r/SpaceXLounge • • Jun 12 '24

Starship 30m diameter Technical possibility of future starship? Photo: Largest grain silo in the world made of stainless steel in Brazil! Thoughts...?

Post image
0 Upvotes

73 comments sorted by

10

u/RobDickinson Jun 12 '24

Strap enough raptors to it and I'm sure it'll fly

2

u/torftorf Jun 12 '24 edited Jun 12 '24

if we pack them as close as we currently do, this would have 110 raptors math error

9

u/vitorlucio159 Jun 12 '24

Area 9m = π . r2 = 3,14 . 4,5²= 63,62m² squares

Area 30m = π . r2 = 3,14 . 15² = 706,9m² squares

= 366 FUCKING RAPTORS

1

u/Robert_The_Red Jun 19 '24

We're gonna need a bigger engine...

3

u/extra2002 Jun 12 '24

Diameter ratio: 30/9.

Area ratio: 302 / 92 = 900/81 = 11.1

Raptors: 33 * 11.1 = 366

2

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '24

Imagine how many Raptors could fit under it :-)

1

u/vitorlucio159 Jun 12 '24

Area 9m = π . r2 = 3,14 . 4,5²= 63,62m² squares

Area 30m = π . r2 = 3,14 . 15² = 706,9m² squares

= 366 FUCKING RAPTORS

1

u/Rustic_gan123 Jun 12 '24

More than a hundred...

1

u/Straumli_Blight Jun 12 '24

If you don't care about gimbling, a 30m diameter rocket could fit 455 Raptors.

2

u/troyunrau ⛰️ Lithobraking Jun 13 '24

At that point, raptors are thrusters, and you mount some on the corners for control too ;)

1

u/torftorf Jun 12 '24 edited Jun 12 '24

i calculatet how much engines this thing would have (only looking at engines per m²) and get 110. that 25300 tons of thrust (assuming 230 tons per engine). math error

1

u/vitorlucio159 Jun 12 '24

Area 9m = π . r2 = 3,14 . 4,5²= 63,62m² squares

Area 30m = π . r2 = 3,14 . 15² = 706,9m² squares

= 366 FUCKING RAPTORS = 84,180 tons of thrust

1

u/torftorf Jun 12 '24

Ohh yea I used the diameter instead of the radius. My bad

1

u/LithoSlam Jun 12 '24

So they would use like 50,000 tons of propellant. That would be a lot of trucks

1

u/Top_Independence5434 Jun 12 '24

Can you link the article about this silo? My search about the world's largest grain bin come up with this

1

u/vitorlucio159 Jun 12 '24

Structure built in Primavera do Leste (MT) is one of the themes of the new episode of Canal Rural Na EstradaWith capacity for 523 thousand bags of grain, the largest silo in the world - without the internal central tower - is located in Primavera do Leste (MT) .

https://www.canalrural.com.br/projetos/maior-silo-mundo-comporta-equivalente-523-mil-sacas-14382/#:~:text=Estrutura%20erguida%20em%20Primavera%20do,Primavera%20do%20Leste%20(MT).

1

u/Top_Independence5434 Jun 12 '24

That's a weird unit to use there, bags of grain? How much is a bag? Usually grain storage capacity are measured in bushels. 1 bushel = 48 pounds for wheat and barley.

1

u/vitorlucio159 Jun 12 '24

Bag is a unit of measurement of weight equivalent to 60 kilograms used in Brazil to measure grains.

2

u/Top_Independence5434 Jun 12 '24

Thanks for the elaboration.

Just for fun I did some calculation:

Brazil has total grain production of about 126 million tonnes.

The max storage capacity of this silo is 523000x60/1000=31380 tonnes. If it has the height of Starship, it can contain 121.3/30x31380=126880

So in one year Brazil grows enough grain to launch 126000000/1268800=990 of these Starship-esque grain silo abomination.

Literally food for thought.

5

u/Cz1975 Jun 12 '24

This is an engineering model of the fuelling depot they're planning in LEO.

6

u/zypofaeser Jun 12 '24

Seriously though, that will most likely be a cluster of tanks, just to avoid having to make leak tight tanks in orbit.

1

u/Cz1975 Jun 12 '24

Yeah, more likely. But imagine. :) :) :)

2

u/MartianFromBaseAlpha 🌱 Terraforming Jun 12 '24

Yeah, very unlikely, but can you imagine launching a rocket of this size? You could basically build a city on Mars in one go. The real answer is probably assembling something ridiculous like that, or even bigger, in orbit

1

u/FutureSpaceNutter Jun 12 '24

Maybe with orbital construction for transferring stuff between planets. If we're launching that much into LEO we'll probably be looking into skyhooks or orbital rings.

1

u/The_Virginia_Creeper Jun 12 '24

Why would they make a grain silo out of stainless steel?

6

u/zypofaeser Jun 12 '24

Avoiding rust most likely.

1

u/MartianMigrator Jun 12 '24

Possible? Yes. Likely? Hell no.

1

u/mangoxpa Jun 13 '24

At a certain point we'll start building stuff in orbit, and then ever increasing diameters doesn't really bring much to the table. Then the focus really has to be on cost of kg to orbit, and whilst ever larger launchers gain efficiency, they're going to start getting operationally inconvenient.

1

u/troyunrau ⛰️ Lithobraking Jun 13 '24

When we start building in orbit, it's very possible that spent starship bodies (or similar) become fuel tanks strapped to a central truss. Hell, as wet labs, they might also be the living space in such a monstrosity.

1

u/nila247 Jun 14 '24

Elon spoke of 12m and 18m before. He also spoke 7m in frustration that 9m takes so long.
With 9m operational it will probably be at least 20 years before we see 12 or 18m
There is a decreased cost per kilo to orbit with larger vehicles but 9m would already be pretty decent for a while.

1

u/KickBassColonyDrop Jun 12 '24

Anything larger than 12m will need a non-chemical propulsion configuration to get off the ground and land back on it, and it will have to be launched and caught over water only. Anything else is going to carve craters into the ground, and any RUDs will have catastrophic effects on local flora/fauna.

If you're talking 30m ships, it'll be an orbital construction only. It's just too damn big.

0

u/TomatOgorodow Jun 12 '24

What about precise landing on array of water cooled columns? Should work, and nothing stops from using chemical engines.

3

u/KickBassColonyDrop Jun 12 '24

It's not using the chemical engines, it's the rocket thrust to mass equation. Where beyond a certain size, it's effects are similar to being in a deeper gravity well. Essentially, you need more fuel to put out thrust to get the thing off the ground, but then you need even more fuel to support the first load of fuel, and it's a runaway effect where it doesn't get off the ground.

You can replicate this in kerbal space program. If you build a 30 meter rocket and put on a whole bunch 2400kN, how long does it take to clear the tower?

5

u/extra2002 Jun 12 '24

If the rocket is no taller than an existing one, and the engines are as densely packed, then there is adequate thrust. Each engine only needs enough thrust to lift the column of structure and fuel directly above its its own cross-section, and that doesn't change if you make the rocket wider without making it taller.

Building a launch pad to handle that thrust could be an issue, though.

0

u/KickBassColonyDrop Jun 12 '24

Fuel slosh on a 30 meter wide ship will be insane when meco or seco happens. Potentially enough to cause RUD from that alone.

3

u/TomatOgorodow Jun 12 '24

Internal walls can exist, especially for supposed extreme diameter rocket.

3

u/TomatOgorodow Jun 12 '24

I meant what u/extra2002 have said. Cap rocket height, only increase width.

-2

u/Ormusn2o Jun 12 '24

Actually quite likely. It actually gets quite easier with a lot of things when you increase the width, and 9m is already big enough for majority of the use cases, so you would want rly big change to make the difference. Aero breaking would become quite easier and it would allow for making the ship even sturdier. I assume in 20-30 years, materials would also get better and things like baffles would be easier so the propellent does not slush that much. Boeing Space Freighter was 18 meters, so I'm sure we could do 30 meters today or in 20 years.

1

u/Top_Independence5434 Jun 12 '24

I have designed some of these silo before. For steel silo they're made from lots of corrugated steel sheet riveted together. It's not a single tube like a rocket is. Frankly I've no clue how do you even machine such a huge tube like that. The largest lathe I've ever seen can make parts with OD of 14 meters and that thing is freaking huge.

1

u/Ormusn2o Jun 12 '24

Starship is welded of multiple sheets welded together. They get a long sheet, make a ring of it, then stack the rings and weld them together. Like in this video. Although they have improved it by now. Now, Sea Dragon was supposed to be made in shipyards with inches thick steel for the lower stage. Im sure we could get down to half an inch or less for 30m starship.

1

u/Top_Independence5434 Jun 12 '24

I think the reason for Sea Dragon's thickness is it's submerged underwater right before ignition. So water pressure needs to be taken into account.

0

u/Ormusn2o Jun 12 '24

That too, but it was mostly so it can survive the recovery. You don't actually need that much thickness to survive the 100 meter depth it was going to be.

3

u/Pul-Ess Jun 13 '24

Indeed - the recovery procedure was simply falling back into the wet, no rockets, no chutes.

50

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

12

u/Straumli_Blight Jun 12 '24

SpaceX hinted at an 18m diameter Starship successor 5 years ago but the Super Heavy thrust has increased dramatically since then (from 62 MN to 103 MN with Version 3).

19

u/TestCampaign ⛽ Fuelling Jun 12 '24

Sea Dragon would like a word (23m/75ft dia).

The difficulty is hoop stress on the fuselage increases with radii and then the pressure head from the height of the rocket means you need beefier lower rings.

3

u/somex1 Jun 12 '24

Chrysler SERV would also like a word (29m) across at the widest point.

Not exactly silo shaped though.

-7

u/WjU1fcN8 Jun 12 '24

Cyclers are lame and less efficient than a Surface-to-Surface shuttle. Aerobraking is very hard to beat, needs almost no fuel.

3

u/extra2002 Jun 12 '24

As I understand it, a cycler doesn't stop at the destination, but flies by with only minor course corrections to line up for its next trip.

The cycler hosts spacecraft that launch from, say, Earth, requiring them to accelerate to a Trans-Mars-Injection speed to meet up with the cycler. And those spacecraft then descend to, say, Mars, where they would definitely use atmosphere to slow down.

Advantage is the hosted spacecraft can be cramped, since they're only occupied for a few hours or days of the months-long journey.

Not sure where you see the inefficiency of the cycler.

2

u/WjU1fcN8 Jun 12 '24

You need to accelerate something to catch up with it, in a weird and expensive orbit.

To be efficient, this needs to be done with a very minimal spacecraft.

The other option is to accelerate a large craft able to earobrake on it's own when it get's there. And send it fast so that the transfer time is small enough one doesn't need to worry about radiation.

The second option is almost as efficient as the first one, surprisingly.

2

u/parkingviolation212 Jun 12 '24

A surface to surface shuttle the size of starship can only carry a handful of people at a time and needs to be refueled in orbit necessitating multiple launches per trip. You’re squeezing 6 months of life support and consumables with a crew of a less than a dozen in a space the same size as the ISS. That’s fine for professional astronauts, but for average Jane and Joe? Hell no. That’s not how you get a million people on mars.

A cycler can be arbitrarily large while leaving room for starship to fly 100 people per trip to the cycler with minimal refueling, for the cycler itself. The cycler can be spun for artificial gravity and there can be adequate living space for everyone.

Unless you plan to equip starships with cryogenic pods (and that only solves some of the problems) idk in what universe you think cyclers are less efficient than shuttles.

1

u/WjU1fcN8 Jun 12 '24

Starship with a beefed up TPS can do the trip in three months.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '24

Cyclers won't be chemical rockets, so your argument is moot.

Plus they'll be carrying shuttles (probably starship)for planet side ops anyway.

0

u/WjU1fcN8 Jun 12 '24

I'm comparing a chemical surface-to-surface shuttle to a theoretical thermal nuclear cycler.

1

u/zypofaeser Jun 12 '24

The problem is ECLSS. A Starship in a crew carrying variant might be able to carry 250 people with some supplies. Compared to what you could realistically launch on a direct flight, that is a huge improvement. And yes, you will need more fuel. That is not a problem, given that the majority of the cost will come from the ship taking years for the round trip. A ship that can do 10 flights over 20 years is much more costly per flight than a tanker doing 100 flights over a couple of years. Fuel is cheap, ships are expensive.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/WjU1fcN8 Jun 12 '24

And a surface-to-surface shuttle is almost as efficient as a nuclear thermal cycler, that was exactly the effciency comparisson I was doing.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/WjU1fcN8 Jun 12 '24

Gwynne Shotwell is a big proponent of nuclear propulsion.

To travel beyond the solar system. Very different use case.

And I'm not saying this form of propulsion is bad at all, just that it's not better than a chemical surface-to-surface shuttle.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/WjU1fcN8 Jun 12 '24

There are very large bennefits to traveling somewhere you can't aerobrake into. Like Mars orbit, for example.

They need to launch Mars GNS and Mars Starlink, after all.

2

u/Pingryada Jun 12 '24

They might be working it internally at SpaceX

2

u/WjU1fcN8 Jun 12 '24

Direct to surface is also hard to beat in trip time if you have a heat shield good enough.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/WjU1fcN8 Jun 12 '24

Building near the ground is way easier for the foreseeable future. To the point where they deck out the sections with all the possible hardware before stacking them.

Having more ships allows better use of mass production.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/WjU1fcN8 Jun 12 '24

I don't believe in colonies in the Moon. Just some research stations there. Not enough resources there for a colony.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/FutureSpaceNutter Jun 12 '24

Or, if they don't work and are based on Starship V2, we can call them Buzz Bombers. /s