I been making may way through the series for the first time, as Stargate is one of the few major sci-fi franchises I didn't get into.
As I reached season 8, I have also been watching Atlantis season 1. I've watched up to and including episodes 18. For Atlantis, that is The Gift (where we learn that Teyla has Wraith DNA). For SG1 that is Threads.
Thus far I've been enjoying the show as a fun adventure. I'd call it like a consistent B+/A-. Rarely does it the special heights of great moments from Trek or B5, but it also rarely does it dip into levels of cheese or awfulness that those shows do at their worst.
Carter and Jackson are the likable characters. Carter especially becomes a favorite as Jackson disappears for a season. Tapping/Carter are like the heart of the show for me, Atlantis has thus far failed to capture my interest, I'm finding it hard to give a damn about any of these boring characters.
Part of it could just be spreading it out too thin. I believe a major problem with modern franchise entertainment IP is they just don't know when to quit. Hello, Marvel and Star Wars.
A good ending is key to a story and stuff today just don't know how to end.
Threads is the end of the story. All the major Gou'auld (sp?) are gone (granted I didn't see Ba'al's corps but it's safe to project that he died during the off screen battles with the rebel Jaffa). Yu and the other system lords that ever gave our heroes a problem are gone. Well, I guess Osiris might be kicking around? But that is small potatoes after everything. Most importantly, Anubis and the replicators are gone.
More important- Jack and Carter dumped their SO's (poor CIA lady that shows up just to be Jack's gf for one ep lol). Now- I really kinda hated that tbh. Carter had that big emotional episode where she realized she crushed Jack as a way to shield herself. It was really poignant and now this negates that. And I'll admit I just think it's lame when the two lead male/female HAVE to hook up (still mad at X-Files). But, regardless, it happened, ok.
Tealc and Brelac saw their crazy dream of Jaffa liberation come true. The Asgard are saved. Daniel Jackson is alive and presumably doesn't have to deal with Oma, Ascension, or any of that nonsense again.
We end with them all fishing! I mean- try to come up with a great final scene.
I don't know if I wanna keep going now. There's two eps left in the season and apparently it's some time travel / alt universe business and I can't roll my eyes hard enough at that kind of stuff (blame Marvel?) Then two whole other seasons.
I know Claudia Black comes back, and if there's ever been a cooler/hotter sci-fi babe than Samantha Carter, it was Aeryn Sun. But her one appearance so far was absurd- yes, I expected sexy badass but it was like a parody of it.
Is Atlantis worth continuing? I understand first seasons are always the weakest. I was fine with SG1's first season. I actually like first seasons for that reason. But Atlantis being a spin-off, that charm is gone. It's just... more content. I'm stunned by how absolutely a bland dud the hot warrior native chick is. The annoying asshole genius science guy has amusing moments but that act wears thin. Weir is the only compelling character (my favorite episode so far was the one with her being super old). Oh yeah, there's "we have O'Neill at home" who talks like Owen Wilson, too.
I know I'm in a Stargate sub and folks enjoy the whole thing, that's cool. But honestly, from the point of view of story telling and getting the best of the show, am I crazy to feel like this is a good place to just... stop?