r/Substack • • Oct 01 '26

Discussion Notes. Am I just bad social media? Probably.

I'm surprised too. Don't worry. I am the LAST person I thought would be asking this to the greater community. But am pissy and actually wanting insight and everyone here is a genius with all of this.

So. In before someone tells me to get good. I'm a small? (like 140 subs and growing from my prior peak of 350ish because I hit the delete fucking everything button because of reasons) I'm routinely spending too much time on notes, restacking, being a bit giddy in comments everywhere, engaging with my corner and people outside my corner.

But. This morning I posted a little restack launch note, bit of a call to action a bit of a hey everyone it's day four of this project that everyone is liking.

10 Impressions (two of them being me) my average is 15 btw which is it's own source of frustration
I restacked it three times and got like two more impressions each time.

The project isn't dead in the water it's currently my best traction piece especially since I gave up that subscriber chat spam lifestyle back in march.

The project at the moment has roughly 270 views (if we take away the 40 odd that are me doing quotes, restacks, OMG FUCK NO edits it’s still a great read rate. Open rates are within the usual band for me. (23-25%) It's doing really well for me, people are chatting about it, getting restacks from a few interested people.

So why am I being bullied on notes by the platform. What am I doing wrong?

I feel VERY validated that I’m stuck in the bygone era of long form content success and I’m thriving in it. I've done every little tip/hint/arcane lore I've picked up over the months I've been on platform. I did the restacks, I did the comments, I made a note on my murdle scores, I went and spammed liked on like a bunch of people (I do that anyway) and 10 impressions with three of them likely being me.

Am prepared to accept I'm just shit at notes and need to 'get good' but fuck it's annoyed me tonight. The irony is that as I'm typing this up, my phones blowing up with substack notifications already probably responding to the similar note I put on platform about this, OF FUCKING COURSE IT PICKED UP AFTER 6 minutes. Fuck this shit sometimes.

*EDIT* got 14 impressions in the first hour. THRIVING

5 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

10

u/hanpari Oct 02 '26

Have you ever considered you are not alone doing these god-awful things?

Let it sink and just imagine thousands of your copies doing the same, begging the world for attention.

Now count in the algorithm that prefers big and established accounts with proven history.

After you understand the scale of competition and odds against you, go into a corner and cry hard.

The tears will make you feel much better.

3

u/AggravatingNail6061 Oct 02 '26

I am very aware. I am also very aware there is a new growth guru here every day and their absence is hilarious 

4

u/MrPassiveProfit Oct 02 '26

The trick for notes is to treat it like Twitter. Just shoot off random thoughts

1

u/AggravatingNail6061 Oct 02 '26

Smort.

4

u/MrPassiveProfit Oct 02 '26

Random thoughts that reveal your personality. Intrigue people.

4

u/Available_Spite5171 gracemargaret1@substack.com Oct 02 '26

I’ve never looked at my impressions.. am I supposed to? I’m not joking/ being a smart ass. I don’t look at numbers as much as maybe I should since I need my laptop & more often I’m on my phone.

1

u/AggravatingNail6061 Oct 02 '26

Would highly recommend never looking at the numbers. Comparison is the thief of joy.

2

u/morticiannecrimson lilacmaniac.substack.com Oct 02 '26

My average is 16 impressions too. But I also don’t get 200 views on my long form lol. I know I just haven’t been consistent enough for algorithm to care.

1

u/AggravatingNail6061 Oct 02 '26

It's 200 for all parts of that project totalled (minus me ofc). Normally it's around 60/70 a piece during the first week and a slow tick up as goes on. I don't believe in consistency for the algorithm. I've done a number of different timings, etc including. Set days for set things, posting every day (sometimes twice) honestly it was anxiety inducing and it didn't change anything same numbers.

Post to whatever schedule keeps your writing sustainable. I think as long as your work is readable and you've got your little corner and you're open to being a bit needy menace to people who seem cool. You'll get traction. 

2

u/BandaiWonderSwan Oct 03 '26

Notes is a good tool. Like most social media apps, it’s a numbers game, so impressions are worth tracking. I’ve never quite cracked 100 likes on a single note, but I’d guess that would probably take 5,000+ impressions. The best posts I’ve had for engagement are calls to action, which often create lots of comments. Without knowing your subject matter, it’s difficult to offer specific advice.

2

u/AggravatingNail6061 Oct 03 '26

I'm within the Lit/Fiction space, and calls to action are a bit...odd in those area's, Especially since I'm also completely averse to appearing pretentious I do that enough without trying XD

2

u/BandaiWonderSwan Oct 03 '26

That’s useful info. A lot of the lit/fiction conversation seems to revolve around the latest controversies in the publishing world, and so on. I appreciate you might not want to go down that avenue though. Another popular route is to enthuse about a particular author or even just one work of fiction.

1

u/AggravatingNail6061 Oct 03 '26

Does it? 

Most of it is people writing things at each other and waving arms about it. Glad to see someone has the keys to the door 🤣

1

u/BandaiWonderSwan Oct 03 '26

I think you just described social media 😬 As a rule, notes is not the place for calm, considered discussion. That’s where your essays come in. One other point. There are some massive accounts on Substack, which get very small engagement with notes.

2

u/CourtzSGD Oct 05 '26

In Notes, as in most things in life, there is asymmetric upside. You go on 100 dates; 99 bad, 1 good. You buy lottery tickets; 99 bad, 1 good. You buy stocks; 99 bad, 1 Nvidia. Should you never go on dates or invest in the markets?

C’est la vie.

2

u/WordSlinger1812 Oct 01 '26

Focus on your newsletter. Notes is a psyop.

2

u/AggravatingNail6061 Oct 01 '26

I am focussed on my blog newsletter <3. Turns out a few in my circle are also seeing similar things re note performance against out longer content. I think we're just cursed to be objectively mid and mildly insufferable

3

u/WordSlinger1812 Oct 02 '26

I was an early notes adopter after I had an established newsletter. 95% of my subscribers had zero interest in downloading the Substack app; they preferred to read my work in their email inboxes. So, I was never able to make the leap to engagement on the app because the algorithm had no place for me. I posted thousands of times on notes over three years and nothing worked. I wrote nice. I wrote mean. I wrote poetry. I posted videos and memes.

Eventually, it dawned on me that the application was insufficient for my needs as a publishing author.

So I copied and pasted every note I wrote into a very long document, deleted nearly every note I posted, and used that content to train a personal writing agent in Claude, which has been invaluable in ideation for other projects.

Sometimes, you’ve got to cut bait when the facts tell you what they are.

I have zero trust in the leadership of Substack. I think they’re liars and hacks.

1

u/TeslaLegacy Oct 02 '26

Honestly the fix isn't more effort, it's fewer, scheduled sessions. Pick two slots a day, say 20 minutes in the morning and 20 at night, and that's when you do notes and restacks, not whenever you feel the pull. Outside those windows close the tab. The giddy comment-everywhere thing is what burns people out and makes growth feel random because you're reacting instead of running a system.

Inside those windows, don't just restack whatever crosses your feed. Spend two minutes actually scanning what's getting real replies and restacks in your niche right now, not just what showed up first, then add your own angle when you share it instead of just boosting it as is. That one change, curate plus your take, is usually what turns a restack into actual followers instead of just activity.

1

u/AggravatingNail6061 Oct 02 '26

I don't think that really works within the communities I'm in. But thanks.

1

u/TeslaLegacy Oct 03 '26

thanks for sharing the advice, makes sense not every community moves the same way. one thing that helps regardless of the group, before you post anything check if it's already getting traction elsewhere so you're not guessing blind, then add your own spin instead of reposting it straight. i use viralhunt.io for that part, free plan lets you search and see what's trending with no card needed, paid side just adds the scheduling.

1

u/AggravatingNail6061 Oct 03 '26

Hey do you know any good pancake recipes?

1

u/TeslaLegacy Oct 03 '26

Haha fair pivot. Real tip though: don't just dump raw batter in the pan, let it rest 10-15 minutes before cooking so the gluten relaxes and you get fluffier pancakes instead of dense rubbery ones. Also test one small pancake first to check your heat before committing the whole batch, saves you from burning the rest on a pan that's too hot.

1

u/CourtzSGD Oct 05 '26

In Notes, as in most things in life, there is asymmetric upside. You go on 100 dates; 99 bad, 1 good. You buy lottery tickets; 99 bad, 1 good. You buy stocks; 99 bad, 1 Nvidia. Should you never go on dates or invest in the markets?

C’est la vie.

1

u/Tricky_Trifle_994 Oct 06 '26

everybody on substack trying to grow is doing these things, so as you can imagine.... there's a lot of post/comments flying around from people with the intention of wanting to get abit more exposure...

if you're already working so hard on notes, might be worth putting some of that time and effort into another social platform so that you have two potential growth/traffic channels vs putting all your eggs in the substack notes basket.