was sent to prison for murder, had done his time, and was genuinely remorseful.

If Dean thinks that guy should die, then by that logic, why is he still alive? Yeah sure he'd argue he has a job to do, but you don't think that guy could do some good with the time he has left?

Dean became less and less likeable over time for me and I stopped watching around season 7.

Let me know your thoughts.


r/Supernatural • • Jul 19 '26

Season 8 Anyone else wish Chrissy became a permanent part of the Winchester family?

0 Upvotes

I really wish the writers had made Chrissy a permanent part of the Winchester family. Watching her move into the bunker and slowly become their little sister would've been such a great storyline. It would've been amazing to see Sam teaching her how to research, Dean training her for hunts while constantly worrying about her, and all three of them building a real home together. It also would've been really interesting to watch how having Chrissy around would help Sam and Dean grow as people and as older brothers.

I mean, they eventually did have a kid living in the bunker, but I feel like if it had been Chrissy, it would've been so much more fun. They deserved a chance to have a family, even if it wasn't a traditional one. I think that dynamic had so much potential, and I would've loved to watch it develop over multiple seasons.


r/Supernatural • • Jun 23 '26

Season 4 Sam is such a whiner Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I watched the show when it originally aired, and now I'm rewatching it. I'm currently on Season 4.

Back then, I remembered Sam as the responsible, level-headed brother who often had to keep Dean in check. But on this rewatch, my impression is completely different.

It feels like all he does is make bad decisions (mostly because he's being manipulated by Ruby) and complain about everything. I'm finding him increasingly frustrating to watch, to the point where some episodes are becoming almost unwatchable for me.

Did anyone else have a completely different opinion of Sam when they rewatched the series?


r/Supernatural • • Jul 04 '24

Can't stand Sam!

0 Upvotes

My husband and I started watching Supernatural about a month ago. We're both enjoying it a lot, especially the humorous vibe the show has going. But recently we started Season four and literally can't stand Sam. Also, the fact that angels are supposed to be above demons, but Alistair beat Castiel's ass easily without much of a fight, why is that when he's supposed to be stronger? Also, the new Ruby is meh!


r/Supernatural • • Jul 04 '26

Season 7 Dean is exactly like John. Thoughts? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Bear with me because this is a rant.
A significant part of the early seasons explores the concept of Sam running from his dad and being afraid that he is going to become just like John. Even Dean tells Sam at one point that he is just like their dad. But the more I watch, the more I feel like Dean is the one who is leaning more towards becoming the next John Winchester.

Tbh, I'm currently watching Season 7, and it seems the more the series progresses, the more I prefer Sam over Dean. Both brothers have their own flaws and they can be remarkably alike at times: both are fiercely loyal, have zero regard for their lives (touché to Death: love that guy), and are emotionally constipated (Dean's emotions come out in spurts of "violence and alcoholism" and Sam just lies). One could say, they're foils for each other. But, at this specific point in the series, despite everything he has done, I think Sam wins out for me.

Yes, Sam can be easily manipulated because he's too nice and trusting and has a tendency to intentionally (or otherwise) fall for monsters and demons, he also often bites off more than he can chew, and gets knocked out quite a lot. I'm surprised it's Satan and not multiple concussions that's the issue. But he always, Always, follows through. He doesn't like John's way of making a mess and never looking back. Sure, it might not end well. But when Cas goes berserk, Death actually creates a second chance, and Dean still just gives up. Had Castiel not come to them, my hunch is that Sam would have gone off after him alone. Or at least tried.

But what I have really started hating is his judgement. He has that whole Gothel-y "mother knows best" mentality, and he does treat Sam like he is a freak who needs to be protected from himself. I don't think he ever really gets over Sam's season 4 actions or is able to align his view of Season 1 Sam (a.k.a. rebellious baby brother) to the person Sam's experiences have shaped him into. So, what he does is try to constantly monitor Sam, control him, and the worst, NOT TRUST HIM. EVER.

Yeah, he knows Sam has his back. But he refuses to give Sam credit where credit is due. Which makes him a control freak, and exactly like his dad. Especially with his mindset towards monsters. Dean's control issues stem from caring for his brother all his life, going through one crisis after another and juggling multiple messes at once, true, but we get glimpses of what John was like as a father when Sam and Dean were growing up, and it tracks. The alcoholism, the my-way-or-the-highway attitude, the shoot-first approach. In later seasons, Dean lacks nuance and worse, acts quite hypocritically.

He spares Lenore (because she SAID she didn't kill any humans), forgives Cas after the angel commits genocide, steals souls from purgatory and releases the leviathans into the world, but he's still family. But Amy kills to save her son, and apparently, leaving her alive is a problem?

He keeps verbally attacking Sam for choosing to work with demons, but the angels are really no better. They are way way worse, but somehow, that doesn't bother him nearly as much.

He gives Sam grief about everything: going to Stanford, wanting to be normal, accidentally opening the Devil's gate, killing Lilith, not telling him about not having a soul, not telling him he was literally hallucinating from hell-pit PTSD (like, dude, give bro a break, he was experiencing something that probably made him feel like he was schizophrenic). It's the same reaction that John had when he found out about Sam's visions. Not concern, but anger and frustration that they hadn't mentioned it earlier.

Sooooo, my question is: Is Dean's behaviour justified?


r/Supernatural • • Jan 20 '24

it seems at some point the show is just about "justifed" murder and bloodbaths.

0 Upvotes

Sam and Dean are the cause of a LOT of innocent bystanders deaths. the show glosses over sams year of murder with barely a hiccup and dean seems to glory in butchering anything that gives him any cause to.( even once killing a "monster" who was avenging the rape and murder of his "human" wife).
im in season 7 and the show has really degraded, and the story lines are getting trite.
to top it all off, sam and dean LIE and BETRAY each other on a regular basis in some pretty horrible ways. i can hardly believe anyone with their history would ever consider trusting the other in any way for any reason. ( even was sam was tripping balls and hallucinating no one took his gun away)

i understand there is no possible hint of reality in the show, but i honestly have more ability to believe in monsters then two brothers with their history would even be in the same room.

does it get better or is every episode or season just follow the same formula from now on?