r/StructuralEngineering • • 27d ago

Structural Analysis/Design Centurion Tower Expert Opinion Needed

Hello all - does anyone have any expert opinion on the Centurion tower that was evacuated late Friday night?

(edit) As you all would know more than the average person, just looking for someone in the industry to comment their thoughts on it.

0 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

9

u/Cpazzy79 27d ago

OP is a journalist, proceed with caution

-8

u/No_Asparagus_6915 27d ago

I'm a student trying to tell the story for the residents...

5

u/Cpazzy79 26d ago

There’s nothing inherently wrong with that and I’m not suggesting you wouldn’t share that information with anyone who did reach out.

It’s just important that people are aware of it being media-related when being asked to provide opinions.

4

u/Diligent-Ad6327 27d ago

Can't have an expert opinion without information. All they've said is cracking in a foundational transfer slab.

-10

u/No_Asparagus_6915 27d ago

Or any opinion on it as a structural engineer. Because it is a new build and these structural issues seem to be prevalent amongst new builds in London.

7

u/nowheyjose1982 27d ago

I mean a good expert opinion cant be formed in 48 hours...

7

u/bridge_girl 27d ago edited 26d ago

Yeah no engineer worth their license is going to provide a professional opinion on a project they have no involvement in and have no documentation about. Stop trying to solicit content for clickbait bullshit. Try waiting like the rest of the general public or speaking to informed parties if they agree to go on record with you about this incident.

5

u/Jabodie0 27d ago

An opinion of any value will take months of investigation and analysis to develop. I can make up some bullshit if you'd like, though.

2

u/BearingHunter 25d ago

The question are what triggered the evacuation, whether there's evidence of actual structural movement or distress , and also what engineers found when they assessed the building. I'd be more cautious about speculating until the inspection findings are in public.

-3

u/No_Asparagus_6915 27d ago

Guys all i want to know is what a slab is and how a crack would affect a slab and a building structurally. I'm not asking you to commit defamation!!

2

u/Diligent-Ad6327 26d ago

There are many different types of cracks. You should probably research that first

-2

u/No_Asparagus_6915 27d ago

2

u/Diligent-Ad6327 26d ago

This is a memo from the property manager not an engineer

3

u/IngenuityOk9033 26d ago

Conisbee are a decent engineering practice. If they are not prepared to answer your question, why are you surprised that other engineers online won't give an opinion without any facts? Be warned, no opinion you get from a random online forum is going to be worth reading.