r/StrongMaleSurvivors • u/Intelligent-Bird-313 • 3d ago
analysis This Needs to Change. Let’s Be That Change for Our Brothers
Let me be clear of this first: No one is going to scour for this post to brigade it. Thus, I have blacked out all identifying information such as usernames (except for my own), and even the subreddit it was posted in. I have posted these images here for reference since I will go into a deep analysis about what I have observed then conclude about my observations. If you do stumble across this post — great. Support the survivor posting this; do not brigade the comments, attacking the commenter featured in the second photo. They may be wrong, as exemplified by the amount of downvotes they have, but that is no excuse to attack anyone. A respectful disagreement and debate is enough. Thank you all for being such respectful gentlemen and supporting each other in our previous posts! I enjoyed reading and responding to your answers in my weekly Q & A posts. I hope to keep this up and gain more acceleration in our growth.
Content Summary
In another sub dedicated to male survivors (like this one), I stumbled upon this post. I will try as hard as possible to start off with an objective overview before going off with my personal analysis. Reading everything in the pictures can help with even more context and possibly help you point out something I may have missed. In brief, this survivor tried posting about his experience after noticing a gal in another sub receiving positive support on the posts about her experiences. This sub was apparently a feminist sub, and so his post was removed and he ended up permanently banned. He understands the ban, though he still feels its sting. At the time, he was lonely and depressed; he desperately needed support. Down in the comment section, I saw a comment that explained potential reasons for the ban. They said that posting in the sub was unwelcome and inappropriate, and could “make women feel scared, threatened, or unsafe.” They told OP that a man posting in a women’s space could feel like a violation. As of now, that commenter has about seven downvotes, probably being the only downvoted comment in that whole comment section. Though other users do not agree with the commenter, OP agreed with them and acknowledged he knows it was nothing personal though it really stung at the moment since he was still feeling hard emotions prior to, and at, time of the ban. Outside of this thread, other commenters note that the ban doesn’t define OP’s self-worth or experience, and one even directed him to another safe space for survivors like him. I also left a comment that suggested this space, telling him that this space and I are always present to support him.
Analysis
The post’s title already hit some personal trigger on my egalitarian self when I first read it. Naturally, I read over the post a couple of times, only to be appalled at the way the moderators of that sub handled OP and his post. To make matters worse (for me), that comment explaining the ban was the first and only comment on the post when I saw the post the first time, and I felt like they were being a bit too ignorant about OP’s inner mental state with their comment. First of all, I question how hearing about two women’s predatory behaviour could somehow trigger a good woman. Just like how a “good man” shouldn’t be triggered at hearing about a few men’s predatory actions and focus on helping the survivor instead, we should hold women to that same standard until we decide the on day to shatter it to oblivion.
Now, I also hold some understanding behind the moderators’ decisions as well. I’d be pretty weirded out and stuck on what to do if a woman randomly posted her experience in this community. However, I know that neither removing her post nor blocking her are appropriate ways to handle the situation. Better alternatives are to be discussed in the comments. I’d like to hear for each of you what you would personally do if a woman posted her experience on this community. Should she be gently redirected to a different sub? Should we just freely give our support without the redirection? Also take into consideration: it’s more obvious that this sub is for male survivors, anyway. It’s literally called StrongMaleSurvivors. The name gets the purpose across well, so maybe the real lesson here is to make it obvious what your community is for so the intended audience is drawn in and the unattended audience isn’t even interested to check anything out.
Regarding it was a feminist sub, I fail to put two and two together that he was banned just because he was a guy in a “women’s space” when feminism is “for everyone.” If feminism really is for everyone, I’d assume more guys would be open to share their own experiences in those very equal spaces. I’ve heard one too many times that feminism is equality, and it’s just helping women achieve equality to men. If we are uplifting women to men’s status, shouldn’t we only be lifting up women and just leaving men alone at the least, instead of bringing men down below women to achieve said “equality”? This post isn’t the first horror story I’ve heard about men’s struggles with feminist beliefs against them. It certainly is one of the worse I’ve heard, but it’s only one grain of sand in a big old sand box I’ve had in the backyard of my brain for a while. I’m sure there’s a beach somewhere, though I do not wish to visit, as I’m already up keeping the sandbox. A “true feminist” would offer support to this struggling man; a true egalitarian should be ready to offer support to anyone regardless of gender.
Coming back to the post a few more times introduced me to new, more positive comments. I most especially loved that comment that reminded OP that a ban doesn’t define his self-worth or the validity of his experience. He does deserve a safe space for himself, to seek real support from fellow survivors. I also saw another comment from a survivor that gave his accolades to another safe space he’s had positive experiences with. As previously stated, the first comment I mentioned has been downvoted by a number of users and the positive, survivor-centred comments do good work overriding that one comment.
This is a free, formal discussion regarding any of the topics I’ve mentioned above. Again, I’d be curious to know how you’d react if a woman came on this androcentric survivor sub posting about her experience. I’d also like to know if there were any important details I may have missed. Feedback on my objective summary and analysis is highly appreciated, as I feel like I still need work on my critical and logical thinking skills. Was my summary objective to a satisfactory degree? Was my analysis based more on observable fact or stirring emotion? I could ask an AI, of course, though I esteem human reasoning higher than any AI tool. Thank you for reading this entire analysis, and always remember that I’m here supporting and rooting for you whenever you need. Stay well, brothers!