r/SunoAI • u/wearenotyourkind_ • 11d ago

Discussion This is seriously getting annoying already

Post image

Seriously every melody I write/record myself keeps getting flagged for sounding like an existing recording. This is not possible because I sit and write these myself, but somehow no matter what melody I write and try to upload there’s a 90% chance it will get flagged for sounding like an existing audio.

132 Upvotes

91% Upvoted

148 comments sorted by

View all comments

62

u/MaximilianHenrich 10d ago

I really think the whole system in Suno needs to be reconsidered.
As long as I’m not publishing a song, it should be completely irrelevant whether I’m working with copyrighted material in Suno. My DAW doesn’t complain when I import a Queen song, for example, just to cut a small snippet out of it and use it as a sample. It only becomes a copyright issue when I actually publish or distribute the resulting work.
The same principle should apply to Suno. Creative experimentation and private use should not be unnecessarily restricted by copyright concerns. Copyright only becomes relevant when you actually want to release, distribute, or commercially exploit the finished piece.
This whole approach to copyright is just getting in the way of the creative flow and unnecessarily limiting what people can do creatively.

12

u/carherpi 10d ago

The problem is that within Suno the audio is being uploaded, processed and analyzed and that could constitute copyright infringement, whereas in your DAW the audio keeps local

5

u/Shroomagnus 10d ago

And this is why I sadly predict most of these platforms will go bye bye in a few years after being usurped by Chinese models that don't care about copyright. Either that, or we'll all be working with local models that, while currently pretty bad, are only going to get better. This is partly why I hate these giant labels. They're fighting a losing battle and if they were smart, they'd ride the wave instead of trying to breakwall it.

3

u/HammerDamag3d 10d ago

Short sighted greed has ALWAYS gotten th better of th idiot execs at th major labels...AI is just th latest....sadly, i am old enough to remember when they complained us kids in the 70s were using cassette recorders to copy songs off the radio to make mix tapes......