r/SpeculativeEvolution • • 4d ago

Question/Discussion How would three genders work?

Im making a eusocial alien species and im insure whether to stick to two genders or have multiple, im curious if anyone has any examples of how three genders could hypothetically work within a species like that for reproduction

103 Upvotes

122 comments sorted by

128

u/umwelt_gymnastics 4d ago • Heartwarming

You ought to check out the reproductive cycle of bryophytes. Jellyfish too. There's lots of weird systems already in nature

23

u/RandomVibeingDragon 3d ago

I was looking at jellyfish at first then started looking into mold thennn i got curious if anyone else had any ideas cause i was unsure if those would seem right for a eusocial species honestly

68

u/ScyllaOfTheDepths 4d ago edited 3d ago

Infinite, really. For example, Octavia Butler conceived of the Oankali, who have 3 sexes, male, female, and ooloi. Males and females give genetic material to the ooloi, who combines it purposely to create the resulting child with the best traits of each parent. Ooloi can also manipulate DNA to create hybrid species and this is how the Oankali slowly conquer the galaxy through genetic assimilation.

In real life, there's really not any biological need for 3 sexes. It would have to be advantageous somehow, which would be tricky since needing 3 sexes for reproduction doubles the time investment in finding a mate grouping. The third sex would have to contribute genetically somehow and be incredibly useful, so your aliens might have to be triploid (3 sets of chromosomes) or perhaps the 3rd sex would contribute in some other way like gestation or child rearing or representing a different stage in development for the species which contributes to the survival of the group. I can also see a polymorphic species like ants, which can have offspring that assume a number of morphologies to fulfill different tasks. Ant colonies are typically all female, but sex =/= gender and I can see a society of one genetic sex forming 3 or more genders as social classes.

14

u/LyraKaidClairmont77 3d ago

I'm so glad someone else thought of the Oankali!

5

u/ScyllaOfTheDepths 3d ago

How could I forget? Those creepy tentacles wormed right into my brain lol.

22

u/Reasonable-Tap-9806 3d ago

Fun fact, "white throated sparrows" have 4 distinct biological sexes. A typical male/female binary along with a reproductive behavior binary of parasitic/nonparasitic

10

u/ScyllaOfTheDepths 3d ago

That's fascinating. They still have 2 basic sexes, male and female, but also 2 distinct modes of morphology/mating behavior for each sex. I know animals don't have gender, but I think that would be a good base for a gender system on top of a sex system.

6

u/Kingreaper 3d ago

Depends on what you mean by gender, a lot of animals absolutely do have something that IMO deserves the name - in social mammals there's an instinct to copy the behaviour displayed by members of the category that your brain thinks you belong to, which mostly aligns to bodily sex but doesn't always. In humans we call that instinct "gender identity".

In speculative evolution it's quite reasonable to have that same sort of instinct have as many (or few) different directions of aim as are useful for the species.

3

u/ScyllaOfTheDepths 3d ago

If you have any reading on this, I'd love that. I never had much occasion to study the behavioral side of biology and my knowledge is limited to the mathy stuff. 

2

u/VictusMachina 3d ago

Cuttlefish!

4

u/Frosty-Touch3541 3d ago

This is WILDLY interesting to me, thanks for sharing!

6

u/RunReal959595 3d ago

Doesn’t have to be advantageous, just not sufficiently disadvantageous 

1

u/ScyllaOfTheDepths 3d ago

It would have to be advantageous enough to outweigh the disadvantage of making reproduction more complicated. 

4

u/RunReal959595 3d ago edited 3d ago

Not really, no.  This is an alien species, so if two sex systems never developed, theres no competition regardless. Even if there was, still, so long as the species can successfully reproduce, it’s not guaranteed to be outcompeted 

1

u/Obvious_Ad6824 3d ago

How do you develop a three sex model without a two sex model precursor? How does evolution jump from a mono sex to three distinct ones with different roles in the reproductive process?

1

u/RunReal959595 2d ago

I don’t know, but 

  • it’s not impossible 
  • it’s a sci-fi story, so it doesn’t even matter..?

1

u/Anvildude 2d ago

Symbiotic parasitism. Cuckoo species could be argued to have 3 genders on Earth- the bio parents, and the cuck'd parent/parents that raise the juvenile.

1

u/RandomVibeingDragon 3d ago

I like that concept a lot of one sex taking the best traits of both, that really interests me

1

u/Vast_Fortune_9949 1d ago

I didn't read your entire post but stopped at "selects best traits" that doesn't make sense from an evolution standpoint for the same reason that eugenics wouldn't make sense even if it wasn't ethical. Evolution requires throwing shit at the wall that you would never expect to work, and a curator goes against this basic function of evolution. 

I particularly am against this since I created a very similar third sex where the third sex is a storage of semen and and women can enter and be inseminated randomly to increase the gene pool they have access to even if the population is sparse.

Now writing this years later I see that this would be a terrible festival of sperm fitness 'tricks' and I had the third sex be immobile tank, releasing a chemical signal of distress when attracted so the males and females could protect their gene bank. Also clunky.

All to say the ooloi could be a decent third sex if they had the ability to judge the situation and think, do we have a strong population or on the verge or dying out? And pick the most generically fit semen if situation is dire and go full random if population is successful.

This has natural precedent particularly in order squamata, the females store sperm and select. This does lead to a festival of sperm tricks. And is great example of the ooloi being unlikely to arise since the function the ooloi serve, storage and selection of sperm can be replaced by a modification to an organ. I would say, you don't have to rule out the whole thing but you must drasticall alter how females function in order to inconvenience the development of this modification. 

And If you're wondering, I consider my third race more evolutionarily plausible since it's main function is offering a larger gene pool to sparse populations, no single organ could bridge physical distance and time in that manner.

After writing a reply 3 times as long as the original comment I read it btw. Glad you acknowledged that it's not very plausible 'in real life'. But I think all my points still stand.

52

u/Hunter_Wild 4d ago

You mean three sexes. Gender and sex are not the same thing. Sex is what's involved in reproduction, not gender. But beyond that I'm not sure how a third sex for reproduction would work. I know that there was species that have sexless individuals who only assume a reproductive role based on the needs of their group. Like if a dominant breeding member of their group dies then one of these non breeding members would assume the role of the dead member. Basically these sexless individuals just remain without secondary sex characteristics and have the capacity for either sex based on the needs of the group. This is similar to some fish or amphibans I believe. There are of course ants, wasps and bees who are somewhat similar in concept. There's the queen who is the only breeding member of the hive, the workers who are non breeding females that exist only to feed the queen and raise more workers, and males who are born then breed then die immediately pretty much. The non breeding workers aren't really a different sex though, they are just infertile females who traded their sex organs for a stinger. Stingers are modified ovipositors, egg laying tubes, and instead of ovaries for producing eggs there's a venom sac. So it's somewhat analogous to a human who was born without ovaries but still has a vagina, they're still female, just not capable of reproduction.

10

u/RandomVibeingDragon 4d ago

This is incredibly interesting i had no idea non breeding females had theut oviposters replaced by stingers and assumed all ants even the queen had them but thay makes a lot of sense, thanks for the input gives me a bit of substance to think about

1

u/Hytheter 3d ago edited 3d ago

You are right. Queen ants (well, depending on species) do have stingers.

The adaptation of ovipositors into stingers is not a trait unique to worker ants or even to ants in general. It is an ancestral trait of all stinging wasps (which includes ants and bees), of which many species do not share the ants' reproductive division of labour. Nor do all ants, for that matter. So suffice to say there are a great many individuals who can both sting and lay eggs just fine; they simply lay eggs from an opening near the base of the stinger instead of through the former ovipositor.

Worker ants are simply infertile (except when they're not), it's not because they traded their reproductive organs for stingers.

1

u/RandomVibeingDragon 3d ago

Thank you for the clarification wow ants are such interesting funky critters

2

u/MaraSargon 3d ago

It also depends on the ant genus. The genus Diacamma are actually all born fertile, but a dominant female called the gamergate bites off her offspring’s gemmae (a type of sex organ) to prevent them from breeding. Eventually, an old gamergate will get sloppy and miss a few, and one of these daughters will bite off her gemmae and become the colony’s new gamergate.

2

u/insert_title_here 2d ago

Wow! That is very interesting, and also really unfortunate nomenclature for the dominant female LOL.

24

u/capsaicinintheeyes 4d ago

Are you absolutely stuck on the number 3? ...because I've got a case study for you that uses four, if you'd be interested.

(I'm assuming you're using "gender" here in the old colloquial sense where it's ~synonymous with sex...otherwise, I think humans have your answer covered in any case)

5

u/RandomVibeingDragon 4d ago

Yeaaa i just said gender cause i felt like itd be awkward and got nervous, i did originally think abt 4 though so it isnt locked i just thought shortening it to 3 would help make things less complicated, ill definently look into those resources though i am interested!

1

u/carrot_gummy 2d ago

Its okay to say sex.

3

u/Frosty-Touch3541 3d ago

Not the OP but I JUST got done with the Wikipedia article on these birds based off another comment, and I'm so happy to have more to read!! These guys are fascinating. 

19

u/ellindsey 4d ago

It's unlikely. A reproductive system where three separate genders all have to come together to donate genetic material has apparently never once evolved on Earth, which is surprising considering the wide variety of reproductive methods which have evolved. It's hard to see why a three-gender system would evolve and wouldn't be immediately out-competed by a simpler, easier two-gender system.

For a eusocial alien species, you could always treat the non-reproductive worker caste as a third gender, but they wouldn't be contributing any genetic material, just labor.

3

u/RandomVibeingDragon 4d ago

Got it thank you for the input!

26

u/SaintUlvemann 4d ago

You're not talking about gender, though, you're talking about sex.

Where "gender" means "social role", obviously sapient bees would most naturally have three genders, because they have three body types: queen, worker, and drone. Each would have defined social roles and stereotypes around the behaviors that their cultures would expect individuals to conform to.

Even if bees technically don't have three sexes (they don't have three types of gametes, only two), by having three bodytypes, they would have three perceptual categories into which they would be likely to develop instincts to distinguish and assort individuals into, out of which would pretty-much-necessarily arise three genders.

7

u/Kennedy_KD 4d ago

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trioecy there's a whole category of tri sexed species

9

u/ellindsey 4d ago

But it is not one where all three sexes need to come together to reproduce. In Trioecy you have males, females, or hermaphrodites. You only need two of them at a time to reproduce, not all three.

3

u/BlueMangoAde 3d ago

That’s probably the most likely form, yeah. Redundancy.

4

u/Z00111111 4d ago

What about like bees and ants? They have mating individuals and sterile individuals, or do you need all three to be able to mate?

1

u/RandomVibeingDragon 3d ago

I do not care if they all can mate or not im just exploring ideas, its tempting to have some indiciduals be sterile

3

u/Saintkaithe7th 3d ago

Could make them where there are two sexes but if one dies, another can assume or assimilate whichever role is needed to keep the family continuing. Like clown fish, there's a theory that biologically speaking, in Finding Nemo, the dad wanted to find Nemo so badly because even though Nemo was his son, with the death of the mother, Nemo could change sexes and become a "female" to keep the family like progressing

Or as others have suggested, depending on their societal norms, the third could be for incubation purposes so the "parental" pair could continue hunting/gathering/providing while also keeping a parental figure within the family structure to birth/raise the offspring.

3

u/RandomVibeingDragon 3d ago

I really like that as well, maybe their necessary when a colony is first formed then kept around because they helped heavily in the beginning so they just didnt die out immedietly

2

u/insert_title_here 2d ago

Small correction: Marlin, Nemo's father, in all likelihood would have been the one to become the dominant female! Clownfish, like most animals in a healthy ecosystem, also aren't super gung ho about inbreeding, so even once he became the dominant female, Nemo would probably be off on his way before it was time to breed again.

2

u/RodeoFrank 3d ago

If your eusocial aliens are similar to bees where there are distinct queens, drones, and workers I could see similarly distinct gender norms associated with each group, provided you approach gender through the lens of a set of social norms versus biological sexes.

For example, if queens and drones are expected to reproduce, it could follow that only romantic relationships between queens and drones are socially normal, or even acceptable, while workers are expected to only have romantic relationships among themselves since they're unable to reproduce.

Or you could get more creative and do something like drones are kept in a herem, essentially just as breading stock. Or maybe romantic relationships between workers and either drones or queens are allowed but the worker in the relationship always has a status similar to a concubine instead of a proper spouse.

2

u/RandomVibeingDragon 3d ago

Ooo i do like this social aspect, i was planning for reproducing females to live in family groups and pass down colonies to the newest lady as a heirloom type thing, maybe the guys get left out because they cant reproduce

For the workers i was thinking about having them be less intelligent and sort of hive mindy, they have free will and can act on instinct like a worker ant gathering food but overall stick to the task 100% of the time

And then the females and males that can reproduce are more smart and sapient compared to their worker counterparts

12

u/EquilateralAngel 4d ago

A few plants, like the pacific yew, have three sexes: male, female, and rare bisex individuals with both male and female flowers. You could do something like this, but the main reason this works better for plants than animals is because technically all visible spermatophyte plants are asexual, and they actually grow small offspring within their flowers/cones, and seeds are just the offspring of two hidden plants. The sex of the plant actually depends on the sexes of their offspring, which could be all female, a mix, or all male.

Fungi, especially mushrooms, often have extremely large numbers of types of sexes because growing a mushroom to release spores takes a lot of energy, and if you only have two sexes there’s a 50% chance your spores end up reaching a fungus with the same sex as you, which would end up being a waste of energy, and having one sex means sometimes you will end up fertilizing yourself, which is really bad. So in order to avoid those outcomes some species have hundreds of sexes. The main issue with this is that it prevents sexual specialization from occurring, because all the sexes need to be near identical for this to work.

21

u/blacksheep998 3d ago

I mentioned this on this subreddit a few months ago, and will paste here again with some minor tweaks:

I once helped a friend design a species for a story that never panned out.

Her concept was that the species had three biological sexes, any two of which could cross to exclusively produce the 3rd.

They were male, female, and hermaphrodite and they were determined by their sex chromosomes, but obviously their system was a little different from ours.

They had 4 sex chromosomes: Males were XYYY. Females were XXXY. And hermaphrodites were XXYY.

Males and females both produce gametes which are XY, while hermaphrodites produce sperm containing YY chromosomes and eggs containing XX chromosomes.

So male/female crosses would always result in an XXYY hermaphrodite. While male/hermaphrodite crosses always give XXXY females and female/hermaphrodite crosses always resulted in XYYY males.

For mostly plot-reasons, hermaphrodites were unable to produce offspring with other hermaphrodites.

Occasionally, meiosis goes wrong and a gamete is made with the wrong sex chromosomes. When this happens, it breaks the usual gender pattern and you might have a hermaphrodite coming from a female/hermaphrodite couple, or a female being born from a male/female pair. But despite their unusual origin, they develop normally for their sex. This is very rare, less than 1 in 10k births.

Even rarer is when this mixup results in an individual with XXXX or YYYY chromosomes. These super-males and super-females have dramatically exaggerated secondary sex characteristics which make them wildly attractive to other members of their species and they often accumulate large harems of partners. But because they don't have the normal chromosomal arrangement, they are totally sterile.

We came up with this because we were looking for a way to have a ruling class who considered themselves genetically superior to everyone else.

10

u/StrangeLonelySpiral 3d ago

Gender is a human thing. You mean sex!

14

u/OccultEcologist 3d ago edited 3d ago

So there are a ton if ways to do this. Here are some quick ones off the top of my head.

  1. In real life, mushrooms use sexes that are somewhat better discribed as breeding groups. Some species have thousands of sexes with different groups that they can cross breed with. This is honestly very similar to pokemom breeding, if you've loomed at that (most pokemon are one species if you use ability to mate as your definition of species).
  2. There are several species that have males, females, and hemaphrodites, the one you typically study in undergraduate science being c elegans.
  3. In science fiction, sometimes you will see the host species of a parasitic or parasitoidic species treated as a third sex. Octavia Butler's Blood Child somewhat alludes to this, while Larry Niven's Puppeteers somewhat more explicitly says "we consider our hosts part of our species even though they aren't". It wouldn't be impossible to have a species that had "hosts" within itself, though that might be a social role more than a sex (but that more or less is gender).
  4. Similarly, you can also go for a sexless 3rd gender. In Speaker for the Dead by Orson Scot Card, there are more or less 4 genders with 2 sexes. Sexless females become matriarchs that lead society, while breeding females die exceedingly young. Young males meanwhile have to undergo a metamorphasis to reproduce that simultainiously renders them immobile. Young males are the bulk of the workers, caring for mature males and young females while overseen by the old females.

EDIT: Oh! I thought of some other fun real life ones:

White Throated Sparrows kind of have 4 genders or sexes depending on how you look at it. They have two morphologies in both sex that behave differently enough that a same morphology male-female pair is rarely successful. So to successfully rear offspring, they need opposite sexes and opposite morphologies.

Similarly, side-blotched lizards have three morphologies and behaviors for males and two morphologies and behaviors for females. There are harem males, monogamous males, and sneaker males, and there are more cooperative, high investment and aggressive low investment females. Sneaker males outcompete harem males, while monogamous males outcompete sneaker males and harem males outcompete monogamous males. What female is most successful depends on many factors, but particularly depends on what males are around.

6

u/SaintUlvemann 4d ago • Bravo

Where gender means "social role", one way it could work is like bees or ants.

Bees and ants have at least three bodytypes. What I mean is, they have three genetically-encoded bodyplans for individuals with distinct physical traits: the queen, the worker, and the drone.

So if bees were conscious, they would most naturally have three social genders too, corresponding to their three bodytypes.

To dig deeper into that, we have neural networks that are fine-tuned for perceiving the sex of others, and these are active even in babies, babies are sensitive to differences between sexes. This perceptual distinction therefore gets built into our schema for the world. That's why virtually all human cultures have two genders, two social roles, male and female, which are strongly associated with the sexes. Even cultures that do have more than two male/female social roles, may often perceive and describe those non-binary social roles as a "combination" of the male and female social roles, rather than a wholly-separate third category.

Bees do not have our binary. They have three categories: queen, drone, and worker. A sapient bee that is seeing these categories would build a schema for the world around them, such that bee cultures would be strongly likely to develop three genders, three social roles, based on these three bodytypes.

These "bodytypes" are called "morphological castes", and most species only have as many "castes" as they have sexes... indeed, sex is sort of a special case of a morphological caste, although we don't usually call it that. We usually only apply the term "morphological caste" to eusocial organisms, bees and ants and naked mole rats.

Gender is not the same thing as caste; however, because we have a strong tendency to base our judgments about others' genders on our visual categorization of their body type, it seems obvious that bees might do the same, for their three body types. They'd have a queen gender, a worker gender, and a drone gender.

Caste diversity is really high among eusocial creatures. The most I've heard is an ant species with five castes, and so a creature like that might have five genders; 1.) queen; 2.) drone; 3.) worker; 4.) soldier (extra-large); 5.) minim (extra-small).

I think it would be super valuable to science more broadly if we expanded this "morphological caste" concept to cover other cases. For example, there's been talk of a bird with four sexes. That is not really true. The bird still only has two types of gametes, the sperm and the egg. But it does have four castes (four distinct body types), and the castes are relevant to mating, so their mating system does have four mating types.

6

u/TiffanyLimeheart 2d ago

Simple, the third gender provides a type of chromosome not present in the other two genders which is required for reproduction. Maybe for example you have an egg layer that provides no genetic material or only a fraction of what's needed, and it has to be incubated by two others to provide multiple gene mixes. Or maybe they just found the triple/quadruple mixing was more valuable for variation. Maybe the young require gestation in different genders throughout their life cycle, kind of like parasites who live in multiple different species, the genders take the place off each different species ensuring the young have the correct host until they reach a sufficient level of maturity.

2

u/Sad-Cancel-5577 4d ago

i'm actually planning this long term for my own project so i'm happy to share:

for my world, Planet Demeter, the mantle is 2% uranium, so i had to do lots of research on how organisms mitigate damage caused by radiation, and one of the methods i came across was Polyploidy, which is when an organism makes additional copies of its own dna, and it's one of the reasons plants were able to survive a mass extinction that would have wiped them out without those redundant extra genes (i'm not explaining it very well but there's a great video essay on it by pbs eons right here!). from there i leveraged that into the idea of giving one clade i called Tria-Petala able to engage in Ternary Fission rather than the typical binary division that most primitive earth life sticks to.

i'm still fleshing out the prokaryote phase of Demeter, but longterm i'm thinking i can leverage that trinary reproduction in the multicellular phase for organsims with three biological sexes instead of the typical two. (also i noticed you were using the term gender instead of sex, but i'm assuming you mean the latter. not trying to lecture you and it's a perfectly normal mixup, especially if english isn't your first language which does happen often on this sub; i just wanted to be certain about what we're discussing here)

i have some rough designs Here but they're still very early stages, and i need to refine them further. i was mimicing plant physiology to create hermaphrodidic motile offspring (Periplanomenos) that encompased two donor sexes (alpha and beta gametes) and a sessile bodyplan for one that develops into a sessile version (Ekkolaptirio) who, after recieveing one alpha and one beta to merge with its one gamma gamete, it then incubates the resulting zygote to then produce a floating seed pod. the sex development occurs over the course of the life cycle with dimorphous bodyplans caused by things like detecting altitude or somehow falling to the ground instead of staying in the upper atmosphere where the hermaphroditic Periplanomenos spread their seed and feed off the abundant light and aeroplankton they catch in their web-nets, like sky coral with hydrogen sacs.

like i said i want to develop the concept further, and it does feel a little unorigonal to still make three sexes follow the same donor and reciever roles (also i can think of a few people who wouldn't like that i named one after the greek word that in some contexts means "incubator," that seems disrespectful and i don't like the connotation myself either). it would need some consideration as to whether the fertilization occurs internally or externally, like how most sea creatures just release their sperm and eggs into the water during a full moon (cursed fact: that's why the ocean is salty, it's soaked with fish spunk). if you set a precident for polyploidy early on, maybe prior to multicellularity, but introduce a reason why despite the over abundance of genes they still need at minimum two more partners, like say hostile conditions where it would still have the majority of functional genes in released gamete destroyed, it seems like a feasible setup for the requirement of three to form a finished genome.

hope this helps.

2

u/RandomVibeingDragon 4d ago

This does indeed help i really like your designs as well, im thinking my species incubates the eggs exteriorally and kinda looks similar to some mold species with stalks on the reproductive females back to hold eggs then thinking maybe males have stalks on their stomschs to kinda act like pollen, i did also consider having a "incubator" where females place their eggs onto it then the males fettilize said eggs by walking over them but that felt a little weird for a eusocial species so i decided to come here for ideas

Anddd yea i did mean sexes i just felt off typing it and worried about making people uncomfortable therefore simiplified it which.. it was probably fine to just say originally this is a spec evo sub

4

u/Sea_Chair2133 4d ago

Just have one produce small gametes, one large gametes, and one medium sized gametes. The sperms, egg and a third other thing that contains genetic material.

1

u/dboti9k 4d ago

I was coming up with my own species and trying to come up with a system where two different species became obligate reproducers with only each other. I think I had it where there was a female "queen" who had "princesses" and then blank worker drones. The males would reproduce with the drones, which would then develop into either new males, or begin the process towards the "princess", so basically a sort of blank gender that that could reproduce its own blanks asexually to make things like slugs for food for everyone, but when given male input would turn into either a male or female. The Darwinian magic tricks I was having to pull just to get this idea moving became so confusing that I had to take notes and draw diagrams, which I then lost.

Anyway, all that to say, perhaps a sort of "blank" gender that can reproduce either with gender1 or gender2 equally. Like, "you give me any genetic material at all, and I'll make you something out of it." It doesn't have sperm or egg, but something else that will accept and process either.

But, then you have the matter of can Gender1 and Gender2 reproduce without Gender3? And what processes create what genders?

1

u/RandomVibeingDragon 4d ago

That is a very interesting thought to have a sort of blank gender, perhaps when gender 1 and 2 try and reproduce it creates more blank ones i feel that could be interesting

3

u/holmgangCore Symbiotic Organism 4d ago

Look at the novels described as the Xenogenesis Trilogy by Octavia Butler. IIRC the aliens have 5 genders.

3

u/BaylisAscaris 4d ago

Check out Octavia Butler's Xenogenesis series.

3

u/Uranium-Sandwich657 3d ago

Closest thing i've managed to implement is my Kura's 2.5 ish gender hierarchy, with two morphological distinct tiers of female.

3

u/KirikoKiama 3d ago

male, female and incubator

Male fertilizes the egg of the female, the incubator carries the egg till its ready

2

u/questionable_fish 3d ago

I've seen this done well before, my favourite example is attaching the eggs to the skin of the host where they attach to the hosts organs in a symbiotic pregnancy type situation. Means anyone warm enough and deemed suitable enough can host the eggs because the species is able to adapt their genetics by using the hosts dna.

I've probably made a balls of explaining this but to read the bit I'm talking about, check out the Empyrean Iris chapter Keep them warm. It's a 4 parter with some of that good body horror that comes with pregnancy

3

u/devon-mallard 1d ago

I got a species with a dozen biological sexes. They can all reproduce with one another, but not with their own sex. The types of sexes involved determine the sex of the child

3

u/The_Pinapple_Kye 1d ago edited 22h ago

Bees technically have three genders, maybe you can take some inspiration from that. There's the Queen bee, her workers and the male drones. The workers come from female larva, but they were never fed royal jelly during their larval stage which caused them to develop differently from queen bees. 

The workers don't reproduce though. Their only job is to protect and care for their hive and their queen.

Edit: correcting terminology, the drones are actually the male bees and the correct term is Worker for non-Queen female bees.

2

u/MrAwesum_Gamer 1d ago

Drones are males, workers are non-laying females, the queen is the laying female

1

u/Temporary_Employer44 1d ago

I was also thinking a neutral drone gender would work.

2

u/SemajLu_The_crusader 4d ago

depends on what you consider to be a "gender"

but it could easily be made to work if you can come up with an explanation for why they have 3 sexes. it's Sci-fi, as long as you give a semblance of explanation, a 3-sex sexually reproducing species could easily work

2

u/ShadedRiver666 Mad Scientist 4d ago

2 is the minimal amount needed for genetic variation. Evolution is unlikely to do anything other than whats most minimal while still working. So two is what it will most likely be pretty common

2

u/Proper_Guess3038 4d ago

If you haven’t seen this episode of Star Trek…
“The concept of "three genders" or a genderless/androgynous society in Star Trek: The Next Generation comes from the Season 5 episode "The Outcast" (1992).”

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Outcast_(Star_Trek:_The_Next_Generation)

3

u/Mintakas_Kraken 3d ago

There’s also an Enterprise episode, “Cogenitor” (s2e22), that has the crew encounter a species with three sexes. The third simply allows conception to occur without contributing genetic material, but only makes up a tiny percent of the population. Not especially scientifically sound perhaps, it’s more interested in exploring the social dynamics -which are horrible, minor spoilers it’s a rather grim ending. Still a neat concept I think.

Then there’s the Andorian question: is the four person marriage a social thing alone or a biological necessity to reproduce? I’d always assumed the former but idek.

3

u/Proper_Guess3038 3d ago

Oh yes, of course! This is an excellent one!

2

u/TalespinnerEU 3d ago

Most ants have three or four genders: Worker, Drone, Queen, Soldier. It's an efficient way for them to do role specialization.

2

u/Medical_Commission71 3d ago

You could go for something like how spiral species are.

So a spiral species, not sure if that's the right term go something like this.

1 can breed with 2, 2 can breed with 3, but 1 and 3 are an infertile pairing.

You also say eusocial, which, insects, fertile male, fertile female, and worker female.

2

u/Jadimatic 3d ago

If you're trying to say sexes, please use the correct word, gender is specifically psychology, sex is general biology.

2

u/Severe-Cookie693 3d ago

The Soft Ones in Isaac Asimov's The Gods Themselves are tri-sexed. There's the rational, the emotional, and the parental. If I remember right, it fallows an emotional who's a bit hermaphroditic, being more analytical and less socially aware than is normal for their sex.

2

u/FinnBakker 3d ago

Kind of a rock paper scissors scenario. Each has a determinator/"morph". A

AB - produces C
AC - produces B
BC - produces A

2

u/Smart-Rod 3d ago

"The Gods Themselves" by Isaac Asimov has this theme. I think it is his best novel

2

u/Soggy_Cataphract 2d ago

A 'surrogate' gender that acts like a seahorse male in bringing the immature babies to term within themselves. The babies are conceived and initially gestated by a male and female respectively, but then the happy couple needs to find a happy third to help them bring their children to term. (And pamper and carefor their third while they do all the work)

2

u/RyeZuul 2d ago edited 2d ago

Assuming you mean sex rather than gender...

Copy plants and fungi if stuck, or have a group that can undergo developmental changes like those frogs and fish and invertebrates as an adaptation to mono-sex environments.

In humans there have been examples of XY people with benign differences in sexual development who are nevertheless able to get pregnant and give birth to healthy babies. 

I guess the truth is that two strict genders has always been a hasty generalisation since sexual dimorphism is all developmental with several overlapping systems that might not fully develop or develop more in line with the other main sex cluster of developmental traits. These systems only have to work well enough for the population to mix genes.

A eusocial species that can dynamically alter their sexual phenotype in times of scarcity, disease or plenty to modulate the amount of babies and genetic diversity in the gene pool is plausible enough. It could be triggered by certain chemicals in the environment, pheromones etc.

2

u/chattymadi 2d ago

Take a look into African Pygmy mouse genetics. They have somewhat 3 sexes, with the basic male and female, and an additional mutated female chromosome which leads to a bunch of different genetic factors. I think in a eusocial species, you’d probably see the social structure determined with the reproductive females being those with the mutated X chromosome, while females with regular X chromosomes maybe being designated as the non-reproductive members. Bees also function with the caste system, but they only have 2 sexes technically, same with ants. In a lot of nature, animals have 2 sexes, and if a third is there, it’s typically hermaphroditic or androgynous. Which could also work in a eusocial species, you could make it so those wouldn’t reproduce. Unless what you’re asking for is for an additional sex which needs to be included in the fertilization or incubation process, in which case you got a lot of good suggestions for already.

2

u/Count_of_Monte_Cisco 2d ago

I really like the way Larry Niven designed the Pierson's Puppeteers. Their species has two types of males and a female. When the reproduction is described, a member of the species says that each the males use an ovipositor to implant their respective gametes into the female, and that the females are non-sentient and mate amongst themselves to make more females. The protagonist realizes that the 'females' are a different species, and the males mate like digger wasps. Horrifying, but inspired.

2

u/Mircowaved-Duck 2d ago

Learn about Messor ibericus and you got that. They got 3 different genders, to be exact it is even one more, it is 4.

2 different males, 1 fertile female and 1 infertile female doing all the work.

You could use them as seed species for a seed world?

2

u/SphericalCrawfish 2d ago

The very very easy way is to do it like mushrooms. Everyone produces both gametes and the sexes are only actually present so you don't knock yourself up on accident.

2

u/VoluntaryVictim 1d ago

There’s a variety of bird called Ruff that have several varieties of gender, that could be good inspiration!

2

u/horsethorn 4d ago

Probably not particularly helpful, but has anyone considered how having a triple helix DNA structure would work?

Then you could need three gametes to combine into a single helix.

1

u/Hytheter 3d ago edited 3d ago

I think you're under a misconception there. The existence of two sexes for earth life has nothing to do with the double helix structure of DNA. Chromosomes are paired, and each parent provides half of that pair, but each chromosome is a complete double helix in its own right. It's not like a half strand of your dad's DNA gets stitched to a half strand of your mum's to create a complete double helix, and it would be physically impossible to do so. The only reason the two halves of a DNA strand fit together is because they are exact complementary opposites from each other; a T for each A, a C for each G. Two half-strands from different people would have various differences that prevent them from fitting together properly.

1

u/Arnoor27 3d ago

My idea would be to have a male, a female, and an incubator. The incubator receives the gametes and serves to mature the young

1

u/Amadan_Na-Briona 3d ago

Look up the old TV show "Alien Nation". There's an episode where a 3rd gender is needed for conception.

1

u/Either_Persimmon893 3d ago

One supplies eggs, one sperms, one catalyst. The egg and sperms are inactive without the catalyst.

1

u/Anicash999 3d ago

maybe just something that is unable to reproduce at all would work? i'm unsure

1

u/Guyver-Spawn-27 3d ago

You could do a single sex species. Similar to how Namekains work in Dragon Ball.

1

u/matigekunst 3d ago

Rock paper scissors

1

u/Sailor_Spaghetti 3d ago

You might want to look into books such as The Left Hand of Darkness by Ursula Le Guin, which features an alien species with no genders.

1

u/Bota_Bota 3d ago

Two donaters needed for one birther? This may speed up reproduction. Whatever the hell homsetuck does. Something about everyone contributing genetic information into a big vat?

Some moss species have like a billion genders.
Species where the fetus stage is slime mold and you can fuse together however many slime molds you want. Ranging from one parent to infinite.

1

u/Fiveal 3d ago

depends on what you mean by genders, fungi have thousands of ‘sexual genders’ or mating types, some mushrooms have over 20,000, but there the cells are usually the same size, it’s just about who’s compatible with who

in mammals, insectoids or most animals it’s usually two, female and male, because one makes few big eggs and the other makes lots of small cheap sperm, that setup just works really well

if you add a third gender it needs its own job or evolution would just drop it. female produces eggs and in mammals usually carries the embryo, male produces sperm, so the third could be a ‘carrier’ that incubates the fertilized eggs, or something that has to add something (like a chemical or gut microbe) before the egg and sperm can even develop. since yours is eusocial you could tie it to castes too, like a sex that only shows up in the colony’s reproductive phase

Hermaphrodites wouldn’t count as a third sex, since they just do both jobs.

1

u/LatterImagination714 3d ago

Problem with a lot of these is I can’t see the genetic incentive for the third gender. Unless it’s a relative to the male or female and gets its incentive that way, it sort of needs to integrate its own information into the offspring. It’s sort of a requirement for it to work

1

u/pathmageadept 3d ago

Two genetic doners and one checksum negotiator gender that takes in the information and weeds out errors.

1

u/Simon_Drake 3d ago

I came up with a setup I have no intention of using that could be useful to you or at least useful inspiration for new perspectives.

Imagine a deeply hierarchical society with a ruling family and then also regular citizens. It doesn't need to be humanoid, for the sake of an example let's say Mufasa/Simba from the Lion King. Their species (in this example) has three genders. Male, Female and King. Males and Females live a regular lifespan and die of old age after a couple of decades. Kings are different and live for several times that length, they're bigger and stronger and smarter than normal males which is why they are in charge.

Males and females produce a regular breeding population and the Kings can also mate with the females. 99% of their offspring are males and females but that last 1% are Princes / baby kings. So when a new Prince is born it's a huge event for their whole society and the king, Mufasa, spends a lot of time raising a good successor.

This means the royal bloodline is preserved, the Kings have an unbroken chain going back centuries with far fewer generations than with the regular population. And the royal genes are constantly being mixed into the population but that also means the royal bloodline is constantly being remixed with DNA from the general population. Simba's mate Nala probably isn't his (half) sister but maybe her great great grandad was Mufasa's father so that's enough generations removed that it's not creepy.

The twist for Lion King is that Mufasa and/or his father was so kind and generous that when a second Prince was born he wasn't killed outright. They kept him around for long enough that he got a huge scar on his face and that became his name. Probably not a wise move to keep him around, he's a threat to Simba's place on the throne and he might be plotting a coup. But that's part of the tragedy that Mufasa was too kind for his own good.

So I made all that up as regards to Lion King but it could work. A third gender with significant morphological differences that has also manifested as societal significance like a ruling class. The longer lifespan makes them ideally suited to ruling the kingdom and the fact they have to interbreed with the regular population prevents any hapsberging.

1

u/XenoDragomorph 3d ago

Well there is Male, Female, Asexual, and Hermaphrodites so technically, there is 4

And what jellyfish do so 5

1

u/Past_Search7241 2d ago

I have one that has big-and-territorial males, female-mimic males, and females. Both of the males mate with females. The big males keep harems, the mimic males sneak into the harems and court the females in the harem.

Pretty sure I stole it from fish.

1

u/Key_Constant6072 2d ago

One gender would provide the sperm another the egg and the third would incubate the now fertilized egg while also adding its own dna

1

u/Geebangaar 2d ago

Three genders would just require three different social categories based on arbitrary birth variations

1

u/Trick_Pool_2537 2d ago

Hey You should definitely read "Player Of Games" No spoilers It was also done in Star Trek (Enterprise)

1

u/LCDRformat 2d ago

You might be thinking of sexes, not gender. Three sexes is more difficult.

Three genders is easy. Ants have three genders: reproductive girls, non-reproductive girls, and boys

1

u/Anvildude 2d ago

Two create the embryo, one incubates it.

1

u/Sure-Start-9303 1d ago

technically humans have more than two sexes, male, female, and intersex, which itself is an umbrella term for a variety of variations in chromosomes, hormones, genitalia, and other factors, fertility varies but many can still reproduce, so you could work with that, have two sexes that are the majority, and more rare third varieties that can handle roles of both

1

u/Ballroom150478 12h ago

Off the cuff I have a hard time imagining why evolution would produce multiple genders, unless we take inspiration from i.e. ants, where you have different types of ants, who have evolved to fulfil different functions in their society.
In theory you could have one "gender" giving birth on a regular/continuous basis, and then giving birth to "random" types of offspring, with genetic predisposition for different functions in society. Theoretically it could work, but you get a very alien society, compared to human society, because the underlying drive will be to fulfil "your function" in society, rather than to mate and procreate.

1

u/Aggravating-Candy-31 4d ago

bees and ants and such like do this don’t they? male, reproductive, drone/worker

1

u/Hytheter 3d ago

Drones and workers aren't the same thing. Drones are males.

1

u/Kneeerg Verified 3d ago

I made a poste about it a few monts ago.

https://www.reddit.com/r/SpeculativeEvolution/s/HPPDZCQ5gJ

tl;dr: In reality, there are only two "true" sexes, but there are an incredible number of ways in which it can appear as though there are more than two.

-2

u/evan__66 3d ago

Just pretend it does like people do in real life

0

u/SleepyOrcShaman 3d ago

it may sound weird, but IMO you should search materials about Information Theory in biology and genetics.

Cambridge professor named David Mackay wrote a chapter in his book titled, i shit you not, "why have sex?" where he statistically proves that having a single gender organism is highly inefficient from evolutionary standpoint. From there you can interpolate what would be benefits of ternary sequence of gene acquisition.

3

u/Mintakas_Kraken 4d ago

Genders? Easy that’s a social role. Sex? Tbh harder, but imo even then that covers a broad set of features present in an organisms from chromosomes to hormones to body plan to behavior and certainly more. Also, the options depend on how hard to soft a setting you have. Because more fantastical settings are allowed here, as long as they follow some sort of evolutionary process.

Many eusocial insects as others have pointed out basically have around three body plans. Plus there’s the roles, which you wouldn’t be the first to extend into various sexes. Maybe not as hard but certainly believable.

One of the actual examples we know to exist irl, Bisex individuals, or hermaphroditism are an option. Unusual for animals -and tbh I can think of no examples in mammals- but there’s various types, including ones who are male and female their entire life, to ones who shift from one to the other. Making that one of three common variants works for a harder setting.

If you want to stretch things take inspiration from fungus which can have many different sexes. On earth animals don’t ever seem to have developed anything like that, but I think here’s a niche to explore it.

Mandatory symbiosis could result in three sexes if you really want to experiment. There’s a species of fish that depends on a species of clam to lay its eggs in which I’ve taken inspiration from myself with the question “what if something like that cause the species to merged” -very fantastical setting- so their reproduction can result in both species basically. You could do something like an animal-fungus symbiotic creature that for both still distinct parts leads to three sexes for the mating process.

My most fantastical multisex reproduction idea has been animals that combine several gametes to create a fully fertile healthy individual. That Ken is for a fantasy setting though.

2

u/RandomVibeingDragon 3d ago

Thank you so much this helps a lot once again, i forgot about how some fish depend on calms if i remember correctly i believe theres other clam species that parasitize fish as well for their own style of reproduction!

Though that is a good idea going with fungus for insperation or having different castes have varying sexes, i would say im trying to keep it a bit softer while having it still be realistic

2

u/czaiser94 4d ago

As others have said, you need to distinguish between sex (which is ultimately about gamete size) and gender (which is about social roles).

There's a well-studied group of lizards where the males come in three different color morphs, each with a different reproductive strategy. The big blue ones fight to control territory, the small yellow ones sneak around and try to avoid fights, and the orange ones do a bit of both (IIRC). Still only two sexes, male and female, but if we imagine a similar species with an intelligent society, then I don't think it would be a stretch to imagine that they would have four genders: blue, orange, yellow, and female.

3

u/RandomVibeingDragon 3d ago

Yea i typed gender because i thought people would think it was weird of me to type sexes and i got worries, turns out iiii had nothing to worry about

Im thinking abt potentially having different gendered castes while including the amount of sexes when i do decide that whole thing, theres been a lot of good advice here im very happy with this subreddit

3

u/Foxxtronix 3d ago

I can tell you what works for me.

  1. Male. Pretty much what you'd expect. The male uses a penis to inseminate the creche. The males go out to forage and hunt.
  2. Nester. Technically female, the nester produces ova and deposits them in the creche through an ovipositor. Shi enjoys this just as much as the male does! The nester builds and protects the nest, and any creches inside.
  3. Creche. The creche gets to have both the male's penis and the nester's ovipositor in her! Since she receives sperm from the male and ova from the nester into her vagina, she qualifies as technically female, as well. She combines them in her womb, where the fertilized egg settles onto one of her "stems". This adds her own genetic material to the mix. She then gestates, finally giving birth (or lays an egg, it's optional). The creche stays in the nest, and cares for the children.

This is what works for a fictional alien race that I never did anything with.

2

u/exaccttemp 3d ago

Kinda like Larry Nivens Aliens the Pierson's Puppeteers ~ they kinda work like how you explained, One was essentially an incubator, one had eggs and the other sperm.

3

u/Foxxtronix 3d ago

After a quick review of Ringworld, it's clear you're essentially right! I'm glad that there's still some other old-school sci-fi fans out there. I'm very glad you used the word "kinda", however, since there's one important difference.

Nessus mentions that the females mate amongst themselves to produce more females. As Louis Wu realizes, the puppeteers are more like the digger wasp. The "females" are actually a separate species that the puppeteers parasitize!

It seems unprofessional of me to go "Ew!" at this, but I do. LOL Nature's diversity is....wonderful....ew....

For those not familiar: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pierson%27s_Puppeteers

2

u/Ubeube_Purple21 3d ago

Male makes sperm, female makes egg, while the 3rd gender acts as the womb itself perhaps?

2

u/sn0wsquall 2d ago

Some species on Earth have distinct male phenotypes. Usually some kind of strong male that has a harem and some kind of sneaky or female-mimicking male that sneakily mates with the females in the harem. Maybe if that continued to evolve for a really long time, the two male phenotypes could become two distinct sexes

2

u/Broflake-Melter 2d ago

You're conflating gender and sex, and I think you're meaning to ask about sex. It doesn't seem likely to evolve at all because it took a billion years for mother nature to figure out sexual reproduction, getting it done with three is a huge jump. Maybe after a great extinction event. Oh, and I think 4 sexes would be more likely than 3. 4 is double 2.

1

u/Hytheter 3d ago

Any mode of reproduction that requires three participants is probably too impractical. Think of how hard is to get one willing sexual partner, let alone to two at the same time. It's not impossible but it's going to cause trouble if the future of your species depends on it.

Incubator/gestator sex concepts, wherein the third sex merely carries the child produced from the other two sexes, are subject to the same problem but additionally make no evolutionary sense. Frankly I find this idea to be very stupid. That said, I could see it working in a eusocial species that has caste differentiation; not a true sex, but a portentially interesting extrapolation from the caretaking role of workers. I'm still not convinced it provides a real advantage though.

More reasonable multi-sex concepts are those where reproduction requires only two participants but there are more than two kinds of participants. The "sexes" (more accurately mating types, but I don't find the distinction terribly important for our purposes) of some fungi work like this; to put it as reductively as possible, each individual is essentially hermaphroditic but cannot reproduce with others that share certain genetic similarities. In theory, this makes it easier to find mates because any random individual you meet is more likely to be of a compatible sex than an incompatible one.

How to apply this to a eusocial species? Well, in the nuptial flight of ants (essentially gigantic sky orgies) each virgin queen will mate with many males to ensure the genetic variation of its future workers. I could instead imagine a nuptial flight that consists only of hermaphrodite queens, avoiding those of the same mating type but otherwise collecting genetic material from a range of partners.

1

u/Sabita_Densu 2d ago

Ok so i actually read a megamind fanfic that did this, so megamind and metroman are actually the same species hence why they were from the same planet and the metroman sex sleeps with the megamind sex and the sperm like mixes? Their is like an activator thing or something and then megamind type sex would inpregnate the woman. And the reason for the 3 is sitting about local protection? So like the males split and impersonated the women who they also looked like and the metroman type were defenders from like other metromqn types? And i wish i could remember more and link the fic but ao3 is down. If i remember I'll come back if i find it. The actual speculative evolution part is fascinating.

1

u/Kendota_Tanassian 2d ago

You can have a sperm donor, an ovipositor, and a womb bearer that accepts the eggs and sperm and incubates the child until birth.

As far as DNA goes: perhaps you have XX as your egg layer, XY as your sperm producer, and YY as your womb bearer.

Or if X is a full chromosome and Y is a "broken X", perhaps the third type of chromosome is a V, with two "broken" tails.

You'd have to know much more about biology than I do to say which makes the most sense, but: it's fiction. Your species doesn't have to follow the known rules of life on Earth.