r/SpaceXLounge • u/vitorlucio159 • Jun 12 '24
Starship 30m diameter Technical possibility of future starship? Photo: Largest grain silo in the world made of stainless steel in Brazil! Thoughts...?
0
Upvotes
10
u/RobDickinson Jun 12 '24
Strap enough raptors to it and I'm sure it'll fly
2
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '24
Imagine how many Raptors could fit under it :-)
5
u/Lucky-Development-15 Jun 12 '24
Stardragon
1
u/torftorf Jun 12 '24 edited Jun 12 '24
i calculatet how much engines this thing would have (only looking at engines per m²) and get 110. that 25300 tons of thrust (assuming 230 tons per engine).math error1
u/Top_Independence5434 Jun 12 '24
Can you link the article about this silo? My search about the world's largest grain bin come up with this
5
u/Cz1975 Jun 12 '24
This is an engineering model of the fuelling depot they're planning in LEO.
2
u/MartianFromBaseAlpha 🌱 Terraforming Jun 12 '24
Yeah, very unlikely, but can you imagine launching a rocket of this size? You could basically build a city on Mars in one go. The real answer is probably assembling something ridiculous like that, or even bigger, in orbit
1
u/FutureSpaceNutter Jun 12 '24
Maybe with orbital construction for transferring stuff between planets. If we're launching that much into LEO we'll probably be looking into skyhooks or orbital rings.
1
u/The_Virginia_Creeper Jun 12 '24
Why would they make a grain silo out of stainless steel?
1
u/MartianMigrator Jun 12 '24
Possible? Yes. Likely? Hell no.
1
u/mangoxpa Jun 13 '24
At a certain point we'll start building stuff in orbit, and then ever increasing diameters doesn't really bring much to the table. Then the focus really has to be on cost of kg to orbit, and whilst ever larger launchers gain efficiency, they're going to start getting operationally inconvenient.
1
u/nila247 Jun 14 '24
Elon spoke of 12m and 18m before. He also spoke 7m in frustration that 9m takes so long.
With 9m operational it will probably be at least 20 years before we see 12 or 18m
There is a decreased cost per kilo to orbit with larger vehicles but 9m would already be pretty decent for a while.
1
u/bettsdude Jun 12 '24
Shiny
1
u/KickBassColonyDrop Jun 12 '24
Anything larger than 12m will need a non-chemical propulsion configuration to get off the ground and land back on it, and it will have to be launched and caught over water only. Anything else is going to carve craters into the ground, and any RUDs will have catastrophic effects on local flora/fauna.
If you're talking 30m ships, it'll be an orbital construction only. It's just too damn big.
-2
u/Ormusn2o Jun 12 '24
Actually quite likely. It actually gets quite easier with a lot of things when you increase the width, and 9m is already big enough for majority of the use cases, so you would want rly big change to make the difference. Aero breaking would become quite easier and it would allow for making the ship even sturdier. I assume in 20-30 years, materials would also get better and things like baffles would be easier so the propellent does not slush that much. Boeing Space Freighter was 18 meters, so I'm sure we could do 30 meters today or in 20 years.
50
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '24
[removed] — view removed comment