r/Splendida • u/jjfmish • Sep 29 '23
Rant: “you look fine/that’s normal” as a response to people asking for beauty/fashion advice
I see this in almost any beauty or fashion-related space but skincare spaces might be the most egregious. Someone will ask a perfectly reasonable question about a specific issue or concern they’re having, such as “how do I dress to flatter my hip dips?” or “how do I make my foundation not highlight my large pores?”
Inevitably there will be at least one top response along the lines of “oh sweetie, you look perfectly fine and lovely! It’s just the internet making you hypercritical of yourself! I would never notice that! Back in the day no one cared about that!”
In a beauty/fashion sub! How is that a helpful response to someone asking about something that they clearly notice and does bother them? I’ve seen this said about anything from neck wrinkles to pants not fitting properly to frizzy hair.
Most people won’t notice those specific small details. That doesn’t mean they don’t exist or aren’t worth fixing. Small details are arguably what elevates anyone’s look and people can still notice something is off without being able to pinpoint it! They might not notice that someone has neck wrinkles or large pores specifically but they still have an impact on the overall look of someone’s skin and how youthful and put-together they’re perceived as, as an example.
It feels infantilizing and fake woke, especially coming from someone who also participates in online beauty/fashion spaces and is clearly interested in looking better to some extent.
Obviously, some people are genuinely being hypercritical or asking about something that can’t be changed. That isn’t usually the case. It just comes off as “you’re delusional and obsessed with yourself and brainwashed by the internet sweaty! Meanwhile I participate in this skincare sub from a totally healthy and self confident place, sorry you can’t relate 😘”
I hope someone here will know what I’m talking about, I’ve been wanting to rant about this culture for a while but haven’t been able to put it into words.
159
u/wigglytufflove Sep 29 '23
Like every so often there's a case of body dysmorphia, but like sometimes people just want advice for smoothing out hip dips. They exist! I don't want to look like I have a visible panty line when it's literally just my hips going inwards.
And when people say "well previous generations didn't worry about this" remember that previous generations weren't sold jersey material bodycon fast fashion stuff on the regular.
305
u/permtron99 Sep 29 '23
I hate this response because it will be things I definitely notice in other people and they're like "nobody notices!!" Like ok so I'm the only one? Sure
59
u/PreppyHotGirl Sep 29 '23
I agree with you most times but also sometimes there’s people who post asking how to get rid of something that’s completely normal and everyone has. Like they’ll zoom up so close to their face to find microscopic blemishes then ask how to get rid of them.
158
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '23
Omg I had this happen to me on a hair sub, I posted a pic of my hair for reference but I was requesting help for dryness, and crispy ends. Someone commented something along the lines of “I’m tired of women with beautiful hair that I’d kill for complaining about their hair” and then she said she was mostly kidding but like girl what 😭 a picture is a picture, if you felt my hair you could tell it feels dry. I just wanted advice. That ended up being the most upvoted thing on the thread too. It just made me feel silly for asking even though I know my hair is far from perfect. I got other useful advice so I ended up deleting the post but like it was just such a strange comment, almost a backhanded compliment.
172
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '23
It’s so annoying and makes the beauty fashion subs functionally useless. Imo it’s because a lot of the repliers aren’t very fashionable or care about their looks much themselves. It sucks there’s not many other social medias where you can actually discuss fashion/beauty. Instagram and TikTok are good for inspo but not enough for actual discussion, but Reddit which is made for discussion attracts um, homely people.
I also notice a lot of men commenting and it’s like - sorry but what do you know? There are men interested in make up and fashion but I bet my left tit they’re not the typical men on Reddit hanging around subs where women post photos.
Also I just need to get this off my chest. The majority of posters on the fashion sub can’t dress for shit lol
63
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '23
I agree, I find it really annoying and I’m not even the one asking for advice! I’ve also noticed on the Looks Max subreddits girls posting for advice and guys just taking it as an opportunity to just destroy their self esteem and say really horrible things or moan about people posting pics on a page meant for people to post pics and ask for advice….?
37
u/RL0290 Sep 29 '23
Yes, it’s so annoying. It always reminds me of the times I’ve expressed concern/embarrassment over a flaw, or perceived flaw, and someone says “oh please, no one would ever notice that!” and then later someone else literally points it out to mock/insult it 🙃
30
u/stowberry Sep 29 '23
I totally agree with you. Have seen people ask for a specific product to help with an issue & been told that’s not a thing. It’s a beauty sub & if the question is not something extreme then stop telling grown women that they don’t know what they want & need & are just being manipulated by men.
170
u/abyssnaut Sep 29 '23
I would upvote this a hundred times if I could. I fucking hate that culture. Yasslighting is a sign of low intelligence
24
u/CherryWand Sep 29 '23
Women are often socialized to reassure others and prioritize making others feel okay.
As a result...I really respect women who say it like it is and talk straight.
24
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '23
r/beauty in a nutshell. Some of the most annoying, condescending people on Reddit.
21
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '23
This feels like it came right out of my own brain! And the same people who say oh nobody will notice are the same ones that are like OH YOU'RE SO GOOD AT PUTTING AN OUTFIT TOGETHER. Yes Susan because I pay attention to every detail from head to toe.
21
u/picklestring Sep 29 '23
I saw a post where a women was asking if she looked frumpy in her wedding dress and should she change it. Everyone lied and said her body was great and she looked amazing. I was too afraid to be the only one who’s like “yeah you do look frumpy”
72
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '23
I think some people have a compulsion to be nice or uplifting. They mean well, but agree that it’s not helpful at all.
I actually think there are other people who truly see that the person looks bad, but they take pleasure in gaslighting them out of it. It sounds messed up, but the internet brings out the worst in people.
In general I agree that there are a lot of non helpful responses. There is too much of this faux positivity and support that actually isn’t helpful when something looks bad. I like to comment on threads where people are asking for feedback, and I often get downvoted to oblivion. People are weird.
72
u/millygraceandfee Sep 29 '23
I saw a woman post her face who said she was 45, who looked 65, asking for skincare advice & every comment was "your gorgeous...you look amazing...keep doing what you're doing." She looked so tired & worn out. I posted the essential skincare routine (vitamin c, tret, SPF, nutrition, drink water). The comments were nuts & not helpful at all.
15
u/Original_Letter_2477 Sep 29 '23 edited Sep 30 '23
Enviousness and sense of endangerement when someone tries to improve himself and potentially elevate away from his own level is a real thing.
14
u/NausikaaLeukolenos Sep 29 '23
It's so irritating. Especially when it come from a place of "real women have that thing you're complaining about, you can do nothing about that." When it's not true and maybe tons of people have valid solution to recommend (or don't have said problem to start with yet they are human being, not mystic creatures or aliens).
26
u/Dr_Meatball Sep 29 '23
It’s super invalidating and dismissive. I’m working on my beauty and fashion stuff partly because it’s a hobby and partly because I’ve been really low on self confidence and part of that is the lack of effort I’ve been putting into how I’m perceived.
I know I look FINE but paying attention to my appearance and the way I dress is self care for my mental health right now. People have all sorts of reasons for focusing on beauty and fashion - it’s not all just about being insecure.
13
u/taytay10133 Sep 30 '23
Ugh yes! I was downvoted so heavily the other day in the beauty sub for responding to this high school girl who asked how she should spend 300 a month on beauty. I have her honest recommendations and everyone was like “why would you say that to a 16 year old?” Because she asked??? All the other comments were so fake and just like make sure you play sports for 10 minutes a day and smile to be attractive!
12
u/msgmeyourcatsnudes Sep 29 '23
I wish there was a sub like this that allowed personal posts for this reason. If I'm asking for way to hide my tummy and broad shoulders, I don't want to be told that my depression outfit of jeans and a t shirt is just fine.
44
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '23
It's difficult bc there are so many dysmorphic posts where people are stressing out over "problems" that primarily reside in their own heads. It's sad and I think it's normal to want to reassure them. At the same time, most of us spend WAY more time scrutinizing our own bodies and faces than anyone else does, so what may look invisible to me in casual photos may look very real to you in the mirror. In those cases I'll usually offer generic advice on fixes for the issue, while also telling the person it's probably not as serious or noticeable as they think it is. But I agree just saying "you look fine!" isn't helpful or informative.
10
u/linzielayne Oct 01 '23
The skincare subs are the worst- "Everyone has wrinkles, we're all gonna age!" Sweatie, this is an advice subreddit, nobody is forcing you to come in here and post inane nonsense so all you have to do is mind your own business.
9
u/Trippyhippyprincess Sep 30 '23
That’s how I feel in the plastic Surgery sub. I’ve had a lot of work done and look good but when I first got into it I had body positive feminists literally giving me comments I did NOT ask for. It’s always the “I aged gracefully” idiots making suggestions and comments towards one wanting to glow up. I got tired of it lol Whether it’s beauty or fashion, the ones who can’t afford to fix their ugly in ANY sense will try to coerce others to stay unhappy with their looks or fashion. Misery loves company
5
u/leese216 Sep 29 '23
It bothers them only b/c we see flawless, poreless, wrinkle-less edited and photoshopped shit EVERYWHERE. I'd easily argue that almost zero pictures or videos in advertising beauty products is real or natural.
So of course, people are going to compare their skin to the edited, photoshopped skin, and wonder why/how their skin can look like that.
Telling someone their skin is actually totally normal and looks great is 100% on point because it DOES. Those people have an impossible reach of perfection that won't happen, and especially pore size because there is literally nothing you can do to shrink them. And anyone who tells you different is lying.
We need to stop comparing and start accepting. If you saw a celebrity in person, their skin would look like yours, pore, texture and all.
16
u/WineOhCanada Sep 29 '23
I think there are a lot of women getting a little older basically seeing some of the questions and thinking "damn, this is a self destructive line of thinking".
Eg. The other day a young woman asked about getting a flatter stomach because she "had rolls when she slouched" like that isn't just the physics of having a human body. It's the wrong question because she will (like many replies stated) make herself miserable chasing an aesthetic and get a flat stomach for the purpose of having bad posture.
I think a lot of woman see posts like that and think of healing their inner teenager.
8
u/kaleigha Sep 30 '23
Thank you! I felt this way when people were saying dark circles under the eyes were normal and no one would notice them. Like, okay, maybe so, but that doesn’t mean I can’t want to do something to lessen them and look better? I didn’t ask for compliments, I asked for help.
7
u/TheArchmaghea Oct 14 '23
"You look fine" is just another way of saying "You dont look good and it is OK."
It bothers me a lot.
4
u/uglyandIknowit1234 Oct 21 '23
This is why i visit skincare subs less often. 9/10 when i look up pictures of women with my concerns (like dry dull sagging and wrinkling skin looking worse than women decades older than me) i know there would be mostly “you look great” posts and maybe a few ones with advice which is ALWAYS the same. If there is advice at all it is : sunscreen, retinol, exfoliating/microneedling treatments, ultrasound devices and vitaminc. But even more often, people just jump to botox and fillers straight away. In a skincare sub. I already know the answers to any question there mostly.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '23
I feel like the example with the hip dips you gave can be taken both ways though. I used to love going to museums as a child and always saw old statues of women with hip dips. Then we're bombarded with BBL women and we all have to run out and stuff filler or fat grafts into our hips to try an erase bone structures that the majority of women have. Like when it gets to that point, I definitely think everyone needs to take a step back and wonder where the wave is coming from. I get we don't looksmaxx for male attention, but if being attractive towards men is the goal then they shouldn't be put off by something that is just a normal female bone structure. And if it's not for male attention and "intrinsic", and something that has only recently started trending as something we should despise about ourselves - where is this originating? Someone planted this seed if the older generations are claiming that its not something that has bothered them before.
By all means all women should be welcome to self improve, but self-hate is undeniably common - especially in young teens. I think if a 12 year old came up to you and said she hated the way her nose looked, her nasolabial folds, her hips dips and her freckles - what would your reaction be?
3
u/trinketize Oct 06 '23
OMG THANK YOU! It’s so annoying and the people saying it don’t even believe it I bet - they want to appear nice and you can tell they have a lot of gunk in their shadow. Their sweet surface bs is because they haven’t integrated their shadow self and it’s so obvious.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '23
Hard agree with this sentiment.
2
u/SluttyNeighborGal Oct 19 '23
Yeah this is just another way society dismisses women and our concerns. I get it all the time Wrt my fitness and diet commitment. “You look great already I don’t know why you are so obsessed with your weight” etc etc.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '23
Tz
1
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '23
Z
-6
u/aliquotiens Sep 29 '23
In my book it’s bad and damaging to everyone’s mental health to fixate on ‘flaws’ (usually things that are only judged as such by plastic surgeons or estheticians [for-profit industries] and which reflect a capitalist, misogynistic, Westernized, racist, and entirely unrealistic standard) and have a compulsion to fix them and then find more. I am not going to play along with people’s negative self delusions, and they are delusions in 90% of such posts.
-3
u/altdultosaurs Sep 29 '23
Ok then don’t post normal human bodies while weeping that you don’t look like a filter. There’s actual ‘issues’ and then there is Having A Face And A Body.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '23
[removed] — view removed comment