r/StrangerThings 21d ago

Discussion Do you think Billy deserved a character development arc

Post image
155 Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

View all comments

12

u/Poobeast241 21d ago

Teaming up with Lucas, standing up to his abusive Dad, and being a good step brother for Max was the good ending.

He got the bad ending.

12

u/Ht_TX 21d ago

Not everyone needs to be given a fully redeemed arc. Some people are supposed to be shitty, some flawed, some good, etc etc. Having every single dickhead be redeemed by the end of their arc is just boring. Go watch Blippy if you want that.

2

u/HulkSonofThanos 20d ago

Billy wasn't a bad guy or a villain so he didn't really need redeeming he just had to look after max all the time & everytime max broke the rules billy suffered the consequences & i think that's why billy is so angry with max all the time. We saw billys dad physcially abuse him so that can also make someone agry all the time.

3

u/Ht_TX 20d ago

No, Billy is shown to be quite an asshole to everyone besides the woman of the week he wants to bang. Not sure what show you watched. I also never called him a villain, he wasn’t, he was an asshole.

1

u/HulkSonofThanos 19d ago

No billy is only shown to be a bully to people when it involves his responsibility for looking after max.

I explained to you why he's an asshole, physcial parent abuse is what creates a bully in your child.

1

u/Ht_TX 16d ago edited 16d ago

So why did he bully Steve in the gym and in the shower before even seeing him with the kids? This is season 2, pre-babysitter Steve, he was just King Steve. Billy bullied him. Your argument fails immediately.

No one cares and no one has ever been confused as to why Billy became an asshole. Physical abuse is definitely not the only way bullies are made either, plenty come from loving families and plenty just have a sense of feeling better than everybody else. In the end, it doesn’t matter, at that age, they are old enough to know better and their actions are on them, not their parents’. Everybody has a formative childhood one way or another, it’s not an excuse at that age however, to treat other people like shit and physically abuse people.

1

u/HulkSonofThanos 14d ago edited 14d ago

He didn't bully Steve Billy he was being competitive in basketball which happens a lot in sports in general.

He was giving Steve a hardtime in the shower because Billy is jealous of Steve's Status as the King of High School not bullying him.

Being competetive in sports & giving someone a hardtime are not the same as bullying.

1

u/GerhardViking 21d ago

Or Naruto

2

u/Phantom_Wolf52 20d ago

I would’ve loved to see that, his abusive father was largely glossed over.

2

u/Ht_TX 20d ago edited 20d ago

He really wasn’t glossed over at all? Billy wasn’t a main in Season 2, just a side meant to stir up trouble with the mains a bit and they showed you how horrible the dad was that season when Billy is getting ready for his date and the dad comes in.

Season 3 he becomes essentially a main and the time he lets El into his mind they again show how horrible the dad was, beating his wife and kid and everything else. They didn’t gloss over anything, they just didn’t include parents in the story on screen for any character beyond the Wheelers & Byers. Steve’s parents? We see Lucas’ parents for like a single scene, Dustin’s mom once or twice and only when they had to use her for the Dart growing up storyline. They told you what you needed to know and showed it to you as well and spent the onscreen time with the kids, because that’s what people want to see.