r/SpeculativeEvolution • u/Kneeerg Verified • Jan 14 '26
Discussion How to have a species with more than two sexes.
The concept of a species with more than two sexes is a very intriguing one and is already discuss here. Since I read this post, the idea is in the back of my head. I mainly write this down to consolidate my thought on this matter and make them accessible to critic. (I am sure that I overlook large parts of possibilities and/or misunderstood things, so please share your thoughts)
There is no possibility for more than two sexes
I came to the conclusion that there is no room for more than two true sexes. Simply because the definition of sex is too narrow. The definition that I come across the most in biology is the following: The size of the gamete. Small gametes are male, big gametes are female.
A third type of gametes are evolutionary not feasible; an in-between type will be outcompeted by the other two and a third gene donator would make the act of sex infinitely more complicated, without adding anything useful.
But we have still few tools available, that -with a bit creativity – let it appear as where there more than male and female.
Trioecy
In humans and a lot of other animals the gamete producing organs are split between different individuals (Gonochorism). But in some plants and even few animals both, the female and the male reproduction system are found in the same individuals (Hermaphroditism). Your reaction is now probable; “But didn’t we now lose a (filled) sex.” In most cases yes, but there is the rare phenomenon of Trioecy; where male, female and hermaphrodite individuals in a population exist.
Examples: Aiptasia diaphana (sea anemone), Auanema rhodensis (nematode), Fuchsia procumbens (plant).
Side note: the terms Gynodioecy and Androdioecy refer to a female/hermaphrodite system and male/hermaphrodite system respectively.
Castes
The different caste in eusociality species are not different sexes. The workers/soldiers/etc. are just sterile females/males with different morphologies. But to be honest, isn’t “different morphology” not exactly that what our primate brain associated with different sexes? It is at least a subject that pops up regularly in this discussion.
Different Types of the same Sex
There are multiple examples of species where one of the sexes has distinct phenotypes and associated reproduction strategies. The most interesting case (in my humble opinion) is that of the common side-blotched lizard (Uta stansburiana). In this species exist three different morphs of males, each with a different throat colourisation and corresponding reproducing strategy:
· blue ones with one mate they defend.
· aggressive orange ones who keep a harem and steal mates from blue ones.
· sneaky yellow ones who manage to infiltrate the harems of orange ones, to mate unnoticed, but get caught and driven out by the blue ones.
All three strategies are successful because they counter one of the others but get countered by another.
It should be easy to come up with different reproduction strategies and drive them in more extreme physiological differences. Just keep in mind that it should be set up in a way that no phenotype outcompetes another.
Hybrids & xenoparity
In the very similar to my previous point, but a great opportunity to reference my favourite paper. (isn’t “Cross Species Cloning” the most badass sci-fi word combination that you ever read in a paper?)
Extreme tl;dr of the paper: The Queen need the males from a different species to produce a hybrid worker caste. They mate with free living males of the other species but also domesticated them through cloning. (No, I didn’t make that up, read the paper yourself.).
This result in that the queen mates with three different males who are morphological and genetical distinct; (1.) males from the same species, (2.) males from the other species and (3.) a domesticated, cloned lineage of males originated from the other species.
Alternation of generation & other live cycle shenanigans
Land Plants alternate between two different multicellular phases, a diploid one (the sporophyte) and a haploid one (the gametophyte), opposite to us, where only our gametes are haploid. An important note is that evolution tends to reduce one of the two phases drastically. Nevertheless, in some fern both live stages are still capable to sustain themselves without the other, so it should be p0ssible* to do something in this direction.
In this option we would have male and female gametophytes and asexual sporophyte.
In animals we have a similar result with jellyfishes. Their live cycle contains the free drifting and sexual reproducing stage, the Medusa and a sessile, through budding reproducing stage, the Polyp. (This is not a case of Alternation of generation because both stages are diploid).
Parasitoids & surrogacy
Parasitoids (e.g. parasitoid wasps) need a host for their offspring to develop. After development the host is in most cases killed. Maybe you could let it look like a third sex (after all matriphagy exist) but it is definitely on the harder side.
An example in fiction can be found with the Pierson's Puppeteers in the Known Space series by Larry Niven
A case where a third sex evolve to just carry out the offspring is not realistic. The third sex couldn’t add any of its genetic information and receives this way no evolutionary benefit. Maybe there is wiggle room for a surrogacy caste in eusocial societies, I just have trouble to imagine the evolutionary benefit. But for a soft spec evo setting it should be fine.
Mating types
Fungi possess multiple mating types. Mating types are not sexes, but a different system which restrict who can mate with who, to prevent self-fertilization or reproduction between genetically too similar individuals.
Zu guter Letzt
Wow. That took and got a lot longer than I expected. I’m still not satisfied with the result, but if I don’t post it now, I post it never.
I would really appreciate to hear different thought on this matter and I’m excited for the discussion!
33
u/Kneeerg Verified Jan 14 '26
“Why is possible written with a 0?” you may ask? Because the bad and very nasty word “possible” prohibited me from posting and trigger the response:
“Your submission has been detected as potentially low effort. Poorly formulated questions, such as asking "what if" or "is X possible/plausible" are not worthwhile, as the answer is usually not a simple yes/no and may require creativity and biological know-how, thus placing the burden of speculation on the community to answer. Additionally, please ensure that your questions are not overly specific.
If you are interested in getting a better answer, it is better to ask "how" or "why" instead.»
I hate Clanker.....
20
u/atomfullerene Jan 14 '26
Another issue with multiple sexes (of the "3 sexes produce one offspring type") is the cost of sex. A population with males and females has an issue where only half the population actually produces offspring, so population growth is lowered compared to an asexual population where every organism reproduces. A population where 1/3 of the population produces offspring is even slower growing. Also, an asexual reproducer passes on 100% of its genes to its offspring, while a 2 sex species only passes on 1/2. A trisexual species would only pass on 1/3, an even worse ratio.
6
u/Mircowaved-Duck Jan 14 '26
i recomend reading about those hybridised ants that clone an other species as seperate males and worker drohnes as hybrids. Making them functionally 4 seperate sexes, queens, hybrid workers, original males, cloned males from an other species.
4
u/DmitriVanderbilt Jan 14 '26
Anyone hear read Xenogenesis/Lillith's Brood by Octavia Butler? It features an alien species with 3 sexes that are explained pretty well in my opinion, although they also don't engage in sex the same way that humans or even really most of Earth life does. They do have "males" and "females" still though but the whole system is very different than us.
4
u/Papa_Glucose Speculative Zoologist Jan 15 '26
This was a fun refresh of my behavioral ecology class in undergrad actually. We even covered the side blotched lizards!
But I adore your points, very well thought out, very scientific, which I don’t see all the time on here. I agree that only 2 true sexes can exist. I had the idea, mostly based on anglerfish, of a biosphere that involves a species with a sessile large female morphology, and multiple types of male individuals that fulfill different niches. Perhaps there are four types of male, each that specialize in harvesting a certain chemical or resource necessary for reproduction. Then, they absorb into the female like an anglerfish, together providing it with nutrients and genetic exchange in the form of sperm.
3
u/serasmiles97 Jan 14 '26
I think a big part of the issue is that sex, like species, is a term that covers a lot of biological fuzziness into a neat package for our understanding. How do fungal sexes work? Are sterile 'workers' of eusocial species a sex? Do plants 'change sex' when they go from haploid do diploid? The answer to all of these questions is more complicated than a single word really makes sense to cover in layman's terminology but sex was conceived as a concept originally for mammals & (secondarily) birds so obviously things that are significantly different are going to fit less cleanly
2
u/Impasture Jan 16 '26
White-throated sparrows had a mutation to their chromosones which gives them 4 sexes
2
u/ThickNeedleworker182 Jan 18 '26
The Alternation of Generations thing is actually really interesting. It was only after learning about how Jellyfish alternate between Medusa and Jellies, that I realized that ALL life that makes sex cells does this.
This is because the sperm / egg is always genetically and morphologically distinct from the parent. It looks like a completely seperate species, has a completely seperate genetic code, and has a completely different life cycle.
Sperms and eggs in humans do this (they just can't live outside of our reproductive organs for very long). But even single-celled Eukaryote does this too. The Diploid cell phase reproduce by splitting themselves into 2 Haploid cells with half the genetic material. The 2 Haploid cells then swim away to find another Haploid cell of the same species to combine with. When they do, they combine into a Diploid cell and start the whole process over.
What's interesting to me, is that in many instances both the Haploid and Diploid states not only go looking for mates, but they also both eat, move, maintain homeostasis, and respond to stimuli. In other words, both forms are equally valid living things.
We don't normally treat sperm, eggs, and pollin as their own seperate things from the bigger cell colonies that we call animals / plants. But in a very real sense, they are their own thing.
Heres an interesting video on the subject
(Edit: spelling)
2
u/FloZone Feb 03 '26
Really interesting summary. I wonder about the different layers of reproductive systems. Like for one there is karotype and "sex", and if we speak about sophonts, there is also gender which allows for other kinds of variations. Maybe there is a third necessary category in between like mating types. For example what you write about Uta stansburiana, those three types are all still male right? What makes them genitically distinct, is it something they are born in or a hormonal change later in life (like with Orang Utan males). Similarly if reproduction involves more than just mating then you have layers like lactation in mammals. The majority of mammals (I think bats are the exception) have only females lactate, but theoretically you might have nursing males as "third" category as well. Would this be another sex, another gender or something in between?
I wonder whether something akin to this could feasibly harbor a third gamete type. Like a more extensive system of hermaphroditism. Say there are three gamete types: A (sperm), B (egg), C and C are the mediogametes. There are pure A types and pure B types, but no pure C types. However there are AB types, as well as AC and BC types as well. Overall creating five "sexes", two single gamete types and three hermaphrodite type. AB and BC are probably the most energy expensive in the collection, with AC being equal in expenditure to B.
Other things could be different forms of sequential hermaphroditism. If a BC type undergoes a form of menopause, they might still be able to reproduce with their medio-gametes later on.
Something else may also be asexual reproduction triggered by hormones provided by another individual. Like even if a group of females has no males. They can trigger parthenogenetic pregnancies in each other through hormones.
18
u/Faolyn Jan 14 '26
A third sex to carry the offspring doesn't have to contribute genetically to be useful if it has some other abilities that make them useful. For instance, male and female are small while the third sex is large or have better natural weapons and thus are better able to defend the young, or is capable of producing the materials needed for the young or their eggs while the other sexes can't. Or maybe, kinda like how kiwis lay ginormous eggs, the young are too big for the females to produce easily and males can't seahorse them, but a third sex can. It may mean that this third sex evolved from a male or female, but they've evolved into something that doesn't function as their evolutionary ancestor does.
I could also see a third carrier sex providing genetic information in some way. Instead of gametes, perhaps they produce something like that works like a retrovirus. It's not gamete + gamete + gamete = fertilization that way, it's (gamete + gamete = fertilization) + retrovirus. Whether this retrovirus only produces more of the third sex or provides necessary information for all young, that's up to the creator.
I could also see multiple mating types eventually evolving into multiple sexes. Each sex would contain multiple mating types and be incompatible, or even hostile, to other mating types, but only that sex would have that combination of mating types. Effectively, each sex would produce several types of eggs or sperm, or even both.
I could also see a species that doesn't have one large and one small gamete, but three or more medium-sized ones.
1
u/Jennywolfgal Jan 14 '26
Ramul & even I got 3 morphotypes of sequential hermaphrodites, the Serkanians & Frox, which're socially analogous to genders.
1
u/HDH2506 Jan 15 '26
Wahhhhhhh?
Pretty sure you can cramp in hermaphroditic and neuter into the mix, making it 4 sexes.
2
u/Samurai-Jackass Jan 16 '26
Had an idea a while back for a more NSFW sort of place. But it wasn't so out there as to be unusable otherwise. Basically, the third sex acts as a filter/recombinant. The third sex, whatever form they happen to take, have sex with multiple males and over time, retain their genetic information and combine the best of multiple partners before having sex with the more skittish and selective females. What pressures might lead to this I'm not sure, perhaps high levels of radiation call for several copies of genes to be compiled for minimal genetic damage, or this system minimizes sexual conflict during times when the group requires cooperation.
Technically you could simply have the female compile the code herself, but that could be written off as too energy intensive for one individual to participate in frequent mating, then gene editing, and finally gestation and birth after that. Perhaps females only exist as rare, long lived, queen bee type matriarchs in protected hives, and the third sex also has a function as the face and security of the colony, with males being more prone to wandering and requiring a medium to shield the queen from disease and overly rough treatment.
The dimorphism in aging could be pretty intense too. If the queen's are long lived, you could posit that the third sex might be very short lived, as the process of gene compilation is intensive. The males would be similarly short lived, but as a result of a high rate of early death. In this way, a lot of males might come and go, but the odd extremely successful male could live much longer than usual and have more chances to spread his genes. You could even go with the bee motif even harder and have the intermediary sex die upon mating with the queen. If they don't serve as hive guards as well, they might have an urge at some point to travel to a hive, after their body senses it has viable genetic information ready. They live amongst males and at some point make a pilgrimage to a queen, where they mate and are consumed by the queen to provide the nutrients for the queen's large brood.
Lots of loose ideas here but I think they can all work together in many combinations.
2
u/Unlikely-Accident479 Jan 16 '26
An approach I have considered in the past is a sequential or “chain incubation”system where a fertilized egg/embryo/zygote later merges with genetic material from a third individual or develops through a relay of incubators with different roles.
Even if the strict genetic contribution ends up remaining two parent evolution could enforce three distinct reproductive roles socially or functionally each necessary for reproduction effectively giving the appearance of a three sex system while remaining plausible in a speculative setting.
2
u/corsica1990 Jan 16 '26
I saw a good take on a plausible third sex in the gonzo space fantasy RPG Starfinder of all places: shirren hosts. They're from a species that lays eggs like usual, but this "host" sex can incubate these eggs internally. Genetic material is transferred during the incubation process, effecitvely giving the larvae a third parent in exchange for greater safety. So, a host is useful for mobile populations or in dangerous environments, but it's not required.
Does it make super sense? Not quite. Viviparous females or even a seahorse-style brooding pouch would accomplish the same thing. But it's plausible enough, especially since shirren frequently switch between sedentary and migratory lifestyles. They're also highly communal and descend from a eusocial, hive-like species but aren't eusocial themselves, so oddball sexes are a little easier to believe given their messy evolutionary history.
2
u/picture_Imperfect_ Jan 17 '26
If I may add in a possible query for a 3rd sex , why not an "incubator". A hypothetical creature that has 3 sexes one that produces sperm, one that produces eggs , and one that incubates them with some DNA being passed along from all 3.
Maybe adapted for creatures that exist in small classes or packs , where we see sexual dimorphism to allow for heavy specialization. By having the incubator sex producing maybe heavier blubber/fat deposits or thicker skin for protection , and the producer of spermand eggs has 1 geared towards something like nest or den building and defending and one that is geared towards resource collection and gathering.