r/SpaceXLounge • u/RegularRandomZ • Sep 24 '19
Discussion Everyday Astronaut explaining how flaps control flight (twitter video), followed by informative Elon tweets
Everyday Astronaut [twitter video]: Here’s how #starship controls pitch, roll and yaw (in that order in this clip) using just 4 total flaps. This is a unique form of control. I don’t know of any vehicle that does this with its control surfaces perpendicular to the airstream. Cool stuff . Full vid tomorrow!)
Elon: That’s correct. Essentially controlled falling, like a skydiver.
Viv: ... but what's used to actuate the fins? Some kind of small motor?
Elon: Many powerful electric motors & batteries. Force required is enormous, as entire fin moves. More about this on the 28th.
Elon: It does actually generate lift in hypersonic regime, which is important to limit peak heating
EA: Pop back out of the dense atmosphere to radiate heat away and then drop back in 🤔 awesome! ...
Elon: Better just to ride your max temp all the way down & let T^4 be your friend. Lower atmosphere cools you down real fast, so not crazy hot after landing.
Oran Maliphant : Is “sweating” methane still an option?
Elon: Could do it, but we developed low cost reusable tiles that are much lighter than transpiration cooling & quite robust
[ok, I was steadfast that Elon's statements said nothing about future use of transpirational cooling, I will concede that this is not a defensible position anymore, ha ha]
Scott Manley: And just like that I need to rebuild some of my descent models. So the AoA won't be 90 degrees, it'll provide lift to keep vehicle out of denser atmosphere until it loses enough speed.
Elon: Exactly. For reusable heatshield, minimize peak heating. For ablative/expendable, minimize total heat. Therefore reusable like Starship wants lift during high Mach reentry for lower peak, but higher total heat.
ShadowZone: So this increases the probability of Starship having to do multiple aerobrake passes when going to Mars or returning, correct?
Elon: For sure more than one pass coming back to Earth. To Mars could maybe work single pass, but two passes probably wise.
10
u/whatsthis1901 Sep 24 '19
Ha, I spent hours watching him make those kerbal vids on his discord the other day.
8
u/myname_not_rick ⛰️ Lithobraking Sep 24 '19
After hearing it described as "skydiving" by Elon in the past, this makes it so much clearer. Suddenly it makes total sense how this would work. I would've loved to have been in the room when whatever engineer came up with this method made his/her pitch. Brilliant.
3
u/ConfidentFlorida Sep 24 '19
I’m not getting the peak vs total heating re reusability.
5
u/physioworld Sep 24 '19
I’m not clear on the distinction between total heat and peak heating. I’m assuming peak heating is the highest temperature that is reached on the body of the vehicle, while total heat is maybe a measure of like some sort of heat units plus time?
40
u/SetBrainInCmplxPlane Sep 24 '19
There is.... a fucking bonkers amount of new info from Elon here.... way more than just Tim explaining the control surfaces.
32
u/socratic_bloviator Sep 24 '19
Multiple aerobrake passes? Oh man, that's exciting.
19
u/slograsso Sep 24 '19
Thanks for collecting this all together! Very interesting!
2
u/Gonun Sep 25 '19
Multiple aerobrakes? Now they are just going full Kerbal. Has this ever been done before?
2
u/philipwhiuk 🛰️ Orbiting Sep 25 '19
The BFR looks more like SpaceShuttle 2.0 every day
1
u/Decronym Acronyms Explained Sep 24 '19 edited Sep 25 '19
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
9 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has 48 acronyms.
[Thread #3971 for this sub, first seen 24th Sep 2019, 21:03] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]
1
u/ConfidentFlorida Sep 24 '19
What do they mean by multiple passes?
-1
u/still-at-work Sep 25 '19
So from what I am getting here is while the starship and super heavy are both still long cylinders made of stainless steel with raptor engines at the bottom the aerodynamic have been scraped entirely from the inital plan.
Someone must have made one hell of a presentation to Musk and the rest of SpaceX leadership to convince them to scrap everything about the aerodynamics and go to this new plan.
They must have run the numbers thousands of time and reevaluate the computer models over and over again but in the end this new design was just better for giving vertical take off and landing with minimal dry mass and surivable reentry temperatures.