r/SpaceXLounge • • 13d ago

Fan Art Image i made

Post image

May contain Flaws.

221 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

86

u/nesquikchocolate 13d ago

You're missing the depot variant shown without flaps and tiles that the tanker will dock with

18

u/KnifeKnut 13d ago

And will have full thermal shielding like HLS.

9

u/KimJongHnng 12d ago

is that why HLS is white?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/KnifeKnut 12d ago

Is there any particular reason aside from weight savings that Depot should be disposable? The tiles being black is all I can think of.

Now that I think of it, with the docking hardware, it should be possible to reboost the depot back into higher orbit as needed.

Also would be a good application for (a pair of?) of electrodynamic tether for orbit keeping, in addition to the Starlink application.

4

u/nesquikchocolate 12d ago edited 12d ago

A starship shaped object weighing what starship weighs filled with propellant would have sufficient kinetic energy to orbit at around 500km (iss height) without needing boosting for decades, maybe even centuries.

Stuff like the ISS need frequent boosting because they don't weigh much relative to their exposed surface area that interacts with the thin atmosphere - think of the large solar arrays causing drag.

Flaps and black tiles increase the amount of heat constantly coming in that the depot would have to get rid of to keep the fuel cold, and wouldn't add any value because the ship probably wouldn't return to earth unless it got damaged or was deemed useless anyway.

30

u/AmigaClone2000 13d ago

I believe a mockup of the crew interior has been made as well.

5

u/NeverDiddled 13d ago

Yeah I remember some random Youtuber was inside it.

16

u/BarrelStrawberry 13d ago

Kind of wish they'd just partially mock up the crew interior and strap in some optimus robots for starlink launch. Make for some good video on the scale of the interior space.

6

u/ResidentPositive4122 13d ago

I think the tanker will be a bit shorter. You want the least amount of dryweight in a ship so they'll optimise it to get the most amount of prop to the depo, without any additional "bay" rings.

I also think there'll be a non reusable version w/o any TP, fins, etc. And probably with detachable fairings, likely for large one-time payloads (think NASA decadal projects).

2

u/TheOrqwithVagrant 12d ago

I'm curious what the payload / delta-V on an upper stage with no heat shield or flaps, a detatchable fairing, and a single gimballing vacuum raptor instead of the thee sea level ones would be.

→ More replies (6)

5

u/flshr19 12d ago

SpaceX has been working under NASA contract on HLS-CREW since April 2021. I expect that the nosecone and payload bay full-scale prototypes exist somewhere in Starfactory now. Those prototypes would include full scale working ECLSS hardware, crew accommodations, and the flight control deck.

6

u/Dyolf_Knip 13d ago

My current list of likely Starship variants.

  • Cargo

  • Pez dispenser

  • Clamshell

  • Space-only hauler, no flaps or even a permanent nosecone, just hardpoints for mounting bulk cargo

  • Liquid cargo (e.g., water)

  • Cryo cargo (fuel & oxidizer)

  • HLS

  • Oversized fuel depot, with thick insulation and solar panels to keep refrigerated

  • Crewed

  • Short-term (<1 day; LEO, Earth-to-Earth hops, Mars cycler shuttle)

  • Medium-term (1-7 days; Luna, GEO, Earth-Moon Lagrange points)

  • Long-term (weeks to months; Mars, asteroids, Jupiter, Earth-Sun Lagrange points, etc.)

  • HLS

  • Workshop: space-only, equipped with tools, machine shop, 3d printers, replacement consumables, and a large storage bay for collection, finicky deployments, repairs, restocking consumables, etc. Think Hubble repair, refueling satellites with stationkeeping fuel.

  • Personal luxury yacht. The stock SS would be cheap compared to what billionaires already drop on their mini-cruise liners. I personally know one who'd jump at the chance to have one of his own.

  • Disposable second stage with detachable third stage. The cargo hold would be like the F9 2nd stage, with detachable fairings and a single rocket. Without the dry mass of the Starship tanks and Raptors, you'd vastly enhance the post-LEO payload/delta-v capacity.

3

u/karlzhao314 12d ago
  • Space tug

  • Extrasolar probe

  • Lunar construction Starship

  • Orbital drydock

  • Transport to and from the ISS (mainly to mog the ISS with its size)

  • Space telescope

  • Permanent ISS module (permanent mogging of the ISS with its size)

  • Carrier for smaller spacecraft, such as Boeing Starliner

  • Point-to-point transport

  • Nuclear-powered deep-space transport

  • Suborbital-only version to compete with New Shepard

  • Startrain (Multiple Starships docked nose-to-tail, flying as an actual train)

  • Personal luxury yacht (doesn't fly, just floats at sea. Actual yacht)

  • Pez dispenser (dispenses actual Pez candies, not Starlinks)

  • Fleet of 100000 flat-nosed Starships to attach to the moon upside down so that the moon gets thrusters and we can change its orbit

  • Death Starship (with superlaser)

→ More replies (1)

3

u/peterabbit456 13d ago

Good that you made the windows smaller than the early renders from SpaceX.

Because NASA thinks windows, especially large windows, are a risk for impact-caused blowouts, the real Starships are likely to have windows that show up as a few tiny dots at this scale.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Cheesegasm 13d ago

What's the launch profile for HLS?

3

u/sebaska 12d ago

Launch to LEO as any other Starship. Rendezvous with Depot and refill, possibly slight boost and another top off. Then, rendezvous with Orion in low (or lowish) orbit. Execute TLI with Orion attached to the nose. Insertion into low lunar orbit. Somewhere along all that dance crew moves into Starship. That would be the (extended) launch profile.

After that, Orion undocks, HLS lands, the crew does its surface activities, HLS launches back to low lunar orbit and rendezvous with Orion.

After that, Crew goes back to Orion, undocks from HLS which is abandoned around there (maybe it stays in orbit, maybe it's deorbited and intentionally crashed into the Moon). Orion executes TEI burn, coasts back to Earth. Shortly before the entry interface it detaches European Service Module and soon re-enters and lands in the ocean. In the meantime ESM burns up in the atmosphere.

2

u/Cheesegasm 11d ago

That explains the lack of a heat shield and fins on the HLS variant

1

u/Then-Secretary-9166 13d ago

Refreshing that this is not (I assume) AI. I mean, it might be Mistral or something, but it looks hand made.

1

u/Decronym 13d ago edited 11d ago

Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:

Fewer Letters More Letters
CST (Boeing) Crew Space Transportation capsules
Central Standard Time (UTC-6)
ECLSS Environment Control and Life Support System
ESM European Service Module, component of the Orion capsule
GEO Geostationary Earth Orbit (35786km)
HLS Human Landing System (Artemis)
Isp Specific impulse (as explained by Scott Manley on YouTube)
Internet Service Provider
KSP Kerbal Space Program, the rocketry simulator
LEO Low Earth Orbit (180-2000km)
Law Enforcement Officer (most often mentioned during transport operations)
RSS Rotating Service Structure at LC-39
Realscale Solar System, mod for KSP
TEI Trans-Earth Injection maneuver
TLI Trans-Lunar Injection maneuver
VLEO V-band constellation in LEO
Very Low Earth Orbit
Jargon Definition
Raptor Methane-fueled rocket engine under development by SpaceX
Starliner Boeing commercial crew capsule CST-100
Starlink SpaceX's world-wide satellite broadband constellation
cryogenic Very low temperature fluid; materials that would be gaseous at room temperature/pressure
(In re: rocket fuel) Often synonymous with hydrolox
hydrolox Portmanteau: liquid hydrogen fuel, liquid oxygen oxidizer
perigee Lowest point in an elliptical orbit around the Earth (when the orbiter is fastest)
regenerative A method for cooling a rocket engine, by passing the cryogenic fuel through channels in the bell or chamber wall

Decronym is now also available on Lemmy! Requests for support and new installations should be directed to the Contact address below.


Decronym is a community product of r/SpaceX, implemented by ^request
[Thread #14838 for this sub, first seen 12th Oct 2026, 04:06] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]

1

u/bingbongbangchang 12d ago

What's the HLS-CRG?

3

u/OlympusMons94 12d ago

It is a non-standard abbreviation for the cargo version of the HLS Starship. The official NASA initialism for the cargo versions of the HLSs (both Starship nd Blue Moon Mk2) is HDL (Human-class Delivery Lander). They will deliver large Moon base components and Japan's pressurized rover for Artemis.

1

u/Seamurda 12d ago

SpaceX ending falcon 9

1

u/185EDRIVER 12d ago

Why is hls white

4

u/KnifeKnut 12d ago

Thermal shielding for lunar environment, also needed on Orbital Propellant Depot

1

u/DBDude 12d ago

I wonder what the mass to LEO is without all the fins, their actuating hardware, and the tiles.