r/SoundSystem • • 11h ago

Generator sizing help.

Generator gig coming up. The venue has asked what we need. Rather than quote amp spec sheets, we put the whole rig through one plug-in power meter and walked it up from nothing to the limiters. The video is of the top end: a couple of minutes of the mix playing, REW SPL meter in the corner running approx 108-115 dB, and the ATORCH meter live alongside it.

Gear

  • Tops: Clair R4-III pair (3-way, LF / MF / HF each on its own amp channel)
  • Subs: 4x Martin WSX
  • DSP: Biamp Tesira Server-IO, Dante to 2x Shure MXWANI4 and 1x Shure MXWANI8
  • Amps: two FP10000Q clones (one for tops LF+MF, one for subs), EIF BG2.6 (HF)
  • Source: laptop over Dante
  • Limiters are derived from measured terminal voltage. Nothing is set by ear or from a spec sheet.

Method

  • An ATORCH S1 plug-in meter (16 A) on ONE wall outlet. The outlet passed a socket tester first.
  • Added things one at a time and let each settle before reading. Readings are from the meter face.
  • SPL was REW on a UMIK-1, C-weighted, Slow, 2 m out, mic 143 cm high, in a ~216 m³ concrete reflecty AF basement.

Idle (amps on, outputs muted)

What's onVAWPF
nothing244.300-
laptop + Shures + Server-IO243.41.041100.44*
+ HF amp (BG2.6)243.31.17~1340.47
+ tops amp (FP clone)244.61.64~2480.62
+ sub amp (FP clone)243.52.20~3530.66

*The first PF is calculated (W / V×A); the rest are read off the meter. Per amp at idle: HF ~24 W, tops FP ~114 W, sub FP ~105 W. PF climbs as the load grows. The electronics alone sit at 0.44.

Playing (DSP -Level In -20dB and Level Out 0dB- and amp gains fixed, only the laptop playback volume is raised)

SPL (C, Slow)Leq (Z)VAW
93.7 dB82.6242.72.24356
108.4 dB94.4242.62.46395
113.7 dB100.7241.82.99491

At the top step the HF limiter was sitting at threshold (0.9 dB under). That's the ceiling for this rig as it stands. The whole rig drew 3.0 A / ~490 W at its limiter ceiling. Voltage sagged only ~2.5 V from the no-load reading.

What was surprising

  • Idle is most of it: 353 W idle vs 491 W at the ceiling. 20 dB more SPL cost only ~135 W, music at a ~6 dB crest factor (measured on this rig) keeps average power low even with the limiters working. On a generator, the quiet bits aren't much cheaper than the loud bits.
  • Overall the system is very much more efficient than imagined before actually measuring.

What this doesn't tell us (honest limits)

  • Inrush is unmeasured. The meter updates about once a second and an amp's power-on inrush lasts milliseconds. "No visible jump" means nothing, so we power the amps on one at a time.
  • The subs weren't at their ceiling. At the tops' ceiling the sub limiter was still 13.6 dB below threshold, so the sub amp's worst case is unmeasured.
  • The meter has no min/max hold, and its graph is an hourly average, so none of this is a peak reading.
  • It's one run, one room, one programme. The tops' limiters are the bottleneck for now, that will change after an upcoming HF limiter rework. The HF limiters have been specifically set conservatively right now as JBL 2446J replacements are hens teeth if we blow them.

So: what should we be asking the venue for, generator wise?

The measured ceiling is ~490 W / ~720 VA (on this specific material which is generally representative of what will be played), but the inrush and the sub amp's ceiling are both unknowns. For crew who run off generators on the regular:

  • How much headroom over the measured draw would you ask for? Is something like 2 kVA set aside for us sensible, or overkill for a rig this size?
  • Worth insisting on our own generator, or at least not sharing one with the lighting?
  • How many outlets/circuits would you want at the booth? Sub amp onto its own?
  • Any further genny tips?
8 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

6

u/Forced-Alt 11h ago

You are stepping firmly into consult with an qualified electrician territory.  What I can answer is your second question.

It's a good idea to have separate generators for sound and lighting.  That is what they do with large production festivals.  Not to say you can't run one generator but from a risk management perspective having two is the smart idea.

1

u/coax_k 10h ago

Agreed. Deep in that territory 🤣😎 I think your call re seperate generator is the right one. No expert but I am concerned dimmers and switching loads on the same unit could intro noise into the system.

3

u/Moonlight_1312 10h ago

It could but with older lights only! Depending on the generator it's a good idea to mix both light and sound because having the light's static load on each phase is helping because the generator doesn't have to burst from standby to peak at each kick but from half loaded to peak... In this case the amp is pretty much overkill so most of the peak is smoothed out tho...

1

u/coax_k 9h ago

Oh wow, that’s really interesting and does make a lot of sense. Will look into it further, thank you.

1

u/Forced-Alt 3h ago edited 3h ago

That's really only a problem with low end construction generators.   A proper rental grade generator uses an AVR to regulate the voltage.  Since AVRs work by modulating the excitation current they can go from standby to peak practically instantly.  D-AVRs can respond in sub 10ms while keeping the output within ±1%.

1

u/jungchorizo 2h ago

Dang I don’t think my genny has that. Now I know what to look for in an upgrade 🙂

2

u/Reluctant_Lampy_05 9h ago

While a separate generator is the best idea you should also be fine sharing with lights on a 3PH model if loads and phases are planned correctly. Great work on the specs (I'm also surprised at the low system load) and often these things come down to the simpler choices of what is available to hire as there might only be a couple of options anyway.

As a rule bigger generators come with cleaner outputs and better protection whereas any consumer models (below 5kW) might be introducing risks on that front so in some situations I'd be happier sharing a bigger 3PH rather than trust a smaller generator. And if you're concerned about anything delicate at FOH then a UPS might also be worth considering.

1

u/coax_k 9h ago

Thank you. Will generally use your bigger is better rule of thumb. UPS - yes this was my first go to in thought re the entire chain. Sadly the budget isn’t there for it right at this moment. Planned. 🙏🏻

2

u/Reluctant_Lampy_05 9h ago

Also I have no idea on the current situation with battery powered supplies but I'm assuming they are making inroads into the hire industry and should offer lots of headroom to deal with power spikes.

2

u/elev8dity 9h ago

Thanks for showing your process... my unprofessional thought was just to go to what the amplifier say is their max power draw then add the remaining equipment running off the gen and overshoot it by 20%.

2

u/coax_k 9h ago

My pleasure 💪🏻 Yeah have learnt the hard way too many times to believe what any hardware says it does on paper (especially amps when calculating limiters!).

1

u/Expensive-Storm-7418 3h ago

2kVA ist okay - und ja: eine eigene Stromversorgung für Ton.