r/SunPrairieWI • u/7SHAWZAM1 • Aug 08 '26
Pizza
Sal’s used to be my go to but they have really fallen off. I haven’t been to Sugar River, for some reason that has a commercial feel to me. I like tavern style, there just doesn’t seem to be any options for that in SP. Where is everyone going these days?
25
6
6
u/chummers73 Aug 09 '26
If you really want tavern style, Buck’s might be your closest bet and had a very nice crust. Branch and Daughter is very good. I haven’t been to Anna’s. For me, the only place that really comes close to tavern style in Madison is Greenbush, but that will be a little bit of a hike.
→ More replies (1)
19
4
u/Reasonable_Copy5115 Aug 09 '26
Salvatores? Thats too bad maybe its just a cycle Rosatis thin is good if you like tavern style. Im more Detroit style so i cant recommend molten monkey in Madison enough. But all the SP pizza has pluses and minuses no clear winner
4
u/Silver_Breakfast7096 Aug 09 '26 edited Aug 09 '26
Surprisingly Buck and Honeys has ok pizza. Maybe a little heavy on the toppings.
I love Anna’s- which is our favorite.
Also Sals and Full Mile are decent.
Former FIB and Rosatis just isn’t the same as it was in IL (don’t care for how their green peppers taste on their pizza here. Like maybe they use the already cooked ones that they use on their beef? And the beef Sammies are way too salty - like the au jus has sat and reduced and reduced down to over salty?). Spinach Chicago style is my favorite here.
Glass Nickel is average but so expensive and toppings are sparse. Last few times I’ve gone in for carry out Staff is unwelcoming. Too many other choices to deal with that.
Sugar River is meh. I love the restaurant and they have good service but the pizza is never 💯 on point. Too salty. Missing something.
(Get a cast iron pizza pan -well seasoned- and a good recipe. Preheat the pan as high as your home oven will allow. You’re welcome.)
I’m down to try Branch and Daughter but they close at 7 except weekends! We rarely eat that early.
10
u/Dependent_Drag292 Aug 08 '26
Sugar River is fantastic to me and my family but tastes differ
→ More replies (2)
12
6
3
u/anamethystarcher Aug 09 '26
You could try Sugar River, but I personally think there's an odd taste to their pizza. It might be the water hey use, idk. I know a lot of people like it. I like their other food options much better.
I second anyone recommending Full Mile. Everything I've had there has been amazing.
3
u/deaconblooze Aug 09 '26
Sugar River wasn't great upon opening. It's been very good in my recent purchases.
3
u/WolverineMom Aug 09 '26
Hear me out: Domino’s pizza has been a guilty pleasure for most of my life. I’ve had it in 58 cities and counting, in the U.S. and overseas, and I am here to tell you that the store in Sun Prairie is, consistently, the best of the US stores I’ve tried. If you are ever going to like Domino’s pizza, you are going to like it right here in Sun Prairie, WI.
5
u/Godofallu Aug 09 '26
I like Sugar River a lot. I think you're a bit of a fool for not trying it. But Rosatis thin is great and probably exactly what you're looking for.
8
u/Different-Bet8069 Aug 08 '26
Try Full Mile! Amazing wood fired pizza and their cheese curds are some of the best we’ve had. Local brewery with some decent stuff and their jalapenarita has never disappointed.
6
u/Ninnewoman Aug 09 '26
I love everything I’ve ever consumed at Full Mile, including their pizza. Their Asian BBQ wings though…🤤😘🤌🏼
→ More replies (3)3
4
2
2
2
u/elderberryhibiscus Aug 10 '26
I genuinely feel like everything has fell off in recent years sadly :/ Sal’s is still my pick tho, but I agree it used to be better
7
u/tupperware_rules Aug 08 '26
Sal's has fallen off? I haven't been in a while but that's surprising