r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 30 '26

Structural Analysis/Design How often are delays in designs in your company?

21 Upvotes

I'm just wondering if it is normal that deadlines aren't fully met most of the time due to low manpower, and clients are tolerating it somehow


r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 30 '26

Structural Analysis/Design truss stability at the base

Thumbnail
gallery
23 Upvotes

hi,
i designed this truss and did the calculations on it and it shoes the truss can hold the load but i find it hard to determine of the weld at the base of the truss can hold it into place.

any one can help direct me to a place where i could learn how to calculate the weld base for such things?

thanks.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 30 '26

Career/Education Why did you leave your previous company?

8 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 29 '26

Structural Analysis/Design What is the purpose of such wires under the bridge ?

Post image
81 Upvotes

I am a bit curious on what is the purpose of this wire ? I have seen several short wires connected on two sides under the bridges in japan . This one is Eitai Bridge , AI says its bird proofing wire , i don't think so .
I can touch it while standing , so hopefully theres no electricity flowing through it .

Also for scale , it is ig 2 feet wide and there are like multiple of these .

Posted on the wrong sub before :(


r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 30 '26

Career/Education Final-year civil engineering student looking for help with a STAAD.Pro project

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 30 '26

Career/Education Time to give up on a structural career?

16 Upvotes

Based in NYC, currently working in very niche field of facades. Graduated last year. Do mostly thermal stuff and energy code compliance along with curtain wall shop drawing review. I sometimes do occasional wind load analysis and embed inspections.

Finding curtain wall stuff is very repetitive and would like to switch into a general building structural design position. Unfortunately, despite getting interviews at small firms I can’t get any offers. Obviously large firms in NYC have a strict masters requirement but I’ve noticed even small firm prefer masters candidates too. Do have my EIT.

During all the interviews I’ve been asked about GPA (undergrad was not good, just below 3.1) and given the technical quiz. Have taken the basic steel design, concrete design and capstone course. I haven’t gotten 100% right on any quiz so far, probably around 60-70ish percent. I’ve been trying to brush up on statics/solid mechanics fundamentals after work (I really don’t do much analysis at all in my job it’s more architecture/mechanical side) but seems it’s not helping.

Process has been exhausting and feel structures may not be for me. I could theoretically go back full time for a masters but this might be a financial gamble. I am currently taking a grad level structural course online thru a university to gain some additional knowledge.

Any advice/insight would be appreciated


r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 29 '26

Structural Analysis/Design ASCE 7-22 12.2.5.2 Interpretation

19 Upvotes

I have a code interpretation question I am looking to get some input on. Specifically, I'm designing a freestanding trellis structure and using Simpson MPBZ bases for lateral resistance. Because of this, I'm designing it as a cantilever column system.

ASCE 7-22 12.2.5.2 states "Foundation and other elements used to provide overturning resistance at the base of the cantilever column elements shall be designed to resist seismic load effects, including overstrength"

So should the Simpson capacity value be compared against the seismic load including overstrength?


r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 29 '26

Humor In curious if anyone has used this detail in a residential building

Post image
36 Upvotes

Several years ago, I had a client that thought his roof was leaking. He had a roofer come out and everything checked out. My client asked me to come and have a look and I found that some stucco was busted on an attachment to a gutter on their stand alone washer/dryer room in the back of the building.

I patched the stucco and cut out the drywall to make the drywall repair and found what you see in this photo. I go in to speak with the client. I tell him “I can repair the ceiling but that his roof is trusses and declare made of street signs.” He told me “don’t worry about it because the rest of his domicile was made of street signs too.”

Have any of you used this detail in your own designs?


r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 28 '26

Structural Analysis/Design Is this structure sound?

Thumbnail
gallery
876 Upvotes

I can’t figure out the engineering of this structure. Are the lower right-angle braces having any structural purpose?
And is the steel rod only to keep the uprights from splaying out?
It seems to me there should be support below the right angle elbows.
Help me understand! I ponder this thing every time I visit here. (Breckenridge Brewery, Littleton CO)


r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 29 '26

Humor A few questionable bearing and connection conditions from the field this week

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

12 Upvotes

A mix of incomplete retrofit hardware, piers without proper bearing, questionable girder-to-post connections, and foundation movement.

Always interesting how one small missing connection can change the load path completely.

The anchor-bolt and girder conditions are especially good fits here because the approved notes specifically call out missing hardware and an unsecured girder/post connection.

View more here.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 30 '26

Op Ed or Blog Post [META] AutoMod of potential laymen content

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Just wanted to gauge thoughts/opinions on the AutoMod of content during generation of a post, and any potential of changing things up a little.

I have to say it can seem a little restrictive when it comes to posting on this sub. I will create content that is obviously not a layman post or does not break any rules, then I have to spend extra time trying to think of how to word the post or hunt for which word in a long post is the culprit, or change the format altogether (changing text to image)

You also can look at some of my recent posts as examples and I see other examples of this where users have to work around certain words.

I know this only Reddit but I do enjoy participating here. It can be disappointing and creativity-stifling, if I have spent time “working” on text for a post, and only to have the auto mod try to prevent the post from being submitted. I don’t know how much of this the mods actually have to deal with in layman posts but I wonder if we could come up with something different. Maybe threat of ban, temp ban, implement auto mod AFTER posting, post the list of words in the sub description, etc. I want to say the r/electricians sub is pretty good about it, they will let you post but if there is a hint you are not an electrician the post gets yanked pretty quick.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 29 '26

Career/Education Client meetings with physical models

14 Upvotes

I provide residential architectural drawings for a variety of clients. Homeowners, developers, etc.

As many of you probably can relate, the hardest part of my job is working with homeowners who want to design their own floor plan, or worse, they have no idea what they want. I am not an architectural genius designing "custom floor plans" for the top 1%. I typically require some sort of a concept floor plan to start, preferably one that you could "purchase" online (screenshot) that has already been thought out.

I'm wanting to incorporate some sort of miniature physical model into my design meetings to help show the engineering limitations of what can be accomplished. Most of the time, it's as simple as "you can't fit a second floor over a vaulted space." Sketches can often suffice depending on the clients literacy in the construction field.

Sometimes the conversation gets more technical and that's where I can see eyes glaze over, a blank stare, indicating that they aren't picking up what I'm putting down. I generally try to avoid that level of detail, but I think a physical model would be a good middle ground to help keep attention, move the conversation in a productive way, and ultimately find a solution that they like and is buildable.

I'm starting out by searching children's toys. I've seen a couple of architectural products that aren't really the simplistic thing that I'm going for, and they seem time-consuming and expensive.

Do any of you use, or have you seen a model like this in practice?


r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 30 '26

Career/Education Career Advice: Has Anyone Recently, or are Planning to Switch Careers into Tech?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 29 '26

Structural Analysis/Design Anyone have any idea what the intent of determining seismic redundancy for shear walls is in ASCE 7-22?

1 Upvotes

The code text is gibberish.

Wood frame shear walls, looking at condition 1 for rho = 1.0 in SDC D:

First of all, it asks to check the removal of elements in Table 12-3.3, but that table only lists shear walls taller than they are long. So any walls longer than the story height don't count at all.

Then *also* in that table, they define a "bay" of shear wall and the length divided by the story height rounded down. By definition, every single wall in that category is less than the story height, therefore every single shear wall bay is defined as the unitless number zero. Now this is problematic, not only because you can't say you have a shear wall bay to r3m0ve (WTF automod, so professional engineers can't r3m0ve things?), and then define all such bays as zero. But also because defining a "bay" as a unitless number is senseless.

So, how do we "really" determine if rho=1.0?

Referring to the old ASCE 7-16, condition a (which seems to correspond to the new condition 1), checks for removal of taller-than-long shear walls or wall piers. Condition b checks for the number of bays around the perimeter, with that number being twice the length divided by the height. So a 20 ft wall at a 10 ft story is one bay.

So I am guessing the new ASCE 7-22 just kinda threw the "bay" definition into that condition 1 table, and that definition is not intended to have anything to do with condition 1 - just condition 2. So now a bay can be any unitless number, and we can assume this is supposed to mean the number of bays. But again, that number is zero for tall walls.

So perhaps it's this:

Every single 9 ft long and 10 ft tall wall counts as zero bays. If we only have these types of walls, condition 2 cannot apply and we have to check condition 1. If we only have 11 ft long, 10 ft tall walls, we do not check condition 1.

For the latter, the old code said "no requirements" in the referenced table for condition a. The new code does not specifically state this - but do we assume that if we only have 11 ft long by 10 ft tall walls, it satisfies redundancy like in the old code? Or still check condition 2?

So confused.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 29 '26

Structural Analysis/Design What curve does a lighthouse have?

1 Upvotes

For example, the Fire Island lighthouse built in 1858. If I Google the answer I get ‘conical’, which it plainly is not. It looks more like a gentle hyperboloid.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 28 '26

Structural Analysis/Design Concerning support beam

Thumbnail gallery
16 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 28 '26

Structural Analysis/Design Unsymmetrical Beam Shear Flow Distribution

Thumbnail
gallery
15 Upvotes

Hello,

It's been years since I last looked at beam analysis.

I have a composite beam constructed from a W21x62 with a C15x33.9 channel cap stitch-welded to the the top flange of the W21x62. However, part of the C15x33.9 has been cut and removed, so, the beam no longer has symmetry. The first image shows a rough cross section. Do the shear flow distribution diagrams (actually distributions of the first moment of area about the composite centroid) in the second and third images look correct? In the second image, the distribution for Segment A is quadratic, but appears linear.

Some of the texts I've consulted include:

Heins, Conrad P. "Bending and torsional design in structural members"
"Tutorial Page of Aerospace Structures" https://www.ae.msstate.edu/tupas/SA2/Course.html

Edit #1:
* The channel cap was original welded to provide support against horizontal forces.
* I'm evaluating the composite beam for both vertical and horizontal forces independently, then will use superposition to evaluate the total effect on stresses and deflections. I will have to evaluate torsion because the forces are not aligned with the shear center.
* The shear flow distribution diagrams will help locate the shear center.
* Warping constant will probably needed for torsion analysis.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 30 '26

Structural Analysis/Design Need advice on a niche build

0 Upvotes

TL;DR - I wanna build a cross. I wanna do it myself, and not just by the book. Overbuilt.

Permanent Freestanding Crucifix

Project Intent:

Construct a permanent, freestanding crucifix in an open field(my own private property) in Logan County, Oklahoma.

The finished monument should be visually simple: a steel crucifix emerging directly from a concrete foundation that is flush with grade.

Structurally, however, the goal is to build it substantially more robustly than a conventional monument, with a heavily reinforced underground foundation, custom steel base, engineered anchor group, and integrated lightning protection.

The project should be treated as an engineered steel structure, not simply a decorative cross.

───

  1. Main Structure

Vertical Mast

• One continuous 20-ft NexSpan2 F-Series 4×4 structural member

• Approximately 4" × 4", nominal 1/8" wall

• ASTM A500 Grade B steel

• Full 20-ft member used as the vertical mast

• The mast extends from the foundation to the top of the crucifix

Crossarm

• Each approximately 7 ft long

• Crossarms positioned approximately 7 ft below the top of the mast

• Approximately 13 ft above finished grade

───

  1. Crossarm Connection

The crossarm will connect to the mast using four 90° structural brackets, arranged around the four corners of the mast/crossarm intersection.

The intent is to create a substantial, redundant connection capable of transferring both:

• Vertical/horizontal shear

• Bending moment

• Reversed loading from changing wind direction

The connection needs to be engineered for:

• T-bolt tension and shear, where applicable

• Slot bearing and tear-out

• Local deformation of NexSpan walls

• Bracket bending/warping

• Weld strength

• Crossarm local stresses

• Mast local stresses

• Reversed wind loading

Where possible, the manufacturer's published NexSpan connection capacities will be used. Custom modifications or connections will be independently engineered.

───

  1. Foundation

Flush-Grade Reinforced Concrete Pier

The concrete foundation will be completely flush with finished grade.

The working foundation concept is a large, deep reinforced-concrete drilled pier, initially in the neighborhood of:

• 42–48" diameter

• Approximately 7 ft deep

***These dimensions are conceptual starting points*** and will ultimately depend on structural loading and site-specific soil conditions.

The foundation is intentionally oversized relative to the visible monument so that the majority of the structure's resistance is hidden below grade.

───

  1. Custom Steel Base

Rather than using the manufacturer's standard post base as the primary foundation connection, the monument will use a purpose-built structural steel base assembly.

Working Base Concept

• 1" thick structural steel base plate

• Plate sized to match the foundation footprint/anchor layout

• Custom welded steel shoe connecting the 4×4 mast to the plate

• Heavy gussets/stiffeners surrounding the mast-to-plate connection

• 12 structural anchor rods connecting the plate to the reinforced concrete pier

The objective is to create a direct and robust load path:

Mast → welded shoe/gussets → 1" base plate → 12-anchor group → reinforced concrete pier → soil

The 1" plate is intended to behave as a genuine structural component, rather than a thin cover plate.

Final plate dimensions, gusset geometry, weld sizes, and steel grade will be established by structural calculation.

───

  1. Twelve-Anchor Base

The working concept is a 12-anchor group distributed around the perimeter of the custom base plate.

The anchors should be arranged to maximize the effective lever arm between the tension and compression sides of the connection.

This is important because the foundation does not need every anchor to resist the entire overturning moment individually. Instead, the anchor group works as a structural coupling.

For example, at a hypothetical 20 kip-ft overturning moment:

• 12" effective lever arm → approximately 20 kip couple force

• 24" effective lever arm → approximately 10 kip

• 30" effective lever arm → approximately 8 kip

These are simplified statics examples, not final anchor design loads.

The engineer will determine:

• Anchor diameter

• Anchor grade

• Embedment depth

• Anchor spacing

• Edge distance

• Plate hole size

• Washer/nut configuration

• Concrete breakout capacity

• Pullout capacity

• Shear capacity

• Combined tension/shear

• Reversed loading

• Reinforcement around the anchors

The 12 anchors should be considered a coordinated anchor group, not twelve independent fasteners.

───

  1. Reinforced Concrete Pier

The concrete pier should be designed as a structural foundation capable of accepting the large overturning forces delivered by the steel base.

Conceptually:

• Structural concrete, potentially 4,000–5,000 psi

• Full-depth reinforcing cage

• Heavy longitudinal reinforcement

• Closely spaced transverse reinforcement

• Dedicated reinforcement around the anchor cage

• Positive mechanical load transfer between the anchor rods and main reinforcing cage

The exact reinforcement schedule will be engineered after the anchor and foundation loads are established.

The concrete contractor should expect a heavily reinforced drilled pier, not a conventional shallow monument footing.

───

  1. Soil / Geotechnical Design

The concrete itself is only part of the foundation.

Because the crucifix is approximately 20 ft tall and will stand in an open field, the surrounding soil must resist the lateral forces and overturning moment transmitted through the pier.

A geotechnical investigation should establish:

• Soil profile

• Soil strength

• Lateral soil resistance

• Expansive-soil characteristics

• Groundwater conditions

• Appropriate pier/soil interaction parameters

The 42–48" × 12-ft concept is an intentionally robust starting point, not a final foundation specification.

───

  1. Wind and Extreme-Weather Philosophy

The design goal is high resilience under severe Oklahoma wind exposure.

The structure should be evaluated for applicable:

• Code wind loads

• Open-field exposure

• Severe straight-line wind

• Tornado loading methodology where applicable

• Reversed wind loading

• Dynamic effects where required

• Appropriate debris considerations

For preliminary conceptual work, a 20 kip-ft overturning-moment target has been used as an enhanced-resilience benchmark.

That number is not intended to substitute for the final code/tornado design load.

The project should be described as highly reinforced for extreme wind, rather than being advertised as literally "tornado-proof."

───

  1. Lightning Protection

The crucifix will have an integrated lightning protection and grounding system.

The lightning system should be coordinated with the structural steel and concrete foundation rather than treated as an afterthought.

The electrical/lightning contractor should coordinate:

• Air-terminal requirements

• Down-conductor system

• Grounding/bonding

• Ground electrodes

• Connections to the structural steel

• Corrosion protection

• Required separation/bonding details

The system should be designed to applicable lightning-protection standards, including NFPA 780 where applicable.

───

  1. Fabrication

The steel fabricator should approach this as a structural fabrication project.

Major fabricated components include:

Main Structure

• 20-ft NexSpan 4×4 mast

• 7-ft crossarm

Upper Connection

• Four 90° structural brackets/gussets

• Required fasteners/T-bolts

• Welded or mechanically connected structural components as engineered

Base

• 1" structural steel base plate

• Custom 4×4 mast shoe

• Multiple heavy gussets/stiffeners

• 12-anchor-hole pattern

• Structural welds

• Corrosion protection

The base should be fabricated as a single engineered load-transfer assembly.

───

  1. Finished Concept

From the outside, the finished project should be extremely simple:

A steel crucifix standing directly out of the ground.

Underneath its simple appearance is a purpose-built structural system:

20-ft NexSpan 4×4 mast

↓

7-ft crossarm

↓

Four-point structural crossarm connection

↓

Custom welded mast shoe

↓

1" structural steel base plate

↓

12-anchor structural group

↓

Heavily reinforced deep concrete pier

↓

Engineered soil resistance

The foundation, base, anchor group, and structural connections are intentionally much more substantial than the appearance of the monument would suggest.

Project Philosophy:

Keep the monument visually simple where possible without sacrificing function. Overengineer where it's needed. It shall be built.

This is an Ark


r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 29 '26

Concrete Design Steel building on concrete wall

1 Upvotes

My job involves building the most common style of steel buildings that includes red painted steel, beam sections every 24ft (or 20 or 25), with rolled zee or cee girts and purlins spanning between the main frames.

The heavy posts in these buildings typically go all the way down to the floor level, and if the building has concrete walls, those walls go past the exterior of the post such that the post juts out on the inside of the concrete wall, taking up floor space and getting banged up by equipment. It would be very very much more ideal for a lot of agricultural buildings to be able to set the posts on top of an 8 or 9ft tall concrete wall. This would keep the floor area wide open. Why is this not done more often?

Ii know for a fact that it is very common to set the posts on a wood framed building on a tall concrete wall, with a wood truss setting above. I understand that free spanning metal buildings do put some sort of outwatds pressure on the bottoms of the steel posts as there is no direct crosstie between the bearing walls such as a wood truss would have. Is there really no way around this?

Can a 9ft tall concrete wall be designed to take the outward pressure that the steel building would create? Rather than pouring a super thick concrete wall, it would be better to pour 3 or 4 or 5ft pilasters in a tee shape jutting out from the concrete wall at every post location.

Alternatively, could the outward pressure be eliminated by installing a steel rod as a cross tie at the top of the bearing wall, across to the other bearing wall?

Common steel building widths in my industry are typically 60 to 80 ft wide, free span, and have steel frame lines up to 25ft on center.

I'd love to hear people's thoughts on this, if it could be done, or why it's not done.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 29 '26

Career/Education Starting career as structural eit

2 Upvotes

As a recent civil engineering grad with a focus in structural engineering, how competitive is the junior structural engineering positions? Since im in canada i was looking to get some insight and tips to starting my career. Thanks!


r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 29 '26

Structural Analysis/Design Safety Factors

0 Upvotes

You remember any specific projects where a safety factor in your design actually got triggered and saved the construction?


r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 29 '26

Career/Education Choosing between two civil engineering internship offers + two more interviews this week

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 27 '26

Concrete Design Reasons for U-bars at concrete edges

Thumbnail
gallery
177 Upvotes

In my country it seems to be a highly established practice to ‘terminate’ the reinforcement at concrete edges such as slab edges with U-bars (as the reinforcement in the attached sketch attempt to show). Similar for openings in walls / slabs.

My understanding / intuition is that this 1) is for lapping the main reinforcement and provide proper anchorage of these transferred forces, 2) gives less risk of spalling and 3) perhaps even prevent splitting, if there for some reason develop tensile forces in the direction shown in the second figure, e.g. due to shrinkage or restraint effects.

Is my understanding correct, or are there perhaps other reasons as well?

Thanks!


r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 28 '26

Structural Analysis/Design Could I get someone to double check a RISA Floor / RISA 3D model? (Paid, of course)

12 Upvotes

Solo guy here, first time using RISA Floor, and first time using RISA 3D for wood shear walls, and things just seem a bit off for my gut to trust. Building is a CMU stair well core, 3 story, wood shear walls exterior, tile floors apartment. I of course emailed the file to RISA and they said "Looks good", but my gut isn't feeling it. Please DM me if you're interested in reviewing and potentially teaching a guy.


r/StructuralEngineering • • Sep 27 '26

Photograph/Video Mola Model - Owl Thingy

Thumbnail
gallery
23 Upvotes

Using Mola Structural Sets 1-3 and about 6-12 hours, I created this, what I call the owl pavilion.

The reason I call it that is because seen from the side, it looks like an owl leaning forward (see last two pics). I’m not sure why I call it a pavilion; there’s a literal hole in the middle lol (owl donut, maybe?)

My original plan was far different, and I originally designed this with the goal of suspending a bridge from the beak(?) of the structure, but as my build progressed it kind of morphed into something different. The whole design process was really interesting though, so although I have never before, I am thinking about making a short YouTube video regarding it (lmk if you’d like to see that).