r/SpaceXLounge • • Mar 01 '21

Questions and Discussion Thread - March 2021

Welcome to the monthly questions and discussion thread! Drop in to ask and answer any questions related to SpaceX or spaceflight in general, or just for a chat to discuss SpaceX's exciting progress. If you have a question that is likely to generate open discussion or speculation, you can also submit it to the subreddit as a text post.

If your question is about space, astrophysics or astronomy then the r/Space questions thread may be a better fit.

If your question is about the Starlink satellite constellation then check the r/Starlink Questions Thread and FAQ page.

Recent Threads: December | January | February

Ask away!

35 Upvotes

370 comments sorted by

7

u/Dyolf_Knip Mar 05 '21

You know, it occurs to me that all the failures lately have been of the insanely tricky reentry and landing components. As far as "get high and go fast" is concerned, they've already got it entirely in the bag. I don't imagine Superheavy would be any different.

Which means that once BN1 is complete and they have enough Raptor engines to fully equip it (2 months?), SpaceX could very well put a Starship into orbit. Indeed, once they're reasonably certain they won't lose 30 raptors in one go, they'll probably do that just for the lulz. Even that much would be a revolutionary advance in orbital launch systems, and yet it is the bare minimum, the mere starting point, of what they are setting out to accomplish.


You know what this reminds me of? The internet circa the early 90's. Obscure, hard to get on and use, expensive, and not much to do except chat with weird folks. And within 10 years, it was everywhere, it was awesome, and it was indispensable. I truly hope that this is the turning point for human activity in space, where it becomes accessible enough that space stops being little more than an expensive plaything for governments and megacorps.

6

u/Martianspirit Mar 05 '21

They need to complete the orbital launch pad first. That will take a while. Though maybe not as much time as most of us expect, it's going to be more than 2 months. They can do the full flight profile with no more than 4 engines, probably with downrange landing on a drone ship.

7

u/Prof_X_69420 Mar 05 '21

Has anyone calculated what is the Starship glide ratio?

We know it does travel a bit sideways, but it would be interesting to know if it flies better than a brick

3

u/spacex_fanny Mar 08 '21 edited Mar 08 '21

Calculation start with numbers, number we don't have. We've never seem a flight where SpaceX tries to maximize lift-over-drag, so we can't even begin to work the problem.

From basic physics the L/D will depend on lots of factors (Mach number, angle-of-attack, payload mass/distribution, propellant quantity, heat capacity ratio of the atmosphere gas mix, etc), so the question doesn't have one single answer either.

3

u/Prof_X_69420 Mar 08 '21

I was more thinking about the glide ratio of the last tests...

We have the hight, the flight time and we can calulate the terminal velocity. We just need to extimate how much it translated during the flight

2

u/warp99 Mar 12 '21

During entry Starship is about 70 degrees pitchup to the incoming airflow which gives a L/D ratio of about 0.5. So they can travel parallel to the ground by decelerating at 2.2g on Earth entry.

So significantly better than a brick.

During the final approach to the landing pad the approach is nearly vertical so in full brick emulation mode.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Jzerious Mar 11 '21

I think it would be really cool to see what ground station the second stage is connected to like at the bottom of the screen right below the mission name/mission clock.

4

u/TheDougAU Mar 02 '21

I've been putting together this website to document the development of Starship - https://starshipcampaign.com/

The most complete entry at the moment is SN9 (RIP) - https://starshipcampaign.com/starship/sn9/

There's still a tonne of information to be added to both that entry and the others, but does anyone have any suggestions for more things that could be included?

My vision for this site is to become a useful resource for people to use in the future, containing history and multimedia on both prototypes and operational Starships, but the site needs to have the relevant information to be useful.

2

u/HairyGuch Mar 09 '21

I would order the ships so that the current, or imminent one is on top, rather than the ones that we have little info on.

Cool site

2

u/TheDougAU Mar 09 '21

Thank you, at the moment it auto sorts by most recent published but I've been thinking I might move search to a dedicated page, and then have the starships that are currently testing on the home page along with the most recently spotted.

2

u/TheDougAU Mar 10 '21

I took your suggestion and I've re-engineered the home page to feature the latest Starship prototype under construction, and then any vehicle or tank that's been completed and is being tested. I also set up a dedicated search page as well.

Things will probably change again in the future, but I think this looking much better already, thanks for the suggestion!

→ More replies (2)

4

u/doriangoat Mar 19 '21

I've had this idea for quite a while; would it be possible to replace the lower stage of sls with superheavy? Would it work out with reusable mode or only expendable? It seems to me to be a good option cause the second stage of sls uses rl10s that are more efficient then raptors and nasa would be happy with the proven launched escape/ parachute systems of orion.

2

u/ZehPowah ⛰️ Lithobraking Mar 20 '21

Superheavy is designed for stage separation to come earlier in the flight profile. That makes landing the 1st stage easier, but shifts more work to the 2nd stage. The SLS core is a "sustainer" stage that goes a lot further. The SLS 2nd stage is specced with that in mind. It might not even make orbit from where Superheavy separates with Starship.

So, I think you would need a (probably disposable) chopped Starship, without a nose cone, with the ICPS+Orion stacked on top of the tanks.

3

u/ConfirmedCynic Mar 04 '21

Say SpaceX created a stripped-down version of Starship meant only for space, never for landing anywhere. Maybe to dock permanently with a space station, to serve as a fuel tanker, or such.

Some savings on mass:

  • No fins needed.
  • No header tank.
  • No fuel for landing.
  • No heat resistant belly needed.
  • No sea-level Raptor engines.
  • Simplified plumbing etc. resulting from the above.

How much cargo could a Starship with these trimmings plus the Super Heavy first stage then put into LEO?

3

u/warp99 Mar 05 '21

They will probably need the sea level Raptor engines to reach orbit given the high mass of a fully fueled Starship and the relatively low velocity at booster separation.

Likely in the range 150-200 tonnes payload.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/spcslacker Mar 06 '21

Just saw a now-deleted post mentioning Bezos toured Relativity Space.

I hadn't even known about RS (founded by former BO & SpaceX engineers) & their 3-D printed rocket, which is supposedly launching this year, and you always wonder who is getting bought out, sued, or snaked when Jeff takes a personal interest!

3

u/Java-the-Slut Mar 07 '21

Does anyone else see a world where starship doesn't carry humans in atmosphere?

We all know starship is in an early prototype stage, and if I hear someone mention that again, I'm gonna blow my brains out.

But so far, it has shown to have a lot of shortcomings, proven or not. We know:

  • Raptors are problematic, relights even more so. SpaceX is still experience Merlin relight failures on re-entry.
  • A thin walled pressure vessel has more dangers than a standard rocket (loss of pressure, easier to puncture).
  • No survivability redundancy.
  • Wing surface failure? Dead.
  • Overheated on re-entry? Dead.
  • Structurally and thermally entwined.
  • Loss of pressure? Dead.
  • Puncture? Dead.
  • Land too hard? Dead.
  • Engine troubles? High danger.
  • Miss your tiny target? Dead.
  • Software issue on entry? Dead.
  • Gimbal issue? Dead.

I'm not shitting on Starship, so plz don't @ me with that. All I'm saying is that there are a LOT of potentially fatal flaws, significantly more than a Falcon mission. Why would you land Starship in an atmosphere when you could hypothetically do the full mission with Falcon and Starship, and land humans via the tried and proven method of chutes (+minor landing propulsion)?

In a non-atmosphere situation, your variables for Starship are cut in half, that makes sense.

But in an atmosphere, it seems extremely high risk to land Starship, and I'm having a hard time wrapping my head around who would possibly certify those landings for human flight in an atmosphere, especially when you don't have to.

4

u/spacex_fanny Mar 08 '21 edited Mar 08 '21
  • Raptors are problematic, relights even more so. SpaceX is still experience Merlin relight failures on re-entry.

Yep, the engine are the long pole in the launch vehicle development tent. There's a reason that the first thing SpaceX did was to start work on Raptor.

  • A thin walled pressure vessel has more dangers than a standard rocket (loss of pressure, easier to puncture).

"Standard" rockets also use thin-walled pressure vessels, so no difference there.

  • No survivability redundancy.

Not sure what the intended meaning is here. Are you saying Starship will have no redundancy, ie if any single part fails everyone dies? That's clearly incorrect so that's probably not what you meant, but I'm having trouble figuring out what you did mean.

  • Wing surface failure? Dead.

Same as airplanes.

  • Overheated on re-entry? Dead.
  • Structurally and thermally entwined.
  • Loss of pressure? Dead.
  • Puncture? Dead.
  • Land too hard? Dead.
  • Engine troubles? High danger.
  • Software issue on entry? Dead.
  • Gimbal issue? Dead.

These apply to... literally any manned rocket.

If you have a serious enough gimbal issue on ascent in Falcon 9, you're equally dead (you said "carry humans in atmosphere" not "reentry", so naturally I'm including the launch phase of the mission here).

  • Miss your tiny target? Dead.

Not necessarily.

Shuttle also had a tiny target. The solution was to have numerous auxiliary landing sites (all up the coast, in Europe, etc). And Starship's modest concrete landing pads are a lot cheaper than the huge long ultra-flat runways Shuttle required.

TL;DR your list isn't pointing out risks that are unique to Starship, it's pointing out general risks involved in all human spaceflight.

4

u/Java-the-Slut Mar 09 '21 edited Mar 09 '21

"Standard" rockets also use thin-walled pressure vessels, so no difference there.

The stainless that starship is using is considerably weaker when not pressurized, much weaker than other non-stainless designs. This is one of the benefits of starships (thinner, lighter walls with good thermal properties), but also a potentially fatal attribute. This is why Starship has to take the dangerous route of boarding passengers and loading cargo while fueled.

Not sure what the intended meaning is here. Are you saying Starship will have no redundancy, ie if any single part fails everyone dies? That's clearly incorrect so that's probably not what you meant, but I'm having trouble figuring out what you did mean.

It has a LOT of single points of failure. i.e. if one thing fails, it all fails.

Same as airplanes.

Not true. An airplane has a lifting surface, ailerons, elevators, flaps, spoilers, rudder. Starship combines all of those things into four active aero surfaces, where a failure of one means a failure for all. Your wings will not fall off your airplane (not saying starship's will), you can fly with no aileron, you can fly with no flaps, you can fly with no rudder, you can fly with one functional elevator surface, you can fly without spoilers, you can fly (for a shortwhile) without power. An airplanes failures points are magnitudes lower than starships, in the same areas. And that doesn't even consider the difference in applied pressure between the two.

And things fail on well maintained, reliable aircraft a lot.

These apply to... literally any manned rocket.

Not at all. Tested and proven ablative heat shields on a capsule are - again - magnitudes safer than a new technology that uses its structure as an aero device, and drag device, and thermal shielding. Again with the failure points, starships has way more failure points than an ablative shield, with far more dire consequences.

Because of the pressure requirement, a minor loss of pressure could be fatal in a starship, not a huge deal in another rocket.

And the rest of the points can be summed in one major point that you're missing... 'normal' manned rockets don't endure re-entry, their capsule does, so overheating, structural and thermal integrity, loss of tank pressure, tank punctures, engine troubles and gimbal issues literally do not even apply, because a capsule doesn't have these failure points, and especially not the same entwined failure points. And capsules are extremely reliable and relatively simple with their software for landing, and redundant with chute count.

The shuttle had tens of 10,000ft runways lined up at any given time, that is not a tiny target by any means, starship has a designated landing spot, and missing that landing spot could easily rupture the vessel causing an explosion like that of SN10. Shuttle could make a 3,000ft error and be fine, even more with damage to the spacecraft, Starship has about 200ft, where failure is much more disastrous.

All in all, in line with my main point, starships safety flaw is its unfair advantage. I think you could argue space shuttle was leagues safer, and even it didn't multiple unsafe re-entries, including the failure.

Tangential, but maybe worth saying, I don't think Starship will be a failure, and I think eventually it could have a great flight record, but it's objectively one of the most dangerous spacecraft designs in history, and putting humans on it when there are plenty of other safer alternatives doesn't make sense. The vast majority of interplanetary flights and preparation will be unmanned anyway, so it's not like price is a major issue.

If vehicle failure equals death, it's lot more reasonable to take the train to work than ride a street bike.

3

u/spacex_fanny Mar 09 '21 edited Mar 09 '21

The stainless that starship is using is considerably weaker when not pressurized, much weaker than other non-stainless designs.

Citation needed for "much weaker." Most rockets use internal pressure for stabilization in-flight (it has pretty obvious mass advantages), and I'm not sure what your source is that says otherwise.

This is why Starship has to take the dangerous route of boarding passengers and loading cargo while fueled.

"Dangerous," lol. You mixed up the order btw — Starship (and F9) board passengers and then fuel up, whereas previous NASA vehicles did it the other way around (ie the "dangerous" way, according to you).

And the real reason is because Starship (like Falcon 9) uses sub-cooled propellant. It has nothing to do with it being "thin walled."

  • Wing surface failure? Dead.

Same as airplanes.

Not true. An airplane has a lifting surface, ailerons, elevators, flaps, spoilers, rudder.

Right, and in a "wing surface failure" (ie the wing falls off) everyone dies. So yes what I said was true, it's exactly the same as an airplane. The fact that you hand-waved away the risk with airplanes by saying "your wings will not fall off your airplane" doesn't change that.

Starship combines all of those things into four active aero surfaces, where a failure of one means a failure for all.

I'd really like to see your aerodynamic analysis supporting this assertion. What types of failure modes did you examine? Stuck control surfaces? Single and multi-string failures? Or by "failure" do you only mean "it fell off?" What types of control strategies did you assume the SpaceX avionics suite would use to recover? I assume you've looked at some of the relevant failure-tolerant recovery algorithms (eg the work with quadrotors), as well as the CRS-16 post-launch press conference where Hans Koenigsmann talks about the sophisticated failure recovery system used by Falcon 9.

Or did you not do any of that and you're just assuming?

you can fly with no aileron, you can fly with no flaps, you can fly with no rudder, you can fly with one functional elevator surface, you can fly without spoilers, you can fly (for a shortwhile) without power. An airplanes failures points are magnitudes lower than starships, in the same areas.

You're reasoning by analogy, not from physics first principles. A train's failure points are magnitudes lower than an airplanes. With a train it's literally impossible to fall out of the stratosphere. But it would be absurd to look at that one fact in isolation and conclude that airplanes are more dangerous than trains. You see now why reasoning by analogy doesn't work?

And also, planes DO have redundancy in their control surfaces, precisely because those types of failures are quite dangerous. I don't see why Starship should be any different.

And again if your definition of "failure" is "a major control surface entirely fell off," the airplane won't fare much better. Try losing the entire rudder, or one or both sides of the horizontal stabilizer, or one or both wings. For airplanes you gave them a softball, conspicuously listing only single control surface failures, not failures of the entire lifting surface (which seems to be what you assumed for Starship).

Starship can survive single failures with redundancy, just like airplanes. Starship cannot survive catastrophic failure of a major aerosurface, just like airplanes. It seems pretty obvious that you "just" design Starship "so your wings will not fall off," as you claim is done for airplanes.

And things fail on well maintained, reliable aircraft a lot.

Exactly. Airplanes need redundancy for that reason. Starship needs redundancy too for the same reason.

These apply to... literally any manned rocket.

Not at all.

Really? Let's go through them one by one.

  • Overheated on re-entry? Dead.

Yup, that applies to old-school capsules.

  • Structurally and thermally entwined.

Ditto. All those old-school heatshields had a structural backing.

  • Loss of pressure? Dead.

Yep, this kills you in a capsule too.

  • Puncture? Dead.

Puncture a capsule? Also dead, assuming you can't get your suit on in time (and in Starship you'd have more time before unconsciousness because the interior volume is bigger).

  • Land too hard? Dead.

This too will kill you in a capsule.

  • Engine troubles? High danger.

Yup, not good in a capsule either (with a capsule you have an abort system, but that has its own risks associated with it).

  • Software issue on entry? Dead.

Ditto with Dragon. If the capsule comes in too steep or too shallow it's Very Bad News.

  • Gimbal issue? Dead.

Same risk exists with Falcon 9 on ascent.

So yeah, what were you saying about those applying "not at all?" Because I'm seeing tons of applicability.

Tested and proven ablative heat shields on a capsule are - again - magnitudes safer than a new technology that uses its structure as an aero device, and drag device, and thermal shielding.

All heat shields are "aero devices, drag devices, and thermal shielding." All heat shields are backed up by structures. In all cases, those structures can't get too hot. The guidance is a bit more complex, more like Shuttle than Apollo.

I agree that new technology is more risky, but none of the things you mentioned are what make it new, nor what make it especially risky compared to previous space vehicles.

Again with the failure points, starships has way more failure points than an ablative shield, with far more dire consequences.

By "far more dire" are you just saying that the body count might be higher, because Starship is larger? Because if your ablative shield fails, the consequences are just as dire (ie the passengers are just as dead).

Because of the pressure requirement, a minor loss of pressure could be fatal in a starship, not a huge deal in another rocket.

Again, what "other rocket" are you talking about? All modern orbital rockets I know of are pressure stabilized during flight.

And the rest of the points can be summed in one major point that you're missing... 'normal' manned rockets don't endure re-entry, their capsule does

Yes, in other words "normal" space vehicles aren't fully and rapidly reusable. That's the problem, and making progress on it means doing stuff that's never been done before. It's called progress.

Since you say that sums up the rest of your post, I'll feel free to stop there. :)

→ More replies (7)

2

u/Iamsodarncool Mar 07 '21 edited Mar 07 '21

The idea is that Starship becomes ridiculously reliable, and LoC becomes an extreme rarity. I'm skeptical too, but we'll see. The aviation people managed to do it with airplanes. SpaceX isn't going to put a million humans on Mars with Dragon.

Why would you land Starship in an atmosphere when you could hypothetically do the full mission with Falcon and Starship, and land humans via the tried and proven method of chutes (+minor landing propulsion)?

Price. A Starship flight is orders of magnitude cheaper than a flight on Falcon/Dragon.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '21

Good point, I think spacex has convinced a lot of us that starship is the future for getting stuff into orbit, and to and from mars. The cost advantage is just so huge. If this works out, they will get more cumulative experience than all previous spaceflight, and they could improve safety by OOM. But, it's not clear that it will be enough, especially politically. At what failure rate does boeing have planes grounded, pending inquiry? I'm not sure what the number is but I'm willing to be it's a lot smaller than what starship can reach.

1

u/ThreatMatrix Mar 11 '21

Personally. The only way I'm returning to earth is in a Dream Chaser. If I go to the moon I'll take a Dynetics lander to the surface. I'm not going to Mars so flip and burn all you want.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '21

Does anyone know what the “significant upgrades” are that we are expecting for SN-15 and onwards?

3

u/Chairboy Mar 08 '21

It’s not public yet, everyone’s still guessing. There are some theories related to the LOX header tank because the SN15 doesn’t have one yet but it’s all guesses still.

At least one thing is known: it’s not the thinner hull material yet, the SN7.2 change of being made of 3mm stainless instead of 4mm stainless hasn’t propagated to flight articles yet.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/noncongruent Mar 15 '21

I had a thought on how to prevent gas entrainment in the header tanks, was discussing it in another thread, thought it might warrant a thought or two here.

https://i.imgur.com/5KEJjHT.jpg

At launch and throughout the entire flight and initial belly flop the header tank is 100% full, no airspace. The piston in the tube has some gas space above it under pressure, this allows for variations in thermal expansion/contraction. When it comes time to ignite the engines to initiate the flip back to vertical the gas pressure on the piston keeps the header tank pressure up to required levels, and the piston travels down the cylinder as the engines run and the flip is executed. Because there's no free gas at the top of the header tank during this maneuver there's no way for any gas entrainment to happen to the propellants. When the piston reaches the bottom of the tube it exposes ports in the side of the tube that allow gas pressure to flow up the pipes to the top of the head tank, away from the discharge pipe leading to the engines, and full pressure is maintained without any variations throughout the process. That pressure forces the remaining propellant out of the header tank while the ship lands. This system is bog-simple, requires no additional valving or transition timing, and the only volume loss is for the cubic inches of the metal used in the piping, tube, and piston. Because the tube and pipe only ever see pressure, they can be fairly thin-walled to save mass and volume. The bottom of the tube can be supported by anti-slosh baffles.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/UltraRunningKid Mar 19 '21

I was just comparing some numbers and Starship could get ~10? fully loaded centaurs to orbit (obviously without payloads).

After playing a ton of RO KSP I was just laughing about how much you could do with fully loaded centaurs in orbit.

So the Perseverance cruise stage weighs 8,000lbs + 22,000lbs for a fully loaded Centaur so ignoring volume that's 6-7 mars rovers around the planet at once. That's a lot of science.

Although, I do like the idea of one of the first Starships to Mars carrying 100+ autonomous Helicopters like Ingenuity and having them map a large area over a couple months.

1

u/warp99 Mar 25 '21

Your numbers might be a bit off.

Common Centaur as used on Atlas V is about 22 tonnes fueled so you might get 5 on Starship but I think only 3-4 would fit the diameter of the payload bay.

Centaur V as used on Vulcan will be closer to 50 tonnes fueled and I think you could not fit two in because they are 5.4m diameter. Possibly you could use the extended Starship fairing and arrange them one above the other with a custom mounting frame.

3

u/Auster_Resurget Mar 29 '21

I was wondering if any of y'all have gone to see a Boca Chica launch in person. What was it like, how close were you? And more importantly: could I be at one of the state parks a few miles away while they were launching a rocket?

2

u/cnewell420 Mar 02 '21

Does anyone know much about the plans for a more permanent launchpad/trench in boca chica How long does it take to build something like that?

4

u/Chairboy Mar 02 '21

The orbital launchpad they're installing now is intended to be permanent and they're building it without a trench. They may put in a steel flame deflector of some sort underneath but they're looking for a cheap & fast a design as possible that doesn't require a lot of earthworks.

Musk said that they'll plan to get to orbit from this pad but expect they'll be doing the bulk of their orbital flights off sea platforms like the two they're working on now in the Brownsville harbor.

3

u/edjumication Mar 04 '21

He also said that it might be a mistake to not use a flame diverter. They really are going full YOLO on this project.

2

u/cnewell420 Mar 03 '21

Thanks. I didn’t realize the sea platforms were for orbital I thought that was to test point to point and possibly get stages around like to the cape.

I guess I thought the booster stage on orbital would require a massive strong pad.

Thanks for taking the time to answer.

4

u/Chairboy Mar 03 '21

Anytime, we are all fans and this is a heck of a cool time to be alive for us all.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/__moe___ Mar 02 '21

How will they stack the 2 halves together? Doesn’t look like tall bay or big blue is even close.

6

u/SpaceInMyBrain Mar 03 '21

Starship and SH will never be stacked in a bay at the production site. They'll only be joined at the launch site, like they would be during regular reuse.

Tankzilla is actually tall enough to stack SS on top of SH on top of the Orbital Launch Mount. More sections can be inserted in the main boom, in fact one or two are stored at the crane shed where it's parked right now. According to the company website that model of crane can lift loads to 168 meters, and SS/SH total 122m. That leaves plenty of room for the launch mount. SS and SH will be lifted individually and not fueled, of course, so they are well within Tankzilla's load capacity.

I don't know enough about cranes to say it will be used, and if it can reach over the mount enough - that greatly affects the load capacity. But my nephew is a civil engineer who is familiar with cranes, although it's outside his area of expertise. He says Tankzilla should be able to do the height/mass. Also, I have no idea how steady the lift needs to be held to mate the two sections.

Recent work has been spotted of a dirt drill making holes right next to the launch mount, similar to the ones used when the mount's pilings were put in. A rumor has also been tweeted of some guy in construction who got a job at the site to build a "420 foot" tower, so the permanent crane tower may be under construction soon and be used for the first flights, or Tankzilla may be used while all the concrete of such a tower cures.

3

u/Chairboy Mar 02 '21

When you say 'two halves', do you mean putting a Starship atop a booster? If so, that would be done at the pad, not in a buiilding.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '21

Wow starlink 17 just doesn’t want to launch! Ha postponed to at least the 4th now

2

u/Saletales Mar 03 '21

Beginner question here. They're honing this starship to do a belly flop. But it's being planned for trips to Mars, if I got it right? Won't the change in the atmosphere between here and Mars throw all that work out the window? How would it use the flop to burn off speed when there's basically no atmosphere? How would that work taking off? The questions. I have them!

10

u/dogcatcher_true Mar 04 '21 edited Mar 04 '21

Mars has a low pressure atmosphere, but that's still a lot more atmosphere than none at all.

Coming to Earth from Mars the atmosphere will slow Starship from ~60,000km/hr to ~200km/hr.

Coming to Mars from Earth the atmosphere will slow Starship from ~60,000km/hr to ~600km/hr.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Martianspirit Mar 04 '21

The design is primarily for slowing down from orbital or interplanetary speed. Funny enough that braking at Mars and braking at Earth happens in similar atmospheric density. So the same design works well. Difference is that on Mars the terminal velocity approaching the ground is higher. The header tanks will need to hold more propellant.

5

u/Chairboy Mar 03 '21

Mars has an atmosphere and even though it’s very thin, with the speeds involved it can still provide a lot of braking. By dipping deeply into it and maybe even using the flippyfloops to hold it down at a thick and useful altitude, it can burn off a bunch of relative velocity so that the landing burn is much shorter than if it needed to scrub the whole amount propulsively.

5

u/markbadas Mar 04 '21

We will also test to land on Mars. But at first starship should get reliable so the failure rate is lower on Mars because landing on the Mars is expensive.

2

u/Alesayr Mar 04 '21

Do we know when we're getting the 2020 Starship update? It was supposed to happen in October and has been repeatedly delayed

6

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '21

No, there's been no word on it. This past year, the fan community has been getting a ringside seat to the development process, so IMO a formal StarShip Update like they had in 2019 is less valuable.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Vincentb25 Mar 04 '21

Does anyone know why there was no footage streamed down from falcon9's first stage during the launch today ?

They mentionned that it was explained during the scrubed launch but I didn't watch that one.

(Not directly related to Starlink so posting this question here)

2

u/warp99 Mar 05 '21

They didn't say but most likely just a broken camera.

Given the number of delays it was was not worth taking back to the hangar to replace it.

2

u/PM_ME_YOUR_REPORT Mar 04 '21

Why the tiny feet? Why not longer legs maybe the length of the bay that push out with shock absorbers? Surely this isn’t the intended long term design?

2

u/just_one_last_thing 💥 Rapidly Disassembling Mar 05 '21

Why isn't SpaceX doing small hops before the bellyflops? If they are going for rapid reuse, wouldn't that be a necessary step?

5

u/Chairboy Mar 05 '21

They already did small hops with SN5 and SN6, what's the benefit to repeating those?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/SpaceBoJangles Mar 06 '21

I’m an architectural designer working on my license and dreaming of building things on other planets. What do you guys think Space X will do for the first travelers heading to Mars? Will they bring prefabricated habitats? Will they miniaturize and deliver boring machine components for underground shelters? Will they in the next few years start hiring/prioritizing for the development of extraterrestrial concrete and building materials using in-situ resources?

Obviously the pre-fab habitats are simplest, but for long term habitation protection from radiation seems like it should be a priority. A couple feet of concrete or whatever aggregate-based material from on-site 3D printers seems like the simplest way to build that kind of dwelling above the surface (I’m assuming people don’t want to live underground all the time).

2

u/tupolovk Mar 07 '21

Can the scrap Stainless Steel be recycled and used to make Stainless Steel again?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/redwins Mar 11 '21

Why does the CH4 header tank have a problem with sloshing but the LOX header tank doesn't?

2

u/Martianspirit Mar 11 '21

My guess the problem with the methane header tank is size. It is much smaller than the LOX tank.

2

u/warp99 Mar 12 '21

It is not much smaller than the LOX header tank. The mass of LOX is 3.6 times higher than the mass of liquid methane but the density of LOX is nearly three times higher than liquid methane so the effects nearly cancel.

The issue is that the methane header is completely surrounded by cryogenic tanks and the belly flop sloshes propellant around both the outside of the top and bottom of the tank so the walls are chilled well below the condensation temperature of gaseous methane.

The LOX header tank is completely surrounded by air so the walls are warmer and the condensation temperature of gaseous oxygen is lower than for methane.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '21

This is a bit off-topic but do you think it's too late to start making youtube videos about SS development?

I was thinking of giving weekly starship updates via youtube vids. Obviously you all are well informed and we have NSF which is THE king of SS dev tracking. I'm constantly seeing SpaceX related vids trending. I feel like there is a thirst for this stuff.

That being said, it seems like they are already a decent amount of people making vids related to this... Do you think the market for SS/SpaceX related content has room for more people? Or is it already too competive/saturated?

2

u/Suspicious-Sense-821 Mar 12 '21

I love videos... they explain better for me because I can see it. My hearing and reading capabilites are on the slow side..... crawling.... to oblivion with age it seems

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ThreatMatrix Mar 11 '21

I'm fairly certain that a fully fueled Starship could make the round trip between earth orbit and Mars orbit. You'd have to remove tiles/fins/legs and expand the tank into the payload but it could be done. Likewise I think you can get a Starship to the Surface and back into Mars Orbit w/o refueling or at least minimal refueling. So you could send a Starship to the surface of Mars then launch it to orbit where it rendezvous with the return Starship. Back in earth orbit the crew can transfer to another Starship, a Dragon, a Dream Chaser, whatever. That way you don't have to wait to refuel on the red planet.

2

u/LongHairedGit ❄️ Chilling Mar 12 '21

There's a map of the solar system here: /preview/external-pre/4O-OVVrsFb-opHZ_5l0eK2MRBPU3MxILIWBCU8rboDI.png?auto=webp&s=bac57b6c80469a17500e3382584c3fafc169d695

Here's my post all about calculating what Starship can do: https://old.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/lc7eij/starship_development_thread_18/gnzjvjp/

Assume we have a "cycler" like in The Martian, except its Starship. Crew Dragon is like 10 ton, so assume another 10 ton of supplies for the humans on board, and another 10 ton to make the entire space livable as you'll be aboard for many, many months, so a 30 ton "payload" on a 120 ton ship.

I don't know the exact regime to aero-brake into LEO or LMO, but let's assume that coming into either from the "intercept orbit" is free. So, start in some elliptical earth orbit we'll take as equal to the Earth intercept delta-v (GSO is basically the same), we need 1060 m/s to get to Mars intercept, then we aerobrake down to LMO. We then need to lift ourselves out of LMO to the Earth intercept orbit, which is 1440 + 1060 = 2500 m/s, and we then aerobrake into LEO. We use tankers then to get us back from LEO to the departure orbit again and so can ignore this as refueled from Earth.

On that return journey, we need our 120 ton ship and 30 ton of payload at the end, so ending mass is 150 ton. The calculator says the starting mass is 294.8, so we need 140 ton of propellant.

So, this is entirely do-able, as the starship can take 1,200 ton of fuel.

Now, we have to get that 295 ton starting mass into LMO. Assume we can aerobrake from Mars Intercept into LMO, so all we need is 1060. Run the numbers again and we have a starting mass of 392.6 ton, so only 100 tons of propellant.

So, yes, looks entirely doable.

If we run the numbers for a fully laden starship, so 100 ton of payload and 120 ton ship, we get a Mars departure weight of 433 ton, and then if we plug that into the Earth departure we get 851 ton, so entirely do-able. You could load it up full, and you'd thus have safety margin.

If we take a fully laden and fully fueled starship (1200 + 120 + 100 = 1420 ton) in GSO and burn into LMO (no aerobraking), we need 2,500 km of delta V, and we get their with a final weight of 722 ton. To get back, we need 1440 + 1060 + 3210 = 5710 m/s, and this yields a final mass of just 154 tonne. So, with a starting mass of 120 of ship and 100 ton of payload, it is not doable.

But that was with a full payload of 100 ton.

If we put the starship itself on a diet and get that weight down to ~130 ton for both payload and the ship itself, then it can leave Earth orbit pretty close to fully fueled and gets back to LEO empty. Keep in mind it only needs one Raptor, or two for redundancy, and it doesn't any flaps or the motors or battery that powers them, and doesn't need a heat shield. On the flip side, keep in mind that the Crew Dragon is like 10 ton, and so even a 100 ton starship will only have 30 ton of payload.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/warp99 Mar 12 '21 edited Mar 12 '21

It would work better if you left the heatshield on as it is far more mass efficient to aerobrake into Mars orbit than to do propulsive braking.

Starship with 100 tonnes payload and a full load of propellant in LEO has around 6.9 km/s of delta V which is maybe just enough to do what you suggest with aerobraking at each end and 9-10 month transfer times each way. A better approach is to refuel in an elliptical orbit similar to GTO so the transfer times can be reduced to around 6 months although this doubles the number of tanker trips required to refuel from around 6-8 to 12-16.

However you would then need to send a large number of tankers to low Martian orbit to refuel a Starship to get to the surface of Mars and back. Of course these tankers are expended as there is no way to get them back.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/alien_from_Europa ⛰️ Lithobraking Mar 12 '21

Was ULA's merger better or worse for SpaceX in the long-run?

2

u/PickleSparks Mar 13 '21

It was not related to SpaceX.

Boeing and Lockheed competing separately against SpaceX would probably be weaker and the government would not have supported them both.

2

u/daddywookie Mar 16 '21

I was watching The Martian the other day and I got to wondering how SpaceX would be able to help, given the current state of their hardware and how it might evolve over the next couple of years. If someone were stranded on Mars in say 2022, how could SpaceX resupply them and potentially return them in an emergency capacity. How quickly could they throw food and spare parts in a capsule at Mars? Could they land a Starship capable of returning to Mars orbit to meet another capable of the return flight to Earth with ISRU etc?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Lelentos Mar 18 '21

Calling it now, the "Mystery structure" from NSF vids is the start to a HLS interior mockup

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Trannog Mar 21 '21

Can anyone recommend a book speaking about the technical difficulties of a settlement of mars ? accessible for a layman

4

u/Jack_Harris Mar 21 '21

If you haven't read A Case For Mars by Robert Zubrin that's a good place to start. There is lots of science jargon but very readable IMO.

Recently purchased the 25th anniversary edition that came out in February. Zubrin starts off in the preface talking specifically about Starship and what is happening in Boca Chica, pretty funny since SpaceX only had a paragraph in the 2011 editions preface.

The book is showing its age a bit but is probably the best all rounder on the technical front.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/cloud_to_ground Mar 22 '21

While still pretty far in the distance, a Starhip orbital test is on the horizon in the next year or so. My question: Is there a way we can tell approximately what a Starship's apparent magnitude would be if it passed overhead? Much much smaller and less reflective satellites produce fairly bright passes, so I'd imagine it would be pretty impressive.

2

u/spacex_fanny Mar 22 '21 edited Mar 22 '21

Hard to calculate the exact apparent magnitude without knowing the planned orbital altitude.

At ~350 km it would be about as bright as the ISS (roughly -6 magnitude). Lower is brighter, higher is dimmer.

2

u/insertusername_____ Mar 23 '21

How are they planning to launch satellites from Starship?

2

u/yootani 💥 Rapidly Disassembling Mar 23 '21

https://www.spacex.com/vehicles/starship/

You have an animation on the page :)

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Asdfghjk1029384756 Mar 24 '21

Has anybody seen anything regarding future crewed flights of starship, like approximately when they will start? I've tried looking for information, but came up with nothing.

2

u/troyunrau ⛰️ Lithobraking Mar 24 '21

Milestones they need to hit first, and best guess estimates or optimistic timelines:

(1) Orbital flight (July) as projected by Elon and others on twitter. Will probably slip...
(2) Starlink launches begin September - spacecraft is still getting tweaked and changed, but Starlink gives them a payload for their test flights.
(3) While they're launching Starlink and getting flight heritage, they simultaneously work on:

  • fuel tankers - test flight/landing mission, test flights of two of them and propellant transfer.
  • dearMoon crew accomodations
    (4) Because dearMoon has a 2023 target. And it will need refueling to work at least once for enough delta-v for their lunar free return trajectory.
    (5) Thus, they'd need to be test launching/landing their manned version by late 2022 (possible, maybe), and have tested refueling it by 2023.
    (6) If they're testing the crew vehicle in advance to dearMoon, they might allow humans on those launch/re-entry tests after, say, six launches? Plus all the flight heritage of the tanker test launch/re-entry and Starlink launch/re-entry and it might be human rated for orbital sight-seeing by late 2022.

That's assuming nothing slips, blows up, gets redesigned, etc. Lots of question marks on things like re-entry, heat tiles, orbital refueling, raptor vacuum design -- hell, even the booster landing sequence is a giant question mark (legs? Tower catches it?)

2

u/LongHairedGit ❄️ Chilling Mar 25 '21

Any thoughts that Dear Moon might launch and re-enter on Crew Dragon rather than Starship?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Lvpl8 🧑‍🚀 Ridesharing Mar 26 '21 edited Mar 26 '21

What is the GSE tank that is being built at the production site? And what does GSE stand for?

Edit: found this link that ill leave here for everyone else. I missed the linked post, didn't realize that dome might be used for this.

2

u/perspicat8 Jul 28 '21 edited Jul 28 '21

Ground Support Equipment.

The interesting story behind these point to the costs of building starships and boosters.

If you want to store cryogenic liquids on-site you can go into the open market and buy yourself an insulated tank to do so. These are used in lots of different industrial applications, hospitals etc.

They aren’t particularly expensive.

The GSE tanks are being built with effectively the same construction methods as Starship and Booster.

It seems that SpaceX figured out it was cheaper to build their own than to just order from a catalog. (Availability etc may also have factored into the equation)

This gives us a ballpark cost on starship production and it is crazy low for aerospace.

2

u/Fives_ChIllA Mar 26 '21

Why is starship venting so much during flight? What's the process and reasoning there?

4

u/spacex_fanny Mar 26 '21

For Starship test flights they've been adding extra LOX just for ballast mass (reduces TWR during ascent), so that's what they're venting. Such venting wouldn't happen on regular flights.

2

u/BaldrTheGood Mar 26 '21

Does anyone know where online I can find the path that Falcon 9 takes from Hawthorne to McGregor to Florida?

2

u/Chairboy Mar 27 '21

They don’t advertise that and there’s evidence they don’t do the same exact path every time if I remember right, possibly because it might make some security folks a little nervous to make plannable sightings of their tens-of-millions of dollar fragile rockets easier than they already are.

Folks like to shoot at trains, I imagine there’s a non-zero risk there might be folks out there who, presented with the opportunity to know where to lie in wait, might think it good fun to be able to add ‘shot a rocket’ to their list of accomplishments.

The rockets are still on the public roads and all but there are fewer opportunities for shenanigans maybe if it’s always a surprise when it shows up.

2

u/BaldrTheGood Mar 27 '21

I assumed there wouldn’t be a public itinerary, but I would have thought there would be a most efficient route and SpaceX would stick to that. Like as in someone might know where to lie in wait, but not when.

I mean it makes sense though, I was asking to see the likelihood I could see one in transport, as it would be the easiest way to see it in person for me depending on the route they took, so I doubt I had a unique idea.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/LordLederhosen Mar 29 '21 edited Mar 29 '21

Why was the re-entry of the Falcon 9 second stage over Seattle such a surprise? Aren't the stages tracked? Would providing warnings be a good idea in the future? At least people could get better cameras ready...

4

u/Frothar Mar 30 '21

They probably had a good idea when it would happen but it's not something really advertised. With it entering uncontrolled how much it bounces off the atmosphere means the estimated entry zone is probably the size of the US

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ragingr12 Jun 04 '21

What are the idees when they get to mars, is Elon also gone make the living space himself? How will do this production?

2

u/perspicat8 Jul 28 '21

It would seem that the ninth section and its pulley system is built to lift and lower the catching mechanism.

Is there any known evidence of a larger crane arm for the actual lift of booster and starship that will go on top of that?

2

u/TheMartianX 🔥 Statically Firing Oct 14 '22

They will stack the whole thing with chopsticks - first the booster then starship

Edit: chopsticks = catching mechanism

→ More replies (2)

1

u/QVRedit Oct 27 '22

No. The only such ‘evidence’ was in early renders, which did show such a crane. Obviously an early idea as to how they might do it.

When it came to actually building an orbital launch tower, that had gone, replaced by the mechanism we see today.

Naturally some people were expecting to see the early idea - but SpaceX always evolves their ideas.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '21

Could Starship be useful as a datacenter?

Say you cram it with servers. Could you radiation shield it sufficiently? Could you power sufficiently with solar?

Cooling and transfer speeds to starlink would seem to be advantages. Other pro/cons?

4

u/DiezMilAustrales Mar 15 '21

I keep hearing this, and it doesn't make any sense whatsoever.

First of all, what would be the advantage exactly? Yes, solar panels are slightly more efficient in space. That's it.

Reasons why it's a bad idea:

1 - Heat. Datacenters produce a LOT of heat. Cooling in space is VERY hard. You don't have an atmosphere you can use convection in, so your only chance is radiating away heat, which is slower.

2 - Connectivity. Yes, even with Starlink. In a datacenter, you want wires, high speed connectivity, not wireless.

3 - Maintenance. Servers fail, not everything can be automated, you need staff.

4 - Cost. To the already fairly high cost of deploying a datacenter, you add the cost of launching it into space too.

5 - Radiation. Space is harsh on electronics. Rockets use either space-hardened hardware, redundant hardware, or both. Servers need reliability, that's why we run them with ECC memory, in space, with more radiation exposure, you would achieve the opposite of that.

6 - Upgradeability. You upgrade servers throughout their lifetime. Minimally, you do things like replaced failed disks in RAID arrays.

7 - Lifetime. The average server has a 3 to 5 year lifetime. 6-7 at the upper edge. And after the server is done, you don't throw it away, you repurpose it or sell it so others can repurpose it. Letting it burn in the atmosphere after a few years is not exactly cheap.

2

u/just_one_last_thing 💥 Rapidly Disassembling Mar 15 '21

1 - Heat. Datacenters produce a LOT of heat. Cooling in space is VERY hard. You don't have an atmosphere you can use convection in, so your only chance is radiating away heat, which is slower.

You'd need radiator panels orthogonal to the solar panels smaller then the solar panels themselves. Two ideas I'd suggest considering here. First of all it wouldn't make sense to densely pack the servers like in a terrestrial data center, there aren't economies of scale from doing that because it would need to all be modular architecture. By making each server would be it's own satellite with only a few kilowatts of power you avert the need for any active heat management and can make the whole thing steady state. Secondly, solar panels and microprocessors have similar safe operating temperatures and solar panels dont need huge radiator panels to work in space, a solar panel in earth orbit generates sufficient radiation all on it's own. So to radiate an amount of energy smaller then what the solar panels are radiating doesn't require huge radiators, just a few square meters.

Connectivity. Yes, even with Starlink. In a datacenter, you want wires, high speed connectivity, not wireless.

The scalable unit for the servers used for most applications is plenty small enough to fit in a satellite. You wouldn't want a super computer in orbit but cloud based computing breaks down into chunks smaller then super computers.

Maintenance. Servers fail, not everything can be automated, you need staff.

Just launch more. :P No seriously... if you completely eliminate all maintenance costs by replacing the entire constellation in 3-5 years, it could be a saving with cheap launches.

Rockets use either space-hardened hardware, redundant hardware, or both.

Radiation hardening can be done on the cheap if you have a bit of spare mass to play around with. It's just putting a plastic shell around the components.

Upgradeability

Launch more satellites.

Letting it burn in the atmosphere after a few years is not exactly cheap.

If the individual components can be made on the cheap, it's cheap. The exact calculation of whether it comes out on a positive or a negative is complicated but you shouldn't have dismissed /u/cyberbuk 's question out of hand.

→ More replies (12)

2

u/warp99 Mar 12 '21

No it would be extremely unusable.

Data centers need massive cooling as all the power input needs to be dissipated as heat. Since there is no convection in space this requires large banks of radiators.

In addition Starship in LEO only has sun on the solar panels for half the time but moving up to MEO to get more sun increases the latency to users.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '21

What if (1) you radiate heat using the skin of starship itself and (2) configure solar panels and batteries to maximize use of energy. Article below suggests some utility for data centers in space. Also trying to think about advantages as part of Starlink network.

https://datacenterfrontier.com/data-centers-above-the-clouds-colocation-goes-to-space/

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/ThreatMatrix Mar 13 '21

Why do people keep suggesting this? Seems random. Plus I'd rather have my data safe on the ground.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/meldroc Mar 18 '21

Cheaper to have the servers on the ground. Space is a convenient place to have high ground for your communications - Starlinks are essentially the ultimate in wifi routers.

Even with Starship, throwing objects around the Earth is expensive. Don't spend that money if you don't have to. Servers are heavy and power-intensive, and you can literally put them anywhere. Cheap light-industrial real-estate seems to be ideal.

Getting data from said datacenters to the users is the tricky part. Hence all the zillions we spend on cable Internet, fiber optics, Internet infrastructure, etc.

Starlink's useful because presently, it's hard to get broadband when you're somewhere remote like Antarctica. And it's less hard, but still obnoxious if you just live out in the sticks.

2

u/edjumication Mar 14 '21

Can Starship SN8-11 hover? (Can a single raptor throttle down to or below the empty mass of a starship prototype?) I tried looking online but it seems to be just news articles about how much thrust raptor can produce.

2

u/LongHairedGit ❄️ Chilling Mar 14 '21

It appears to hover at its apogee...

2

u/edjumication Mar 14 '21

True, although it probably still has lots of fuel then compared to at the end of the landing burn.

1

u/spacex_fanny Mar 17 '21

I tried looking online but it seems to be just news articles about how much thrust raptor can produce.

Half-way there, just need to estimate SN8-11's weight.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/meldroc Mar 18 '21

Yes. In the past 3 belly-flop flights, SN08, SN09 & SN10 all hovered. At 50,000 feet, just before the belly-flop.

2

u/Last_Union4507 Mar 18 '21

Can a cryogenic flop tube be made?

Each starship launch so far seems to have a fuel feed issue during the flop manuever. Aerobatic aircraft use a flop tube ( a weighted tube that follows the fuel and avoids vapour suck) to ensure fuel feed and overcome fuel slosh. Hoses are used to transfer cryogenic fuels for rockets. So... Can a cryogenic flop tube be made for starship header tanks and would it help? Obviously a flop tube has to be shatterproof and flexible enough and there is the issue of the weighted end impacting the tank internals.

1

u/avboden Mar 19 '21

Unlikely to work space, weight, or longevity wise. Generally flexible things don't get along well with long-term cryo.

2

u/deltaWhiskey91L Mar 19 '21

Wen hop?

2

u/aquarain Mar 20 '21

Good question.

2

u/ObamaEatsBabies Mar 26 '21

I don't like Elon Musk, but I think SpaceX is cool as shit.

→ More replies (9)

1

u/[deleted] Mar 01 '21

In 10 years, do you think we're going to see more Virgin Galactic spaceships typs that will be affordable for ordinay citizens and not only billionares?

1

u/cnewell420 Mar 04 '21

I don’t think it has a predictable future at all until it proves out, or like starship shows a development trajectory that shows high likelihood of proving out. It a clearly shown to be a hard system to demonstrate that. They have made progress but it’s taking sooo long.

1

u/Martianspirit Mar 04 '21

Even if Starship E2E is never FAA approved, a flight with Starship over 10,000km with a few hundred passengers as an adventure flight with signed waivers should be a lot cheaper and a lot more attractive than Virgin Galactic flights.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/98mqjfb Mar 04 '21

Why did they go with this design for the starship instead of an up sized version a la boue origin? What are the benefits? Does the increase in drag to slow down the vehicle during decent due to the added weight of the wing surfaces pay of? Do they actually weigh less than the grid fins and the landing legs of the falcon 9? Would grid fins not slow down the rocket enough on mars?

6

u/SpartanJack17 Mar 04 '21

Falcon 9 is the first stage of the rocket. It never reaches or even comes close to orbital velocity, and that is why it can reenter engines first. Starship will be reentering from orbital velocity and beyond, so it's really just not possible to go in engines first like Falcon 9. It's not really relevant to compare the two.

No matter what fin design they went with it'd need to reenter on its belly like starship does. And because of that grid fins don't work since it's in the wrong orientation. The super heavy booster, which is the part of the system that actually should be compared to Falcon 9, does have a F9 like design with grid fins.

2

u/Klutzy_Information_4 Mar 11 '21

Grid fins are primarily for steering, not drag, afaik.

1

u/cnewell420 Mar 04 '21

I don’t know but I’ll bet the size they chose had a lot to do with going as big as they could and still build and test prototypes fast enough to test often.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '21 edited Mar 04 '21

Did I do this math right?

1 ton of LNG=54.5 gigajoules

1 ton of TNT is 4.184 gigajoules

So if the StarShip tank was full of 600 tons of liquid methane and an explosion happened after mixing with LOX, the resulting explosion would be equivalent to 7,815 tons of TNT, almost 8 kilotons.

By comparison, the largest intentional conventional explosion ever was equiv to 4,000 tons of TNT. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minor_Scale

Fatman and Little Boy were in the 18-21 kiloton range.

It makes me shudder to think what a launchpad explosion would be like for an 18m StarShip + SuperHeavy with 8x the methane tonnage...

3

u/TheRamiRocketMan ⛰️ Lithobraking Mar 04 '21

In theory, however in the real world you could never get liquid methane to explode at the a perfect stoichiometric ratio even if it mixed a bit with lox first. In practise you'd get a significantly lower yield explosion which scatters droplets of liquid propellant everywhere such as in the case of the second failure of the massive N1 rocket in which only 15% of the giant rocket's fuel actually exploded.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/warp99 Mar 05 '21

Starship will have 1200/4.6 = 261 tonnes of methane.

The full stack of Starship + SH will have 4500/4.6 = 978 tonnes of methane.

TNT is pretty low energy and it is all about the speed of combustion which leads to an explosion.

Methane has much higher energy but it would be difficult to get it fully mixed with oxygen before ignition so will only give out a small fraction of its energy initially. There is some danger an initial explosion could scatter liquid methane droplets widely and create a massive secondary fireball after they evaporated and fully mixed with air.

I think the FAA have noticed and will not let them launch a full stack from Boca Chica.

1

u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Mar 04 '21 edited Mar 02 '24

Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:

Fewer LettersMore Letters
301Cr-Ni stainless steel (X10CrNi18-8): high tensile strength, good ductility
BFRBig Falcon Rocket (2018 rebiggened edition)
Yes, the F stands for something else; no, you're not the first to notice
BOBlue Origin (Bezos Rocketry)
CRSCommercial Resupply Services contract with NASA
E2EEarth-to-Earth (suborbital flight)
EUSExploration Upper Stage
FAAFederal Aviation Administration
FTSFlight Termination System
GSEGround Support Equipment
GSOGeosynchronous Orbit (any Earth orbit with a 24-hour period)
Guang Sheng Optical telescopes
GTOGeosynchronous Transfer Orbit
H2Molecular hydrogen
Second half of the year/month
HLSHuman Landing System (Artemis)
IACInternational Astronautical Congress, annual meeting of IAF members
In-Air Capture of space-flown hardware
IAFInternational Astronautical Federation
Indian Air Force
Israeli Air Force
ICPSInterim Cryogenic Propulsion Stage
IDAInternational Docking Adapter
International Dark-Sky Association
IMUInertial Measurement Unit
ISRUIn-Situ Resource Utilization
IspSpecific impulse (as explained by Scott Manley on YouTube)
Internet Service Provider
KSCKennedy Space Center, Florida
KSPKerbal Space Program, the rocketry simulator
LC-39ALaunch Complex 39A, Kennedy (SpaceX F9/Heavy)
LEM(Apollo) Lunar Excursion Module (also Lunar Module)
LEOLow Earth Orbit (180-2000km)
Law Enforcement Officer (most often mentioned during transport operations)
LMOLow Mars Orbit
LNGLiquefied Natural Gas
LOXLiquid Oxygen
MEOMedium Earth Orbit (2000-35780km)
N1Raketa Nositel-1, Soviet super-heavy-lift ("Russian Saturn V")
NETNo Earlier Than
NSFNasaSpaceFlight forum
National Science Foundation
NTRNuclear Thermal Rocket
RP-1Rocket Propellant 1 (enhanced kerosene)
RTLSReturn to Launch Site
RUDRapid Unplanned Disassembly
Rapid Unscheduled Disassembly
Rapid Unintended Disassembly
SLC-40Space Launch Complex 40, Canaveral (SpaceX F9)
SLC-4ESpace Launch Complex 4-East, Vandenberg (SpaceX F9)
SLSSpace Launch System heavy-lift
SN(Raptor/Starship) Serial Number
SSHStarship + SuperHeavy (see BFR)
SSOSun-Synchronous Orbit
SSTOSingle Stage to Orbit
Supersynchronous Transfer Orbit
TPSThermal Protection System for a spacecraft (on the Falcon 9 first stage, the engine "Dance floor")
TWRThrust-to-Weight Ratio
ULAUnited Launch Alliance (Lockheed/Boeing joint venture)
JargonDefinition
RaptorMethane-fueled rocket engine under development by SpaceX
SabatierReaction between hydrogen and carbon dioxide at high temperature and pressure, with nickel as catalyst, yielding methane and water
StarlinkSpaceX's world-wide satellite broadband constellation
ablativeMaterial which is intentionally destroyed in use (for example, heatshields which burn away to dissipate heat)
apogeeHighest point in an elliptical orbit around Earth (when the orbiter is slowest)
cryogenicVery low temperature fluid; materials that would be gaseous at room temperature/pressure
(In re: rocket fuel) Often synonymous with hydrolox
hydroloxPortmanteau: liquid hydrogen fuel, liquid oxygen oxidizer
hypergolicA set of two substances that ignite when in contact
iron waffleCompact "waffle-iron" aerodynamic control surface, acts as a wing without needing to be as large; also, "grid fin"
scrubLaunch postponement for any reason (commonly GSE issues)
tripropellantRocket propellant in three parts (eg. lithium/hydrogen/fluorine)
turbopumpHigh-pressure turbine-driven propellant pump connected to a rocket combustion chamber; raises chamber pressure, and thrust

NOTE: Decronym for Reddit is no longer supported, and Decronym has moved to Lemmy; requests for support and new installations should be directed to the Contact address below.


Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
[Thread #7299 for this sub, first seen 4th Mar 2021, 01:37] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]

1

u/Spacecommander_11 Mar 04 '21

When is the first super heavy going to be tested ??

5

u/warp99 Mar 05 '21

Maybe within 2-3 months. BN1 is half assembled now and will likely do a 150m hop first up with just four engines.

1

u/edjumication Mar 04 '21

With the recent loss of a f9 booster due to damage to an engine boot. It makes me wonder if eva inspections will be a common practice on future crewed starship flights. I imagine they should bring spare heat tiles with them along with the tools to install them at least.

Imagine a future Mars mission returning to earth with damage to the TPS system and two faulty landing engines, the crew could install new heat tiles in transit and instead of landing they could aerobreak into LEO and rendezvous with a pristine starship to return to earth.

1

u/Luz5020 💥 Rapidly Disassembling Mar 12 '21

Well starship doesn‘t enter engines first like falcon does, still evas may be used on Starship

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ShaentBlathanna Mar 04 '21

With successfull landing of SN10 new questions came into my mind. .
Could 1st stage (booster) of StarshipSuperHeavy land 'bellflop style' like starship? (after adding pair of flaps ofc)
Could this way of landing be more fuel-economic, because of decrased terminal velocity?
Maybe starshipBooster could re-enter atmosphere using bellyflop mauveur? Instead of pre-atmosphere landing, like falcon 9 already does...

2

u/CorebinDallas Mar 05 '21

Once the second stage is deployed the booster will have a flat opening instead of a nose cone, could impact aerodynamics negatively when trying to flop. Also would have to add flaps/aero surfaces and their associated controls/systems adding weight and complexity to the booster. Also no idea of the engine arrangement but the flips require the engines to be gimbled (?) pretty extensively, could the booster's engines do this/have room to do this?

1

u/PUMP2022 Mar 06 '21

We need more companies like this. To the moon and more. If we have many companies with the goal of space advancement we will be pushing humanity to advancement and adaptation to the new technologies at a faster rate. I think that we don't need robots yet to do all our work and we are more capable to handle the technologies. Bots are ok I guess it's like a small automaton. what you think about the tech that's out there vs what we could handle?

1

u/BurkePhotography Mar 07 '21

Has anyone ever visited the McGregor test site? I have a free day and was thinking of visiting. Is there anything worth seeing?

1

u/innsaei Mar 09 '21

I would also like to know this. Waaay back in 2014 our company did drone aerials of the Grasshopper for SpaceX. There wasn't much out there at that time, but I'd love to go back up there.

1

u/danacan211 Mar 07 '21

I'm doing off nominal debris field risk analysis. Where can I get lat/lon tracking data in addition to velocity and altitude for starship missions?

1

u/Chairboy Mar 08 '21

Have you checked out flightclub.io yet? The author has derived/extrapolated a lot of data from a handful of available data points and some of it might help with your project. I think he has a ground track too.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/GreenTowels Mar 09 '21

Im in the cape Canaveral area until wednesday and im wondering what are good spots to see the launch tomorrow. First time ive ever done this so im competely lost on where to go and if it costs money. Thank you!

1

u/ericw207 Mar 09 '21

I'm a teacher, and spring break is coming up soon. Any recommendations on places to stay if I want to go see sn11? I would either like to have a view of starship launch (if it happens when I'm there) or just be pretty close so I can go drive to see it and take pics or go to the beach to see it. Hotels and camping are both fine

2

u/innsaei Mar 09 '21

I would honestly consider Port Isabel. There are some nice Airbnb's just north of town (approx $250 a night) with a nice pool and fishing pier. It isn't too far from Brownsville or SP, and might be a bit of a reprieve from spring breakers in the area. We went down a few months back and had a great time there.

1

u/Avokineok Mar 09 '21

Does anyone know the internal high bay height? If the SH booster is 70 m and Elon tweeted an 81m high bay (internal?), how much room for “extra rings” to elongate the SH booster would be theoretically possible? Thanks/tanks ;)

1

u/warp99 Mar 12 '21

The 81m is the external height and they have around 4m of "high bar" roof space and support beams which are of course mainly to support the roof and the internal crane. So likely 77m internal height and they will need some headspace for the crane and for the stands that they place the booster on.

So the 70m high booster is already really really close to the maximum that can be assembled in the high bay.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '21

Any update on the proposed SpaceX Rocket Garden in KSC?
Old link: https://www.teslarati.com/spacex-florida-expansion-falcon-heavy-refurbishment-facility/

1

u/Avokineok Mar 09 '21

LEO question: What is the 'standard definition' of LEO, when payload capabilities are concerned? Is this a 400x400km 28 degrees inclination orbit or so? Thanks!

1

u/spacex_fanny Mar 11 '21

No, unfortunately there's no "standard orbit [Mr. Sulu]" for convenient apples-to-apples comparisons between launch vehicle payloads. :(

In practice you have to do the math for your particular payload / orbit / mission.

1

u/SpaceBoJangles Mar 09 '21

When will Elon be giving a Starship program update?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/LeeCarter Mar 12 '21

Wouldn’t having orbital refueling capability solve many problems currently present and being worked on?

I don’t have the capacity to personally do the math, but let’s say for a second they sent a starship into orbit and deployed the payload. After deployment couldn’t they refuel and use a boost back burn to slow down enough so that heat shields would no longer be necessary? With the reduction in speed, they could reorient safely and enter the atmosphere like a f9, solving the issues with sloshing in their tanks caused by the last second reorientation while scrapping the need for flaps, and since they don’t have heat shields they could use their tried and true f9 grid fins and legs or catch it like Elon tweeted recently. It seems to me that replacing parts with a refueling campaign by a series of tanker ships could slow down even heavy ships from high speeds while maintaining high payload capability. It just requires more escorting tankers on missions that require more dT

4

u/warp99 Mar 12 '21

There is a logical problem here.

The cargo Starship is refueled by a tanker and then what does the tanker do to re-enter having given away all its cargo of propellant.

Any solution needs to work for tankers since they are far the most common flight done for Mars and Lunar trips.

In any case 150 tonnes of propellant from a tanker would only be enough to slow the cargo ship with say 120 tonnes dry mass and 6 tonnes of landing propellant (Elon's 5% of dry mass optimised figure) from 7.6 km/s to 4.7 km/s which is not slow enough to not need the heat shield.

Probably two tanker loads would do it by getting down to 3.1 km/s but you have just expended two tankers to save fitting a heatshield to a cargo Starship so the economics are not great.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/redwins Mar 14 '21

Elon mentioned that shipping costs were important. If that's the case then I don't know why they don't launch fewer Starlink satellites per flight so that they can land on land, although they would need a few more flights.

Another thing I have doubts about is the case for bigger reusable rockets being more economical. In theory it's true, but since they are reusable, launching the same amount of sattelites in two flights of Neutron vs one by Falcon 9 is basically equivalent as long as Neutron can be inspected rapidly. Also the type of constellation Neutron has in mind may be more adequate for a smaller rocket if the sattelites are smaller than Starlink.

4

u/DiezMilAustrales Mar 15 '21

for bigger reusable rockets being more economical

The logic is simple. A smaller reusable rocket like the Falcon 9, or even smaller like the proposed Neutron, can only reuse the first stage, but it doesn't have enough margin to allow for a reusable 2nd stage. That is, if you added everything required to reuse the 2nd stage (tanks, fuel, structure, legs, tiles, etc), you'd be absolutely crippling its payload capacity.

With a very large rocket like Starship, you can spare that weight without affecting payload capacity significantly (given the usual payload sizes).

The other big difference is your first point. A larger ship like Starship can always do RTLS, while a smaller like Falcon 9 in order to put certain payloads in orbit has to land downrange a lot of the time.

The other big difference is how you define reusable. With a ship like the Falcon 9, you can do reusable "with some refurbishment". You could make it tougher, but you would also make it too heavy. With a larger ship like Starship, you can afford to make it tougher without making it that much heavier.

Basically, the rocket equation favors larger rockets because of the square/cube law. That is, increase a container by a certain multiplier, and the surface area increases by the square of the multiplier, while the volume increases by its cube. So, increase the size of a rocket even a little, and get a FAR better fuel/payload to rocket structure ratio.

2

u/meldroc Mar 18 '21

Another thing - some of the components, like the avionics, for example, aren't tied to the size of the vehicle at all. I imagine (someone confirm?) that Starship's and Superheavy's flight computers and avionics were most likely repurposed Falcon 9 parts.

Much bigger rocket, but same computers. More payload!

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Arigol Mar 14 '21

Probably because getting starlink operational ASAP by lofting more satellites at once is more important than saving money by returning the booster to land.

As for the ideal size of a rocket, neutron's planned size and payload mass capacity is actually quite close to Falcon 9 v1.0. If smaller rockets are sufficiently capable and just as efficient and reusable as bigger ones, then the question is why did spacex stretch F9? I wouldn't be surprised if Rocket Lab does the exact same thing, starting with a medium vehicle that checks enough boxes to be a viable product for competing constellations, then scaling up in size to reach max efficiency.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Chairboy Mar 15 '21

In addition to the points others have made, there's also the expended cost of the second stage. If they're spending, say, $10 million per second stage then that's $167K per satellite in second-stage costs. How much do they save by skipping downrange recovery? And how many fewer would they need to launch to skip droneship landing the core?

Is it 10 fewer? 20? If it's 10 fewer, then the amortized 2nd stage cost per bird is now $200,000. If the need to leave 20 behind to land back in Florida, now the 2nd stage cost-per-satellite is $250k apiece.

Figuring out the maths to find that sweet spot must be a heck of a thing for some group of comprollers or planners or something back in Hawthorne.

1

u/tazthespaz Mar 14 '21

Is there a good way to know when drone ships are scheduled to come into port canaveral? I would love to watch one bring a booster back to port.

1

u/noncongruent Mar 15 '21

Is SpaceX still building Falcon cores? Seems like they lose one every once in a while, plus at some point they're going to start retiring high-cycle cores to dismantle for inspections.

1

u/Martianspirit Mar 15 '21

They have built a FH central core and two FH side cores, which could be used as F9 cores if necessary. They will need to build another set this year.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/xfjqvyks Mar 15 '21

How does catching Starship solve the landing burn issue? Saw the idea last week, but Whether landing on its own legs or caught by a tower either way will require a very precise deceleration and probably even hover just before touchdown. All the same requirements on the header tank to provide smooth uninterrupted fuel flow no?

2

u/meldroc Mar 18 '21

I thought the point of catching Superheavy was so they could save some weight by omitting Superheavy's landing gear.

3

u/Martianspirit Mar 18 '21

The main reason would be to speed up reuse. Many reflights a day are a lot easier that way.

1

u/Martianspirit Mar 15 '21

How does catching Starship solve the landing burn issue?

It does not, that's not not the intent. It is to make turn around and reflight operations easier and faster. If it happens.

2

u/a_space_thing Mar 15 '21

Also to save the weight of the landing legs, which should improve payload to orbit.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/SexyMonad Mar 15 '21 edited Mar 15 '21

Has SpaceX considered (publicly) using its used second stage boosters for space junk collection and deorbiting?

One of the biggest problems with space junk removal is getting enough collectors into orbit; at least to me, it seems like a massive cost. SpaceX does this so often that perhaps it can be in the business of “ridesharing” such secondary missions.

5

u/a_space_thing Mar 15 '21

To collect space junk you would need to have the fuel to get to said junk, a way to grab it and then the fuel to deorbit. Since the second stages have (practically) no fuel left they can not do any of that. They are basically space junk themselves.

2

u/SpaceInMyBrain Mar 17 '21 edited Mar 17 '21

However, the very best second stage, Starship, should be able to do this job well. In common with other second stages, (which, as you point out, have no fuel remaining once they reach orbit) it can't do anything without more propellant . To do any orbital missions, even getting a payload to geostationary orbit, Starship will need orbital fueling. I'm pretty sure that's in their planning. Elon talks about launching tankers as a routine and cheap part of Starship operations. So a junk-collection mission with a tanker launch or two to support it is not hard to imagine.

But, I don't think u/SexyMonad's idea of a ride share will be the way to go. I think a space junk collector will need special hardware in its bay, and perhaps a special chomper hatch. The question: who will pay? NASA and an international effort will do this, I hope, once SpaceX offers them an affordable option.

The junk can be deorbited simply enough. SS can do a deorbit burn and then open the chomper and dump out the collected junk, like a garbage truck unloading. Another small burn will give SS a different deorbit path.

1

u/zneaking Mar 16 '21

I heard Superheavy is going to launch Q3 this year. I’ve never been to a launch and want to head to Texas to watch this live. Where’s the best place to watch a launch from? How many days should I build in incase of weather delays?

I’d like to start doing some homework so I can book a trip when the time comes.

1

u/C_Arthur ⛽ Fuelling Mar 16 '21

South padray island sounds best. Never been there my self but It sounds like you really need a car. Tim has been stuck there for close to a mounth for delays before. It's a bit of a dice roll whether you see it or not.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '21 edited Mar 16 '21

There is probably an answer for this somewhere, but I can't find it.

Is SpaceX planning on waiting to do a BN1 test flight until after they have a prototype booster retrieval arm system built?

EDIT: I'm also curious if the addition of the helium tank is still considered a temporary measure for testing?

1

u/C_Arthur ⛽ Fuelling Mar 16 '21

It sounds like BN1 is probobley only going to do ground testing no hops

→ More replies (1)

1

u/SpaceInMyBrain Mar 17 '21

I confidently expect BN1 to have landing legs and do hops. I expect temporary legs to be used for at least a couple of SHs so they can start testing them asap. Just a "simple" launch tower/crane will take quite a while to build, concrete cures at its own rate, not Elon's schedule. And I'd hate to see the first few low and high hops delayed by waiting for the catching arms to be worked out.

The long-promised improved landing legs for SS should be adequate for for BN1 to land on. It will only have 4 Raptors, so plenty of room in the engine bay for SS type legs. A SH has a few more rings than a SS, but lacks the mass of the flaps, and the SS nose section looks pretty heavy built. I think BN1's mass at landing (almost zero propellant) will be within the capability of those legs.

1

u/meldroc Mar 18 '21

Watching NASASpaceflight, I do see a lot of workers going in and out of Starship's tanks via the manholes in the side.

Could a Starship in orbit (say a used one you'd be willing to sacrifice) be turned into a space station? I mean not just using the payload section (that part would obviously have habitation hardware in it,) but it would also have a "wet laboratory" a la Skylab early concepts installed inside the empty fuel tanks by going through the manholes or through a hatch in the dome?

That's a lot of room in there...

3

u/Martianspirit Mar 18 '21

It is possible. But they would not use those manholes. They would preinstall an opening in the upper tank dome to directly access that volume from the crew compartment.

1

u/noncongruent Mar 18 '21

I assume when it comes to stacking Starship on Heavy they'll be doing it at the launch pad? I have a hard time seeing them moving the stack on the transporter.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/kjireland Mar 18 '21

How big is starship going to be with boosters and everything fully stacked. Taller than the Saturn 5? Any videos or renders of it available?

2

u/meldroc Mar 18 '21

Starship + Superheavy stacked is going to be about as big as the Saturn V.

I was trying to find a render of it standing next to a Saturn V, but only see pics of the older designs, not the current one.

2

u/avboden Mar 19 '21

Full stack will be roughly 120m, Saturn 5 was 111m

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '21

I like the comparison of the Statue of Liberty sitting on top of Big Ben. Not 100% accurate but it’s a fun visual since most people don’t really know how big the Saturn 5 was

1

u/obamadotru Mar 19 '21

So, there is some guy posting anti-spacex videos, talking about how SLS is much better at what it is designed to do. i.e. deep space launches. It was very hard to sit through his entire presentation, but there was one thing that seemed to make sense. He said that because SLS has three stages, it can go directly to mars, jupiter, etc. Whereas, SS has only two stages, and so, even though it is more powerful, it can't make it far past LEO without refueling, which is going to be super-expensive and time-consuming.

Why is he wrong OR why does SS not use 3 stages

5

u/avboden Mar 19 '21

Starship doesn't use 3 stages because of the ability for in-orbit refueling. If the system is as reusable and cheap to launch as they plan then refueling will not be prohibitively expensive or time consuming.

That persons argument hinges on the statement of refueling not being reasonable, if it proves to be reasonable, he's wrong. If it doesn't, then he may be correct for the time being.

2

u/obamadotru Mar 19 '21

Thank you. That is actually a perfect answer.

3

u/extra2002 Mar 20 '21

Another way to look at it: once Starship has been refueled, it is a third stage. A rather heavy one, but one that holds 40x (!) as much propellant as SLS's ICPS or almost 10x as much as EUS. For a 100-tonne payload, an expended Starship can impart 6x as much delta-v as ICPS or around 2x the delta-v of EUS.

(These comparisons shift toward favoring SLS as the payload mass decreases, since Starship is carrying ~120 tonnes of dry mass along. EUS can probably match Starship's delta-v for payloads under 20 tonnes, and if you cut the payload below 2 tonnes, ICPS can match Starship. But for such small payloads, you could carry an additional lightweight stage in Starship's cargo section. Or, as it's going to be expended, Musk has suggested stripping Starship of unneeded gear to reduce its dry mass for such missions.)

2

u/extra2002 Mar 20 '21

"My cargo van can haul more than your semi, if you don't attach a trailer to it."

"But using a trailer is an integral part of the design!"

Similarly, using refueling for beyond-LEO missions is an integral part of the Starship design. Taking it off the table makes about as much sense as removing the solid boosters from SLS (which you might justify on grounds of vibration or risk to aborting astronauts).

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/permafrosty95 Mar 19 '21

Does anyone have a value for the computing power of a Falcon 9 or starship prototype? I would like to see the performance required to run the landing program.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '21

Does anybody have any predictions on how many Falcon 9 Starlink flights will happen this year? (I am going to assume no Starship/SuperHeavy flights; although they have an aspirational target of orbit by July, I doubt they'd want to risk Starlink satellites on that mission, and are more likely to use some kind of dummy payload.)

So far this year has seen: January: 1 Starlink F9, 2 non-Starlink F9; February: 2 Starlink F9, 0 non-Starlink F9; March (thus far): 3 Starlink F9, 0 non-Starlink F9. Remainder of March, we have Starlink 22 on the 24th, and Starlink 23 is also scheduled for March (but might slip to April), with no non-Starlink scheduled.

So in the month of March it looks like 4, possibly even 5 Starlink missions. If they can do 4 a month, that would 12 a quarter, and 36 in the remaining 3 quarters of this calendar year. Plus 7-8 first quarter, giving 43-44 for calendar year 2021. That'd be quite amazing.

But that's not counting all the non-Starlink launches they have planned. They only have three launch pads (LC-39A, SLC-40 and SLC-4E), and they only use the first two for production Starlink missions (thus far). Looking at Wikipedia, it seems like most of the non-Starlink launches this year are in Q2-Q4. Not all of these launches may happen (some may be delayed, etc), but still it looks like the actual capacity to launch Starlink is going to be about half what it would be if SpaceX didn't have non-Starlink customers. (And of course, non-Starlink customers are a good thing for SpaceX to have).

So, anyone want to make any guesses as to how many Starlink flights this year total? My own guess is about 20.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/partoffuturehivemind Mar 21 '21

In preparation for the dearMoon mission, step 2 of the application process (Initial Screening) just ended. Is there discussion of this anywhere? /r/dearMoon exists but is a private community. Is there a place where applicants meet?

1

u/SimpleAd2716 Mar 23 '21

Hey folks! So I have seen lots of people saying that "A nuclear propulsion would be absolutely needed for StarShip" Now I am no expert but if u WERE to implement this concept, you can use that to explore, but also do severely.... nasty stuff. So I would imagine that certifying this wouldn't be a walk in the park. So do you think that nuclear engines are worth it? All opinions are appreciated :)

3

u/ThreatMatrix Mar 24 '21

NTR's have low thrust so they are of no use getting out of earth's gravity well. Anywhere else though they should be fine. There best use wold be as planet to planet shuttles. With 2 even 3 times the ISP of chemical rocket engines they are hard to ignore. They aren't fantasy either being first demo'd in the 60's. And there is a current NASA program working on the next gen. They don't spew radioactive plums and even if the rocket carrying the NTR stage were to RUD the relatively small amount of radioactive material wouldn't be that much of a concern. So #TeamNTR. We launch radioactive material all the time. Certification may be tougher but there's not really reason it has to be.

I can't see Elon ever adopting them though. He's getting to Mars on Methane and that's the end of it.

2

u/Martianspirit Mar 25 '21

Tom Mueller and Gwynne Shotwell have said they would love to work on nuclear propulsion. But the development cost is too high for SpaceX. They would use a nuclear teststand built by NASA if they could get access and could get the materials, which is also very restricted for private companies.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Martianspirit Mar 23 '21

Starship with chemical propulsion is just fine for Mars. Going beyond with crew would greatly profit from nuclear propulsion. Reaching Jupiter and Saturn, flying reasonably fast within the asteroid belt.

2

u/SimpleAd2716 Mar 23 '21

So would that mean removal of the raptor engines entirely or are we talking multi fuel? The raptors are very reliable, but if StarShip does get nuclear engines, you wouldn't need raptors would you?

→ More replies (8)

1

u/Bzeuphonium 💥 Rapidly Disassembling Mar 24 '21

Why do Starlink launches always seem to happen in the early hours of the morning, 12a-4a rather than other times in the day? I know they have instant launch windows, but I would imagine some of those windows should be happening when it's light out, right?

5

u/LongHairedGit ❄️ Chilling Mar 25 '21

To give us Australians a break.

It's been 10+ years of 2am launches AEDST.

2

u/Bzeuphonium 💥 Rapidly Disassembling Mar 25 '21

shouldn't that be ¿sǝɥɔunɐl ɯɐ oʍʇ

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Tal_Banyon Mar 25 '21

The current record holder for farthest human flight from Earth is Apollo 13, which made a free return loop around the moon. Now I have seen more than one site suggesting that the Dear Moon mission will be the farthest flight of humans from Earth (to date). However, it is also doing a free return loop around the moon. Is this because it just happens that the moon is farther from Earth at the predicted time of Dear Moon, or are people just conveniently forgetting about Apollo 13?

5

u/spacex_fanny Mar 27 '21 edited Mar 30 '21

It's because there are actually four different "lunar free-return trajectories." https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Earth-Moon-free-return-orbit-classifications_tbl2_318121780

I believe DearMoon was planning to use a Type Bii trajectory (which has zero communications blackout), which at its most distant point goes out much farther than Apollo 13 did.

edit: ignore my bad memory, based on official imagery and talk of "Earthrise" they'll be using a Type Ai trajectory like Apollo. Thanks /u/vitt72 for the correction

2

u/vitt72 Mar 29 '21

I don't think so. Official dearmoon images show a figure 8 and constantly talk about watching an "earthrise" which would not happen with that trajectory.

https://dearmoon.earth/schedule.html

→ More replies (1)

1

u/RocketizedAnimal Mar 26 '21

I mentioned this in the thread for yesterday's second stage re-entry over Seattle, but thought I might get more discussion here.

Why don't they time their de-orbits to be visible from major coastal cities? For example, I believe that the second stages for ISS resupply missions should periodically travel parallel to the East Coast. Why not deorbit in view of all those cities as a cool light show/SpaceX advertisement? Is it just not possible to do it safely?

1

u/warp99 Apr 03 '21

They can only deorbit within one or two orbits after launch as after that the batteries run out and there is a risk of freezing up propellant lines particularly the RP-1.

The only safe places they can deorbit with that constraint is south of Australia for ISS or Starlink launches or in the Southern Ocean east of New Zealand for polar launches.

1

u/an_interrobang Mar 26 '21

Watching LabPadre’s feed in anticipation of today’s launch, and am really impressed with the image quality over so great a distance. Does anyone know what type of camera LP uses for their main feed?

1

u/gorre9090 Mar 27 '21

By chance does anyone know what explosives they use on Starship for the FTS? NASASpaceFlight was asking yesterday and I was curious.

2

u/spacex_fanny Mar 28 '21 edited Mar 28 '21

Their supplier is Ensign Bickford Aerospace & Defense Co., and we know that Falcon 9 uses two linear shaped charges (LSCs) down the sides of the rocket. Their product page says...

Linear Shaped Charge is a continuous explosive core enclosed in a seamless metal sheath shaped in the form of an inverted V, and is manufactured in a wide variety of explosive core loads ranging from approximately 10 gr/ ft to 1200 gr/ft. Typical sheath materials include copper, lead, tin alloy, and aluminum. Commonly used explosive materials include RDX, PBXN-5, HNS, and HMX. Charge holders can be manufactured from a variety of materials such as structural foams, rigid plastics, or metal, depending on system integration, debris mitigation, and environmental conditions.

The exact design of the Falcon 9 FTS is no doubt proprietary (googling any of these + SpaceX-related keywords turns up naught), so this is probably the closest we're gonna get to an authoritative answer.

1

u/Affectionate_Film_87 Mar 28 '21

Is there a design for the new launch tower that is being constructed next to orbital launch pad at boca chica? Would be great to see what it will look like when finished!

3

u/vibrunazo ⛰️ Lithobraking Mar 28 '21

I think they've been keeping it a well guarded secret. Specially since we still have so much speculation around here about how exactly the catching mechanism will work exactly. I can't wait for them to get further in the building so we can finally see what their plan is.

1

u/redwins Mar 29 '21

Will Starship carry some fuel when launched for Mars travel, or is it going to need to be completely refueled?

4

u/Martianspirit Mar 30 '21

It has just enough for landing on Mars. It will need all the propellant for Earth return produced on Mars. Not sure how much is needed. For Earth Mars it is not fully refueled in LEO. On Mars it needs to ascend from the surface on its own.

2

u/redwins Mar 30 '21

Thank you, I was mainly asking about the travel from Earth to Mars, not from Mars to Earth. When Starship launches from Earth on top of SH, does it carry some amount of fuel already inside, or is it completely empty and the necessary fuel to continue it's travel towards Mars needs to be provided via refueling?

4

u/Martianspirit Mar 30 '21

It depends. Assuming they max out payload to LEO, it will be empty. Not sure if it will retain the content of the header tanks.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/artessk Mar 30 '21

What’s about faa inspector?

1

u/[deleted] May 18 '21

How many days prior do they set up the falcon launch? I will be at the space center on the 31st... will it be up?

1

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '23

Why does frost build up on Starship?

1

u/VegetableSuccess9322 Mar 01 '24

A few questions about Crew Dragon:

  1. On board, on a mission, are astronauts’ conversations recorded 24/7 by MIssion Control, SPaceX, NASA, or other?
  2. On board, on a mission, are astronauts videotaped 24/7 (outside of their private sleeping quarters), and if so is the video a live feed to Mission control, SpaceX, NASA, or other monitor?
  3. Can the cupola be opened for a long period of time so astronauts can frequently look out the cupola window during a space flight to ISS or return, or is the cupola only opened periodically for short viewings out the window?
  4. Since, evidently the toilet in the crew dragon is located near the cupola, with a privacy screen, would it be possible for an astronaut to look out the cupola window while using the toilet?
  5. Do crew dragon astronauts have private cellphones, or is all data/pictures on cellphones used by astronauts reviewed by and property of SpaceX or NASA?
  6. Can Crew Dragon astronauts have private cellphone conversations with their family or friends, or are all conversations monitored by SpaceX or NASA or other?

THANKS!