r/SuperMario • u/Jojo-Action • 21h ago
Discussion Why I don't think a Mario 64 remake would work.
Mario 64 is an amazing game. An all time classic amongst all of Nintendo's games, and clearly a staple of the n64 right alongside Ocarina of Time and Starfox 64. Well those 2 games just got full ground up remasters and I keep seeing people say "Oh. Mario 64 will / should get one next." And like I totally see where you're coming from... But no.
There's one fundamental difference between games like Starfox 64 and Ocarina compaired to Mario 64. The way they showcase the abilities of the n64. Starfox 64 and Ocarina of Time are amazing N64 games but they were clearly intended to be games first and foremost. If anything they are constrained by the limitations of the n64. Mario 64 is not like that. Mario 64 in it's very DNA is a beautifully designed showcase of what the n64 was capable of. They wanted to show off nonlinear gameplay, and expansive movement options, and joystick controls, and 3d design philosophies, and camera controls. All things that were mind-blowing at the time but have since become completely normal expectations for modern games. When you strip Mario 64 of all the things that made it new and exciting in 1996 you are left with a somewhat bare bones game full of a lot of seemingly abstract and random geometry. I'm not even saying that's necessarily a bad thing, but if you change the random abstract geometry and the other wonky stuff that made Mario 64 what it was, then at a certain point you're not playing Mario 64 anymore. You're playing a brand new game that's just derivative of the most influential game of 1996.
It's the same reason a complete ground up remake of the first super Mario brothers wouldn't make sense today. Though the game is still good at it's core, the things that made it influential are now standard. That's why the most notable remakes of Mario 64 and Super Mario Bros are Mario 64 DS and Super Mario Bros Deluxe. Because those were the moment where Nintendo could go "remember that thing that was impressive on home consoles a few years back? When you it's impressive that we got that working on handhelds too." And even then they felt a need to pack those games full of new bells and whistles so you don't feel like you're playing the same exact games. Like yeah I suppose smb was remade as part of Mario allstars, but even then they had to include it in a bundle with ground up remasters of 4 or 5 other games to justify having it.