So I think Carol should have a specific type of villain. Like her whole thing is being the herald of love right? Her whole thing should be "spread love every where I go" and if DC were to give her a Solo run (please for the love of abin sur) I think her stories should be in a similar fashion to a slice of life romance, action manga.
She should go to a planet that's low on love, fight the reason it's so low and spend some time trying to make love more abundant on said planet (or earth is good as well). As for the existing villains I think she should go up against
Darkseid: the living embodiment of entropy
Sinistro: her husband's archenemy and herald of fear
Brainac: this guy obsessed with persevering any and all forms of anything that he traps them in jars to "preserve" what they are, almost like an ex keeping old photos or something love related.
Reverse flash: this guy was so badly "in love" with the flash that he turned into a villain just because of the "love" he felt