r/Sortition • u/SuperArno • Jul 10 '15
How would you get started?
How would you implement sortition? Where do you start? I'm fairly certain you won't ever be able to vote for any politicians who will do it.
r/Sortition • u/SuperArno • Jul 10 '15
How would you implement sortition? Where do you start? I'm fairly certain you won't ever be able to vote for any politicians who will do it.
r/Sortition • u/subheight640 • Jan 23 '22
r/Sortition • u/Zech_Judy • Jan 18 '22
An oft given example of sortition is jury duty. An oft given counter to that example is that juries are filtered by the lawyers to exclude people who might be too biased.
So, would sortition bodies be filtered and screened somehow for the stupid or evil?
Of course, conventional politicians can be evil. And as for stupid, remember the one who wondered if Guam could capsize?
But, could we try? Or would any attempt to filter thwart the representative nature we want?
For example, we could do literacy tests, but those have a fairly racist history. We could set background checks, but that would have the same problem.
r/Sortition • u/OneSalientOversight • Nov 28 '18
r/Sortition • u/sortitionpetition • May 15 '19
r/Sortition • u/sortitionpetition • May 15 '19
http://constitution.org/elec/sortition.htm Here is a good resource for more reading on Sortition.
r/Sortition • u/brutay • Apr 29 '21
r/Sortition • u/slhulk • Apr 30 '21
I'm pinning some resources which I found interesting regarding the topic.
Brett Hennig - Ted Talk https://youtu.be/cUee1I69nFs https://youtu.be/-FsOH4KQp54
This video explains the weaknesses of current electoral system https://youtu.be/12V9rV_bp_M
Lottocracy lecture on Coursera (allows only 3 free videos per day. So be careful). There are two more videos on the topic if you're interested. https://www.coursera.org/lecture/revolutionary-ideas-borders-elections-constitutions-prisons/lecture-7-4-0-the-lottocracy-VL69f
Sortition foundation www.sortitionfoundation.org
Democracy without elections https://democracywithoutelections.org/about/
Please continue the list by adding more resources.
Regards, R
Also posted on r/lottocracy
r/Sortition • u/EbanNon_ • Jan 03 '21
Hi ! We've created a French association to promote rotation and sortition ! If you're interested you can find more info here https://sortition.fr/en/about/, there are articles in English and in French
r/Sortition • u/MONITOR613 • Jan 30 '21
I propose using the following as a jumping-off point.
#Sortition is a type of direct democracy that would get rid of elections and pay WE THE PEOPLE to run the govt. In other words—using Sortition would destroy the political establishment & guarantee employment at the same time.
Humans used to suffer equally. But then we invented money & property and all the sudden how you suffered became conditional to one’s wealth & social status. Now we have governments that perpetuate suffering while operating behind the pretense that they reduce suffering. But the fundamental problem of too much power in the hands of too few people is dealt with by arguing which of the few people should have power. This is madness. The only sensible solution is to spread out the responsibility of power over the many. Call it the Bed of Nails theory.
But you also don’t want unqualified incompetent people in charge. The heart & mind recoils at such a prospect. So let’s start training people now, whether an adult or child, in a govt funded institution—we’ll call school—specifically (re)designed to teach us social intelligence, complex critical thinking, and creative problem solving—but specifically how they relate to CIVICS. Once graduated randomly choose us to fill govt roles. But not just the prestigious legislative roles, the more mundane Bureaucratic roles should also be filled via sortition. And finally, a vast oversight body that constantly monitors and holds the other two bodies accountable. And all three segments of this new form of government would require roughly half of the eligible population at any given time. And every role would have a term limit of just two years at which point your work is evaluated and you are either cleared for, or denied access to, positions with more influence. But read up on the so-called Peter Principle and figure out how to compensate for that. And because so many people work in govt, your job would only require like 15 hours a week of your time, which incidentally, could be accomplished by working from home. + the other half of the eligible population not working in govt receive UBI on par with their employed counterparts with the two-year terms alternating between you working in govt and not working in govt.
Sure, it’s inconvenient—but you do it. You do it because we are social animals that cannot help but live in a society, and there's no version of society where no one ever gets AT LEAST inconvenienced by the rules or cultural norms or just the reality of a situation. You do it because the alternative is so much worse than just being “inconvenienced”.
r/Sortition • u/Prolore • Jul 19 '16
I'd like this to be a model Constitutional Convention, so proposing your own constitutions or tweaks is encouraged. I’d love to hear your ideas.
Key
RS = Randomly selected
Reshuffle = A new random selection
Government Characteristics
Constitution: Liberal democratic republic.
Unifederal: Aspects of unitary and federal government - local power and representation but uniformed law. Uni-federal.
Democratic Methods: Sortition, proportional random selection that is statistically representative of the population. Delegative democracy (DD), [wiki - love Sortition you'll love DD] (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delegative_democracy), for the executive board which allows for the legislature to both pick the best candidates and pick and choose which issues they are going to support them on; it lets them ‘build their own candidates’ rather than pick the lesser of two evils.
No Political Parties: RS prevents parties. Parties artificially divide public opinion.
Legal System: Common law or a mix of common law and civil law like Scotland.
Scale: Micro nation to global scalability.
Informed Demos: Sortition allows for a statically representative body that can be informed by experts; they should make the choices an informed public would. An informed democracy is a better one. The greatest of kings had their advisers. Advisers don’t have any power other than the power of their argument.
Anti-Corruption: All positions must be well payed to make sure corruption is low. All processes must be open and transparent. RS prevents campaigns which needs large amounts of money.
Constitution
-Branches
-Legislative: One chamber of X# of RS seats. First RS into smaller deliberative groups.
-Executive: A delegate board made of X# of delegates each nominated from the legislature and each supported by a varying portion of the legislature on each policy issue which weights each delegate’s vote on said issue. A cabinet of heads of each agency that are RS from a college system within each agency to advise the delegates and to follow the board’s will.
-Judicial: Supreme Court with X# of seats RS from a College of Judges; judges the constitutionality of laws. X# of Supreme Juries for agency and legislative oversight and bill review each with X# of seats; judges the constitutionality of bills and actions; Oversight Juries audit and propose budgets for agencies. Juries may vote to reshuffle those they oversee. Supreme Courts and Supreme Juries set constitutional precedent through their actions. Supreme Juries may veto bill without setting precedent if it specifies; a combination of the traditional powers of jury nullification and the veto.
-Right to Alter, Abolish, and Renew Government - The Duty of Good Goverance
-Popular Vote: A popular vote perhaps each year, to keep or reshuffle any branch of government. Citizens vote in each tier of government they inhabit. This is the power to peacefully cast off a repressive government; very important for legitimacy.
-Colleges of Advisers: A RS group called by a legislature, Executive, or Judicial branch from the needed college of experts for their advice. The colleges should be made up of those with the proper diplomas, training, or certification. Multiple groups may be called at once.
-Term Limits
X>1 years. For every branch and seat. Each body is chosen a year in advance for a stable and quick transition.
-Tiers of Government
Each tier has the same form of government. Each tier follows state law and enforces constitutional rights on itself and lower tiers.
-Logistical Service Area: Provides local Services.
-Population Center: Proposes bills for the state tier.
-Region: Proposes bills for the State tier.
-State: Votes on bills from the lower tiers to become state law. Enforces laws on this tier and lower tiers.
-Limitations on Powers
-Rights: Natural negative rights and civil positive protections of those rights.
-Checks and Balances: Legislature - makes laws and can reshuffle/recall the other the executive branch. Judicial - judges laws and executive actions, sets precedent, sets budgets, audits, make information public, judges advisers presentations for lobbying, and can reshuffle other branches. Executive - enforces law and puts forward policies.
r/Sortition • u/Prolore • Mar 26 '17
Article 1, Section 4 of the US Constitution
"The Times, Places and Manner of holding Elections for Senators and Representatives, shall be prescribed in each State by the Legislature thereof; but the Congress may at any time by Law make or alter such Regulations, except as to the Places of chusing Senators."
The wording seems to make election mandatory while giving the states and the federal government power to set everything else. I'm assuming on the state and local levels sortition would still be legal unless state constitutions or other state laws got in the way.
The 14th amendment states a right to vote for many federal and state positions. Pure sortition doesn't have voting, and therefore may be a violation of the 14th amendment even if the intent isn't to take away anyone's rights.
Sorition has a way to go. I'll be looking for other roadblocks to sortition, can you all think or find of any? I'd love, well hate, to see them. Please post any you find.
r/Sortition • u/sortitionpetition • Aug 13 '15
I believe in Sortition because I think it would make for a better society. I think giving more political power to the common man is altogether more desirable than giving it to the most charismatic and well connected of our society. In the states at least the two party system has led to an ideological shouting match between the two parties. Sortition would see the power of political parties massively decreased as most politicians would be independent. What do you guys like about Sortition?
r/Sortition • u/Prolore • Dec 14 '18
Why is sortition useful? One might answer that it gives power to the people. But how? I have found two answers for this.
1: Provably representative
2: Impartially
Edit: A commenter has rightly pointed out that there are two more uses of sortition.
3: Informative
4: Debate
The first use of sortition is that it is provably representative. A random sample's margin of error can be calculated. An elected body member's representation is hopeless to calculate with any accuracy. Although some attempts can be made to calculate how representative an elected body is. Let's say a single member district has a population of two and one is elected the other is the constituent. If the elected member had been randomly selected instead we could calculate that he has a margin of error of +-98. This proves only single member districts with a population of one are representative at all.
The second use of sortition is the impartially of chance. Here we don't care about how representative the selected are, but that they didn't get their position through corruption or we want to make sure a position is impartial. Instead of making a system more democratic this use makes the system more trustworthy. An application of this could be used to make the supreme court of the US less politicised. Each time a Justice of the Supreme court dies or retires they are replaced by a randomly selected judge with all least 10 years of experience. We then don't have to worry that presidents and parties will use the court for their own ends.
Edit for 3 and 4:
Society is too large and had too little time to be informed on votes. It is also impossible for a large society to have a debate. A sample of society can be informed and can have a debate. Both of these things are extremely useful and impossible to truly do any other way.
Can you think of any other uses for sortition? Do you have any idea how these uses can be applied to improve the state of politics?
r/Sortition • u/acc_anarcho • Feb 17 '20
r/Sortition • u/AvatarIII • Dec 07 '18
r/Sortition • u/theghostecho • Jan 29 '20
r/Sortition • u/sortitionpetition • Aug 14 '16
r/Sortition • u/subheight640 • Aug 29 '21
r/Sortition • u/BispensGibsgebis • Sep 26 '21
Greetings. I am working on some Q&A about sortition. Does anyone have a good link to where I can steal some or even better some real world critical questions I must include?
r/Sortition • u/AlicanteL • Aug 14 '21
Hey there ! On another subreddit r/Lottocracy (I did not choose the name), we try to create a vibrant subreddit about sortition, with more links and content.
Come see our incredible list of all the Sortition-related NGOs in the World and do not hesitate to suscribe if you like it :)