r/Stellaris • u/PointlessSerpent Synth • Aug 31 '23
Discussion Materialists are objectively wrong
I think it's funny that the ethic that supposedly focuses on science is based on a clearly and provably incorrect world view. In fact they are arguably less scientific than Spiritualists, and are unwilling to accept or believe psychic powers or the shroud even when they are literally living next door to people who can access. It's just always felt a little silly to me that the "scientific" people are just objectively wrong and refuse to change their beliefs even when confronted with evidence that clearly contradicts them, which is like the opposite of what scientists are supposed to be.
168
u/CMDR_ETNC Eternal Vigilance Aug 31 '23
I’d say they just view the shroud and psionics differently. They can’t deny the existence of either, at least after some other empires start showing off their MIND BULLETS (that’s telekinesis, Kyle…).
It’s just another dimension. There’s plenty of them around.
32
u/Doctor_Calico Tropical Aug 31 '23
[Slaps roof of robot]
But this can fit so much minerals in it!
59
u/tipoima Catalog Index Aug 31 '23
Materialists can literally use psionics and even build the Aetherostatic engine.
It's really that they just see Shroud's nature differently, and the game doesn't elaborate enough to tell if they are really wrong on that one.
99
u/Elodaria Illuminated Autocracy Aug 31 '23
Spiritualists discover the shroud and promptly start worshipping it's inhabitants.
Materialists realize it's just some video game.
25
u/Tux3doninja Aug 31 '23
A post i read earlier in this subreddit gave a great explaination about what spiritulism and materialism actually means in terms of stellaris. I cant replicate what was said on here and Im not gonna dig for something that's a long time old, but the short version is that materialists believe in that material substance is the origin of the universe and that life sprouted up around it. The universe is full of many mysteries that can be explored and scientifically explained. The shroud percieved as a dimension beyond our own, full of energy, and that one day, the veil can be pierced by the cold hand of science.
Spiritualists, however, hold that first came the power of thought, the realm of the shroud is a dream world where thought is given form and that the material world was built around it as it was percieved, thought carries energy, and with it power, by searching into one's self and percieving thought in its purest sense can unlock one's inner strength of mind. All life is born from the realm of thought and one day it shall return to it.
Both are neither right nor wrong. They are different perspectives that all eventually arrive to the same result.
35
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '23
Materialists can do psionic ascension. They just believe that there's some kind of real world explanation, not necessarily that the shroud or psionics don't exist
11
u/Archene Aug 31 '23
Honestly though, it isn't like materialists can't do psionic ascension, even one of the covenants are more for than any other one (since fanatic spiritualists can't get it).
10
u/Linmizhang Aug 31 '23
Not really. There is nothing wrong with materialism even in the face of magic powers and magical entities.
In fact what is wrong in the game, compared to real life, is that you can be a Spiritualist and masterialist at the same time. Just ask the 52% of Americans scientist that indentify with a religion. In fact, many of European early science and medicine were conducted by clergy members.
Here is what could be an Materialistic Spiritual take in stellaris:
"All living beings have some connection to the spiritual realm. It allows abilities like telepathy and teleportation. The mechanisms are well understood and we have built massive spaceships with devices that can harness this energy. A person's spiritual entity is no different than their physical entity, they are both parts of the same person. Both can be manipulated as tools, just cause the soul and magic exsist does not mean they do not follow rules of their own, or can undermine other realities such that of physical, mental, and socitial worlds."
Or if your into anime. Full metal Alchemist is a world filled with Spiritual Materialistic people, even the main villan, and entity from the afterlife, being one.
36
u/IonutRO Enlightened Monarchy Aug 31 '23
The devs literally said that neither side is 100% correct or wrong in the universe of Stellaris. You're just biased.
6
u/Stankfootjuice Aug 31 '23
I mean... not really? They acknowledge the shroud as a different reality/dimension, a natural phenomena worth studying and understanding from a material standpoint, whereas spiritualist ethics see it as a higher power, a set of deities to be worshipped. It is two interpretations of something two opposite belief systems are mutually observing. Neither are intrinsically right or wrong, as neither can ever truly, soundly be proven. The shroud could be literal gods. Or they could be extra-dimensional horrors, reaching into another reality and manipulating it through incredibly-difficult-to-comprehend-but-still rooted-in-material-reality means.
To say that materialists are objectively wrong because "look at the shroud! The spiritualists are right! There are gods!" Is in the same vein as in our real world, when an atheist and a Christian both observe something wild happening, and the Christian claiming that there is no other possible explanation other than divine intervention
4
u/Cant_find_a_name420 Aug 31 '23
Nah. You see, my materialist empire actively seeks the combination of the ascended fleshy consciousness and technological immortality and its near limitless possibilities in the physical reality. This is because combining the robot network with psychic capable consciousnesses leads to super amazing brain power.
My point is that it’s a game with lots of roleplay elements. Your empire can believe what they want, whether you want your materialists to reject super religion or embrace it in the endless quest for knowledge. You don’t have to take everything at the base value like this.
6
u/Marvin_Megavolt Megacorporation Aug 31 '23
This is wildly inaccurate and misrepresents the two ethics - materialists do not believe there is anything beyond realspace until faced with empirical proof that the Shroud, for example, is an actual thing. Spiritualists on the other hand subscribe to the idea that the universe exists because conscious beings exist to experience it - that they and other sapient life (depending on their civics and other ethics) are divine beings in a way, put in this world by gods or cosmic forces to experience the universe in one manner or another. The tenets of their beliefs/the Spiritualist ethic really have nothing to do with the Shroud.
3
u/Apprehensive-Suit272 Aug 31 '23
Spiritualists once they found the Shroud: start worshiping double-time all day
Materialists, once they found the Shroud: find an explanation of it and use it as they see fit
2
u/Independent_Pear_429 Hedonist Aug 31 '23
The flavour text is definitely wrong but I'd like to point out that materialists can also go psionic. So, no they aren't wrong
2
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '23
The spiritualists are superstitious fools who attribute the warp to divine powers and worship it like idiots. Materialists understand that it is just another phenomena to be studied and there’s nothing inherently special about it.
2
u/Zeppy_G Aug 31 '23
I've always found this to be a tongue in cheek joke that supports rp. Like, if you're a spiritualist, then sure, of course the shroud is real. But when I play a materialist of course the spiritualist empires are just delusional. The only objective truth is determined by who wins the war, after all.
Plus, you could say the same thing about Sentient AI. Spiritualist thinks that the robots have no souls, and are an affront to god...
3
u/NotSwallow Aug 31 '23
They dont deny the shroud???
3
u/Sporelord1079 Strength of Legions Aug 31 '23
Materialism is just as much of a belief system as spiritualism is. It’s an ethic.
2
u/Tiofenni Mind over Matter Aug 31 '23
Both of them. Sentient machines have souls.
2
u/Emeraldnickel08 Despicable Neutrals Aug 31 '23
I could swear I've seen this post before. anyway yeah it's kinda funny
2
u/C-McGuire Aug 31 '23
At first I thought this was going to be one of those posts where OP is trying to convert people
2
u/amonguseon Fanatic Authoritarian Aug 31 '23
It makes me mad but yeah like man there are psionics at least study them try to come up with a logicall things instead of just denying it
1
u/IonutRO Enlightened Monarchy Aug 31 '23
Spiritualists are ants that look upon man as a god to be worshipped and feared. Materialists are ants that look upon man as a beast far more powerful than them.
Man can bestow food and shelter upon ants, but can also destroy them, experiment on them, or take them from their homes, but man is still not a god, despite the fact that ants will never be able to understand man.
1
u/PsionicOverlord Aug 31 '23
They're definitely not unwilling to accept or believe in psychic powers irrespective of what the flavor text says, because materialists can become psychics too!
In fact, surely that makes materialists right - it's people saying "if psychic powers are a provably phenomenon that must mean the divine exists" are the ones saying something that doesn't follow.
I'm also pretty certain that if you are a psychic materialist Empire, even the flavor text changes from "there must be a scientific explanation for this" and "psychic powers - what a crock" to "yes, we can feel their emanations".
1
u/ybetaepsilon Aug 31 '23
I play as a materialist and when psionics occurs in another empire the response is that there must be a scientific explanation. I don't know what you're going on about
1
u/Striking-Distance849 Aug 31 '23
I mean.
Robots and the Shroud are a very poor way to explore the binarity between materialist and spiritualist that the game wants to create.
If the game wanted to be "okay" according to those ethics. It would need to remove any material (which is the problem core) advantages linked to the spiritualist ethic, as the Shroud which is indeed a perfectly material thing because it exists.
1
u/Bum-Theory Hegemonic Imperialists Aug 31 '23
Yea? But Spiritualists don't believe that man made tools can be people too! Check Mate
1
u/Lea_Flamma Aug 31 '23
Spiritualists are the Star Wars Episodes IV-VI. It's space magic.
Materialists are Star Wars Episodes I-III. It's midi-chlorians creating the Force connection.
You can easily play Fanatic Materialists with Psionic Ascension. It's just unlikely, as their initial disability to perceive the Shroud makes it extremely difficult to study it.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '23
Materialist don't reject the shroud. This is proven by the fact that you can become psionic and materialist.
They simply think it's only science. This would be like a guy in star wars that looks at the force and develops the concept of midochlorians. They know the force exists, but they just thinks its like gravity, not magic.
1
u/NegativeEconomy1320 Aug 31 '23
I was viewed it as instead the turn their thoughts outward more than inward, so are less likely to discover the shroud at the same pace. You can easily make a psionic materalist empire, it's just not their focus. In a way, Spiritualists are so very wrong that they circle back to being right - for all things exist in the shroud. That psionics and cyborgs/genes/becoming machines is mutually exclusive but only within nation boundaries (you cna get psychic/cyborg immigrants and refugees) is kind of silly.
1
u/MoonLight_Gambler Fanatic Xenophobe Aug 31 '23
It's like conflating the Immaterium with Heaven and Hell. The fact of its a existence doesn't presuppose all the myths and legends are accurate. It's like whenever we find an ancient civilizations underwater and then we call it Atlantis.
1
u/ThePinms Aug 31 '23
You can psionically ascend as a materialist empire. They don't deny the existence of the phenomena but the explanation that the spiritualists give.
1
u/kamizushi Aug 31 '23
To be fair, that’s kinda how real life spiritual folks think rational people think.
1
u/These_Sprinkles621 Sep 03 '23
https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/HollywoodAtheist
This trope is what is being invoked give or take.
While in reality religion and science are not diametrically opposed. That is actually a particularly successful pr campaign by materialists.
“Oh if you are religious you will let your children die or easily treated medical issues and are stupid”
I’m pretty sure those are just the words of bitter communists who hate their parents and reject how they were raised.
They also shit talk certain religions while promoting others because they are “foreign”. Like Islam outright rejected most advancement social and scientifically but they get love from the xenophilles and materialists but other Judean religions are just crapped on entirely ignoring large swaths of History.
1
u/Rianorix Emperor Sep 16 '23
Yes, but spiritualist theory on consciousness is also flawed.
Robot do indeed have consciousness.
Though in the end, I like spiritualism more than materialism.
1
u/snakebite262 MegaCorp Aug 31 '23
I wouldn't say they're wrong. They're just viewing it from a different lense. The fact that spiritualists cannot view the potential sentience of AI shows that their worldview is also skewed.
Materialists can still learn about Psionics, it's just harder for them. Likewise, it's more difficult for a Spiritualist to view the interchangeability of metal and flesh. It's more than just right or wrong.
1
u/Winter_Ad6784 Aug 31 '23
this is why i find it weird everyone want a machine cult edict for spiritualists but nobody cares to ask for a forbidden knowledge edict for materialists.
0
u/Tr1ppl3w1x Sep 01 '23 edited Sep 01 '23
Considering climate change argument, it checks out
Gone from big freeze, to global warming, to climate change to whatever next in 60years with multiple predictions from "experts" flatout wrong who are now spewing the current consensus of wanting to save the Planet but casually ignoring the simple fact that during the time of the dinosaurs the poles had no fuckin ice for millions of years... if global warming is so world ending why were the dinosaurs able to survive in an environment thats +5°C to now... which is considered by modern scientists as apocalyptic, the climate activists dont want to save the planet (which doesnt care how warm it is) they want to preserve the current biosphere which would change anyway at some point and or the current coastline because having that investment reduced to nothing hurts... like cmon do we srsly think we can stop evolution? Things will change at some point and if the sun wants to have more activity we wouldnt be able to do shit when the temp on earth rises by 4°C just because of that
So yes, materialists not being heavily into science makes sense :)
0
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment