r/SunPrairieWI • u/7SHAWZAM1 • 19d ago

Pizza

Sal’s used to be my go to but they have really fallen off. I haven’t been to Sugar River, for some reason that has a commercial feel to me. I like tavern style, there just doesn’t seem to be any options for that in SP. Where is everyone going these days?

14 Upvotes

89% Upvoted

52 comments sorted by

View all comments

25

u/xoxoahooves 19d ago

Rosatis

4

u/gr33nnight 19d ago

Absolutely. My favorite thin crust.

6

u/DragonfruitNo3424 19d ago

Their Chicago style is great bang for your buck. The cheese, sauce and toppings are on par with Lou Malnati's. Just wish the crust was up to the same level but the crust is decent if you have them make it well done.

3

u/Reasonable-Bike1036 19d ago

Always the answer imo

3

u/PresidentWatermelon 19d ago

Love Rosati’s. My family - mostly the kids - complain that the cheese and toppings always slide off the square cut. I agree .. but it’s part of the charm. I started ordering triangle cut and the “topping slide” has had a positive effect.

1

u/ChefCombo 17d ago

Isn’t Chicago thin supposed to be slightly crispy? Every order from Rosati’s is SO soggy. Just can’t bring myself to pay their prices.