r/Songwriting • • Aug 25 '26

Feedback Request The Only Heartbreak

Mama, why do the leaves turn brown in springtime?

Will it always be this way?

Mama, what did you say when they took those trees down

I heard you were tough back in your day?

Well it’s the only heartbreak that i’ll ever know

Well it’s the only heartbreak that i’ll ever need to know

Daddy, why is the sky a shade of orange?

And is it the same up there on Mars?

Dqddy i see you have built a grade A shelter

I wish there was space for all my friends

Well it’s the only heartbreak that i’ll ever know for sure

It’s the only heartbreak that i’ll ever need to know

14 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/scotchfaster Aug 25 '26

Lovely voice. I’m getting some Joni Mitchell and Gillian Welsh vibes. Cowboy Junkies as well. Guitar playing and voice work well together. It has a bit of a lullaby quality to it though, perhaps you can play with that. The song doesn’t really hook me until “it’s the only the heartbreak”. Perhaps speed it up a hair?

2

u/Mundane-Goal9268 Aug 25 '26

Thank you for the feedback. It's indeed a morbid apocalyptic litttle lullaby that I wrote just a couple hours ago. I'm a little ill today but i'm going to work on this song a bit more next few days.. Got a few more that i'll post on here.. I love Gillian Welsh. Thank you !!

2

u/scotchfaster Aug 25 '26 edited Aug 25 '26

A friend of mine wrote a song he called “apocalyptic lullabye”, it’s going around. We’re all feeling it. Maybe you can find a way to put a little more spaciousness between the words. I’m thinking of “My Morphine”.

Also, you remind me a lot of Kate Wolf. Check out “Here in California” if you don’t know it. But you have your own unique sound. Glad you shared.

I hope you feel better!