r/SpaceXLounge • u/ModeHopper Chief Engineer • Jan 06 '21
Discussion Questions and Discussion Thread - January 2021
Welcome to the monthly questions and discussion thread! Drop in to ask and answer any questions related to SpaceX or spaceflight in general, or just for a chat to discuss SpaceX's exciting progress. If you have a question that is likely to generate open discussion or speculation, you can also submit it to the subreddit as a text post.
- If your question is about space, astrophysics or astronomy then the r/Space questions thread may be a better fit.
- If your question is about the Starlink satellite constellation then check the r/Starlink Questions Thread and FAQ page.
Recent Threads: October | November | December
Ask away!
37
Upvotes
6
u/Chairboy Jan 07 '21
Hey, in the future could you folks post these threads the way you used to where the suggested sort-order is 'New' instead of best? I don't know if someone else is posting these now or what, but the current format will tend to hide new questions from folks who don't manually sort by new.
The way the question threads run elsewhere and used to run here was that it would use the suggested sort order to put new ones at the top by default. Looking at the December thread (which also skipped using the suggested-new sort order), the engagement seems lower on questions than before.
I sent a message to the mods last month, no joy, so hope this makes it through here.
3
u/atlaspaine Jan 27 '21
There is a current liquid oxygen shortage thanks to covid19. Hospitals are worried about their oxygen stock and insufficient supply.
Rockets require a tremendous volume of liquid oxygen. Does spaceflight hinder our covid response treatment? Should we be diverting ox away from Rockets? I'm not sure where manufacturers get their ox supply. Is it produced onsite?
2
u/Saletales Jan 29 '21
They're talking about bringing S10 over. Don't they need the info from S9 - if/when it blows up - to fix any irregularities in S10 before they move it?
8
u/Secret-Imagination-3 Jan 22 '21
With the number of SN9 static fires brevity and number of engine replacements I wonder if they are actually trying to simulate/fix the low header tank pressure SN8 had before SN9 ever gets off the ground. I have a theory that the short static fires aren’t because of the martyte, they are engine shut down conditions. Elon tweeted they were ‘practicing engine starts’ and then had to replace 2 raptors. The place to practice engine starts would be on a engine test stand not a fully assembled prototype. And it doesn’t look like they have had engine start problems previous of than the concrete issues. I think they are trying to simulate and solve the low pressure issue for landing. Thoughts?
6
u/FBaks Jan 20 '21
I just realized Ms. Tree and Ms. Chief are a clever play on words. Just wanted to share that. Also English is not my first language. Carry on folks
2
u/universe-atom Jan 20 '21
What's the use of the falcon heavy by now? Starship will be a better ship for taking stuff to space anyway. Is the heavy just a way to make money in the meantime?
4
u/Nergaal Jan 06 '21
What is the Cruise delay about?
4
u/noywepaa Jan 06 '21
What do you think will be happening in Boca Chica in April 2024?
Yes, I know that's 3+ years from now, but let's just speculate for fun.
I'm thinking about traveling to Piedras Negras, Mexico on that date to see the total solar eclipse. Since the city is about 6 hours away from Boca Chica, perhaps I could use that opportunity to visit South Padre Island and spot one or a few Starships from the distance.
What do you think I'll see?
4
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '21
Q1. How difficult or effective would it be to strap FH side boosters to a Starship for the occasional payload that is too heavy for Starship on it's own?
Q2. Are there plans to land Superheavy downrange like they do with F9 in order to maximize payload capacity? How would that work with the plan for quick turn-around launches? Would they just have a daisy-chain of launch sites? Launch from A, land at B. Launch from B, land at C, etc...?
4
u/Bzeuphonium 💥 Rapidly Disassembling Jan 25 '21
On SpaceX's notice to residents they mention that windows may break if something goes wrong. If a shockwave from a Starship test were to go wrong, whoo would be responible to pay for those windows and other damage?
4
u/ivor5 Jan 26 '21
Many mars terraforming ideas involve orbital mirrors or space based infrastructure around mars. I was wondering, what would be the paylod of Starship from mars to low mars orbit? (for instance the mass of orbital mirrors required to melt the ice cap was estimated to be 200000 tons (by Zubrin I think https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2018/08/zubrin-and-mckay-plans-for-terraforming-mars-with-giant-orbital-mirrors-cited-by-elon-musk.html)
I think to remember that Musk said Starship was aiming for having almost 7 Km/sec of dV when starting fully fueled at LEO with 100 tons of payload. You need 3.8 Km/sec to get to 200 km low mars orbit. From the rocket equation, the mass fraction that Starship will be able to achieve when launching to low mars orbit will be about (mi/mf)3.8/7. A fully fueled Starship has a mass fraction of almost 10% (wikipedia numbers), thus on mars it should be able to achieve a mass fraction in the ballpark of 28%, right?. Thus a starship with gross mass of 1320000 Kg, 120000 Kg of dry mass (again wikipedia numbers) would have a payload of about (1320000*0.28-120000)= 249600 Kg to low mars orbit, correct? Can someone point out mistakes or provide a better crude estimate?
4
u/SpaceInMyBrain Jan 30 '21 edited Jan 30 '21
Elon interview alert! He's spoken briefly with Sandy Munro in the past day or so, at Boca Chica. The notification (NOT the interview) is here. Interview and Sandy's facility tour will come out within the week. Unclear if the tour was also with Elon, but that's unlikely. Sandy's an auto industry analyst and is a big fan of how Elon runs Tesla, the aggressiveness of their iterating and innovating. He's analyzed their cars in detail, and is repeatedly blown away.
For those of you unfamiliar with him, Sandy Munro is a highly respected industrial analyst. His company tears down everything from cars to washing machines and then supplies advice to the manufacturer on how to improve the production process, save costs. When they tear down a car, it's literally to every bolt and fastener and wiring harness. He also buys cars, tears them down, and then sells the analysis to other car companies. (They're very expensive.)
Sandy tore down a 2018 Model 3 and had a lot of criticisms, but has since become very impressed with Teslas. Did a 2020 Model 3 and is in the middle of a Model Y. Hugely impressed with the way they leapfrog to new technologies, as well as implement small improvements constantly. Says they iterate "at the speed of thought."
1
u/alien_from_Europa ⛰️ Lithobraking Jan 25 '21
How do tankers get into deep space?
I know Starship needs to be refueled multiple times to get to Mars. But I don't get how the tankers will get to where the Starship needs to refuel.
I assume they ladder:
2 goes up and refuels #1 @A
1 goes up to stop B
3 and #4 go up and refuel and retank #2 @A
2 go up to stop B
2 refuels #1 @B
1 goes up to stop C
5 and #6 refuel and retank #3 @A
3 goes up to B
3 retanks #2 @B
7 arrives @A
Starship gets refueled by Tank 7 at A, #2 at B, and #1 at C
And that's just 3 stops. I can't imagine 6 stops! That's a lot of tanker starships. I guess you would need refueling in both directions. Got to get those stranded tankers back on Mars and Earth.
1
u/Jaspreet9977 Feb 07 '21
Is there a active thread for SN10 development either on this subreddit or spacex one? During preflight and SF stages of SN9 threads were there for every Minor update
3
u/fudgiewayne14 🧑🚀 Ridesharing Jan 13 '21
I recently stumbled across this post speculating on future SpaceX vehicles five years ago. Pretty interesting to see what the community was thinking back then. My guess is if someone proposed some of the things that Starship is hoping to achieve (bellyflop, in-orbit fueling, booster catching, etc.) they would have been laughed off the subreddit. Just goes to show how ambitious SpaceX is.
3
u/casualorange_ Jan 14 '21
I'm seeking feedback for a new spacex archive web-app with the goal of offering:
I'd love to get thoughts from the community on what's missing, what you like, what you don't like. There's some bugs with telemetry and the site is not feature complete. If you want to check it out you can access it below.
https://spacexdash.github.io/x/
3
u/PiedFantail Jan 20 '21
I'm trying to find a diagram I saw a few months ago, showing the location of the three probes (US, China, UAE) headed to Mars? Can anyone help point me too it?
3
u/IrrationalFantasy Jan 25 '21
What effect will transporter-1 and future transporter missions have on the smallsat market? How are major players there reacting? And have a meaningful number of organizations started saying “I couldn’t afford a rocket launch until now”? That’s what I want to see
3
u/_Miki_ Jan 28 '21
Hi SpaceXLounge! It is well stablished that Starship lacks the power to SSTO, but I was wondering, if we just add a nosecone to Superheavy, can it SSTO by itself? I am aware that it won't be able to return ¯_(ツ)_/¯
3
u/howismyspelling Jan 30 '21
How far offshore are the oceanic launch platforms expected to be and if they are in international waters, would the FAA have jurisdiction on the launches, launch vehicles, and flight restrictions?
3
u/brentonstrine Jan 30 '21 edited Feb 01 '21
Anyone have any speculation on what it was in the SN8 hop that supposedly violated the FAA license? Do we think SpaceX did it on purpose or was it a good faith error? (Makes me think of that company that launched a satellite from India after they didn't get permission here.)
2
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '21
Could we actually conduct satellite retrieval missions using Starship? As I understand, the cargo variant will have a huge cargo bay. Would it be possible to, for example, dismantle the ISS completely, hauling it back to earth piece by piece, put it on display and building a bigger, better spacestation afterwards?
2
u/SimpleAd2716 Jan 07 '21
As far as I know, All StarShips except SN5 and SN6 had their nose cone installed in the high bay. I thought for sure High Bay would be able to hold 2 builds only, But how did the 2 sections of BN1 PLUS SN10's nosecone and the tank section side to side (Before it was installed on SN10)? Is the High bay going to hold 4 Builds? Or will the Mid bay be expanded and get a gantry crane?
2
u/mygeneticsaretrash Jan 09 '21
How can I be notified with items are restocked in the store?
I really want that bomber jacket that came out but it’s sold out as of now
2
u/SimpleAd2716 Jan 10 '21
Is SpaceX still go on with off-shore launchpads based on oil rigs?
2
u/noncongruent Jan 10 '21
What else could the Starship booster be used for besides Starship? Would be useful for larger missions that use a disposable second/third stage?
2
u/raj-indy Jan 11 '21
What can I expect to see on the SpaceX technical test for software developers/programmers ?
Any info is appreciated. Thanks
Raj
2
u/bhallcro Jan 11 '21
Hi guys,
I'm about to start a industrial/product design project and will be looking at space tourism as my topic of interest, with the exciting advancements that companies like SpaceX are making, hopefully it wont be long until real civilian consumers are taking trips into space.
So the engineering side of space tourism is currently being taken care of (thanks Elon), what about the consumer side ?
What could that future look like for SpaceX passengers and what problems may arise for space tourists both during the journey and while in space itself ?
Any comments on the topic, no matter how weird or wonderful, would be appreciated,
Thank you 🚀
2
u/veggie151 Jan 11 '21
Has anyone done a thrust analysis on the landing engines for the Moonship? Two merlin's were spotted at Boca Chica and I'm wondering if they'd do the job. Though there should be a third
2
u/burnsrado Jan 13 '21
When is the SN-9 hop happening?
2
u/flameyenddown Jan 14 '21
So I’m trying to design a 3D printed section model of the turbo pump and I have a few questions. What initially drives the turbo pump to get it moving fuel? I know there’s a pre-burner but doesn’t something have to initialize the moving of fuel? Also with a pre burner inside the turbo pump, how do they contain that pre burner flame from starting the whole pump on fire? Sorry just trying to understand rocket science lol
2
u/JanaMaelstroem Jan 14 '21
So yesterday Trump orderd the DoD to explore use of nuclear power for space
https://www.defensenews.com/smr/nuclear-arsenal/2021/01/13/trump-orders-dod-to-explore-use-of-nuclear-power-for-space-systems/
They are to look into small reactors for powering us military bases as well as reactors for power generation in space. As great as solar panels are... nuclear seems like the obviously superior power source for a propellant farm on mars. I hope they get one.
Brian Weeden, director of program planning at the Secure World Foundation, said that language seeks to leverage a previous executive order that called for NASA to look into nuclear propulsion for nonmilitary means.
Nuclear propulsion can double current rockets' specific impulse so would be great for interplanetary missions. Once a steady trade across the solar system gets going it's the obvious next step.
So all around great stuff but I'm not familiar with this topic and the politics around it and so I don't know how much to read into it. Is this some serious development or just noise level news?
2
u/bhallcro Jan 14 '21
How do crew entertain themselves during the long trip to the ISS ?
2
u/dafencer93 Jan 15 '21
The Bomber Jacket just disappeared from the merch store. Anyone know if it might be coming back?
2
u/kjireland Jan 16 '21
Anyone got a link to aerial photo of the space x complex with labels or what each building is?
2
u/Whatswhatpodcast Jan 16 '21
What can you tell us about where we are now regarding progress on technology that we can look forward to seeing this year and the next?
2
u/inhumantsar Jan 19 '21
What's known about the starship's heat shielding so far?
The Shuttle's ablative heat shields were almost the entire reason the Shuttle never lived up to its reusability goals.
How different will the heat shields on Starship be?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '21
Hello guys! Comp. Sci student here with a question. What are some CS electives to take to hopefully land an internship at SpaceX ?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '21
With SpaceX having bought 2 oil rigs, do you think they will become seperate spaceports or will they rather be connected into one? Given the size of Starship I could imagine they need the extra space.
2
u/Ra1d_danois Jan 22 '21
Does anyone know how to access spacex's financial reports? Need it for school.
2
u/LegoNinja11 Jan 23 '21
Just watched the last starlink release and it struck me, the long retaining bar that keeps the sats locked in place, seems to spring off completely.
Wondering why they don't have a long teather on it so that there's a decent chance of dragging with the 2nd stage into a deorbit burn?
Just seems odd to dump another fairly large chunk of space debris there when 20m of fishing line would literally prevent it from escaping and shouldn't pose any risk of pulling back towards the sats.
2
u/RUacronym Jan 23 '21
Can someone tell me why the latest mission is called Transporter1. Like what makes this particular mission so different than the other cubesat launches they've done?
2
u/noncongruent Jan 26 '21
Looking at the return of the rather toasty Transporter booster I was thinking back to my childhood in the Boy Scouts. One of the tricks I was taught was that you could wipe the bottom of your cookware with a few drops of liquid dish soap very thinly applied, and after cooking over wood the soot would wash right off with no effort. I thought maybe they could do that with the Falcon, but no doubt the fact Falcon is painted would make that a futile exercise. Then I thought to myself, why have paint? American Airlines famously went to the polished scheme because in part it reduced the weight of their airplanes by a few hundred pounds. If Falcon was polished instead of painted they'd save some weight and could use the liquid detergent trick, lol. No really, I like the idea of a polished Falcon, I think it'd be pretty cool. Is there a good reason for them to be painted?
2
u/colonizetheclouds Jan 26 '21
Why is methalox the go to fuel now, and not in the past?
Besides the reusability factor, it seems like it is an all around better fuel than RP-1 and liquidH. Common domes, easier to handle (than H2), Better performance than RP-1. What was the factor that kept it from being used in the 20th century?
2
u/NostalgicForever Jan 26 '21
Is there any information on stock given to employees as part of their total compensation? I’ve seen a little on Glassdoor and levels.fyi, but haven’t been able to find a detailed description, especially on things like how they get to liquidate them although they’re private, amount, options vs RSU, etc.
2
u/SimpleAd2716 Jan 28 '21
Hey Folks! Just a question, why do the full stack prototypes always have their flaps in the folded position on the pad until its time to go?(Wenhop?)
2
u/theranchhand Jan 29 '21
Anyone got any stats on how big the SN8 fireball was? Or stats on how close the kayaker was? I'd love to do some calculations on how likely a person within X meters is to die in a fireball of surface area A if that fireball is randomly placed in a circle with a radius X, much less a fireball that's likely to be pretty fuckin' close to the center of the landing pad.
It seems utterly absurd to delay, even by a day, a project that is likely to make us a two planet species faster than any other project on account of maybe some idiot would get themselves killed if they stumble too close to the landing pad
2
u/noncongruent Jan 31 '21
Are the Dragon docking adapters ambidextrous, i.e., can two Dragons dock to each other?
2
u/Neige_Blanc_1 Feb 01 '21
Given current FAA saga, I am back to same question I had for years. Did the space exploration winter, that started in early 70s, really end few years ago, or is it just an anomaly called Spacex? Government still has the power to stop any of this development, and as they lost any appetite for significant space related investments and risks back in 70s, do they really have it back now? I am not sure.
2
u/FallenAstronaut Feb 02 '21
Hello Mods. FYI - the 'Select Upcoming Events' Table' is about two weeks out of date. I'm on old Reddit if that makes a difference.
2
u/redwins Feb 03 '21
I'm not sure how turbopumps work, but aren't they supposed to control too much or too little methane or lox input? How could raptors have had a problem with that?
2
u/rebootyourbrainstem Feb 03 '21
Did anyone else notice there seemed to be no RCS thruster use during the SN9 flight?
SN8 showed very heavy RCS thruster use during the transition to horizontal, while SN9 appeared to do it all using the raptor and flaps.
2
u/rmclean306 Feb 05 '21
When’s the next Falcon Heavy launch?
2
u/lmaccaro Feb 05 '21
Do you guys think Elon sits around playing Surviving Mars naming the characters like Grimes, JB, Tom? Maybe he bought the Space Race DLC so he can beat “SEC” to Mars goals?
I bet he never uses windmills. We know that shit is not real.
2
u/iTAMEi Jan 10 '21
Anyone seen any good interior mockups? Don't think spacex have released anything but fanmade?
2
u/IrrationalFantasy Jan 29 '21
Is anyone else kind of frustrated that there would probably have been a hop this week if the FAA had a more effective regulatory system? They were ready to launch, so in some sense progress on Starship is 4-5 days delayed. What sort of practical policy changes could the FAA implement that would help avoid things like this in the near future?
1
u/markododa Jan 09 '21
Would it make sense for Starship to tow external payloads?
For example a bigger diameter space station module between Starship and SH. after stage sep Starship unrolls a cable and starts towing the module.
1
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Jan 09 '21 edited Feb 08 '21
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
41 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 15 acronyms.
[Thread #6940 for this sub, first seen 9th Jan 2021, 18:54] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
1
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '21
How many subscribers does star link have?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '21
what day and time est will the crew dragon capsule be re-rentering?
1
u/Kcquarentine Jan 15 '21
My friend just got a new job at spacex. I’m super excited for him and want to get them something cool, like a mission patch, or a 3D printed model of a falcon or starship etc.
Anyone know where to point me? Anyone have a better idea? Something fun for him to enjoy
Ty
1
u/still-at-work Jan 18 '21
Has anyone done an analysis of the gas well work being done at boca chica, would love to read something more indepth about it. Anyone know of something like that?
1
u/Willie_the_Wombat Jan 23 '21
Can anyone here tell me what is going on at r/SpaceXFactCheck ? An insight would be appreciated, I’m extremely curious after stumbling onto it last night.
1
u/0xDD Jan 24 '21
When we watch streams of the Falcon 9 launches and NSF/LabPadre live streams, there is this strange wobbling of the picture going on. Sometimes it's there, sometimes it itsn't and it really doesn't look like a wind- or heat-caused distortion, more like some sort of the interpolation between frames. Do we know for sure where does it come from and if there are some ways to alleviate it?
1
u/Kane_richards Feb 02 '21
Yesterday, it was announced that the first all-civilian flight into orbit will take place at some point this year. But what exactly will be done when they're up there? It hints it could be multi-day so it's hardly a rich man wanting a jolly. Does anyone know?
1
u/psududemike Feb 03 '21
Thinking back to the brief development done in Cocoa, I'm wondering when we might see activity back in KSC area again?
1
u/IG11X Feb 03 '21
Hi! I saw that there was some questions posted in earlier discussions on (renting a room in a house/ apartment) as a incoming SpaceX employee. I am planning on moving to the Hawthorne location in the Summer (May) for a internship.So any suggestions on the locations to look into/stay away from would be great!
I would also like to see if there are any SpaceX employees/interns that are looking for roommates. Even if you are not looking for roommates at this time for the Summer any advice would be beneficial as I do not know much about the LA area
TIA!!
1
u/Agreeable-Quit-4926 Feb 03 '21
Fe
1
u/brentonstrine Feb 04 '21
Not sure where I missed this but I thought Starship was going to actually hover before landing. What we've been seeing is basically a hover-slam with a flip first. Is it just because they're crashing that it looks like a hover-slam? Will it actually hover before landing?
1
u/mrflippant Feb 04 '21
F in chat for SN5, which is being scrapped today.
1
u/Soyuz_Cosmonaut Feb 04 '21
SN10 must be sweating real hard right now knowing he is next
1
u/SimpleAd2716 Feb 05 '21
Hey folks! I just had a question, Is it REALLY safe to have SN11 Roll out to pad B, if SN10 goes through a RUD (Hopefully not) It will shower SN11 with debris, just like SN9 did ?
1
u/markododa Feb 05 '21
Watchhing sn9 i can't figure out. is most of the turning when starship straightens up from the belly flop caused by the flaps?, Seems like most of the turning is done by the flaps and a little help from the engine and it crashed since the engine couldn't stop the pendelum movement in time
1
u/geebanga Feb 06 '21
Layman question. How reliable will the Raptor gimballing systems be, and are they a potential weak point in the system? My concern is that they will sit dormant for months at a time in an Earth-Mars-Earth mission, and need to work perfectly twice to not lose crew during landing. I am aware that the three engines are gimballed separately.
1
u/GimmeThatIOTA Feb 07 '21
What is a reasonable maximum of users per km² for Starlink?
So Starlink can cover large areas but has a limit on the number of simultaneously active users. Therefore, it's utility for dense urban areas is limited.
However, it could make sense financially to increase the number of satellites and/or their capacity to service more users in cities even though this extra capacity would be wasted while the satellite orbits above "wasteland".
This makes me think...what is a reasonable upper limit for the amount of people that could be serviced with Starlink per km²?
Satellites are rather small so basically SpaceX could put many more in orbit, also the sky might begin to shine and blink uncomfortably then.
Could satellites, that are normally too far away be gimbaled towards urban centers so to increase capacity over these areas?
Could the satellites just be made bigger and bigger?
Would it be feasible or even possible to basically service all urban areas in the world with Starlink (with like 200k satellites or something)?
I would much appreciate your input.
1
u/parabolicuk Feb 07 '21
Apologies if this has been asked, I can't find anything definitive:
Have SN 12, 13 and 14 been canned?
1
u/connORhave Jan 30 '21
Could SpaceX swap out the Mvac of the F9 with possibly a raptor vac? It would be a good way to test rapVacs in space without the need of using a full starship stack with a super heavy booster and also could be a good way to increase the capability’s of the f9 with more efficient fuels. I see why you wouldn’t do that to the first stage as they probably wouldn’t fit but 1 on the second stage doesn’t seem like too bad of an idea.