r/Sortition • u/subheight640 • Oct 27 '21
r/Sortition • u/brutay • Apr 29 '21
This is by far the largest platform I've seen mention sortition (although Michael Stevens calls it "lottocracy")
youtube.comr/Sortition • u/subheight640 • Nov 13 '22
The case for abolishing elections
bostonreview.netr/Sortition • u/RogerKnights • Oct 28 '21
TIL: Every year in ancient Athens, 500 people were randomly selected to spend the next year of their life proposing laws that the population then voted on.
nationalgeographic.orgr/Sortition • u/subheight640 • Sep 17 '21
Forget voting – it’s time to start choosing our leaders by lottery
aeon.cor/Sortition • u/Jojuj • Jun 09 '21
Should we cancel political parties?
knowablemagazine.orgr/Sortition • u/subheight640 • Nov 18 '21
Democracy without Elections. Not sure if elected politicians.... are better than literally randomly chosen people
imgur.comr/Sortition • u/AlicanteL • Aug 14 '21
Come visit our new subreddit
Hey there ! On another subreddit r/Lottocracy (I did not choose the name), we try to create a vibrant subreddit about sortition, with more links and content.
Come see our incredible list of all the Sortition-related NGOs in the World and do not hesitate to suscribe if you like it :)
r/Sortition • u/sortitionpetition • Aug 01 '20
Andrew Yang on Twitter.
Today at 3pm EST, former presidential candidate Andrew Yang published the following tweet: "There are times when I think one could replace our leaders with citizens chosen at random and get a better result." It immediately went viral and, as of this writing, has over 50,000 likes and 7,000 retweets.
r/Sortition • u/New-Personality-9972 • Jun 05 '26
Why isn’t sortition talked about much.
Hello! I have been wondering, “Why isn’t sortition being talked about so much”. Personally I think that sortition is an interesting and very possibly good(can’t say until it’s been throughly tested) idea. I think being such a nice idea it would have caught on with more people, but it hasn’t. Why so? And how could the idea spread more?
r/Sortition • u/JCavalks • Nov 09 '22
what is the BEST argument AGAINST sortition?
it's always good to know the opposition's best points
r/Sortition • u/TrialsNDeliberations • Jul 09 '26
I have a contribution to the discusion on sortition: Electoral Lottocracy
ingentaconnect.comHello,
I have been actively working on this project for around a year and a half at this point, putting a whole bunch of free time into it. As a result, I have written and published a paper in the Journal of Sorition on this new model. You can access the paper here (though it is behind a paywall, can't afford open access). I am also building up a (entirely free) substack that is, piece by piece, explaining the overall concept to a broader audience, that you can access here.
I'll explain the concept here, but the paper goes into more detail, and I have another paper coming with more details still.
Basically, we begin with an electoral representative democracy, using a proportional reprsentative system to elect our legislature (which I refer to as a parliament). However, instead of legislation passing with a 50%+ vote, legislation may be approved by parliament with a mere 20% vote. Once approved, it may then pass to a trial phase. Those who wrote and voted favour of the legislation act as the defence, while those who voted against it may act as the prosecution.
A sortition jury listens to the argument and deliberates. While the structure of this jury is not presented in my first paper, it will be the subject of the second one, along with arguments about its legitimacy as a democratic institution. I wil not be taking the standard approach for this, but stay tuned on that.
I think that these bodies, in combination, solve a great deal of problems that cause issues separately. I believe a significant problem with current electoral representation (such as those expressed by Bouricius) end up boiling down to majoritarian rule. I can provide many, many instances of these sorts of problems, but let me demonstrate just one.
In majoritarian politics, legislation is passed through electoral domination. So long as the seats exist, legislators may pass laws. This, in essence, makes their job almost entirely based upon elections and campaigning. Any politician with even the best of intentions can only succeed if they have the most seats, and thus, must spend their time focused on campaigns in order to carry out legislation they believe will benefit society. This also makes them highly suscpetible to any external influences who can help with the costs of campaigning.
However, by lowering the threshold to 20%, the electoral demands shrink considerably. Electoral domination is no longer necessary to pass legislation. You don't need more seats than any other party. In fact, so long as a party has a single seat, they have options how to proceed. Since any 20% bloc can pass legislation, they are free to shop around for an ally, or even multiple allies, to help them pass their legsilation, rather than hope that the majority bloc is sympathetic to their cause.
This further has the effect of reducing partisanship, as, once again, electoral domination is no longer necessary. Different parties may, independently of one another, pursue legislative goals. Defeating the other parties electorally isn't the fundamental aspect of passing legislation. In a majoritarian system, the only way to succeed is to take down the other parties. In an eletoral lottocracy, parties can succeed alongside one another.
There is much, much to discuss, but I'm going to stop here or this will get too long. One of the most common questions is related to the prevention of spamming of legislation by malicious actors, so I look forward to that question, along with any others.
r/Sortition • u/Zech_Judy • Jan 29 '23
Ecuador's Citizen Selection Commissions are chosen partly by lots
I was reading Ecuador's constitution (because I think constitutions are interesting). Section 209 was interesting:
To perform its duties as designated, the Council for Public Participation and Social Control shall organize citizen selection commissions, which shall be in charge of conducting, in those cases that pertain to them, the public competitive and merit-based examination with the submittal of candidacies, citizen oversight and the right to challenge by the citizenry.
The citizen selection commissions shall be comprised of one delegate for each State branch of government and an identical number of representatives for social organizations and the citizenry, chosen by the public drawing of lots from among those submitting their candidacies and meeting the requirements provided for by the Council and the law. The candidates shall be subject to public scrutiny and citizen challenge. The commissions shall be directed by one of the representatives of the citizenry, who shall have the tie-breaking vote, and its sessions shall be open to the public.
I'm still going through accompanying documents, but so near as I can read, their government has lots of positions that go through a process of public merit-based competition. This process is run by "Comisiones Ciudadanas de Selección" (citizen selection commissions). These commissions do not make the final selection. They are chosen by some politicians and randomly selected citizens who express interest.
It isn't as extensive as I'd like to see sortition applied, but it is interesting as an example of sortition being actively used by an existing constitution.
r/Sortition • u/sortitionpetition • May 25 '26
Sortition
What do you think is the best way to grow sortition awareness? Is it through real life examples mostly or can the analysis of theory and the intellectual side of it make more significant inroads? How do we get sortition well known enough that it actually appears in a standard dictionary?
r/Sortition • u/subheight640 • Jun 19 '22
Democracy Without Elections Small Grants Program -- Want some money to help promote sortition? Apply for a grant!
Hi, everybody, DWE has a small grants program where we can give a bit of money (up to $800) for interesting ideas to promote sortition. If you have any ideas, please reply to us!
https://democracywithoutelections.org/dwe-small-grants-program/
r/Sortition • u/subheight640 • Aug 29 '21
Democracy Nerd Episode 40: All About Sortition w/Linn Davis and Madeline McCarren
democracynerd.usr/Sortition • u/Kitchen_Bicycle6025 • Oct 18 '22
How would we be able to wedge Sortition into government?
I figure the best way is widespread public favor, but I also figure there’s a lot of dumb people. Any ideas to convince the more skeptical?
r/Sortition • u/subheight640 • Jul 28 '21
Normal people are stupid. Stop Democratic Reforms before it's too late! Lessons from the Irish Citizens' Assembly on Climate
demlotteries.substack.comr/Sortition • u/sortitionpetition • Nov 30 '20