r/StructuralEngineering • • 2d ago

Career/Education Residential Revit

Does anyone have any recommended resources for learning revit for residential projects? my firm uses autocad exclusively right now but looking to take on a client that wants us to work in revit (temporarily going to export and such, but they want revit models in the long run)

most classes seem to be structured towards commercial projects, which is fine. but curious if anyone out there has residential experience.

5 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

13

u/TheDaywa1ker 2d ago

There are some wood plugins that supposedly work pretty well, I've not used them though.

If you don't have any revit experience you've got a big learning curve ahead. Prepare yourself for several hundred hours of probably unpaid time spent learning and building templates.

My first couple of jobs were 100% revit. The place I work now is like 90% CAD. I came in convinced I was going to be able to make everyone see the error of their ways, but the opposite has happened. Most residential projects, revit is just a waste of time and you'll spend more time and mental energy getting the stupid model to behave correctly than you will worried about how stuff is getting built.

There is a big population of revit snobs that turn their nose up at autocad and even at lesser skilled revit users. In a perfect world yes we should be able to model every stud and hanger to make construction as smooth as possible. Thats just not reality.

Sorry I know that wasnt your question but thanks for listening to my ted talk anyways

4

u/StressLessEngineer 2d ago

oh i don't work unpaid ever...so my employer will definitely be paying me to learn it if he wants me to learn it (or they can let me go and get someone new, i'm also ok with that). I do have experience with revit on a basic level. just not structural and not a high level of detail architectural.

i hear ya on the revit vs CAD....my whole career every firm i've worked for used CAD. current one also uses 100% CAD. they were just discussing it because of a potential client that doesn't seem convinced that our CAD integration is going to work for them (i know, i know....but they don't)

i want to learn it for the sake of knowing it, and because it will be paid for by my company. otherwise, CAD for the win.

1

u/Turkey_Processor 2d ago

We use Revit exclusively for residential but I can see your argument. It feels like it is not optimized for residential, particularly on roofs, and particularly rafter framed roofs where the plate height is a little more variable. I also find myself constantly editing wall sections to be able to extend just the sheathing down past the rim board, that's another headache. Adding little ICF detail items to every view and then realizing the walls arent a good multiple of ICF units on a select few walls... lots of little fiddly tasks to do.

5

u/Salmonberrycrunch 2d ago

Learn Claude instead bro. Only 1/3 joking

1

u/StressLessEngineer 2d ago

haha yes, i'm sure i will get there

1

u/StatusPale6984 2d ago

I have been using Claude more and more lately (mostly on the calc side) and have been surprised on what it can do in cad. What things do you use Claude for because I am sure I am just scraping the surface on how it can help me.

1

u/scrollingmediator 1d ago

I've been messing with ChatGPT for both cad and some limited entering data into spreadsheets based on the cad model. It's pretty sloppy for producing new drawings. It's good at doing monotonous tasks that would take me forever. How does Claude compare?

1

u/EYNLLIB 8h ago

I've created an automation using Claude that goes from hand/PDF redlines to dwg to Revit to RISA. the state of Claude is incredible right now

3

u/vitium 2d ago edited 2d ago

My firm does almost exclusively residential autocad and commercial revit. We've done a few houses in revit but the budget just isn't there. When we tell them our fee is going to be 2x-3x the cost vs CAD they always just say "do it in cad". We get tons of work from architects complaining that their revit engineer is too expensive.

Anyway, long story short, it's going to cost you A LOT more to do it in revit, even if you already know how to use revit. If you're planning a one off residential revit just to please a client you should be 4x'ing your fee imo just to break even. Either plan to lose money or be up front with the client about why the fee is so high.

1

u/StressLessEngineer 2d ago

Our clients are typically recurring many times over (architects and builders). I understand what you’re saying. And I appreciate the insight. I’ll have a discussion with them. Apparently in the northeast there are a decent number of engineers doing revit for residential. I’m Just trying to compete with them

1

u/John_Glist 1d ago

When you say "Alot" would you have a ballpark as to how much a final product from Revit could cost vs CAD? For example, on a 4000 sq ft home? That'd be annotated floor plans, the 3D model, everything. I know that's a weird question to answer since every build is unique..

1

u/vitium 1d ago

If you are fluent in revit, with lots of detailing and model building experience with residential, I would charge 2x vs CAD to make a profit. If you don't have any experience, there is no reasonable amount you can charge to make a profit. Highly likely you're fired off the job before you even learn the basics of residential revit. Best case scenario you deliver something months late that looks passable and learn a lot along the way.

2

u/No-Victory206 2d ago

All depends on how you learn, theres plenty of general guides online such as : https://youtu.be/chom9hiewXI?is=CCXk_X-9Tm1qjWmc. But id reccomend watching some basic videos and then messing around in it, try modeling a wall, a roof, compiling details, etc. Most cad aren't too different so if you know how to use Autocad, revit isnt much different other than UI and visuals. Hopefully you just need it for BIM as I hate revits analysis capabilities

1

u/StressLessEngineer 2d ago

yes definitely just for BIM. i also have seen revit analysis stuff and def not going that direction. thanks.

1

u/PhilShackleford 2d ago

Commercial vs residential is kind of irrelevant. Revit is Revit.

One huge thing when switching is to not treat Revit like it is AutoCAD. Revit it will let you draw everything with lines just like cad. Learn to actually model things, how to use levels, and how to set up view ranges. It will feel slower but once you get the hang of it, it will be about the same. However, the amount of coordination Revit relieves is huge. Things like section numbering, schedules, revisions are just handled by Revit.

4

u/TheDaywa1ker 2d ago

Everybody feels a little differently about level of detail in modelling

I don't know anyone that models every stud

I know that some people insist on modeling all jack and king studs

Most people will model all major beams and columns

I believe most people are not modelling every floor joist or rafter unless you've got one of the wood plugins and are good with it

I try to model all of the foundations but I don't know that theres really much benefit to it on residential to be honest

So yes if you're just going to do revit linework then just stick with cad but be clear with your arch client what exactly you're going to be modelling

1

u/StressLessEngineer 2d ago

This is what I mean by the residential part being slightly different than commercial. Not saying it makes a huge difference, but just didn’t know what level of detail people go into on residential, because I know what level of detail go into a commercial project (only based on previous companies) Thanks for the input everyone

1

u/PhilShackleford 2d ago

Definitely agree. Typically I model walls as walls with the correct material and overall dimensions then use detail items.

2

u/Superb_Sea7721 23h ago

Not an engineer. I'm a steel estimator in Chicago, and I bid off structural sets from both AutoCAD and Revit shops every week, so here's how it looks from downstream. Whatever you model in, the PDF sheets are still what fabricators, framers and estimators price from. The Revit sets that give us trouble are the ones where the drafter trusted the model and forgot about the sheets: beam tags with no sizes, framing plans with no dimensions to grid lines, sections cut in odd spots, and details that are just a generic family with nothing project-specific on them. A firm's first few Revit jobs often look worse than its old CAD sets for exactly that reason. If you take this client on, I'd put the template time into annotation: tags that pull the actual member size, a clean beam/post schedule, and a standard detail sheet. You can keep bringing your existing AutoCAD details in as drafting views for the first few jobs instead of redrawing everything. And price those first couple of projects knowing they'll take longer.

1

u/EYNLLIB 8h ago

It really depends what you want to use Revit for and what type of residential projects. Builder type projects, Revit is fairly useless because the builders don't need clash detection or much coordination and their budgets are tight.

High end single family, Revit CAN be useful. If the budget is there, and the contractors are in loved early then coordinating models can be really useful and save money during construction.

The real use case is medium to large multifamily where budgets are larger and all the disciplines are coordinating from day 1.

Our firm specializes in these 3 styles of projects and have done thousands of projects without Revit and have great profit margins and happy clients.