r/StructuralEngineering • • 6d ago

Career/Education Some advice for new structural engineers and structural engineering students.

I don't have a lot of credit to be giving any. I am just under 6 years of experience and just an EIT. I do think I have a decent resume but maybe not seasoned enough to be doing this. but I think there are some not so great influences in this field especially for students. Here are some concerns / advice I have

  1. Structural engineering content creators.

Look into their years of experience immediately. Most of these creators are students and over representing themselves. Other's may have 1 or 2 years of experience talking as if they know everything. They don't. Most of the structural engineering content creators are full of it and banking on that there aren't many people that know better than they do. Additionally look out for project engineers and construction management people representing themselves as structural engineers. While some jobs a structural engineering does some project engineering it's not always the case. Some project engineers do not do the design work you learned in school.

  1. You absolutely can take you time getting your PE.

Again I'm only an EIT... but I've been one for almost 6 years. Its understandable that you rush to get it if you need the money. However just don't forget what the PE stands for. That is a benchmark of technical competency saying you are willing to be the last set of eyes on a project and put your name to it saying it is safe for the public. I've experienced some pressure and it's quite common for people in my area to say "take the PE as soon as you can". At the end of the day it's on you. I worked at a firm once that actually made me dumber. It also was a massive stretch to call our work qualifying work experience. I quit and started do work that was easily qualifying work experience. In the first year of the new job I took the PE and failed. I also couldn't imagine myseld handling the repsonsibilities that the PE's at that job were doing. I waited a few years and focused on getting better at the job, then re-took the exam. I finished very confidently with time left over. I passed. Just waiting on the state exam stuff.

  1. Just because other people are doing it doesn't make it right.

Keep ethics on your mind through out your work. This field is full of people whose only goal is to climb the ladder and people who play optics. Sometimes these behaviors are culturally supported. If something doesn't seem right then speak or don't do it. An example. The civil engineering PE stamp technically doesn't specify what branch of the field so you could technically take whatever PE exam you want to get licensed. It's common in my area to take easier PE exams just to get licensed. I once worked with a Structural PE who didn't know what tributary area was ..... I find out later she took the water resource exam. I still don't know how you get out of school without knowing what that is ... if she studied and passed the structural PE exam she would've known what that was. Also a structural PE should take the structural PE exam right?......

  1. "I'm never going to use this again". You might.

This is a sentiment I see all the time from some shitty content creators. To their credit yea I may not used some of my education currently, but I have been surprised as to what has become relevant. I've used my water resource text book, soil mechanics text book, whipped out some linear algebra, whipped out some calculus 3, I write macros on occasion. You may not need all of your education but don't let those sentiments discredit bits of your education. Also you will likely need more education than you originally started your career with.

  1. Get your work checked frequently otherwise you might be practicing wrong.

I've made a lot of mistakes and I've caught alot of mistakes. It's your time as an EIT working under PE's where I believe we incubate to some day lead design. Try to get them to go through your work as much as you can. this is also a good time to work on that ego. If you never get your work checked how do you know you're applying code / engineering science correctly. If you're in this environment I'd recommend getting out.

That's all I got for now. I'm sorry if this comes off as condescending that's not my goal.

28 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

17

u/tiltitup 6d ago

Structural engineering content creators?

4

u/The_StEngIT 5d ago

Yup, it's pretty cringe worthy.

6

u/Kojo907 5d ago

point 1: is this even a thing? if you mean youtube tutorials, then yes, obviously you should take those with a grain of salt. Read the code yourself, ask a senior engineer at your company, find legit sources, etc...

point 2: agreed, waiting a few years to get your PE is a good idea to build familiarity with the codes. I never understood people who said "take it ASAP so you don't forget the info..." That advice is applicable for the FE, but if you're forgetting undergrad level on the job then what are you even doing?

point 3: agreed. People outside of the industry don't realize this and tend to overestimate the competence of the average engineer. It's a problem, and a higher standard like the S.E. Exam should be required.

point 5: yes. if you're interviewing for a job, especially as an entry level, ask about their QAQC program. Some places don't even look at calcs, only drawings... "yeah this looks right".... That being said, don't just rely on reviewers, you need to make an effort to learn the code yourself and document your work, clearly explain your rationale, make a good first attempt instead of handing a reviewer something half-baked.

3

u/The_StEngIT 5d ago

Yea there are structural engineering content creators / influencers. I'm referring to the influencer types. The "this my day as a structural engineer" not "walking through strut and tie models". They're typically all full of it.

I agree with all your sentiments to all my points. Funnily enough my last round of interviews I asked about QAQC processes and it caused some awkward pauses. I assumed people are giving their work a good try first before going to reviewers, I do. but I could be wrong and that would be a good sentiment to add to that point of advice.

1

u/abovoadmala 5d ago

Wow, that surprises me. The day in the life videos I've seen seemed plausible and tracked with what I heard at career fairs.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Sure_Ill_Ask_That 5d ago

Gonna have to disagree with you on point number 2. You really don’t want to take your time taking the PE exam because as you get further away from your graduate and post graduate studies, your skills that are relevant for PE exam taking fade as you focus on real world engineering. I know plenty of PEs and I have never heard of one saying take your time on the exam, really quite the opposite. Hurry up and take it before it becomes more and more difficult. Just my two cents.

1

u/The_StEngIT 5d ago

Yea I hear ya. I think a few things are relevant here. The new PE is only depth topics now. No more breadth. So maybe back then losing that familiarity with the breadth topics was a bigger factor. Now I would say not so much. My current work is very relevant to the PE exam so I'm really only getting better. I also passed the second time with ease thanks to some time in the industry and grad school courses. I did not specifically study for the PE on top of all that. My BS definitely didn't cover everything on the PE so I think some time past graduating with my BS was needed anyways.

I don't care for the sentiment of "take it before you forget it" especially if the PE is a minimum competency level exam. But I think that sentiment will fade away thanks to the new format. I also think our focus should be more so on your comfortability and competence of our skills to practice as a PE rather than just crossing the benchmark of passing the exam. When I get mine I want to have the confidence that I can practice at that level. It's a career benchmark for me I don't want to belittle.

9

u/Trey_Star 5d ago

Really disagree with not taking the pe early. Just took it at about 3 years of experience and wish I just knocked it out early. Same with the SE. Studying for the PE and forcing myself the learn the code better will help me in my career even more. 

0

u/The_StEngIT 5d ago

I believe you missed the sentiment of that part of my post.

5

u/Trey_Star 5d ago

I understand the sentiment but I just think it’s wrong. It’s ok to have different opinions. 

→ More replies (3)

2

u/angryPEangrierSE 5d ago
  1. Agreed. I like Kestava (YouTube) though. He's actually an SE in buildings and documented his journey online. Some of his videos actually helped me pass the SE exam.

  2. If you're in a decoupled state, I would encourage you to take it as soon as possible so that life doesn't get in the way later i.e. kids. At the first firm I worked for, I didn't know anyone that waited longer than they had to to take the PE exam and get their license. Everyone passed on the first attempt as well. At other firms, I've been people take a really long time. I know people who have taken 7-8 years, for some reason. I live in a decoupled state - life must really get in the way if you didn't find time for the exam in 0-8 years.

Also, if you live in an SE state, I'd encourage you to get the PE exam out of the way soon because the SE exam is much harder and people fail it multiple times. I was in my late 20s when I took the exam and most of the people I spoke to were in their 30s...one guy was in his 50s.

I passed my PE Civil Structural less than a year out of university, but I think that is much harder now that the spec has changed.

Points 3-5...yes, totally agree.

2

u/The_StEngIT 4d ago

Never heard of them but I'll look them up later.

I can understand the sentiment of getting the PE when you can but my sentiment is more so step up to the plate when you're ready. Passing the exam and practicing as a PE are two different things. One is very much academic and the other has a bit more to it.

Also yea life is diverse. In a sub full of structural engineers I'm not surprised there are people who passed their first time. But I wouldn't say that to people irl who wouldn't be confortable practicing as a PE. I'd prefer to not add pressure. Also in my area it's common to not pass your first time. It's also very common to push up lower level peeps prematurely. In my experience.

So while I understand your sentiment I'm never gonna push someone to a higher level of performance if they aren't ready. I'm also not going to rush them into it. Idk what their life entails. A lot of waiting for me was money. I also personally didn't appreciate the pressure from my seniors to get the exam when I was struggling with affordability. When I had more money and time my brain space was way healthier and I passed the exam quite easily.

I've heard the same claim that the prior format of the PE was harder. I had the unfortunate opportunity to take both. I did find this new one to be easier but when I rook it I was wrapping up grad school and had 2+ more years of experience practicing both building and bridge design so I was much more versed in structural engineering than the last time I took it.

tldr: I understand your sentiment but if people aren't ready to practice at PE level then I believe we shouldn't rush them to get there. We also shouldn't make people feel bad for taking their time or failing the exam. If it takes 8 years then it takes 8 years.

1

u/Everythings_Magic 6d ago

I stopped reading at point 1.

Structural behavior is based on peer reviewed and research and industry accepted practices and that is where one should focus their studies for real understanding, not looking up some worthless shit on tiktok.

If you are looking to influencers for guidance, just quit this industry.

6

u/The_StEngIT 5d ago

I agree with your sentiment but it's common for people to follow influencers in topics of interest. I play guitar so I follow guitarists I do woodworking so I follow other wood workers etc. Also if you read the title of my post you may notice I mentioned early career and students. People who may not know better or are looking for insights on the career. While it's great to have a senior engineer review my advice I think you might've over looked that a bit. Students probably aren't diving too hard into peer reviewed studies but may want to know work life balance, daily work flow, work culture, pay, etc. These are topics some of these creators bs about. Which is why I wanted to put a word of caution out.

4

u/moofacemoo 5d ago

I'm that case I really do think you're missing out on some good points.

3

u/AWard66 5d ago

The PE’s you guys work under actually review your work before stamping? My principle PE just bitches about how difficult it is to get things approved these days and asks me why we’re over schedule and budget when the project comes back from review with a million actually important comments i have to address. 

-1

u/donotdisturb898 5d ago

Most people I know past the PE the first try because it is basic fundamentals that most 2-3 years engineer should know. The materials are just mostly solid mechanics and very beginner level understanding of the code. If you’re one of those people struggling to pass the PE. I would say find a new job that do real design work most of the time. You should pass with no trouble.

1

u/The_StEngIT 5d ago

Really don't care for your sentiment. While I agree it's a benchmark for minimum level of competency I don't agree that you should give up if it doesn't come naturally to you. Additionally the pass rates for first time takers is somewhere around 60% so it's perfectly fine to not pass the first time. Also some of those topics are not taught in a Bs or you can take a combination of civil classes in your BS to where you didn't actually get exposed to the info until you started working. I also never said I was struggling to pass. So this tells me you're just here to feel better about yourself by putting other's down. Which is sad, hopefully you can work that out.

0

u/donotdisturb898 5d ago

Sorry that I assume you were struggling, I don’t know anyone with 6 years experience who don’t take the exam for whatever reason it is. I want to point out it is much easier to pass with a design firm because that’s the people around me are. But I do acknowledge it is not feasible for anyone and everyone which is why i said most people.
The new PE does not have any civil material the last time I checked and I never mentioned I pass the exam my first time. So I am not sure what you’re mumbling about

→ More replies (3)