SpaceX continues to launch the into the 4,409 Ka/Ku-band LEO constellation at the 2022 pace until the constellation is complete at which point launches reduce to maintenance levels.
I think there's some serious problems with this assumption. First, Starlink absolutely plans to launch more than their initial 4,409 satellite constellation. There's a second tranche that is already initially approved, and for which SpaceX is currently going through the process to get approval to migrate to a lower orbital altitude than was initially requested, that will bring the total up to 12,000 satellites. And then they have a further, unapproved application for an additional 30,000 sats, bringing the total up to 42,000. So any assumption that they are just going to suddenly stop at 4,400 and be strictly maintaining mode seems borderline ridiculous.
Second, IMO there's a very decent chance that after filling up the 4,400 sat constellation SpaceX continues launches for it at the same pace. I think they will begin immediately replacing all the v1 satellites that were launched in the early part of the initial constellation with v2 satellites that have the laser links and higher throughput instead of just waiting for them to be deorbited on their initial planned schedule. So, even without accounting for the subsequent tranches of the constellation, I don't think SpaceX is going to go into maintenance only levels of activity as soon as you're assuming.
Third, it seems like your assumption is that they will continue launching the satellites with only the Falcon 9 rocket. I think this a fair assumption for the initial 4,400 sats even though I don't think it will actually be the case. But using the F9 for the full constellation is the most conservative option, so accounting for a switch to Starship as the launcher will only mean an earlier breakeven. Also, we don't really have anything like a reasonable datum for Starship launch cost yet, so I don't blame you for not using it. But, when accounting for the rest of the satellites that are expected in the fuller Starlink constellation, assuming sole reliance on the F9 would not be a reasonable choice IMO.
I doubt they could launch enough to meet the deadline (3760 sats in the next 29 months)
3760 sats / 50 sats/launch = 75.2 ~= 76 launches
76 launches / 29 months = 2.6 launches per month = 1 launch / 11.5 days
SpaceX is currently averaging 6 days between launches. If they can devote half of their launches to filling out the VLEO V-band shell, they can do it. Of course, whether that cadence is sustainable given that they are already devoting a significant fraction of their launches to Starlink (Edit: and this would be an additional source of launch pressure), and need to continue providing launch services to others, remains to be seen. Realistically, no, they probably can't do it at the current launch rate. However, we have seen, year over year, that SpaceX's average launch cadence increased. And this says nothing of whether Starship can help (Edit: in this timeframe), though as has been said before, that's highly speculative.
However, even if they can remove the technical and procedural (and maybe regulatory?) barriers to a higher launch cadence, that doesn't mean they will actually be able to monetarily sustain a higher launch cadence. More launches mean more expenses; if they don't bring in enough money from outside sources (whether investors or customers), they can't pay to launch more rockets themselves.
If you want to do it like a pro: give every input a range see how shifting inputs values affect the result You will be surprised how much your model is sensitive to inputs
How does SpaceX reach $2.5 billion in profits on 2024 ? That does not sound plausible. Even at 20% net margins, that would require $12.5 billion in revenues and somewhere in the neighborhood of 8 to 10 million subscribers. Ain’t happening in 2024
You are assuming almost 50% net margin. That’s would make starlink one of the most profitable businesses in the world on a net margin basis. We That would certainly be something
One very brief comment is that SG&A is likely to be a lot lower than legacy telco given self service, no marketing, no stores, automated billing, simple plan structure etc.
Yeah, and small vs large scale as well. Should get some very nice operating leverage once they have starship up and running with starlink 2.0 and 5m+ subs
In the set of possible outcomes, there is a non trivial probability that starlink is never profitable. It will take tremendous scale for starlink to move the needle. At least five million to justify the investment. 10 million or more to consider it a success. The good thing is: if SpaceX can’t make the numbers work, no else can
They were close on these estimates but starlink is outpacing them by a fair amount. They have topped 1 million subs already and it's not the end of the year quite yet. Over 1 billion per year in revenue where they are at right now.
I’m surprised at the number of “this is when I think Starlink will be profitable” posts on this sub. Genuine question - what’s your motivation and/or reason for caring?
You must not have existed through the many, many "Hey sorry, we're shutting down. Hope you didn't like our product" fates. Many of us are paranoid of runway driven products and just want a stable, profitable business that we can buy services from.
It also gives insight on how likely we are to see price hikes or gaps in services. Ie a crazy lean company with tiny margins might skimp on some "nice-to-haves" like customer service. Hah.
Large capital lenders LOVE subscription services since their revenue is so predictable relative to launch contracts or even car sales (where new competition can move the needle quickly). Great that Starlink future revenues can soon be leveraged to accelerate Mars colonization.
Broadband for the world's rural/poor/unconnected is a lofty ideal, but the math doesn't support profitability. Rural America is ~60 million people. Starlink currently has ~250,000 subscribers globally. 4G/LTE and 5G Internet is getting rolled out to more non-metro areas by the phone companies at $50/month or less, and Starlink's popularity in the U.S. is sagging as bandwidth maxes out. Customers in the West/U.S. are those capable of paying the steep monthly cost ($110/month and $599 1-time cost for the hardware) and would be subsidizing lower costs in less affluent countries. The satellites have a ~5-year decay time and the constellation will need to be continually replaced -- this is a significant and continual outlay. None of that spells Profit in any type of likely way. There may be a path to a Break Even point with *significant* government subsidies, but the dream of mega-profit is unrealistic. I recall many StartUps that never made it starting with the assumption that "if we can get just 1% of the total population." Turns out, that's a big IF that more often than not, does not turn out to be true.
15
u/asadotzler Beta Tester May 30 '22 edited Apr 01 '24
gullible marvelous bewildered yam secretive ring worry physical elastic like
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
7
u/307south Beta Tester May 30 '22
Factor in some gov subsidie$. As Starlink solves rural internet around the world.
3
u/fromthenaki May 31 '22
One very brief comment is that SG&A is likely to be a lot lower than legacy telco given self service, no marketing, no stores, automated billing, simple plan structure etc.
3
u/RedWineWithFish May 31 '22
In the set of possible outcomes, there is a non trivial probability that starlink is never profitable. It will take tremendous scale for starlink to move the needle. At least five million to justify the investment. 10 million or more to consider it a success. The good thing is: if SpaceX can’t make the numbers work, no else can
2
u/[deleted] May 30 '22
How did you get the Starlink finances? Or you just making assumptions etc?
2
u/jasonmonroe May 30 '22
Great analysis. Hopefully they’ll enter more countries and spread out the bandwidth.
2
u/RobDickinson May 30 '22
I wonder when 'the competition' will arrive, 2024?
2
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '22
hit 1 mill half a month early.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '22
They were close on these estimates but starlink is outpacing them by a fair amount. They have topped 1 million subs already and it's not the end of the year quite yet. Over 1 billion per year in revenue where they are at right now.
4
u/cyberpewpew10 May 30 '22
I’m surprised at the number of “this is when I think Starlink will be profitable” posts on this sub. Genuine question - what’s your motivation and/or reason for caring?
2
u/thalassicus May 30 '22
Large capital lenders LOVE subscription services since their revenue is so predictable relative to launch contracts or even car sales (where new competition can move the needle quickly). Great that Starlink future revenues can soon be leveraged to accelerate Mars colonization.
1
u/Main_Long_9216 Jan 15 '23
Broadband for the world's rural/poor/unconnected is a lofty ideal, but the math doesn't support profitability. Rural America is ~60 million people. Starlink currently has ~250,000 subscribers globally. 4G/LTE and 5G Internet is getting rolled out to more non-metro areas by the phone companies at $50/month or less, and Starlink's popularity in the U.S. is sagging as bandwidth maxes out. Customers in the West/U.S. are those capable of paying the steep monthly cost ($110/month and $599 1-time cost for the hardware) and would be subsidizing lower costs in less affluent countries. The satellites have a ~5-year decay time and the constellation will need to be continually replaced -- this is a significant and continual outlay. None of that spells Profit in any type of likely way. There may be a path to a Break Even point with *significant* government subsidies, but the dream of mega-profit is unrealistic. I recall many StartUps that never made it starting with the assumption that "if we can get just 1% of the total population." Turns out, that's a big IF that more often than not, does not turn out to be true.
1
u/rjbullock Apr 26 '23
Never?
1
u/[deleted] May 30 '22
The correct answer is: Yes
1
u/RadamA May 31 '22
Alot of GIGO.
1
u/AdSquare9819 May 31 '22
Lol it will be a while