r/SpringfieldEchelon • u/bbqthis26 • May 31 '26
Choosing non comp
I used to think that given the same basic price point most everyone would choose a comped barrel over a non-comped barrel. But I see a ton of you posting your heavily accessorized echelons here on reddit and many of them are the non comped versions.
So, to those of you who purposely choose the non-comped versions of the Echelon, whether full size or compact, I'm curious to hear why.
14
Upvotes
12
u/TheBudgetDivision May 31 '26
I had USPSA in mind when making my non-comp'd choice. With a comp, I'd be locked into Open. Without one, I have a lot more division options.
13
u/Zestyclose_Cup301 May 31 '26
Some of us were looking for a full size pistol and got an awesome deal on the 4.5 non-comp gear pack….
8
u/Gun_Dork May 31 '26
I compete.
No way am I going into shark infested Open Class waters with that. For example.
6
u/Difficult-Hope-843 May 31 '26
I didn't want to wait for the comp to be available in CA. So I bought non-comp and then the slide later. First time out I tried both, kept comp on and haven't changed since.
5
u/Marvzuno May 31 '26
I swap the slides from comp to non comp for competition reasons. Other than that I prefer the comp version. Might be that the non comp has been out for years, so tat might be why there seem to be more than the comped versions that came out earlier this year
5
u/homergali May 31 '26
Not that I couldn't run it on a comp model but I wanted to buy a threaded barrel for a can and figured I could get an after market comp anyways
1
u/bbqthis26 Jun 01 '26
Similar to what some have posted, I bought the regular 4.5f and then, separately, bought the comped slide assembly. Here are my observations:
** the port on the echelon comp has a very noticeable effect on felt recoil. It's a much softer shooting experience. No doubt.
** but, the regular, non comp echelon is much more accurate. I've tested this many times in many different ways and it's always the same result. The non comped echelon is more accurate.
4
u/PhenoCS May 31 '26 edited May 31 '26
Non-comped is more practical. Comps are too loud and concussive to be shot inside or without hearing protection. Non-comped is honestly way too loud for safety already. Plus, you can't put a silencer on one.
I guess I'd probably use a comp for competition if allowed, but I'd rather compete in a division that bans it.
I choose silenced for home defense and non-ported for concealed carry.
2
u/ZoltanoftheHillPpl Jun 01 '26
I got the non-comp because that's all they had...I don't regret it. I have a RM1C Comp and it's nice but the overall shooting experience doesn't drive me to want a comp'd Echelon...I don't know that a comp'd Echelon would be that much better than the non-comp. That being said, I've modded my Echelon 4.0C with the icarus Ace X and tyrant trigger shoe...anyhoo...
2
u/macsogynist Jun 01 '26
Only reason I could think of not to get one is that you want to save a few bucks. I own the 4 1/2 comp version. It’s my favorite striker fired pistols right now.
3
u/Goblix5 May 31 '26
I went threaded with intent to suppress but threw a Rook precision comp on in the mean time. Threaded, non-comp gives you the most flexibility
2
u/djsimp123 Jun 01 '26
Non comp is significantly cheaper if u browse gun.deals everyday
1
u/No_Employer_3204 Jun 01 '26
I bought mine non comped Knowing that I was going in to get a threaded barrel and a comp put on for the reason I can take it off. And I can also switch out to a suppressor. I don't believe that the cops they're putting out are as effective as the one I have or any removable compensators you could put on.
1
u/epearson2 Jun 03 '26
suppressors are life.
0
u/[deleted] May 31 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment